From the Desk of Zoe Washington consistently popped up in conversations during the year 2020 about which juvenile novel would win the Newbery Medal. It was Janae Marks's first book, but that hadn't stopped other authors from winning the highest award in American youth literature. Ultimately, it didn't get the Newbery, but after reading this book I see why so many believed it worthy. As she turns twelve years old, Zoe has plenty of goals for herself. One of the most audacious is earning a spot on the Kids Bake Challenge!, a Food Network reality television show for aspiring preteen chefs. Yet her focus on this goal dims when Zoe checks the daily mail on her birthday and finds a letter from her father, Marcus...who has spent the past dozen years in prison for murder.
Zoe's mother and stepfather have never been keen on discussing Marcus, and Zoe hesitates to read his letter. Marcus never contacted her before; is he dangerous? Knowing that her mother would probably confiscate the letter, Zoe secretly reads it on her own. Marcus's words seem kind and warm, not at all like a cold-blooded killer. He mentions sending previous letters—whatever happened to those?—and says he wishes he were free so he could be part of her life. Zoe loves her stepfather as her true dad, but part of her is curious to know her biological father. Would her mother let Zoe write back to Marcus?
Her mother reacts with suspicion when Zoe casually mentions Marcus one day, so she drops the subject. Without asking permission, Zoe composes a letter back to Marcus, acknowledging his message and asking a few questions. As the two continue trading letters, Zoe fears her mother will discover the deception, but instead it's Zoe's maternal grandmother who finds out what's going on. Grandma knew Marcus well when he was married to her daughter, and her opinion of him isn't as low as Zoe's mother's. Marcus isn't a manipulator, Grandma says; in fact, she doesn't believe he's a murderer. Twelve years ago after police arrested Marcus for killing that woman, he insisted he had an alibi. It was never substantiated, but Grandma has doubted his guilt ever since. Now that he and Zoe are communicating for the first time, she doesn't want to jeopardize that by alerting Zoe's mother. Grandma reluctantly agrees to keep the secret, on two conditions: that Zoe allow Grandma to read every letter Marcus writes, and that Zoe promises to tell her mother the truth before summer ends. Zoe relaxes a bit: for the moment, she can continue getting to know Marcus.
After all these years, Marcus still maintains he's innocent. He tells Zoe he went to a tag sale the morning of the murder, but when he relayed that piece of information to his public defender attorney prior to the trial, the man dismissed it out of hand. He seemed convinced of Marcus's guilt, and put minimal effort into keeping him out of prison. When the jury handed down a guilty verdict, Marcus appealed through legal channels, but he never had a chance without that witness from the tag sale, and he's given up hope of proving himself innocent. He's eligible for parole after twenty-five years, he assures Zoe; maybe then they'll see each other for the first time in person. Father and daughter together, as they should have been all along.
Hiding all this from her parents is hard on Zoe, but her mother's attitude toward Marcus makes it clear she wouldn't tolerate any communication between Zoe and him. Zoe adores her stepfather and considers him her dad in almost every way, but her connection to Marcus remains despite never meeting him. She finds out from his letters that he shares her love of baking; he enthusiastically supports her dream to appear on the Kids Bake Challenge!, and encourages her to create an original, innovative recipe to wow the judges. Marcus also does his part to further Zoe's music education, suggesting some of his favorite songs from his own adolescence. "My Little Tomato," Marcus fondly calls her in his letters, and whenever Zoe listens to her "Little Tomato Playlist" of the songs he has recommended, she feels close to her biological father as she never thought possible. Could this gentle, generous man have murdered a young woman, and be lying to Zoe about it? Or was he victim of a justice system stacked against him? As weeks pass and Zoe's loyalty to Marcus grows, she can't bring herself to sit back and wait for a parole that may never come. If no one else is interested in saving Marcus, she'll do it herself.
