What do you think?
Rate this book
Toby Bean #1
Toby and the Silver Blood Witches
A sinister plot. A secret city in the sky. A boy with an impossible choice.
Twelve year old Toby has little time for friends or football since his mum fell ill. All he wants is to stay at home and keep an eye on her.
But mysterious things are happening beyond his garden hedge. And who is the strange woman in his attic with her clumsy magic and bothersome bat?
Entangled in adventure, Toby must embark on a dangerous mission. A girl’s life is at stake and time is running out.
Twelve year old Toby has little time for friends or football since his mum fell ill. All he wants is to stay at home and keep an eye on her.
But mysterious things are happening beyond his garden hedge. And who is the strange woman in his attic with her clumsy magic and bothersome bat?
Entangled in adventure, Toby must embark on a dangerous mission. A girl’s life is at stake and time is running out.
240 pages, Paperback
First published July 5, 2021
12 people are currently reading
124 people want to read
About the author
Sally Doherty
6 books13 followersSally Doherty lives in leafy Surrey with her husband and three-legged (but speedy) rescue dog. After studying French and German at university, she worked for a year in London before unexpectedly falling ill with M.E. Being stuck at home and often in bed for fifteen years, however, has lit a cauldron of stories bubbling inside her imagination.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews
Read
December 23, 2022Congratulations for placing 1st in the 2022 BBNYA Competition!
June 20, 2023
Toby and the Silver Blood Witches is a unique and fantastic middle grade. Toby our main character is a kid (12 years old) who you just instantly get behind and support, he is a carer for his mother who suffers from chronic fatigue syndrome. As a result he can’t play football, and has to sacrifice time with this friends, your heart just instantly goes out to him.
But one day a witch crashes in his attic and Toby is launched into a whirlwind of magic and adventure as he battles against sinister powers, helps captive witches and takes care of his mum!
Five stars highly recommend to parents, kids and anybody who enjoys middle grade. I can see why this won the Book Bloggers Novel of the Year Award! - BBNYA
But one day a witch crashes in his attic and Toby is launched into a whirlwind of magic and adventure as he battles against sinister powers, helps captive witches and takes care of his mum!
Five stars highly recommend to parents, kids and anybody who enjoys middle grade. I can see why this won the Book Bloggers Novel of the Year Award! - BBNYA
December 20, 2021
I really enjoyed this book, which I read with my daughters. The protagonist, Toby, is a young carer for his mother who suffers from ME (or chronic fatigue syndrome). This means Toby has had to give up his promising football career and he misses out on spending time with his friends and generally just being a kid. Life isn't very exciting for Toby, until a witch crash-lands in his attic, setting him off on a fast-paced magical adventure to save a young witch's life from the clutches of a nefarious organisation.
I was very impressed with the world building here, really imaginative and original, particularly the Witchery and the innards of the ominous SMI factory located behind Toby's house. The Witchery is definitely a world I'd love to explore further–who wouldn't be fascinated by a secret city of witches in the sky?
The characters are all really well-written too; though Toby is the star of the show, the fluttermouse Barnaby has a special place in all our hearts now. I hope we get to meet these characters again.
The author, as someone with ME herself, deals sensitively when discussing the difficulties of the condition in a way that children will easily understand. There are real young carers like Toby all over the world, and it's refreshing to see not only a disability explored in a children's novel, but to see things from a child's perspective. My eldest daughter (10) was quite interested in what being a young carer meant and we explored it together and the author's experience of living with ME after we finished reading.
A thought-provoking and thoroughly entertaining read.
I was very impressed with the world building here, really imaginative and original, particularly the Witchery and the innards of the ominous SMI factory located behind Toby's house. The Witchery is definitely a world I'd love to explore further–who wouldn't be fascinated by a secret city of witches in the sky?
The characters are all really well-written too; though Toby is the star of the show, the fluttermouse Barnaby has a special place in all our hearts now. I hope we get to meet these characters again.
The author, as someone with ME herself, deals sensitively when discussing the difficulties of the condition in a way that children will easily understand. There are real young carers like Toby all over the world, and it's refreshing to see not only a disability explored in a children's novel, but to see things from a child's perspective. My eldest daughter (10) was quite interested in what being a young carer meant and we explored it together and the author's experience of living with ME after we finished reading.
A thought-provoking and thoroughly entertaining read.
June 18, 2023
What a fantastic book! It has everything: witches,magic, adventure, danger, bullies and the underdog gets to be a hero. What more could you want in a book? Toby is a young carer who has just about given up on everything except taking care of his mother, until a witch crashes into his attic! That’s when the fun begins! Toby must decide to help the witches and risk losing his mother or don’t help them and innocent young witches will die. What will he choose? Toby has to reach deep inside himself to find what is right.
The characters on this book are brilliant and sometimes humorous; Bumble cracked me up! The action is pacy and the story flows along smoothly to keep you engaged. This book is perfect for middle grade readers and adults as well. I can’t wait to see what happens in Toby’s next adventure!
The characters on this book are brilliant and sometimes humorous; Bumble cracked me up! The action is pacy and the story flows along smoothly to keep you engaged. This book is perfect for middle grade readers and adults as well. I can’t wait to see what happens in Toby’s next adventure!
June 28, 2023
Thank you to BBNYA, The Write Reads, and the author for providing me with a free e-book in exchange for an honest review! All opinions contained within are my own.
For the past couple of years, I’ve been getting back into reading middle grade. Sometimes, I just need some whimsy in my life and it has the added bonus of finding books for my 9 year old son. That was part of the reason why I was so excited to learn who won the 2022 BBNYA competition! I feel like a lot of people sleep on middle grade, but it can be such a fun age group to read while also imparting great information and tackling important topics. Toby and the Silver Blood Witches certainly accomplishes all of that in this start to the series.
In the novel, we follow a young man named Toby. Toby is just like any other kid in his class except for one large difference. His mom has a chronic illness that leaves Toby in charge of taking care of her and their household. Toby tries not to let it get to him, shoving all the things that used to fill his life to the side to do what he feels he needs to do. Then, one day, a witch tumbles into his life and his world is changed forever.
This book was a great mixture of what I love in middle grade stories. It had a lot of whimsy, but also incorporated important messages about chronic illness and the effect it can have on not only the sufferer, but their loved ones. There were several moments in this story where I felt so much empathy for both Toby’s mom, who suffers from M.E., and Toby, who has the weight of so much responsibility dropped on his young shoulders. I can’t truly know what it’s like to live with chronic fatigue or to be a young child with a parent who has it, but this book does an incredible job of giving an unbiased glimpse into their world. It truly touched my heart and made me want to learn more about the disease (bonus: there are links at the end of the book to learn more!).
But let us not forget about the magic and whimsy that is suffused throughout this story! I absolutely adored the authors descriptions of the witches and their home. The trio that end up working with Toby and such a delight, from Bumble who is a walking disaster, to Willow, who has a great head on her shoulders. I enjoyed getting to know more about their magic and their world and how it tied into lore from our own. If I could visit Little Witchery, I absolutely would! There were some things, though, that I would have loved a little more information on. Like why the male witches have to live somewhere else and, for that matter, where are they? But, this is the first book to a series, so there’s plenty of time for those questions to be answered.
