What do you think?
Rate this book
Inspector James Given #1
A Shadowed Livery
Warwickshire, England, 1938
While Hitler and Chamberlain are preparing to sign the Munich agreement, the murderer of a Jewish shopkeeper is being hanged in Birmingham.
After witnessing the execution, Inspector James Given, who brought the killer to justice, is surprised to find he has been taken off the investigation to pursue something completely different.
Grovestock House, owned by the wealthy Barleigh family has witnessed a triple death.
With the terrible events neatly written off as a murder and a double suicide, Given is supposed to tidy up a few loose ends with the help of local constable, John Sawyer.
But Given is sure there is more to the case than meets the eye.
What dark secrets were the Barleigh family hiding? Could there be another killer involved?
And how will Given react when he is forced to confront the ghosts of his past…?
While Hitler and Chamberlain are preparing to sign the Munich agreement, the murderer of a Jewish shopkeeper is being hanged in Birmingham.
After witnessing the execution, Inspector James Given, who brought the killer to justice, is surprised to find he has been taken off the investigation to pursue something completely different.
Grovestock House, owned by the wealthy Barleigh family has witnessed a triple death.
With the terrible events neatly written off as a murder and a double suicide, Given is supposed to tidy up a few loose ends with the help of local constable, John Sawyer.
But Given is sure there is more to the case than meets the eye.
What dark secrets were the Barleigh family hiding? Could there be another killer involved?
And how will Given react when he is forced to confront the ghosts of his past…?
276 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 1, 2015
180 people are currently reading
236 people want to read
About the author
Charlie Garratt
12 books18 followersCharlie Garratt is a crime and historical novelist. He has published seven books.
They include the Inspector James Given series, the Meg Valentine Mysteries series and a family saga, A Handkerchief for Maria, a novel based on research in to his own family.
Three of his short stories are included in a collection, Wild Atlantic Words, fifteen tales drawing from life along the west coast of Ireland. One of his short stories won the Read LK competition in 2013.
His most recent book is The Thief-Taker’s Apprentice, a mystery set in 18th century Shropshire.
Charlie is also author and co-author of a number of books and guides on community participation.
Take a look at his website at charliegarratt.com or sign up for his newsletter, Struggling for Words, at charliegarratt.substack.com.
They include the Inspector James Given series, the Meg Valentine Mysteries series and a family saga, A Handkerchief for Maria, a novel based on research in to his own family.
Three of his short stories are included in a collection, Wild Atlantic Words, fifteen tales drawing from life along the west coast of Ireland. One of his short stories won the Read LK competition in 2013.
His most recent book is The Thief-Taker’s Apprentice, a mystery set in 18th century Shropshire.
Charlie is also author and co-author of a number of books and guides on community participation.
Take a look at his website at charliegarratt.com or sign up for his newsletter, Struggling for Words, at charliegarratt.substack.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews
August 15, 2019
Sometimes you receive more than you expect when you choose a book ... I hoped for a decent read, however, Mr Garratt offered me much more - a real treat!
England 1938. The story of a seemingly obvious murder and two suicides in the depth of the English countryside arises some suspicion in Inspector James Given. Acting on a hunch, he uncovers long hidden truth. The plot sounds very much like Agatha Christie, and the novel is written in the style which reminds us of Old Masters of the genre. The narration flows smoothly, and with all plots nicely interwoven, the novel is a rewarding read.
A special mention of good social and historical backgrounds: they are not just to fit the genre template. The feel of post-Munich England is there, together with the insight into the first and second generations of immigrants, and the hints of the tragic future for the German Jews.
England 1938. The story of a seemingly obvious murder and two suicides in the depth of the English countryside arises some suspicion in Inspector James Given. Acting on a hunch, he uncovers long hidden truth. The plot sounds very much like Agatha Christie, and the novel is written in the style which reminds us of Old Masters of the genre. The narration flows smoothly, and with all plots nicely interwoven, the novel is a rewarding read.
A special mention of good social and historical backgrounds: they are not just to fit the genre template. The feel of post-Munich England is there, together with the insight into the first and second generations of immigrants, and the hints of the tragic future for the German Jews.
