This is hard to give a star rating as it's so well put together but the content makes this one of the most utterly painful books I've ever sat through.
This is one of those oral histories, which I've only ever really listened to in audio format in the past (see This Searing Light: The Sun and Everything Else: Joy Division: The Oral History, which I found to be a good listen in the background whilst doing chores or gaming). It's good to dip in and out of. I have chronic fatigue syndrome, and on bad days I can find it hard to focus on something with a through narrative, so this found a place as a book for when I wanted to read something, as opposed to listen, but something easy that doesn't require much brain power. That's not where my issue with the book lies, not at all. It's fantastically compiled and must have been a gargantuan task to undertake, but it's the quotes themselves and the people interviewed that just made this so unlikable.
Take for example the chapter about football and Italia 90. Now, I'm not very well versed in football history, aside from conversations I've had with my dad who is intensely knowledgeable on the topic. David Baddiel, who, quite frankly has had zero character development since the early 90s, and I fear if he were to fall victim to a brain-eating amoeba, the amoeba would starve rapidly, talks about how, suddenly, it was acceptable to be a man who likes women, football, and beer. This threw me. When has it ever NOT been acceptable to be a man who likes these things? I posted this to my Twitter to share my confusion and a friend of mine who was actually around at the time proposed perhaps he is referring to the 1980s idea of the "New Man", but that ultimately, it still comes across the same as people today going on about how "woke culture" has ruined things. A few pages on, Baddiel elaborates further, using the example that football was now becoming separated from the idea of "hooliganism", and uses the Hillsborough tragedy as an example. If you don't know, in short, this was a disaster where 96 people, including children, lost their lives in a crowd crush due to poor crowd control and police incompetence. Of course, the fans got the blame, and The Sun newspaper ran with false headlines about fans supposedly pickpocketing the dead. This is why The Sun is no longer sold in Liverpool.
Basically this is an incredibly tone deaf example for him to use.
What he means is that football became gentrified. It was acceptable for middle class men to like football, now. Irvine Welsh points this out, and I'm actually a little resentful that I agree with Irvine Welsh on something.
Baddiel later goes on to once again defend his infamously racist caricature of Jason Lee on Fantasy Football League, saying that "it was nothing to do with him being black, it was because he was a shit footballer", whilst Baddiel was in blackface, fake dreadlocks and with a fucking pineapple on his head. Then he only apologised when he had a documentary to plug in 2022.
This is a theme throughout the perspectives offered throughout the book. It's all very male, white, and most of all, middle class, and, unsurprisingly pro-establishment. There are some women included, but the lack of quotes from people like Justine Frischmann (who is spoken about as a mere object and is never given the opportunity to speak for herself) and in particular Miki Berenyi, who's 2022 memoir Fingers Crossed completely burns to the ground any last vestiges of the idea of "cool Britannia" not being a breeding ground for misogyny and racism. She even calls out certain musicians by by name for their sexual harassment. Alex James, who was already known to be a violent misogynist in the 90s according to forum posts on Internet Archive dating from around 1996, as well as Graham Coxon and the Gallaghers. The way women's experiences with these men have been completely silenced is unspeakably frustrating.
I've had this joke for a few years now that Britpop was a government psyop, and I'm starting to think there might be some truth to the joke.
Tjinder Singh offers a really refreshing perspective on the use of the Union Flag and its connotations and his experiences as a British Asian in the supposedly progressive 1990s, and as always Jarvis Cocker, Brett Anderson and Jane Savidge have some really great quotes, though being a proud Suede super-fan who has seen them 21 times since 2019 and writes a blog about them, I might be a little bit biased. Anderson in particular does a great job of dismantling the misconception that Suede were trying to resist American Grunge in some way. Anyone who has analysed Suede beyond a surface level can see the clear grunge influence on their sound. He disparages the front cover of his image superimposed over a Union Flag with the headline "yanks go home", which is something he would never say, through the front cover gives the impression of a pull quote. Anderson, and all of Suede, have always been keen to distance themselves from Britpop, and a lot of people ask why this is. They've been vocal in how they feel it was nationalistic and there was a streak of misogyny which made them deeply uncomfortable to be associated with.
I enjoyed the chapter on Asian British culture a lot, but overall this just felt like a load of middle class people having a coked up conversation in a club like nodding dogs.