I also enjoyed getting to know Toby as a character. He had so much going on in his life and it was interesting to watch his growth throughout the novel. Had to roll my eyes when he was suddenly onboard with the rescue mission after seeing a picture of the potential rescuee, haha. Hormones, amiright? Still, moments like that reminded you just how young Toby is and how much he’s had to struggle with on his own. He’s a beautifully nuanced character who truly brought the heart to this story.
Overall, I had a great time with this middle grade fantasy. There were some things that I wished had more explanation, but, for the most part, I was engrossed in this story from start to finish. Again, I can definitely see why this beat out some tough competition to take the top prize for BBNYA 2022!
For the past couple of years, I’ve been getting back into reading middle grade. Sometimes, I just need some whimsy in my life and it has the added bonus of finding books for my 9 year old son. That was part of the reason why I was so excited to learn who won the 2022 BBNYA competition! I feel like a lot of people sleep on middle grade, but it can be such a fun age group to read while also imparting great information and tackling important topics. Toby and the Silver Blood Witches certainly accomplishes all of that in this start to the series.
In the novel, we follow a young man named Toby. Toby is just like any other kid in his class except for one large difference. His mom has a chronic illness that leaves Toby in charge of taking care of her and their household. Toby tries not to let it get to him, shoving all the things that used to fill his life to the side to do what he feels he needs to do. Then, one day, a witch tumbles into his life and his world is changed forever.
This book was a great mixture of what I love in middle grade stories. It had a lot of whimsy, but also incorporated important messages about chronic illness and the effect it can have on not only the sufferer, but their loved ones. There were several moments in this story where I felt so much empathy for both Toby’s mom, who suffers from M.E., and Toby, who has the weight of so much responsibility dropped on his young shoulders. I can’t truly know what it’s like to live with chronic fatigue or to be a young child with a parent who has it, but this book does an incredible job of giving an unbiased glimpse into their world. It truly touched my heart and made me want to learn more about the disease (bonus: there are links at the end of the book to learn more!).
But let us not forget about the magic and whimsy that is suffused throughout this story! I absolutely adored the authors descriptions of the witches and their home. The trio that end up working with Toby and such a delight, from Bumble who is a walking disaster, to Willow, who has a great head on her shoulders. I enjoyed getting to know more about their magic and their world and how it tied into lore from our own. If I could visit Little Witchery, I absolutely would! There were some things, though, that I would have loved a little more information on. Like why the male witches have to live somewhere else and, for that matter, where are they? But, this is the first book to a series, so there’s plenty of time for those questions to be answered.
I also enjoyed getting to know Toby as a character. He had so much going on in his life and it was interesting to watch his growth throughout the novel. Had to roll my eyes when he was suddenly onboard with the rescue mission after seeing a picture of the potential rescuee, haha. Hormones, amiright? Still, moments like that reminded you just how young Toby is and how much he’s had to struggle with on his own. He’s a beautifully nuanced character who truly brought the heart to this story.
Overall, I had a great time with this middle grade fantasy. There were some things that I wished had more explanation, but, for the most part, I was engrossed in this story from start to finish. Again, I can definitely see why this beat out some tough competition to take the top prize for BBNYA 2022!
June 27, 2023
4.5
Book source ~ BBNYA Tour
Toby is a 12-yr-old boy with the weight of the world on his shoulders. Bullied at school because he’s the smallest kid and because he has to take care of his sick mom, he wishes he had some help. Then one day he hears a sound in the attic and his whole world changes. Witches are real and he has an injured one on his hands. Good thing the school term is just ending because he’s about to get even busier.
This is a heart wrenching yet uplifting tale. Toby is a doll and his situation doesn’t just pull on the heart strings, it yanks on them. The witches are wonderful and their world is creative and interesting. I like the world (except the villains, they can go pound salt), Toby’s friends, his mom, and definitely the witches. I also love the witchy world. I’d list what I love about it, but I want readers to discover it without me giving it away. I have to admit, I was on the edge of my seat when Toby had to go into a dangerous situation. Whew!
This book is for anyone who loves middle grade fantasy that’s got a bit of danger and a whole lot of heart.
Book source ~ BBNYA Tour
Toby is a 12-yr-old boy with the weight of the world on his shoulders. Bullied at school because he’s the smallest kid and because he has to take care of his sick mom, he wishes he had some help. Then one day he hears a sound in the attic and his whole world changes. Witches are real and he has an injured one on his hands. Good thing the school term is just ending because he’s about to get even busier.
This is a heart wrenching yet uplifting tale. Toby is a doll and his situation doesn’t just pull on the heart strings, it yanks on them. The witches are wonderful and their world is creative and interesting. I like the world (except the villains, they can go pound salt), Toby’s friends, his mom, and definitely the witches. I also love the witchy world. I’d list what I love about it, but I want readers to discover it without me giving it away. I have to admit, I was on the edge of my seat when Toby had to go into a dangerous situation. Whew!
This book is for anyone who loves middle grade fantasy that’s got a bit of danger and a whole lot of heart.
July 28, 2021
I have been debating whether to write a review or not, because it will be a critical review and I know how hard the author must have worked on this book as she has severe ME herself and every sentence will have been even more painstaking and 'other task' stealing than for able authors.
There are many aspects of the book that I loved. The witches, the magic and adventure, dare doing and rescue making. It is a fun book with plenty to capture your interest and keep you turning the page.
The way severe ME is represented is good, understandably so since the author has the condition herself. The mum is bedridden and not able to talk much, struggling to feed herself. But while possibly shocking to some that such degree of illness can persist for two years it isn't written to shock, its just matter of fact. And it is good to see accurate representation of the condition in a children's book. Also, despite this being a book with magic there is no magical cure, which is good to see.
But as a parent with ME myself, and knowing many other parents with ME, I feel the need to put some content warnings in here. Toby is caring for his mum alone with no support. He has been doing this for two years and it is all he focuses on.
He obviously cares for his mum a lot but it is preventing him doing any fun things like football or parties. He is bullied directly because of his mum's health and told the authorities will take him away
If your child has a parent with ME and they want to read this book I feel you need to be aware that it addresses some very real fears that children with parents with ME have, and to either read it before them or with them, and have chats about the issues that come up. It also is not an easy read if you are a parent with ME.
Being a parent with ME myself and knowing many parents with ME, including those with severe ME, I know how their love for their children pushes them time and time again to do everything they can, and more, for their child. They always do their best to keep their children's lives as normal as possible and to reduce any caring role their children may have as much as possible. Spending most of their daily energy on interacting with their children by reading, cuddling, watching tv, looking at pictures their kids have drawn etc, even if unable to talk, sit up or (much bigger energy required) take them places. I know it is not always possible, severity can reduce the ability to do many or all of these activities, but parents with ME try their hardest for their kids. They are available as a loving and listening, caring parent even if physical activities are limited, and creatively come up with ways to enable games that require less energy from the parent but lots of fun for the kid. What children most need is love. But sadly I see very little if any of this in the book, though the mum obviously does care and worries, there is very little fun or more than eating together with a brief chat and it is suggested that all fun stopped when she became ill.
Toby also struggles mentally quite a lot with looking after his mum
What parents with ME often struggle with most is guilt. Guilt that they are letting their children down and not doing enough. They see the things other families do, as do their children - especially when old enough for social media - and often judge themselves unfairly and harshly. This book paints the picture of what we are frightened of being, what we are frightened of our children's lives being like.