August 16, 2019
This is a historical mystery in the tradition of the golden age of crime, with the country house and a host of suspects, set in Warwickshire in the troubled times before WW2 in 1938. It begins with DI James Given witnessing the hanging of one of two men he had arrested for beating a Jewish butcher to death. There is more work to be done on the case, but Given is moved to another inquiry by Superintendent Dyer, one which requires him to evaluate whether the police were correct in laying to rest the death of three people at Grovestock House, the home of the wealthy Sir Arthur Barleigh and his family, assumed from the available evidence to be a murder-suicide, and suicide. However, the media thinks there has been a cover up, so Given makes his way there, working with the young local village policeman, John Sawyer, who had taken photographs of the crime scenes.
Lady Isabelle had shot her disabled son, Tom, unhappy about his imminent marriage, and then killed herself straight after. The apparently distraught beautiful fiancee, Jenny Bamford, then kills herself with a gun in her bedroom. A gardening boy, Billy Sharp, has gone missing as has Tom's nurse, Trudi Collinge. As Given goes over the evidence in detail and interviews the relevant individuals, everything seems to be in order, but he can feel something is not right and that he is looking at murder. To make matters worse, he is shocked that the woman he wanted to marry but who ran away from him, Elizabeth Parry is the housekeeper, a suspect for whom he still has feelings. Given's background and identity is particularly relevant given the growth of Hitler and fascism in Germany and the rising number of attacks on Jews in Britain, all of which has personal implications for him and his family.
Garratt writes a well plotted historical mystery set amidst the turbulent pre-war times, involving Special Branch and the intelligence services in Given's case. The diligent and determined Given eventually uncovers dangerous family secrets and plenty of intrigue, in a story of class and family. This is an entertaining and engaging read which I very much enjoyed, with its details of the historical period and with a upcoming war on the horizon. Many thanks to Sapere Books for an ARC.
Lady Isabelle had shot her disabled son, Tom, unhappy about his imminent marriage, and then killed herself straight after. The apparently distraught beautiful fiancee, Jenny Bamford, then kills herself with a gun in her bedroom. A gardening boy, Billy Sharp, has gone missing as has Tom's nurse, Trudi Collinge. As Given goes over the evidence in detail and interviews the relevant individuals, everything seems to be in order, but he can feel something is not right and that he is looking at murder. To make matters worse, he is shocked that the woman he wanted to marry but who ran away from him, Elizabeth Parry is the housekeeper, a suspect for whom he still has feelings. Given's background and identity is particularly relevant given the growth of Hitler and fascism in Germany and the rising number of attacks on Jews in Britain, all of which has personal implications for him and his family.
Garratt writes a well plotted historical mystery set amidst the turbulent pre-war times, involving Special Branch and the intelligence services in Given's case. The diligent and determined Given eventually uncovers dangerous family secrets and plenty of intrigue, in a story of class and family. This is an entertaining and engaging read which I very much enjoyed, with its details of the historical period and with a upcoming war on the horizon. Many thanks to Sapere Books for an ARC.
January 11, 2022
A very enjoyable first book.
January 18, 2023
I struggled to get into this historical mystery and then found that the narrative was not as interesting as I hoped. In my opinion, the story went round in a lot of circles – which I think Given felt too – and I thought there could have been more suspense building along the way instead.
The key element that really interested me was the historical backdrop of the story. Set in 1938, Garratt makes many, detailed references to the building tensions in Europe and how the Prime Minister had claimed that war with Germany had been avoided. Yet, Given’s family background demonstrates that no one feels safe anymore and I was interested in how this showed social unrest in England. Furthermore, the growing unrest towards Germany fuels Given’s determination to solve the murder and double suicide in Warwickshire and, when the Epilogue was reached, I could not help but feel shivers down my spine at the newspaper report of such a harrowing incident that took place throughout Germany.
In terms of the crimes themselves, I thought the novel got off to a strong start but it failed to hold my attention. Poor Given makes many enquiries and I felt as frustrated as himself at the frequent dead-ends he found himself at. Although the list of suspects continued to grow, Given could not rule anyone out nor prioritise someone with enough motive to be involved in the crimes. In this way, I thought the plot to be quite tedious and lengthy; this was not aided by the extensive dialogue that did not seem to uncover any clues.
