When I was in my teen years, I read everything I could get my hands on by Rosamunde Pilcher. It was likely not her whole backlist, but closer than one would expect if you knew anything about the tiny, hand-me-down library that existed in my small town growing up. My mom was a fan and owned some of her popular epic-length novels, like Shell Seekers and Coming Home, which was my particular favorite. I filled in the gap with what my library offered and was thoroughly enchanted all around. That was then and until earlier this year it had been many years since I had read Pilcher, and I wasn't sure how re-visiting a fave from my youth would go (half the time I try it goes terribly). For me, that try was a listen of the Coming Home audiobook and it worked really well. I still love it, though I do relate to characters differently than I used to do. However, this is not a review of that or any of her novels. This is meant to be a review of this short story collection that was created by scanning magazines for the 1970s and 1980s that had published short stories by Pilcher, which I was excited to get a chance to read.
The verdict? If you are a Pilcher fan, you'll probably get some enjoyment out of this. I certainly did, but generally speaking, there is nothing special to these stories. A few standout as a quite good, but even then I wasn't satisfied by what was offered because I wished there was more to the story. I wish they had been developed into a full novel. Many were sub-par, and I didn't like the message or characters or both. There were a few that seemed well-suited to the short story format, but mostly it is clear longer stories are where you find the true Pilcher magic.
Most of these short stories revolved around courtship and marriage. Some were pre-courtship, but the promise is there that this m/f duo will suit. A very few did not have the romantic couple featured as the main characters, and those were the ones that seemed more suited to the short story format -- a budding relationship between soon-to-be family members or a regretful older couple seeing their children choose the path to happiness they denied themselves. Those were interesting vignettes that worked for me. However, the ones with the romantic couples front and center were not developed enough to work as well. They either gave you a taste that you wanted more of or were not worth the read.
Her long novels are great at giving a full character study and feature women choosing their own destinies, which maybe tend to end in finding that special someone, but that is not really the point of the story. For these short stories, it often is the point. There is not enough time for the character study, so they don't really make much impact. They are ok, but if just wanting to try Pilcher out, give one of her novels a try. It will be much more satisfying.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a chance to read and review this book. Views are my own.