The main issues get mostly resolved at the end, sort of and we are left with the knowledge that with the witches still around there is room for another adventure in a following book.
--Conclusion--
Maybe we need books like this that show how much families can struggle? How much chronic illness of a parent can affect a child? Certainly reviews I've read so far suggest people have found it informative and has opened their eyes to this reality.
This is not easy to read as a parent with ME, and I would imagine difficult for a child with a severely ill parent, though I'm not disputing that it is hard situation to be in. I feel it paints quite a bleak picture overall, from the ME and young carer perspective, throughout a lot of the book. It might be useful for some families to be able to read a book about this situation so you can talk about things and explore difficult emotions that your child may have. A book like this as an aid to help the discussion may be good.
The magic, adventure and lovely characters of the witches and a bat lighten the book a lot and help him out of the more difficult situations. But they can't magic his mum better (no magical cure here). Without the lightness of these elements it would feel a lot heavier read.
There are many aspects of the book that I loved. The witches, the magic and adventure, dare doing and rescue making. It is a fun book with plenty to capture your interest and keep you turning the page.
The way severe ME is represented is good, understandably so since the author has the condition herself. The mum is bedridden and not able to talk much, struggling to feed herself. But while possibly shocking to some that such degree of illness can persist for two years it isn't written to shock, its just matter of fact. And it is good to see accurate representation of the condition in a children's book. Also, despite this being a book with magic there is no magical cure, which is good to see.
But as a parent with ME myself, and knowing many other parents with ME, I feel the need to put some content warnings in here. Toby is caring for his mum alone with no support. He has been doing this for two years and it is all he focuses on.
"One more sleep. One more day at school. Then the whole of the summer holidays to keep an eye on Mum."He also sees it as his job to keep things quiet so she can recover - a lot of responsibility for a child to have.
"If he made sure everything was quiet and peaceful, if nothing unexpected happened, Mum would be able to rest. Then maybe she’d get better. There was a chance, right?"
He obviously cares for his mum a lot but it is preventing him doing any fun things like football or parties. He is bullied directly because of his mum's health and told the authorities will take him away
" Dacker sauntered past, giving Toby a sharp nudge. “Holidays aren’t going to be much fun for you, are they, Bean?” he sneered. “Got to look after Mummy, haven’t you? I bet they take you away one of these days. A kid shouldn’t be doing all that stuff.”and is worried they won't be able to keep their house.
If your child has a parent with ME and they want to read this book I feel you need to be aware that it addresses some very real fears that children with parents with ME have, and to either read it before them or with them, and have chats about the issues that come up. It also is not an easy read if you are a parent with ME.
Being a parent with ME myself and knowing many parents with ME, including those with severe ME, I know how their love for their children pushes them time and time again to do everything they can, and more, for their child. They always do their best to keep their children's lives as normal as possible and to reduce any caring role their children may have as much as possible. Spending most of their daily energy on interacting with their children by reading, cuddling, watching tv, looking at pictures their kids have drawn etc, even if unable to talk, sit up or (much bigger energy required) take them places. I know it is not always possible, severity can reduce the ability to do many or all of these activities, but parents with ME try their hardest for their kids. They are available as a loving and listening, caring parent even if physical activities are limited, and creatively come up with ways to enable games that require less energy from the parent but lots of fun for the kid. What children most need is love. But sadly I see very little if any of this in the book, though the mum obviously does care and worries, there is very little fun or more than eating together with a brief chat and it is suggested that all fun stopped when she became ill.
Toby also struggles mentally quite a lot with looking after his mum
'It had always been there at the back of his mind - a black cloud hanging over him'. 'don't think, don't feel' is his survival tactic. There are a couple of times where it's mentioned how they used to have fun together, how much life has changed.
What parents with ME often struggle with most is guilt. Guilt that they are letting their children down and not doing enough. They see the things other families do, as do their children - especially when old enough for social media - and often judge themselves unfairly and harshly. This book paints the picture of what we are frightened of being, what we are frightened of our children's lives being like.
The main issues get mostly resolved at the end, sort of and we are left with the knowledge that with the witches still around there is room for another adventure in a following book.
--Conclusion--
Maybe we need books like this that show how much families can struggle? How much chronic illness of a parent can affect a child? Certainly reviews I've read so far suggest people have found it informative and has opened their eyes to this reality.
This is not easy to read as a parent with ME, and I would imagine difficult for a child with a severely ill parent, though I'm not disputing that it is hard situation to be in. I feel it paints quite a bleak picture overall, from the ME and young carer perspective, throughout a lot of the book. It might be useful for some families to be able to read a book about this situation so you can talk about things and explore difficult emotions that your child may have. A book like this as an aid to help the discussion may be good.
The magic, adventure and lovely characters of the witches and a bat lighten the book a lot and help him out of the more difficult situations. But they can't magic his mum better (no magical cure here). Without the lightness of these elements it would feel a lot heavier read.
January 4, 2023
4.5 STARS
June 23, 2023
This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
---
WHAT'S TOBY AND THE SILVER BLOOD WITCHES ABOUT?
Toby Bean doesn't have the easiest life. He's a twelve-year old who's bullied at school and he hasn't spent much time with his football team or friends since his mother became ill a couple of years earlier with myalgic encephalomyelitis (it might have been nice if myalgic encephalomyelitis had been spelled out at least once) and he's had to spend all of his time taking care of her/their house.
After hearing strange noises in their attic a couple of times, Toby goes to investigate only to find an injured woman in the attic—she's strangely dressed, and what she's saying is even stranger. She claims to be a witch who crashed on her broom, landing in the attic. Not only that, but she needs his help to be able to leave. He's just this close to calling the police to come pick her up, but decides to indulge her. He finds her wand around where she thought it fell, and then he sees her use it.
And Toby's complicated life just got more complicated—and more exciting.
He finds himself helping magical people in ways that only non-magical people can, visiting a city that's shouldn't exist, and taking on a secret organization to rescue some witches.
This summer break isn't anything like what Toby'd expected.
WORLDBUILDING
Doherty's worldbuilding is just great. The human/earthen conflict with the witches was introduced and dealt with in a way that is both easy to grasp and believe.
The witches' hidden city was a great concept, and the tour of the city that Doherty took Toby (and the reader) on through it was well done and entertaining. Just about everything she gave the reader about witches—from Witch Bumble's words for objects/animals (think The Little Mermaid's Scuttle) to their wands—is exactly what you want to find in a book like this.
I do think the big, evil human group could've been developed a bit better—they did stop short of twirling their mustaches or Tex Richman-esque maniacal laugh, but just by a hair. But that'd be my only complaint on this front (and that's something that can be addressed in the next book so maybe I'm being premature on this point).
THE DIFFICULTY SETTING
If you think of this as a video game, you're definitely reading a play-through on the "Easy" setting. Every single arc resolves pretty easily and without a lot of tension—there might be some tension or suspense in the setup, but it goes away pretty quickly.
I noticed this first with the arcs involving Toby's friends and his mother, but once I put my finger on it, I realized that'd been what was bugging me about everything.