I think I enjoyed Garratt’s writing style but was hoping for a plot with more pace and excitement. In some ways, it felt as sleepy as the Warwickshire village. The historical element significantly influenced my enjoyment of the novel and this is the major reason why I would try the second book in the series: I am hoping that the story is more exciting and the threat of war feeds into the narrative as well. As far as this crime novel goes, it wasn’t my favourite and it felt a bit old-fashioned.
With thanks to Sapere books for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
The key element that really interested me was the historical backdrop of the story. Set in 1938, Garratt makes many, detailed references to the building tensions in Europe and how the Prime Minister had claimed that war with Germany had been avoided. Yet, Given’s family background demonstrates that no one feels safe anymore and I was interested in how this showed social unrest in England. Furthermore, the growing unrest towards Germany fuels Given’s determination to solve the murder and double suicide in Warwickshire and, when the Epilogue was reached, I could not help but feel shivers down my spine at the newspaper report of such a harrowing incident that took place throughout Germany.
In terms of the crimes themselves, I thought the novel got off to a strong start but it failed to hold my attention. Poor Given makes many enquiries and I felt as frustrated as himself at the frequent dead-ends he found himself at. Although the list of suspects continued to grow, Given could not rule anyone out nor prioritise someone with enough motive to be involved in the crimes. In this way, I thought the plot to be quite tedious and lengthy; this was not aided by the extensive dialogue that did not seem to uncover any clues.
I think I enjoyed Garratt’s writing style but was hoping for a plot with more pace and excitement. In some ways, it felt as sleepy as the Warwickshire village. The historical element significantly influenced my enjoyment of the novel and this is the major reason why I would try the second book in the series: I am hoping that the story is more exciting and the threat of war feeds into the narrative as well. As far as this crime novel goes, it wasn’t my favourite and it felt a bit old-fashioned.
With thanks to Sapere books for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
December 13, 2022
This is one of many crime series that I have wanted to start for a while and I was excited to finally get around to it. The first featuring Inspector James Given, this mystery is set in 1938 and there are rumours of a possible war in Germany at a time when many of the characters involved were either directly involved in WWI or affected by it. Given himself is of a Jewish background, afraid for relatives in Germany and aware of police colleagues anti-Semitism.
Given finds himself pulled off a case to investigate three deaths at Grovestock House. A mother, Lady Isabelle Barleigh, who objected to her wheelchair bound stepson marrying, supposedly shot him and herself, while his intended wife also killed herself. With his own traumatic backstory and romantic entaglements to contend with, GIven tries to unravel the various characters involved and ascertain whether it was a tragedy or murder.
I did like the background and historical context, but couldn't find myself involved with either James Given or the other characters. As a reader I felt quite distant from events. However, I will probably try the second in the series and give it another try, as I do like mysteries set in that historical period.
Given finds himself pulled off a case to investigate three deaths at Grovestock House. A mother, Lady Isabelle Barleigh, who objected to her wheelchair bound stepson marrying, supposedly shot him and herself, while his intended wife also killed herself. With his own traumatic backstory and romantic entaglements to contend with, GIven tries to unravel the various characters involved and ascertain whether it was a tragedy or murder.
I did like the background and historical context, but couldn't find myself involved with either James Given or the other characters. As a reader I felt quite distant from events. However, I will probably try the second in the series and give it another try, as I do like mysteries set in that historical period.
August 7, 2019
Two suspects in the murder of a Jewish butcher are found guilty and sentenced to death. Unfortunately, the unknown man giving the orders to kill is still at large. Before he can continue his investigation, Inspector James Given is pulled off the case to look into another murder which is getting attention from the press. It looked like a clear-cut case of murder-suicide, followed by another suicide in the household at Grovestock House. However, as Given starts asking questions. he finds not all of the facts add up in this unusual case. Given himself has a mysterious background and his personal life ends up playing a key role in the mystery.
This historical mystery takes place in England in 1938 with the world on edge over events beginning to take place in Germany. James is a much more complex character than it first appears, and I enjoyed getting to know him better as the story progresses. I like how he and the local constable John Sawyer work together, even when they don’t always agree on the direction the investigation should take. There is a sense of foreboding at Grovestock and in general because of events occurring throughout Europe. From the clues provided, I was able to guess the motive of the deaths, but the book still held my interest from the beginning through to the very end. Although the case at Grovestock House is resolved, other things are still pending when the book ends, and I look forward to future books to see what happens next. “A Shadowed Livery” is a well-written, well-researched novel that is a great start to a new series.
