Whoa! Ms. Stevens did it again! I’m an emotional mess!
This is a foreboding, dark, depressing, claustrophobic, and disturbing story narrated by two unforgettable, traumatized, and struggling young girls.
Some stories leave a mark on your soul, and this is definitely one of them. The prologue and epilogue alone will wrench your heart, captivate your soul, and bring you to tears. It’s sad, real, harsh, and ugly. It’s utterly soul-crushing.
Cold Creek Highway feels like a haunted place where young girls become prey for a ruthless serial killer. Hitchhiking or being alone at night is like inviting danger—it’s chilling!
Most of the victims have already been forgotten; only their faded missing posters remain, hung around town until they’re torn down and replaced by another girl’s photo.
In the first half of the book, Hailey McBride tells her story: she recently lost her father in a car accident. Her mother died years before, and her father had been her best friend, her partner in crime—the only family she knew. Now, she’s trying to adapt to life with her aunt Lara, whom she loves, along with her niece. But Lara’s husband, Vaughn, is determined to make her life miserable with his overbearing, controlling ways, practically imprisoning her. Then Hailey discovers something in his study that makes her realize she’s in danger, and she needs to disappear to save herself.
Hailey has to leave behind her best friend Jonny and her boyfriend, Amber, who works at the local diner. She believes her outdoor skills will allow her to survive in the Cold Creek wilderness, so she stages her own disappearance, hoping everyone will believe she’s the latest victim of the highway killer. This way, she can live in the woods until she turns 18, at which point Vaughn will no longer have any control over her life.
With her wolf companion, she’s doing fine—until she finds a body in a ditch.
At this point, the second narrator enters: Beth Chevalier, Amber’s responsible, law-student sister, who moves to the town in search of answers. Grieving and desperate for justice, Beth is determined to uncover her sister’s killer by befriending the townspeople, digging up their secrets, and putting herself at risk. As she does, the responsible, “good” daughter transforms, spiraling into a fragile state, popping pills like candy, and eventually forming an intense relationship with Jonny. Her path eventually crosses with Hailey’s.
My thoughts:
The character development in this book is impeccable. You can easily empathize with both girls, despite their differences. Hailey is rebellious, independent, a tough biker with a stubborn streak, while Beth is consumed by guilt, self-destructive, compassionate, and intelligent, always putting others first.
Though the story progression was slow at times, I still enjoyed the rich backstories that allowed me to connect deeply with the characters and understand their motives.
The reveal of the serial killer’s identity was unexpected, and the last third of the book was a rollercoaster! After the slow buildup, the tension skyrocketed, keeping me on the edge of my seat and giving me an adrenaline rush.
The villains are incredibly well-crafted—I haven’t hated a character as much as I hated Vaughn in a long time! He’s despicable, disgusting, and shameless. You’ll find yourself imagining countless ways to make him pay!
Overall: This is an intense, thought-provoking, well-developed, and captivating read. Don’t miss this one!
Special thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for sharing this digital reviewer copy with me in exchange for my honest opinions.