Thanks to NetGalley and Minotaur for the chance to read these samples! But of course this is also available as a free e-book on retail sites as well.
This sampler of cozy mysteries--just the first few chapters of each book--is a great reminder that even within the cozy mystery subgenre there is a lot of variety. I am pretty picky about mysteries but enjoyed the chance to try some things I wouldn't have otherwise.
A DECEPTION AT THORNECREST: AN AMORY AMES MYSTERY by Ashely Weaver
Cover: gives a nice sense of time and place, with the car, the fashions, and the estate. I love the stylized illustration and the texture generated by the shadows on the clothing
Story: 1930s England: Our heroine Amory Ames is 8 months pregnant when another woman comes to her house claiming to be married to the same man. We don't see the husband until the end of the excerpt, but I imagine for people who have read earlier books in the series it's much more easy to trust the husband's integrity. Amory was much too trusting of the woman's story for my taste (she shows the stranger a picture of the man, instead of testing her). And at the end we get a hint of family drama, which seems like it will be a heavy element in the mystery.
Would I Read It: this didn't grab my attention, but fans of Downton Abbey might like it
HIDDEN TREASURE: A JOSIE PRESCOTT ANTIQUES MYSTERY by Jane K Cleland
Cover: features an ancient Egyptian box, which fits with the antiques theme. It's placed a windowsill overlooking a nice landscape, I really liked the clean design and use of perspective
Story: Our heroine Josie has recently bought a house from an older woman, and the woman's relatives are claiming there is a forgotten item. They are seriously annoying -- one even waltzes into the house using a key, claiming the doorbell didn't work (obviously not bothering to knock), and I loved that Josie was not a pushover, and got the locks changed, and generally treated them coolly but professionally. When she actually did find the forgotten item, hidden in an obscure place, she videotaped and measured everything and I wanted to cheer for someone taking care to document things.
Would I Read It: Yes! I love how smart and professional our heroine is. Bonus, there are cats, including a black kitty with a white triangle just like my girl
IN A MIDNIGHT WOOD: A JANE LAWLESS MYSTERY by Ellen Hart
Cover: what I think of as classic cozy mystery, with skull icons woven into an innocuous scene (hotel room, class reunion invitation)
Story: We open with a prologue of the victim twenty years ago, then jump to present day. There are a lot of different POVs in the sample and it felt like we hardly got to know our detective Jane. I also felt a little disappointed that it seems like even though she is a PI, she is more interested in her true crime podcast (I like fictional mysteries and hate true crime, I read cozies because they're so removed from reality!)
Would I Read It: this wasn't for me, with all of the different POVs and hints at sinister doings. I am intrigued, though, that there is a reference to a book of poetry called IN A MIDNIGHT WOOD (like the book title!), maybe there are clues in it
A GARLAND OF BONES by Carolyn Haines
Cover: this is a very silly cartoon cover which gives a good flavor of the book! the dog with reindeer ears is a nice touch, as is the caution tape around the Christmas tree
Story: This opening was stuffed with wacky hijinks and it was too over the top for me, especially the paranormal element with a talkative but cryptic ghost.
Would I Read It: this didn't fit my sense of humor, but I can see where the chaos and silliness would provide a nice screwball escape for other readers
THE GIFT OF THE MAGPIE: A MEG LANGSLOW MYSTERY by Donna Andrews
Cover: I love that we have three birds with crowns to add to the Magi pun
Story: This wasn't quite as wacky as the GARLAND OF BONES excerpt, but any book that opens on talking about cow manure clearly is not taking itself too seriously! This seems very small town, with a colorful cast of characters that all know each other and have a charity project to help out.
Would I Read It: this didn't grab my interest, but the cover copy mentions this is the 28th book so I wonder if it would be easier to start earlier in the series
A WHISKER OF A DOUBT: A CAT CAFE MYSTERY by Cate Conte
Cover: kitty in the snow!
Story: A local wealthy neighborhood is cranky about volunteers coming in to care for a feral cat colony. Our heroine owns a cat cafe and her volunteer list has dwindled lately, so she needs to go out in the snow to provide food for the poor things. And stumbles upon one of the grumpy neighbors. Then we flash back two weeks and see some more grumpiness.
Would I Read It: I have heart eyes because of the cat rescuers, so probably, though the structure of the flashback is annoying as I prefer my stories to progress linearly
WITHOUT A BREW by Ellie Alexander
Cover: super fun, with spilled beer glass and soft pretzels. I was immediately hungry, so that's a good sign!
Story: Our heroine Sloan is a brewmaster who is opening up a small bed-and-breakfast with beer-themed rooms. They're opening next week but all the local hotels are full and a bunch of people come in to fill up the rooms. One group is so obnoxious that the story was hard to read! And we have a mysterious woman who is new to town but seems to know and have beefs with everyone she runs into. You can tell this isn't going to end well!
Would I Read It: this isn't for me, but beer aficionados will love all the descriptions of the brewery, the beer-infused cooking, and the beer-themed B&B (rooms are inspired by the four elements of hops, grain, yeast, and water)
BENDING THE PAW by Diane Kelly
Cover: very cute German shepherd did NOT prepare me for the darkness of the story!
Story: We have 2 chapters from our bad guy's POV, which is a deal-breaker for me, that's way too un-cozy for my taste. The story is fairly violent and bloody so far, and the presence of a workplace harasser (our heroine Megan is a police officer) is just another stressor I didn't need.
Would I Read It: way too stressful for me, but other more adventurous souls may enjoy it. I do adore the idea that the heroine and her love interest both have working dogs, though I'm mixed on the chapter from the K9 point of view
THREAD AND DEAD: THE APRON SHOP SERIES
Cover: very cute, with a beautiful sense of detail and perspective as we have a cat perched on a windowsill looking into a shop with pretty aprons
Story: Our heroine Iris owns a vintage apron and linens shop, which is not something I would ever have thought of, but I'm excited to get to read some lovely clothing detail. An old woman in a nearby town calls her up, as she's discovered some interesting items when cleaning her house including some mysterious designer clothing. This was very cozy so far, no murder yet, and seems there will be an element of historical mystery as the old woman talks about the family history and doesn't know how her mother, who was originally a nursemaid, ended up with all this fancy clothing.
Would I Read It: I'm tentatively interested, especially if we keep getting more lovely textile descriptions
KILLER KUNG PAO: A NOODLE SHOP MYSTERY by Vivien Chien
Cover: another cozy classic, with a Chinese restaurant layout and skull icons woven in
Story: I was instantly won over by our heroine Lana Lee wanting to dye her hair metallic gray as she reminded me of my sister. Her voice is friendly and fun and made the excerpt zip along.
Would I Read It: yes, I like being in our heroine's head
THE MAN IN THE MICROWAVE OVEN by Susan Cox
Cover: this does not have very strong genre signals, as it's just a street scene
Story: Our heroine is hiding her identity, which is inconvenient when she discovers a neighborhood nuisance's body. She is irritated that people are suspicious of her assumed last name Bogart, which is very silly because it was not a great pick if you were aiming for an unremarkable name. Also, her love interest is from Texas and there is a lot of droppin' g's in the dialogue, which is a pet peeve of mine.
Would I Read This: this isn't for me, but others may enjoy the San Francisco setting, or the promise of secret family drama with the heroine's rich estranged English family
Overall: Even though most of these were set in present day, there was plenty of variety in tone and themes, enough that fans of mysteries from the silly to the serious should find an upcoming release to be interested in.