I received this book through the courtesy of Sapere Books. The book was provided to me in exchange for an honest review.
This historical mystery takes place in England in 1938 with the world on edge over events beginning to take place in Germany. James is a much more complex character than it first appears, and I enjoyed getting to know him better as the story progresses. I like how he and the local constable John Sawyer work together, even when they don’t always agree on the direction the investigation should take. There is a sense of foreboding at Grovestock and in general because of events occurring throughout Europe. From the clues provided, I was able to guess the motive of the deaths, but the book still held my interest from the beginning through to the very end. Although the case at Grovestock House is resolved, other things are still pending when the book ends, and I look forward to future books to see what happens next. “A Shadowed Livery” is a well-written, well-researched novel that is a great start to a new series.
I received this book through the courtesy of Sapere Books. The book was provided to me in exchange for an honest review.
August 9, 2019
I would like to thank Sapere Books for an advance copy of A Shadowed Livery, the first novel to feature DI James Given, set in 1938 Warwickshire.
DI Given has just watched a man hang for the murder of a Jewish shopkeeper and is wondering how to find the ringleaders when he is sent to Grovestock House to re-investigate three deaths which had been quickly written off as a murder and two suicides, much to the disgust of the press. With no resources except the local bobby, John Sawyer, it is viewed as a PR exercise until Given starts to find anomalies.
I enjoyed A Shadowed Livery which is an old fashioned whodunnit with a myriad of suspects, few clues and a twisted motive. Reader beware - take nothing at face value. It is not entirely written in the classical style, however, as it is written in the first person from Given’s point of view and his backstory has its own subplot with several surprises. The main plot is initially very interesting and held my attention but it loses momentum by being slow to develop and overly obvious as I had a good idea of where it was going from about half way in. The subplot is sharper, more relevant and, for me, more surprising. I like the way it puts the perils of the era into a personal context as it brings them alive.
James Given is an interesting character with a good backstory. He’s an archetypal detective, smart and tenacious with hidden secrets and problems. I’d like to see more of him.
A Shadowed Livery is a solid start to what I assume will become a series.
DI Given has just watched a man hang for the murder of a Jewish shopkeeper and is wondering how to find the ringleaders when he is sent to Grovestock House to re-investigate three deaths which had been quickly written off as a murder and two suicides, much to the disgust of the press. With no resources except the local bobby, John Sawyer, it is viewed as a PR exercise until Given starts to find anomalies.
I enjoyed A Shadowed Livery which is an old fashioned whodunnit with a myriad of suspects, few clues and a twisted motive. Reader beware - take nothing at face value. It is not entirely written in the classical style, however, as it is written in the first person from Given’s point of view and his backstory has its own subplot with several surprises. The main plot is initially very interesting and held my attention but it loses momentum by being slow to develop and overly obvious as I had a good idea of where it was going from about half way in. The subplot is sharper, more relevant and, for me, more surprising. I like the way it puts the perils of the era into a personal context as it brings them alive.
James Given is an interesting character with a good backstory. He’s an archetypal detective, smart and tenacious with hidden secrets and problems. I’d like to see more of him.
A Shadowed Livery is a solid start to what I assume will become a series.
August 28, 2019
This historical murder mystery is set in 1938 in the brink of WWII. It has the trademarks of the golden age of murder mysteries - a country house, a detective w a complex personality, questionable murders, family secrets and some good old investigation work.
It gripped me from the start and kept my attention until the end with great narrative, nice flow, plots and sub plots. You could sense the intrigue all the way through.
I’m looking forward to reading more Inspector Given’s murder mysteries!
Thank you NetGalley and Sapere Books for the advanced copy!
It gripped me from the start and kept my attention until the end with great narrative, nice flow, plots and sub plots. You could sense the intrigue all the way through.
I’m looking forward to reading more Inspector Given’s murder mysteries!
Thank you NetGalley and Sapere Books for the advanced copy!