This could be by design—particularly if Doherty is aiming at the younger end of the MG audience. If it's not by design, I'd say all the elements for a more suspenseful and satisfying resolution are there, the text just needs to explore that better—and add another hundred or so pages to the book (that's just an assumption on my part based on similar MG books I've read).
To be clear—this isn't a flaw in the stories/arcs—everything ended in a very satisfactory place and I wouldn't ask Doherty (or any author) to change that based on my whims. I just want the journey to that end to be more satisfying. The resolutions—particularly to the friends and mother—didn't feel earned.
SO, WHAT DID I THINK ABOUT TOBY AND THE SILVER BLOOD WITCHES?
This was a perfectly charming and fun read—it was quick, too—not just because of the complexity, but primarily because the narration was so engaging that the real world melted away in the background and the only thing you wanted to focus on was the book.
Toby's an endearing character, and you can't help but root for him and those around him (other than his bullies, obviously). He ends up in a pretty good place and it'll be good to see how a better-adjusted version of him who is already familiar with the world of witches deals with things in the sequel.
I did want more from Toby and the Silver Blood Witches—and think that MG readers would be justified in asking for it—but please note, I'm asking for more of something good. Not wanting a mediocre or disappointing read to offer more. It's good, it just could've been better. Still, most MG readers are going to want to return to this world in the sequel(s) and from re-reading it.
---
Toby raised his eyebrows. What a ridiculous rhyme. Yet, every cell in his body quivered. The sensible voice inside his head reminded him there was no such thing as magic, but he couldn’t help wonder, would something happen?
WHAT'S TOBY AND THE SILVER BLOOD WITCHES ABOUT?
Toby Bean doesn't have the easiest life. He's a twelve-year old who's bullied at school and he hasn't spent much time with his football team or friends since his mother became ill a couple of years earlier with myalgic encephalomyelitis (it might have been nice if myalgic encephalomyelitis had been spelled out at least once) and he's had to spend all of his time taking care of her/their house.
After hearing strange noises in their attic a couple of times, Toby goes to investigate only to find an injured woman in the attic—she's strangely dressed, and what she's saying is even stranger. She claims to be a witch who crashed on her broom, landing in the attic. Not only that, but she needs his help to be able to leave. He's just this close to calling the police to come pick her up, but decides to indulge her. He finds her wand around where she thought it fell, and then he sees her use it.
And Toby's complicated life just got more complicated—and more exciting.
He finds himself helping magical people in ways that only non-magical people can, visiting a city that's shouldn't exist, and taking on a secret organization to rescue some witches.
This summer break isn't anything like what Toby'd expected.
WORLDBUILDING
It was obvious which of them was the Head Witch. It wasn’t just Willow’s height which gave her presence– she exuded a quiet air of authority. Her face was unreadable, neither stern nor overtly friendly. It bore no wrinkles, no lines. It was as if she never betrayed great emotion. She was impassive with a touch of the formidable.
Doherty's worldbuilding is just great. The human/earthen conflict with the witches was introduced and dealt with in a way that is both easy to grasp and believe.
The witches' hidden city was a great concept, and the tour of the city that Doherty took Toby (and the reader) on through it was well done and entertaining. Just about everything she gave the reader about witches—from Witch Bumble's words for objects/animals (think The Little Mermaid's Scuttle) to their wands—is exactly what you want to find in a book like this.
I do think the big, evil human group could've been developed a bit better—they did stop short of twirling their mustaches or Tex Richman-esque maniacal laugh, but just by a hair. But that'd be my only complaint on this front (and that's something that can be addressed in the next book so maybe I'm being premature on this point).
THE DIFFICULTY SETTING
The more she talked, the more Toby felt as if he was falling headlong into a curious fictional world. He needed to take charge of the situation, before it completely spiralled out of control.
If you think of this as a video game, you're definitely reading a play-through on the "Easy" setting. Every single arc resolves pretty easily and without a lot of tension—there might be some tension or suspense in the setup, but it goes away pretty quickly.
I noticed this first with the arcs involving Toby's friends and his mother, but once I put my finger on it, I realized that'd been what was bugging me about everything.
This could be by design—particularly if Doherty is aiming at the younger end of the MG audience. If it's not by design, I'd say all the elements for a more suspenseful and satisfying resolution are there, the text just needs to explore that better—and add another hundred or so pages to the book (that's just an assumption on my part based on similar MG books I've read).
To be clear—this isn't a flaw in the stories/arcs—everything ended in a very satisfactory place and I wouldn't ask Doherty (or any author) to change that based on my whims. I just want the journey to that end to be more satisfying. The resolutions—particularly to the friends and mother—didn't feel earned.
SO, WHAT DID I THINK ABOUT TOBY AND THE SILVER BLOOD WITCHES?
Bumble leaned forwards. “It’s good to be different.”
“Being different is horrible. Being different means you get picked on,” Toby muttered.
“Being different is great! Who wants to be the same as everyone else?”
Toby looked up at her. She sat there in her bright patchwork dress, a bat peeping out of her pocket and her head held high.
Bumble smiled at him. “Be proud to be you, Toby ,” she said gently.
This was a perfectly charming and fun read—it was quick, too—not just because of the complexity, but primarily because the narration was so engaging that the real world melted away in the background and the only thing you wanted to focus on was the book.
Toby's an endearing character, and you can't help but root for him and those around him (other than his bullies, obviously). He ends up in a pretty good place and it'll be good to see how a better-adjusted version of him who is already familiar with the world of witches deals with things in the sequel.
I did want more from Toby and the Silver Blood Witches—and think that MG readers would be justified in asking for it—but please note, I'm asking for more of something good. Not wanting a mediocre or disappointing read to offer more. It's good, it just could've been better. Still, most MG readers are going to want to return to this world in the sequel(s) and from re-reading it.
July 19, 2021
I was lucky enough to read an advance copy of this book (with no obligation to leave a review), and I do mean lucky - it's a fabulous story, full of empathy and kindness, spirit and adventure ... and a lot of magic! When a mystery literally crash-lands in young-carer, Toby's, attic, he is faced with a tough decision. As sole helper to his chronically ill mum, he doesn't even go out for football practice anymore, much less get involved with witches and their uncontrollable broomsticks! But when a young witch's life is at stake, Toby knows he has to do the right thing, even if he's sure someone is watching ...
March 14, 2024
A fantasy adventure story for MG readers with a sympathetic protagonist in Toby. The witches were fun and the plot pacy. A good portrayal of severe ME in the mother. Enjoyed.
December 30, 2024
This is such a brilliant story I just couldn’t put it down! Toby is looking forward to his last day at school. Only one more day and then he can spend the summer holidays hopefully avoiding Dacker and Boz who bully him, and instead spend his days at home looking after his mum who is ill with ME. One day when he finally gets some time to himself Toby’s mum asks him to check on the window in the attic. But when Toby goes up into the attic he finds something he wasn’t expecting, sitting in a corner of the attic is a strange woman in colourful clothing and a swollen ankle. But who is she and how did she get into his attic?
This is such a great and creative adventure. Toby is a young carer for his mum who has ME and because of this he worries about his mum and would prefer to be at home than in school where he is bullied. I like this story for showing the truth about what it can be like to be a young carer and the frustrations and isolation Toby feels from being in this situation, but I love how this story goes and what happens as we focus more on the magical aspect of this tale. The story is a fun one with Toby soon finding the woman in his attic to be a wtich who needs his help to find her wand. And we soon learn more about the strange building that’s near Toby’s house too, what goes on there and more about the witches.
