I have only read one other book by Sam Carrington - I Dare You - which I loved so much I awarded it 5 stars.
I therefore had high hopes for The Open House. I enjoyed the way the scene was set, a house in the village of Stockwood, on the Apple Grove estate, which once belonged to Barb Miller until she sold it to son Nick and his wife Amber to raise their family in, two gorgeous boys Finley and Leo. The trouble is that is about where the idyll ends for we join the family in the middle of a divorce and a frustrated Amber because the house won't sell. She needs the house to sell in order to move away from Devon and start a new life with the boys and new beau Richard. They are headed for Kent where Richard already lives and works but my heart from the start wasn't in tune with this new relationship, romantic me wanted all to work out for a reconciliation with police officer Nick. He seems to be about the only adult in the novel above suspicion, because this is a tale about people not being who you think they are.
Barb, once a local councillor, is all out to stop any proposed building development going ahead in the village and is desperate to see Amber and the children stay because she doesn't want to lose her grandsons. She has already suffered a huge loss over the years as her eldest son Tim went missing, never to return, at the age of 17 and she is also a widow. This makes the reader empathise with Barb but only to a point as she also seems to be the class mother-in-law from hell, interfering and always knowing best.
Keen to move things along, Amber reluctantly agrees to an open house to prompt suitable buyers to come forward. Carl Anderson is the estate agent at Move Horizon who instigates this initiative and he is the one standing on the doorstep on the day of the event welcoming 13 people into the property.
Amber has the SmartRing app which means she can see who is at the door even though she is not present during the open house. She only counts 12 people coming back out though and that is where the story really begins, one of sinister goings on which unsettle and upset Amber, make her feel unsafe and make her question her sanity. Enter also pretty much the whole cast of the novel as perfectly plausible suspects in this living nightmare and you have page after page of people who could be doing everything they can to either stop any prospective sale from going ahead or prevent the family from moving out. But which is it? And who is it?
Could it be a ghost, poltergeist or real person moving furniture, taking things, breaking the doorbell and standing at the foot of the bed? And why? It is chilling and oh-so-addictively thrilling to read. I often make notes as I read to help me when I write reviews and I got to the point where there were so many crossings out with regards to who I thought was playing a devilishly dark game. I changed my mind so may times. As for working out why, my jottings were indecipherable!
Carrington happily litters the novel with red herrings and a box full of twists. These didn't get packed up when Nick had to move out of the marital home, but once those flaps were lifted, oh my goodness, the twists spewed out all over the place.
There was one right at the end which was pure genius (and leaves a terrible lump in the pit of your stomach) but it is hard to adequately explain why I felt some of the twists should not have been kept, but discarded on the moving-out skip, as I have no desire to spoil the plot for anyone. The trouble is, most of the twists became too many and too implausible. I was heading for a 5 star review and then sadly I feel the ending ran away, spiralling out of control. Yes, there were some brilliantly hidden connections and the novel did keep me on the edge of my seat, but the decisions made by the core characters near the end were monstrous, and just seemed too over the top for what had been, until this point, a dark but believable tale.
It wasn't just the decisions, it was who made them and the consequences after the reader finishes the last page that seemed out of tune with the rest of the story. The genius final twist almost pulled it back for me, but sadly on this occasion, it wasn't quite enough. And this last point is purely personal, but I would have preferred a different outcome in terms of Amber and Nick's family. I therefore award this book 4 stars.
I would still highly recommend this book to others and highly recommend the author to others. It certainly hasn't stopped me from hunting out the Sam Carrington books I have still to read, and placing them near the top of a ridiculously long books-to-be-read list though!
Thank you to the author, publisher and Netgalley for the chance to read this book in exchange for this, my honest review.