October 12, 2019
A Shadowed Livery by Charlie Garratt
Inspector James Given #1
Hanging by the neck till you are dead can’t be pleasant but it is not pleasant for the observer either. When Detective Inspector James Given leaves the hanging of a man he brought to justice he is unsettled even though he knew the man was guilty of murder. Returning to the office he is sent off to find out what happened at a country home though his boss believes it is just a matter of looking things over, agreeing and writing the three deaths off as presented – a murder and two suicides. Well, that can’t be because this is a murder mystery police procedural set in 1938 and there would be no real story if it was as the boss thought.
This book took me back in time to 1938 when Hitler was on the rise, Fascism was prevalent in countries outside of Germany, antisemitism was openly embraced by many and war was on the horizon. Life was different without computers, cell phones, forensic capabilities and all we take for granted today. Some people had maids and butlers and gardeners and other help while others had more mundane jobs.
With the crimes to be examined again the setting is in the country in a manor home. James has to go back to the beginning and the case is a bit cold. He interviews and looks at photos of the crime scene and does his best, with Constable Sawyer, to figure out first what really happened. Once that was finally determined James had to move on to who the baddie really was and what the motivation might have been. And, he did figure it out and I have to say...I was surprised...I who read ends of books before I reach them.
This book was very interesting. It told of historical events that were occurring, spoke about the reaction of people to the times, dealt with a heinous crime, mentioned heroes from The Great War, threw in a bit of potential romance and spoke of the social unrest and willingness of some to act against others. It was a bit slow at the time and had the flavor of a vintage who-done-it mystery in keeping with the times and that is just what made it so charming.
Thank you to Sapere Books for the ARC – This is my honest review.
4 Stars
Inspector James Given #1
Hanging by the neck till you are dead can’t be pleasant but it is not pleasant for the observer either. When Detective Inspector James Given leaves the hanging of a man he brought to justice he is unsettled even though he knew the man was guilty of murder. Returning to the office he is sent off to find out what happened at a country home though his boss believes it is just a matter of looking things over, agreeing and writing the three deaths off as presented – a murder and two suicides. Well, that can’t be because this is a murder mystery police procedural set in 1938 and there would be no real story if it was as the boss thought.
This book took me back in time to 1938 when Hitler was on the rise, Fascism was prevalent in countries outside of Germany, antisemitism was openly embraced by many and war was on the horizon. Life was different without computers, cell phones, forensic capabilities and all we take for granted today. Some people had maids and butlers and gardeners and other help while others had more mundane jobs.
With the crimes to be examined again the setting is in the country in a manor home. James has to go back to the beginning and the case is a bit cold. He interviews and looks at photos of the crime scene and does his best, with Constable Sawyer, to figure out first what really happened. Once that was finally determined James had to move on to who the baddie really was and what the motivation might have been. And, he did figure it out and I have to say...I was surprised...I who read ends of books before I reach them.
This book was very interesting. It told of historical events that were occurring, spoke about the reaction of people to the times, dealt with a heinous crime, mentioned heroes from The Great War, threw in a bit of potential romance and spoke of the social unrest and willingness of some to act against others. It was a bit slow at the time and had the flavor of a vintage who-done-it mystery in keeping with the times and that is just what made it so charming.
Thank you to Sapere Books for the ARC – This is my honest review.
4 Stars
August 7, 2019
Could not put this book down and finished it in two days.
It begins with the witnessing of a hanging of a man convicted of beating to death a Jewish shopkeeper in a small town in England. Watching the hanging is Detective Given who has been assigned this case and following the spread of anti Semitic activity. However he is pulled off this case and instead told to investigate and close another case involving a rich family with murder and suicide. Of course things are not as clear as first seen and this makes for some clever detective work.
So begins this twisting murder mystery. What makes it so engrossing is the threads of the history and background of the troubling times 1939 with Europe in turmoil and Hitler beginning his rise. The background and history of Detective Given is explored throughout the book with hints of whys and hows. At first it appears as if the opening of the story plot has no connection with the rest of the story but the threads of the plots begin to twist and turn together with lots of surprises.
The writing is clear and crisp and totally engrossing.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book.