I love some of the silly things that happen, like the issue with flying and the various witches Toby meets who are all very different. I especially loved the world of Little Witchery and how interesting and exciting the story becomes with everything happening there. I also love the cute animals in the story, Barnaby, who can be seen as part of the chapter headers, and Cuddles. The story builds up to a good ending. I love how some things are revealed and how there’s a twist I wasn’t expecting regarding one character at the end. The story ends well, satisfying but leaves you curious about a potential future book and I am excited to find out what will happen in book two!
the book has a map at the start showing you where Toby’s house is and that strnge building called the SMI, as well as some lovely chapter headers and a lovely image of Toby and Bumble at the start of the book. At the end of the book is some information about young carers and ME which was good to read as some children may not have come across the condition or situation other kids are in before. Overall I have really enjoyed this story. I love the serious aspect of showing some of the realities kids face as young carers, and this ends up being resolved in a good way, despite Toby doing everything alone at first. It’s also just a briliant and fun story featuring some really interesting characters (I especially love Bumble!) and a wonderful adventure. There really isn’t anything I disliked about this story, it was just the perfect magical adventure and I can’t wait to find out what happens in the next book in the trilogy! 🙂
-Thanks to BBNYA for a free copy.
This is such a great and creative adventure. Toby is a young carer for his mum who has ME and because of this he worries about his mum and would prefer to be at home than in school where he is bullied. I like this story for showing the truth about what it can be like to be a young carer and the frustrations and isolation Toby feels from being in this situation, but I love how this story goes and what happens as we focus more on the magical aspect of this tale. The story is a fun one with Toby soon finding the woman in his attic to be a wtich who needs his help to find her wand. And we soon learn more about the strange building that’s near Toby’s house too, what goes on there and more about the witches.
I love some of the silly things that happen, like the issue with flying and the various witches Toby meets who are all very different. I especially loved the world of Little Witchery and how interesting and exciting the story becomes with everything happening there. I also love the cute animals in the story, Barnaby, who can be seen as part of the chapter headers, and Cuddles. The story builds up to a good ending. I love how some things are revealed and how there’s a twist I wasn’t expecting regarding one character at the end. The story ends well, satisfying but leaves you curious about a potential future book and I am excited to find out what will happen in book two!
the book has a map at the start showing you where Toby’s house is and that strnge building called the SMI, as well as some lovely chapter headers and a lovely image of Toby and Bumble at the start of the book. At the end of the book is some information about young carers and ME which was good to read as some children may not have come across the condition or situation other kids are in before. Overall I have really enjoyed this story. I love the serious aspect of showing some of the realities kids face as young carers, and this ends up being resolved in a good way, despite Toby doing everything alone at first. It’s also just a briliant and fun story featuring some really interesting characters (I especially love Bumble!) and a wonderful adventure. There really isn’t anything I disliked about this story, it was just the perfect magical adventure and I can’t wait to find out what happens in the next book in the trilogy! 🙂
-Thanks to BBNYA for a free copy.
January 17, 2023
Toby is 12 and he is counting down the days and then the minutes to the end of school, and the summer holidays. But mostly so he can get away from the school bullies Dacker (the leader) and Boz. They torment him. the torment him about his hair and about his mum. Unfortunately it seems like the school holidays isn't gong to stop Toby's tormentors, as they have something they can hold against him.
Toby is a carer for his mum who is ill in bed, she has ME and Toby looks after her and their house. She used to work in the big building behind their house, the S.M.I. Toby thinks this stands for Solar Material Investigation. Whatever, it is a very secretive building, no-one who works there is allowed to talk abut it. His mum never did, and they still pay her even two years after she first got ill - they pay her to keep their secrets! That's how they get to keep their house while his mum can't work.
On getting home that evening, Toby's mum is worrying about the attic windows still being open and Toby goes up to close them. The attic is full of Toby's old toys, but some things are spread across the floor. That's when Toby sees a bundle of brightly coloured rags - except they weren't rags - they were infact the dress of a woman who was laying in his attic! Toby was so shocked he almost fell down the ladder.
She says she fell in the attic window because she was shot at, by the gun on the S.M.I roof. Toby says it's a telescope, but she is adamant. She, Bumble, wants Toby to find her wand, she dropped it you see. Wand? Toby is more worried and thinks he should call the police. But for some reason (is it a memory that he is trying to forget) he agrees to help her. He finds the wand, she calls more witches.
Will Toby help them find yet another lost witch? How can he get into the S.M.I if a witch can't? Where do the witches live? What effect will this have on their money?
Toby's story is a difficult one. On one hand, he's a twelve year old boy who wants to play football, ride his bike and go out with his friends. On the other, he has a loving relationship and loyalty to his mum, she's the only family member mentioned other than his dad who died when Toby was small.
Toby learns about the witches, their home and what you shouldn't do when in their office! He loves Barnaby, Bumble's fluttermouse and Cuddles, her retrieagle (cross between a golden retriever and an eagle). He cares about others and he learns that his friends (and the witches) care about him, even though he has done his best to push them away.
We bought several copies of this book for school and it is very good. Sally's writing, storyline, and characters are just great.
Toby is a carer for his mum who is ill in bed, she has ME and Toby looks after her and their house. She used to work in the big building behind their house, the S.M.I. Toby thinks this stands for Solar Material Investigation. Whatever, it is a very secretive building, no-one who works there is allowed to talk abut it. His mum never did, and they still pay her even two years after she first got ill - they pay her to keep their secrets! That's how they get to keep their house while his mum can't work.
On getting home that evening, Toby's mum is worrying about the attic windows still being open and Toby goes up to close them. The attic is full of Toby's old toys, but some things are spread across the floor. That's when Toby sees a bundle of brightly coloured rags - except they weren't rags - they were infact the dress of a woman who was laying in his attic! Toby was so shocked he almost fell down the ladder.
She says she fell in the attic window because she was shot at, by the gun on the S.M.I roof. Toby says it's a telescope, but she is adamant. She, Bumble, wants Toby to find her wand, she dropped it you see. Wand? Toby is more worried and thinks he should call the police. But for some reason (is it a memory that he is trying to forget) he agrees to help her. He finds the wand, she calls more witches.
Will Toby help them find yet another lost witch? How can he get into the S.M.I if a witch can't? Where do the witches live? What effect will this have on their money?
Toby's story is a difficult one. On one hand, he's a twelve year old boy who wants to play football, ride his bike and go out with his friends. On the other, he has a loving relationship and loyalty to his mum, she's the only family member mentioned other than his dad who died when Toby was small.
Toby learns about the witches, their home and what you shouldn't do when in their office! He loves Barnaby, Bumble's fluttermouse and Cuddles, her retrieagle (cross between a golden retriever and an eagle). He cares about others and he learns that his friends (and the witches) care about him, even though he has done his best to push them away.
We bought several copies of this book for school and it is very good. Sally's writing, storyline, and characters are just great.
