🏳️🌈👩❤👩📚⚢🤠🐃🐎👩❤💋👩📖👭🏳️🌈
That’s in exchange of an honest review that I received an ARC of "Prize Money" by Celeste Castro from Interlude Press (via NetGalley).
So, here it is !!!
My rating : 2,5 ⭐️
I hear about Celeste Castro since a while now but that’s actually the first time I’m able to read a book of hers … I’m glad I did since I love discovering new authors (at least new to me). There’s a lot of potential here, that’s for sure, but what could have been a great book, is, sadly, just an average one …
The story sets in Idaho and focuses on Toma Rozene, an equestrian stuntwoman fresh off the set of a blockbuster film, turned bullfighter & Eva Angeles a double champion of barrel-racing & local farmer … Toma is called home by a family emergency to help run the family business: rescuing fallen rodeo riders before blustering bulls and bucking broncos trample their dreams. But she leaves LA for various other reasons, reasons playing tricks on her state of mind, so she doesn’t know where to go from there …
They meet briefly on the flight bringing them both home. They think they’ll never see each other again … Until, Toma saves Eva from impending disaster caused by a bull on the loose….
The "Pros" :
° the cover
° the original rodeo backdrop & the atmosphere (it’s quite unusual and unique from my POV : I don’t know a lot about barrel racing and bullfighting since it’s not a thing in France)
° the “western” settings (a universe full of the horses, cowgirls, rodeo, wild mustangs, etc… WOW !! When I think about it, sleeping under the stars with wild mustangs, that must so cool !!! )
° both MCs are WOC coming from "minorities" …
° the author's good touches of smart-ass humor (the banters between Toma and her brothers, especially her twin, Tito, were very funny … and what to say about Eva's grandmother, LOL)
° the slow-burn side of the romance
° the good supporting characters, like Tito or Eva's grandmother (she made me laugh, I really liked her, she’s a real firecracker!!)
The "In between" :
° the fluidness of the dialogues which were, sometimes, confusing during some of the back and forths… I mean by that that it was a tad difficult to properly distinguish who was speaking…
° the dialogues in Spanish … I don’t get why there were so many sentences in this language, (sentences which I doubt were that important to the story). I mean, that’s not often but when it happens to have a character talking another native language, the author indicates that English is not this character’s mother tongue and go with the broken English … why not going with this all along ?? Especially since it was quite funny …
° the Wonder Woman fangirling was quite annoying … (especially when you know that in the movie Diana character’s personality is not respected since her bisexuality, which is clearly defined in the comic book, is hidden and she appears as a very naïve straight woman … )
The "Cons" :
° the MCs' lack of depth due to the lack of a real character development. Both MCs have seemingly an interesting background but we can only guess about it … and without knowing it, we can’t understand them fully and appreciate their evolution. They are both women, lesbians, both from a different ethnic minority & evolve in a macho environment (just read about the way Pierson Price, the self-proclaimed voice of the rodeo, talk about competitors from both genders …). I think it’s weird that in there, it feels surprizingly (unbelievably) natural and noones call them on this whereas it’s not the case in real life … In addition, they have their respective adult life (one more "grown-up" than the other since she was far from her family, but still) which forged them as well … It would have been interesting to know more about their past and also more about their internal battles (Toma’s one due to her profession and her bad break-up) and their dreams (especially Eva’s one which would have involved more time spent in the wild working on her project) because it would have allowed the to connect more with the MCs and better get their supposedly great chemistery and why they are so good for one another …
° the story is quite cute but it’s also and mainly lame in a way due to the lack of real angst … for example : when it comes to the chain of incidents regarding the open gates occuring in the arena (for me, it looked like someone intentionally trying to wreak havoc and maybe take out one or even several of the other competitors). Yeah, for a short while, it added a lil bit of mystery to the story but it was really disappointing when, instead of a villain trying to undermine Eva’s path toward her potential third world champion barrel racer title or Toma’s family to perform their new move for the saves, it just happened for a banal reason and then everyone just seemed to forget about it and move on. Same about Eva’s main rival, Melissa … Melissa could have been an "evil queen" (the instigator of the incidents maybe ??), but nope, they became friends, laugh and hug and that’s all…Duh !! I think the author missed (big time) a good opportunity to develop those potential obstacles which could have given a very interesting sub-plot …
° the definitely unsafe first intimate encounter … Seriously ???? Aiming straight to the G-Spot without any washing involved, this after having attended to a celebratory party, spent a huge part of the evening dancing with a lot of different women in a lesbian bar and, so, touched a lot of various things & then come in the hotel room from the bar in a cab + an elevator (a public since it’s the hotel’s lift), that’s yucky as hell …. And not the best way to begin an intimate love life unless the best gift you want to offer your new partner is a vaginal thrush or a huge bacterial vaginosis (which is, without kidding, potentially deadly... JS) 🤢🤮. Even with a shower involved (which can be SUPER SEXY, BTW), it can be risky but, try this with no shower / no clean-up option in real life and I'm not sure you'll stay long without a "delicacy" or the lady…
° the bloody "black moment" happening somewhere between the 90% and the 95% mark. I hate those moments, and even more when they arrive this late in the book and for no good reasons… And don’t make me start about its way too quick resolution to allow a credible ending …
° speaking of an ending … there’s a huge lack of epilogue here …. Having one, escpecially considering the relative shortness of the book and after a so late black moment, would have given the readers the feeling to have a more finished business. Fast forwarding in time could have told us if the MCs had a real HEA or just a HFN (a proposal is not the assurance of a wedding), with their projects and dreams realised despite the obstacles …
° receiving such ARC copy has been very unpleasant because at this high level of "uncorrectedness", it has quickly become painful to read the novel … Yeah, I know, about the novel received, , it’s said clearly that "THIS IS AN ADVANCED, UNCORRECTED READER’S PROOF." (hard to miss since it's in captitals) but seeing so many typos, mistakes, missing words, overuse of some words, repetitions of verbs or the use of the wrong ones + a messy punctuation or the use of "then" instead of "than" (you name it !!! ) at this stade of the book (very shortly before release date), that’s quite surprising, frustrating and, let’s say it, frightening !!! The list of errors of all kind is impressively long (too long !!), and I really wonder if there has been any beta reading or editing done at all … I sure hope there has been a hell of an edition work done since this crappy version as been sent out because, otherwise (& considering all the other point mentioned), this potentially great book will stay a quite average one, wasted by a crappy edition work. That’s a shame that the publisher isn’t able to provide a real "finished product" for us to be able to really appreciate the quality of the author’s work and her real talent…
Personal note : by fear to not see those too numerous things properly corrected, I’d be tempted to never buy the paperback. I wouldn’t want to waste my money in a book so full of mistakes ... The only thing I’d like to do with it is dump it (I’m serious, I already dumped a bunch of paperbacks because of their crappy edition works …)
If I had to make a very short and quite different version of my review, it’d be something like this :
- Did I enjoy this book? => Nope, not really
- Did I find the characters believable? => Nope, because they lack of depth due the lack of a proper character development
- Is this book now included in my "must be re-read"-list? => Nope, unless a very thoroughly edited (and completed) version is released someday…
- Will I purchase the paperback? => Nope, unless a very thoroughly edited (and completed) version is released someday…
- Would I read another book by this author? => I’ll give her another try, someday …
- Would I recommend this book => Nope, but I’ll let people use their free will to read the novel, or not …
🏳️🌈👩❤👩📚⚢🤠🐃🐎👩❤💋👩📖👭🏳️🌈