It begins with the witnessing of a hanging of a man convicted of beating to death a Jewish shopkeeper in a small town in England. Watching the hanging is Detective Given who has been assigned this case and following the spread of anti Semitic activity. However he is pulled off this case and instead told to investigate and close another case involving a rich family with murder and suicide. Of course things are not as clear as first seen and this makes for some clever detective work.
So begins this twisting murder mystery. What makes it so engrossing is the threads of the history and background of the troubling times 1939 with Europe in turmoil and Hitler beginning his rise. The background and history of Detective Given is explored throughout the book with hints of whys and hows. At first it appears as if the opening of the story plot has no connection with the rest of the story but the threads of the plots begin to twist and turn together with lots of surprises.
The writing is clear and crisp and totally engrossing.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book.
August 5, 2019
1938 and after capturing and witnessing the hanging of two criminals, Detective Inspector James Given's next case is to review a recently closed one. There has recently been one murder and two suicides at Gravestock House in Warwickshire. His job is to make sure that nothing has been missed. The verdict is that Lady Isabelle Barleigh killed her son Tom, and then committed suicide, and then his fiancee Jenny Barnford was so distraught that she killed herself. So will he agree with this conclusion.
An interesting and entertaining well-written historical mystery. A good solid start to a new series and I look forward to reading more about the main characters
Received an ARC from the publisher.
An interesting and entertaining well-written historical mystery. A good solid start to a new series and I look forward to reading more about the main characters
Received an ARC from the publisher.
January 13, 2020
This book has received a Discovering Diamonds Review:
Helen Hollick
founder #DDRevs
"Inspector Given is a very likeable chap, and it was his personal background and the setting of looming war which kept me turning the pages."
Helen Hollick
founder #DDRevs
"Inspector Given is a very likeable chap, and it was his personal background and the setting of looming war which kept me turning the pages."
August 19, 2019
I could not put this book down! I thought it was well written and kept me guessing who did it til the very end! It reminded me of the P.D.James detective series I use to read. I will be looking for more in this series! Definitely recommend! Thanks to Sapere books for the early copy
Read
April 21, 2020After this first book I was anxious to read further about Inspector Given.
Thank you, I am recommending to my Book Club.
Thank you, I am recommending to my Book Club.
October 17, 2019
I have not read any books from this author before and realised upon some research that this appears to be the authors first book When I do a review I genuinely do not like to give away any details that might have the prospective reader to guess who did it before reading the book.
So with this in mind I am going to say WHAT A GREAT BOOK, the author writes this from the perspective of the Inspector in charge of the investigation and whilst doing this manages to weave a good story, with some great historical facts and sometimes bits of make believe or expansion on the truth. I have to say that the way the characters were woven and described to us as the reader was very good and in some places made you feel as if you actually there in the times.
I am glad to say that some of the historical facts around events at the time (middle to late 30's), I am familiar with, having done a history qualification at school and still maintain an interest in most things historical. The tale that is told around the apparent suicides/murders is intriguing and although I did not guess until at least the second to last chapter who did do it, I did manage to work out half way through the book, the dark tale that is being unwound alongside the deaths within the book.
I would highly recommend this book to readers who like, Thrillers, Murder Mystery and there is a touch of romance (that could be) within.
So with this in mind I am going to say WHAT A GREAT BOOK, the author writes this from the perspective of the Inspector in charge of the investigation and whilst doing this manages to weave a good story, with some great historical facts and sometimes bits of make believe or expansion on the truth. I have to say that the way the characters were woven and described to us as the reader was very good and in some places made you feel as if you actually there in the times.
I am glad to say that some of the historical facts around events at the time (middle to late 30's), I am familiar with, having done a history qualification at school and still maintain an interest in most things historical. The tale that is told around the apparent suicides/murders is intriguing and although I did not guess until at least the second to last chapter who did do it, I did manage to work out half way through the book, the dark tale that is being unwound alongside the deaths within the book.
I would highly recommend this book to readers who like, Thrillers, Murder Mystery and there is a touch of romance (that could be) within.
September 17, 2019
On the brink of war, Inspector Given is trying to deal with the wave of Anti Antisemitism sweeping the United Kingdom. Two people who were caught in the latest killing are being hanged though the masterminds behind the attack are still free and very much pursuing constant attacks against Jewish businesses.