June 29, 2023
Young Toby is one of those characters you immediately are on side with. You want to protect him, cheer him on, and be his friend. On top of dealing with bullies at school, he also has to miss out on a lot of kid activities, like football, because he has to be home to take care of his mother, who has M.E. (chronic fatigue syndrome). I know how difficult it can be to be a carer for someone who is ill, and to have that burden at such a young age is heartbreaking.
But Toby’s life changes instantly when he he hears noises in his attic and, upon investigating, discovers a witch up there. Soon, he finds himself in the middle of a grand adventure, complete with a magical world and evil villains.
I love the beautiful and creative world that the author has built into this story – the “real world” feels very real, while the “fantasy world” is full of wonder – the descriptions were imaginative and lots of fun to picture in my mind.
The story is very fun to read and the action keeps the pace zipping along. The characters are all very well developed and readers will definitely find some favourites to cheer for among them.
I think that this would be a wonderful fantasy story for kids – it has an uplifting feel to it, magic and adventure, witches and villains, and even some tense, dangerous moments. It will definitely capture the imagination and keep the pages turning!
This is the first book in a trilogy, and I can’t wait to get my hands on the other two books in the series!
*** Thank you to the tour organiser, The Write Reads Tours, for providing me with an e-copy of this book.
But Toby’s life changes instantly when he he hears noises in his attic and, upon investigating, discovers a witch up there. Soon, he finds himself in the middle of a grand adventure, complete with a magical world and evil villains.
I love the beautiful and creative world that the author has built into this story – the “real world” feels very real, while the “fantasy world” is full of wonder – the descriptions were imaginative and lots of fun to picture in my mind.
The story is very fun to read and the action keeps the pace zipping along. The characters are all very well developed and readers will definitely find some favourites to cheer for among them.
I think that this would be a wonderful fantasy story for kids – it has an uplifting feel to it, magic and adventure, witches and villains, and even some tense, dangerous moments. It will definitely capture the imagination and keep the pages turning!
This is the first book in a trilogy, and I can’t wait to get my hands on the other two books in the series!
*** Thank you to the tour organiser, The Write Reads Tours, for providing me with an e-copy of this book.
September 7, 2024
At just 12 years old, Toby carries an immense burden: he has been caring for his bedbound mother since her illness took hold. But his challenges multiply when a witch unexpectedly appears in his attic, thrusting him into a perilous mission to save a young girl’s life!
In the first instalment of the Toby Bean Trilogy, we are invited into a world teeming with magic and adventure. From the very beginning, Doherty’s writing captivates, crafting vivid landscapes that whisk young readers away into the enchanting realm of witches. The narrative is rich in detail, allowing readers to fully immerse themselves in the fantastical elements of the story. The pacing strikes a perfect balance, interspersing moments of tension with reflective pauses.
The plot is both imaginative and engaging, filled with unexpected twists and turns that keep the suspense alive. Toby emerges as a relatable and endearing protagonist, not only as a hero but as a young boy navigating the heavy expectations of being a carer, who is now tasked with the responsibility of saving witches.
I particularly appreciate the author’s choice to include a young carer in the story. Toby’s mother suffers from M.E., a condition that also affects Doherty. As someone with a mild form of M.E. myself, I found this representation both meaningful and inclusive. Additionally, the author generously donates 10% of profits to the M.E. Association, further highlighting the importance of this cause.
Targeted at children aged 9 and up, this magical page-turner is sure to enchant readers of all ages. I highly recommend it to fans of fantasy and adventure!
In the first instalment of the Toby Bean Trilogy, we are invited into a world teeming with magic and adventure. From the very beginning, Doherty’s writing captivates, crafting vivid landscapes that whisk young readers away into the enchanting realm of witches. The narrative is rich in detail, allowing readers to fully immerse themselves in the fantastical elements of the story. The pacing strikes a perfect balance, interspersing moments of tension with reflective pauses.
The plot is both imaginative and engaging, filled with unexpected twists and turns that keep the suspense alive. Toby emerges as a relatable and endearing protagonist, not only as a hero but as a young boy navigating the heavy expectations of being a carer, who is now tasked with the responsibility of saving witches.
I particularly appreciate the author’s choice to include a young carer in the story. Toby’s mother suffers from M.E., a condition that also affects Doherty. As someone with a mild form of M.E. myself, I found this representation both meaningful and inclusive. Additionally, the author generously donates 10% of profits to the M.E. Association, further highlighting the importance of this cause.
Targeted at children aged 9 and up, this magical page-turner is sure to enchant readers of all ages. I highly recommend it to fans of fantasy and adventure!
September 30, 2021
I loved this heart warming middle grade book and I soon became emersed in the magical adventure and found I raced through the book.
In the story 12 year old Toby is trying hard to care for his mum (who has M.E and is bedbound) whilst trying to live a normal life with his friends and school. In the midst of this a strange woman appears to have crashed in his loft with her pet bat Barnaby and her broken broomstick.
She needs his help to rescue a young witch captured in the sinister S.M.I building. Will Toby be able to help on the dangerous mission and rescue the young witch before it's too late?
I loved the the main character Toby and was really rooting for him too as although he had a loving mum, he was leading such a difficult (and often miserable life.)
I thought the author dealt with lots of sensitive issues very well through the book. The story really portrays how difficult life is for young carers. It also shows what a dehabilitating illness M.E is and how hard it must be for children of parents suffering from this condition. Poor Toby even had to deal with bullies at the same time.
Luckily there is also a much lighter and humorous side to the story. I loved all the magic and fun that the witches brought to the story! My favourite part was the trip to the Witchery and I was enthralled by their world.
Overall this was a very entertaining read but with some underlying serious tones. A great read for 9-12 year olds which could lead to some interesting discussions on some important topics.
In the story 12 year old Toby is trying hard to care for his mum (who has M.E and is bedbound) whilst trying to live a normal life with his friends and school. In the midst of this a strange woman appears to have crashed in his loft with her pet bat Barnaby and her broken broomstick.
She needs his help to rescue a young witch captured in the sinister S.M.I building. Will Toby be able to help on the dangerous mission and rescue the young witch before it's too late?
I loved the the main character Toby and was really rooting for him too as although he had a loving mum, he was leading such a difficult (and often miserable life.)
I thought the author dealt with lots of sensitive issues very well through the book. The story really portrays how difficult life is for young carers. It also shows what a dehabilitating illness M.E is and how hard it must be for children of parents suffering from this condition. Poor Toby even had to deal with bullies at the same time.
Luckily there is also a much lighter and humorous side to the story. I loved all the magic and fun that the witches brought to the story! My favourite part was the trip to the Witchery and I was enthralled by their world.
Overall this was a very entertaining read but with some underlying serious tones. A great read for 9-12 year olds which could lead to some interesting discussions on some important topics.
June 26, 2023
"Toby and the Silver Blood Witches", the proud winner of the 2022 Book Bloggers Novel of the Year Award (BBNYA), hits you right in the feels with its surprising emotional depth, making it a standout middle-grade read.
Doherty’s "Toby and the Silver Blood Witches" is a captivating tale that effortlessly weaves together themes of magic and realism, delivering an enchanting narrative that is both heartwarming and exhilarating. The book follows Toby, a 12-year-old who takes on the responsibility of caring for his sick mother, while dealing with bullying and feeling alone. However, when an unexpected encounter with a crash-landed witch propels Toby into a breathtaking adventure, his world is forever transformed.
