3.5 stars, rounded up
The Cascade Killer is an easy-to-read, straightforward mystery. Perfect for a rainy weekend at home, or perhaps cozied up in the trailer while camping, or if you just want a lighter diversion after reading something deep and serious. The author’s style is simple and to-the point: there’s a little mystery, a little adventure, and the hint of a little romance. It’s undemanding, but he tells a compelling story without gratuitous violence, profanity or sex. And I really appreciate that. I don’t know about the rest of the series - though I find it hard to believe Phillips will deviate from his established style - but I honestly think this would make a fantastic Hallmark Mystery.
That said, Luke McCain is an extremely likeable main character. He’s an all-American, awe-shucks kind of guy. He loves nature, animals and helping people. He’s handsome, gainfully employed, owns a home, drives a truck and loves to fish… And he’s good with kids. The guy’s a catch, what’s not to like? As a Washington State Fish and Wildlife officer, he spends his days patrolling Yakima and the eastern slope of the Cascades with his loveable sidekick, Jack, the yellow lab. And while Jack is described as his partner, this turns out to be untrue – and here is my gripe:
Jack is really Luke’s personal pet / hunting dog. We learn he has no formal canine training, yet he accompanies Luke almost everywhere on the job and he is considered an expert scent tracker. Again, no formal training, he just knows what to do. Hmm…
Now, I love Labradors and I’m very familiar with the breed. I have personal experience with them as guide dogs for the blind, in bird hunting, and as a family pet (RIP Gertie). They are also widely used in search and rescue, and in drug and explosives detection. They’re amazing creatures. Intelligent, gentle, loyal – and dopey. Without formal training, the only thing they’ll instinctively find are dirty socks and dropped snacks. There. I said it.
Despite this tangent and harping, I still enjoyed this book immensely. I’m willing to overlook a multitude of writing sins if the story is engaging enough, and The Cascade Killer meets that standard.
Looking forward to continuing this series with the next installment, Cascade Vengeance.