Her relationships with her mother and grandmother aren't the only ones under stress. Summer after summer, Zoe's best friend has been Trevor, whose family lives in the other half of their divided two-family house. Lately Trevor is more interested in hanging out with guys from his basketball team, and not long ago Zoe overheard him talking about her in a very unflattering way. If that's how Trevor sees her, she doesn't want to be friends, but as she commits more and more to proving Marcus innocent, Trevor may be the only one willing to do whatever she needs to free her father. Marcus tells Zoe the name of the woman he claimed could vouch for his whereabouts at the time of the murder all those years ago, but he urges Zoe to forget about his problems and enjoy her life. She isn't responsible for engineering his freedom, and he doesn't want to get her into a messy situation. Zoe has no intention of standing pat; an internet search reveals a few possible leads on this "Susan Thomas" whom Marcus says he met at a tag sale on the morning in question. The most promising lead Zoe has is a professor by that name at Harvard University, a short train ride from where Zoe lives in Boston, but does she have the gumption to sneak away to Harvard by herself and question a stranger? Is Marcus's freedom worth betraying the trust of her own mother and grandmother?
If Zoe can't prove Marcus innocent before her mother finds out she's been corresponding with him, she'll never be allowed to write him again. It's a tense journey downtown and then on the train to Harvard's huge campus, but Zoe isn't alone. An unexpected friend is willing to take the risk with her, to search for a woman who, in all likelihood, won't remember Marcus at all. Time is of the essence to get to Harvard, interview Susan Thomas, and be home before Zoe's mother or Grandma realize she's missing, but Marcus's future depends on it. Zoe may be about to find out the truth, a truth bigger than a twelve-year-old is capable of carrying by herself. Is Marcus a liar, or was he railroaded for a crime he didn't commit? Is he a monster, or just a man abandoned twelve years ago by everyone he knew? Zoe is the only one with both means and motive to end an injustice older than she is.
The mountain Zoe seeks to climb is a real Everest. Would her mother consider the possibility of Marcus's innocence if good evidence is presented, or is she convinced beyond all reasoning that he's evil? Grandma has been hesitant to conceal that Zoe is writing to Marcus; if she finds out Zoe is taking personal risks to exonerate him from decades-old murder charges, will she forbid her from communicating with Marcus at all? Lawyers don't seem to care that Marcus may have gotten a raw deal during his trial, and Zoe can't expect a Harvard professor with no personal ties to Marcus to be deeply invested in an old, settled criminal case. Zoe's parents and Grandma love her deeply, but she feels alone defending Marcus. Yet in Zoe, we see what a determined heart can do when no one else believes. Marcus could easily have lived the rest of his life behind bars, but his future may radically change if Zoe's plan works out. Imagine an innocent man freed from his cage to be with his daughter again; what risk isn't worth that? If Zoe doesn't do it, no one else is lining up to, so it's hard to blame her for disobeying her parents and Grandma. The fate of an innocent man matters, especially if he's your father, and an act of childlike faith could restore to Zoe a part of her life she never knew was missing. What will be Marcus's fate, and Zoe's? The answer is in these pages.
Part of what makes From the Desk of Zoe Washington a splendid novel is the depth and variety of relationships. Zoe feels betrayed by Trevor before the book begins, but sees some signs that their friendship might not be dead. Will they ever be comfortable together as they used to be? The stain of hurt doesn't fade easily. "(I)t was like when you drew something in pencil and then tried to erase it—the pencil lines would mostly go away, but sometimes the indent would still be there, so you could still sort of see what had been erased." Losing her friend permanently is more than Zoe can handle at the moment; perhaps the friendship can be saved if they both need it enough. "Maybe the pencil marks couldn't be erased, but at some point, you could decide to turn to a new page." There is a future with Trevor as her friend, just as Zoe hopes the page can be turned on the ugly pencil marks marring Marcus's past. She can help him flip to a clean page and start writing a more hopeful tomorrow. A happy ending is a lot to expect, but if the miraculous occurs it will be because Zoe believed it could happen and did whatever it took to get there. Saviors come in all shapes, sizes, and ages.
If From the Desk of Zoe Washington had won the 2021 Newbery Medal, I would applaud the selection. Janae Marks writes with beauty, power, and pride, creating wondrously real characters and a situation filled with such moral complexity that there's no telling what the right thing is to do. Is Zoe justified in ignoring her mother's wishes, and Grandma's, to pursue the lead on Marcus's alibi? True, she owes her parents obedience, but if Marcus is innocent then he deserves redress for his wrongful conviction, and who will help him get it if not Zoe? No one else has looked into the facts of his case for more than a decade. The labyrinth of ethical and moral concerns is smartly constructed, stressful though the experience can be while reading. Janae Marks's debut is a fine piece of literature, and part of me wants to rate it three and a half stars. A novel this good doesn't mosey along every day, so when it does, enjoy it. I certainly did.