Doherty’s skillful characterization brings the cast to life, with Toby shining as the central figure, capturing readers’ hearts with his resilience and determination. Yet, it is the endearing flittermouse, Barnaby, who finds a special place within the reader's affections, leaving us yearning for further encounters with these delightful characters.
While the infusion of magic and adventure may initially seem incongruous with the stark realities of Toby’s life, it is precisely this juxtaposition that makes the narrative so compelling. The fusion of realism and enchantment allows Toby’s personal growth to flourish amidst his extraordinary journey, resulting in a narrative that resonates powerfully with readers.
Read more at https://www.summonfantasy.com/reviews...
Doherty’s "Toby and the Silver Blood Witches" is a captivating tale that effortlessly weaves together themes of magic and realism, delivering an enchanting narrative that is both heartwarming and exhilarating. The book follows Toby, a 12-year-old who takes on the responsibility of caring for his sick mother, while dealing with bullying and feeling alone. However, when an unexpected encounter with a crash-landed witch propels Toby into a breathtaking adventure, his world is forever transformed.
Doherty’s skillful characterization brings the cast to life, with Toby shining as the central figure, capturing readers’ hearts with his resilience and determination. Yet, it is the endearing flittermouse, Barnaby, who finds a special place within the reader's affections, leaving us yearning for further encounters with these delightful characters.
While the infusion of magic and adventure may initially seem incongruous with the stark realities of Toby’s life, it is precisely this juxtaposition that makes the narrative so compelling. The fusion of realism and enchantment allows Toby’s personal growth to flourish amidst his extraordinary journey, resulting in a narrative that resonates powerfully with readers.
Read more at https://www.summonfantasy.com/reviews...
January 31, 2023
I'm so late to the party reading Sally's award winning children's book 'Toby and the Silver Blood Witches'
I've heard many good things about this book and they're all true - this is a wonderful magical story full of escapism and adventure whilst still highlighting the difficulties child carers can face daily.
At first glance, this mix of themes may seem incongruous but it works perfectly. The realism and magic combined are what helps Toby's character grow on his personal journey and what makes the book so powerful.
At its core this story is a heartfelt tale about Toby, a 12 year old boy who is single-handedly caring for his bed-bound mum. A boy who is being bullied and has pulled away from his friends. He keeps his head down and his feelings shut away. But when a witch crash lands in his attic he becomes part of an adventure that is scary but life changing in ways he couldn't have imagined. A whole new world exists beyond the mundane, and the witches that inhabit this magical realm need Toby's help. So begins a page turning fantasy that will capture your heart and keep you on the edge of your seat. With memorable fantastical human and animal characters that you'll likely love and cheer for.
I really enjoyed this book and the best thing about being late to read it means I haven't got long to wait until the sequel is published end March 2023!
Recommended book for young and old, 8 - 108!
I've heard many good things about this book and they're all true - this is a wonderful magical story full of escapism and adventure whilst still highlighting the difficulties child carers can face daily.
At first glance, this mix of themes may seem incongruous but it works perfectly. The realism and magic combined are what helps Toby's character grow on his personal journey and what makes the book so powerful.
At its core this story is a heartfelt tale about Toby, a 12 year old boy who is single-handedly caring for his bed-bound mum. A boy who is being bullied and has pulled away from his friends. He keeps his head down and his feelings shut away. But when a witch crash lands in his attic he becomes part of an adventure that is scary but life changing in ways he couldn't have imagined. A whole new world exists beyond the mundane, and the witches that inhabit this magical realm need Toby's help. So begins a page turning fantasy that will capture your heart and keep you on the edge of your seat. With memorable fantastical human and animal characters that you'll likely love and cheer for.
I really enjoyed this book and the best thing about being late to read it means I haven't got long to wait until the sequel is published end March 2023!
Recommended book for young and old, 8 - 108!
June 16, 2023
The first in the Toby Bean trilogy for age 9+. I read this as one of the judges for a book contest and I’ll admit that by no stretch of the imagination would I ever have picked this up. Witchy Fantasy doesn’t even compute on my reading radar. However, I loved it. I sat down to start it and got up when I finished it. It’s very well written but with a message for young carers and people with ME, my only concern is that this could be a trigger for children in this situation. As could the bullying.
Briefly, Toby is 12 years old and a carer for his mother who has ME and is virtually bedridden so Toby has been looking after her, with no help, for two years. His life is centred around his Mum until he discovers a witch who has crash landed in the attic. Witch Bumble has come to earth to search for some witches who went missing in this area. She is soon followed by others and alongside Toby they make plans to save the captured witches.
Never having had children it’s hard for me to judge how they would receive it but I know I would have loved it. Harry Potter meets The Witches! It highlights the issues that child carers may face, talks about the effects of bullying but also shows how a child can face up to things they should never have to. I didn’t see how these difficult issues would work alongside a fantasy adventure but they did. Really well. Very enjoyable. Oh and yes it was the winner of the BBNYA 2022.
Briefly, Toby is 12 years old and a carer for his mother who has ME and is virtually bedridden so Toby has been looking after her, with no help, for two years. His life is centred around his Mum until he discovers a witch who has crash landed in the attic. Witch Bumble has come to earth to search for some witches who went missing in this area. She is soon followed by others and alongside Toby they make plans to save the captured witches.
Never having had children it’s hard for me to judge how they would receive it but I know I would have loved it. Harry Potter meets The Witches! It highlights the issues that child carers may face, talks about the effects of bullying but also shows how a child can face up to things they should never have to. I didn’t see how these difficult issues would work alongside a fantasy adventure but they did. Really well. Very enjoyable. Oh and yes it was the winner of the BBNYA 2022.
November 23, 2021
I read this with my 9yo, and he was very excited by the fast-paced plot and the engaging, sympathetic characters. Along with the fantasy adventure, it's a very gentle and sensitive portrayal of the relationship between a young carer and his mother. My son hadn't really come across this before, in real life or in fiction, and I think it was a great introduction to a very difficult subject.
When a witch crashes into Toby's attic, he quickly finds himself embroiled in a struggle between a sinister organisation based next to his home, and the oppressed witch community. The witches persuade Toby to help Skylark and her sister, both of whom are being held captive. But can Toby rescue the girls and keep the home and income he and his sick mum rely on?
Witty, emotional and magical, I would recommend this book to anyone looking for an original MG fantasy.
When a witch crashes into Toby's attic, he quickly finds himself embroiled in a struggle between a sinister organisation based next to his home, and the oppressed witch community. The witches persuade Toby to help Skylark and her sister, both of whom are being held captive. But can Toby rescue the girls and keep the home and income he and his sick mum rely on?
Witty, emotional and magical, I would recommend this book to anyone looking for an original MG fantasy.
June 30, 2023
This is a FANTASTIC book and deserving of all its accolades - aside from winning BBNYA (Book Bloggers' Novel of the Year Award) 2022, this was also a finalist in The Wishing Shelf Awards 2021 and shortlisted for both The Selfies and The Rubery Book Awards 2022.
Toby is a delightful protagonist that you just can't help but root for. His situation is grounded in reality too; there many young carers (his mum suffers from chronic fatigue or M.E.) all over the world, and the author, who turns out to have M.E. herself, tackles that theme with care and thoughtfulness and heart. All while keeping the fantasy fun and the story an entertaining read overall! There's magic and adventure, witches and whimsy, heroes and hope. Oh, and there's Barnaby!
PS. I hate to have to say in my reviews but: this book is written in British English, so the author did not misspell stuff. Thank you!
Toby is a delightful protagonist that you just can't help but root for. His situation is grounded in reality too; there many young carers (his mum suffers from chronic fatigue or M.E.) all over the world, and the author, who turns out to have M.E. herself, tackles that theme with care and thoughtfulness and heart. All while keeping the fantasy fun and the story an entertaining read overall! There's magic and adventure, witches and whimsy, heroes and hope. Oh, and there's Barnaby!
PS. I hate to have to say in my reviews but: this book is written in British English, so the author did not misspell stuff. Thank you!
October 11, 2024
Toby's mom is sick, and he is her caregiver. A witch has just landed in his attic and needs his help to rescue her niece. There are bullies who just won't leave him alone, and they are holding something overToby's head. It's a lot for one 12 year old boy who misses playing sports and hanging out with his best friends.
The book is 230 pages, and the chapters are not too long. As an educator, I find that students I work with do not have the reading stamina to read many of the longer middle grade books. The story moves along, and there are just enough twists and turns to keep readers turning pages.
I loved Toby's story and, it's books like these that make me think that maybe I am a fantasy-reader person!
The book is 230 pages, and the chapters are not too long. As an educator, I find that students I work with do not have the reading stamina to read many of the longer middle grade books. The story moves along, and there are just enough twists and turns to keep readers turning pages.
I loved Toby's story and, it's books like these that make me think that maybe I am a fantasy-reader person!
July 25, 2021
I love books that wrap you up like a big ole hug, and for me, this was it - the writing is warm and engaging and the plot compelling. I lost track of time while reading, and devoured it in a few sittings.
Toby is a great character, I appreciated that young carers are highlighted in this book, there are so many young unsung heroes out there and I think this will help them feel seen and appreciated. Toby has a lot on his plate and even more is piled on when he has to juggle bullies alongside a few magical problems. He does it admirably and steps up when needed. I have to say I was particularly happy with the ending :) <3
I will be eagerly (impatiently!) awaiting book two!
Toby is a great character, I appreciated that young carers are highlighted in this book, there are so many young unsung heroes out there and I think this will help them feel seen and appreciated. Toby has a lot on his plate and even more is piled on when he has to juggle bullies alongside a few magical problems. He does it admirably and steps up when needed. I have to say I was particularly happy with the ending :) <3
I will be eagerly (impatiently!) awaiting book two!
July 20, 2022
I loved this book! Toby’s life is a bit dreary, consumed as it is with the worries of caring for a sick mum. Until one day a witch crash lands in his attic, leading him into a wondrous and perilous adventure.
Toby and the Silver Blood Witches is fun mix of magic and adventure, with just enough danger to keep things suspenseful without being too scary. I also appreciate that it creates empathy for the situation of young carers. So many kids carry burdens that we don’t see.
We could all use a bit of magic in our lives. This book reminded me that sometimes I need to shake up routine and step out of my comfort zone. I can’t wait for the next book in the trilogy!
Toby and the Silver Blood Witches is fun mix of magic and adventure, with just enough danger to keep things suspenseful without being too scary. I also appreciate that it creates empathy for the situation of young carers. So many kids carry burdens that we don’t see.
We could all use a bit of magic in our lives. This book reminded me that sometimes I need to shake up routine and step out of my comfort zone. I can’t wait for the next book in the trilogy!
July 20, 2021
The word charming could have been invented for this book, a middle-grade fantasy full of magic of all kinds. 12-year-old Toby is a wonderful protagonist, sweet and sensitive but not saccharine, struggling to take care of his chronically ill mother and deal with all of life’s other problems, and then a witch crash lands in his attic. Confident readers of 9-12 will fly through it, and it is also suitable to read to younger children. A delightful start to what will hopefully be a multi-volume series.
August 7, 2021
This is perfectly pitched for MG with a page-turning adventure & a wonderfully imagined magical world that suddenly drops into the main character's life. And Toby needs adventure because he's a young carer & believes all opportunities for fun are lost to him. But masses is at stake too, & Toby has many difficult decisions to make & risks to take, if he is to rise to the occasion & help the witches. It's not all whimsy either - touches of darkness add edge to the danger.
Edge of the seat stuff! Can't wait to see what happens in Book 2 - a few intriguing hints are dropped!
Highly recommended.
Edge of the seat stuff! Can't wait to see what happens in Book 2 - a few intriguing hints are dropped!
Highly recommended.
August 11, 2021
I loved the main character, Toby, the beautiful relationship he has with his mum and his feeling that he had to grow up quickly. The witches are adorable, particularly Witch Bumble and her magical dress. The creatures within the book are delightful and come to life from the page. The story has humour, adventure, intrigue and excitement and is a real page-turner. The author also manages to talk sensitively and realistically about the daily challenges of a young carer and his mum who has ME. I love the world that Sally has created and I can't wait to read the next installment!!
June 28, 2023
Oh my, what a fantastic read! Toby is a young boy, who is taking care of his mother, who suffers from MS. As a carer, he doesn't have many friends, and spends most of his time at home. But things change when a witch crashes into his attic - and Toby is off on the adventure of a lifetime!
This was so much fun, and a great read overall. It was one of those books that pulls you in and refuses to let you stop until you finish the last page. Get your kids reading this summer, and share an adventure that they will not soon forget.
This was so much fun, and a great read overall. It was one of those books that pulls you in and refuses to let you stop until you finish the last page. Get your kids reading this summer, and share an adventure that they will not soon forget.
August 11, 2024
Full disclosure, I am 56 and far too old to be reading books like this. However, I was bewitched at an early age by a kindly crone, who gave me the ability to retain the mind of a ten year old. Everybody utter the sacred incantation 'Deus ex machina'. Anyhow, I find this helpful as I mostly read about dark and deadly deeds, so every now and again I like to re-kindle some of the magic and wonder of reading by torch light, buried under the covers.
Toby did not disappoint. No longer buried under the covers -- too hot -- and the light from my electronic reading device was bright enough as to have no need of a torch, but the magic was there on the page (screen-thingy).
So anyone who likes magic and the notion of getting along with witches instead of being mean should read this book. Especially if they want to learn about fluttermice and golden retrieagles.
Toby did not disappoint. No longer buried under the covers -- too hot -- and the light from my electronic reading device was bright enough as to have no need of a torch, but the magic was there on the page (screen-thingy).
So anyone who likes magic and the notion of getting along with witches instead of being mean should read this book. Especially if they want to learn about fluttermice and golden retrieagles.
December 17, 2023
I really enjoyed this book as a light and fun read. I felt fully immersed in the world of Toby and the witches, and I loved some of the descriptions… I felt like I was experiencing the tastes of some of the foods in the book!
I’ve been trying to read more children’s fiction that has disabled characters, so as someone with ME myself it was great to see this represented. I also found the theme of being a Young Carer harrowing. I wish this book had been around when I was a child!
I’ve been trying to read more children’s fiction that has disabled characters, so as someone with ME myself it was great to see this represented. I also found the theme of being a Young Carer harrowing. I wish this book had been around when I was a child!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 58 reviews