Surprisingly he is taken off the case and given another one - a triple murder cum suicide (apparently) for the flimsiest of reasons. Suspicious about the reasoning behind the murders and thinking it is an inside job Inspector Given is swept into a case with much wider repercussions. It is not a family saga, with family secrets to hide but goes back decades and uncovers a very long trail of coercion, deceit, cover up and many secrets.
Told in a slightly old fashioned style, not detracting from the story or the detection the story is well told. Characterization was spot on and very good reading.
Surprisingly he is taken off the case and given another one - a triple murder cum suicide (apparently) for the flimsiest of reasons. Suspicious about the reasoning behind the murders and thinking it is an inside job Inspector Given is swept into a case with much wider repercussions. It is not a family saga, with family secrets to hide but goes back decades and uncovers a very long trail of coercion, deceit, cover up and many secrets.
Told in a slightly old fashioned style, not detracting from the story or the detection the story is well told. Characterization was spot on and very good reading.
July 24, 2015
Really enjoyed this novel. Loads of twists and turns and an exciting page turner. I found the short chapters added to a sense of suspense with plot and characters gently moving towards a process of revelation. The releasing of information throughout the novel generates mystery and this is paralleled by the first person narration (James Given) internal struggle to keep aspects of his own identity hidden. I liked the complexity of characters and how each had their own 'shadiness'. The solving of the crime highlighted for me the nature of 'identity' through the revealing of each characters' social status and their own prejudices. The unexpected culprit(s) was a surprise and it made be think of how holding onto identity during this turbulent period was essential. In this respect the novel provoked a lot of thought. A good read and I hope Inspector Given solves another crime.
August 20, 2015
This is an excellent 'whodunit' with a setting that would be familiar to all lovers of 'Golden Age' crime fiction: a country house murder mystery on the eve of World War II. Author Charlie Garrett expertly integrates all the usual elements from the genre – family secrets, class snobbery, intrigue both below and above stairs – into an original and satisfying read.
What I particularly like about this novel is that it doesn't shy away from the real life issues that were prevalent at the time, such as the anti-Semitism of Moseley's Blackshirts. Detective Inspector James Given and his sidekick Sawyer have something of a 'Morse and Lewis' feel to them. An unresolved sub-plot gives me the feeling that this novel may be the first of a series: I certainly hope so, and look forward to reading more of Inspector Given's investigations.
What I particularly like about this novel is that it doesn't shy away from the real life issues that were prevalent at the time, such as the anti-Semitism of Moseley's Blackshirts. Detective Inspector James Given and his sidekick Sawyer have something of a 'Morse and Lewis' feel to them. An unresolved sub-plot gives me the feeling that this novel may be the first of a series: I certainly hope so, and look forward to reading more of Inspector Given's investigations.
June 21, 2020
Bravo!
I enjoyed this complex murder mystery. It has everything going for it:lots of suspects, subplots, twists and turns. I was able to figure out the "who" about midway, but didn't know the "why" until the end. Looking forward to the next installment. Bravo, Mr Garratt!
I enjoyed this complex murder mystery. It has everything going for it:lots of suspects, subplots, twists and turns. I was able to figure out the "who" about midway, but didn't know the "why" until the end. Looking forward to the next installment. Bravo, Mr Garratt!
May 20, 2020
Very good on the history of the time and the fear engendered by Hitler's purges. The mystery was intricate and well plotted. The lead character had several elaborate back stories. In total, an interesting read but I did not connect well enough to add other books to my very long TBR list.
August 20, 2017
5 stars
In late September 1938, Peter Bishop was hanged for his crimes with six people in attendance. One was Inspector James Given who arrested him for kicking a shopkeeper to death in the street. Given has been investigating the spate of beatings again Jewish people.
Superintendent Henry Dyer takes Inspector Given off the case and hands him a different sort of puzzle. Grovestock House is the home of a very influential and wealthy family named Barleigh. There has been a murder and two suicides. The police thought it solved until the press was quoted as saying the family got off too lightly because of their standing and wealth. So Dyer sends James out to take another look.
Apparently, Lady Isabelle Barleigh shot her disabled son Tom and then turned the gun on herself. Almost immediately, the son’s fiancée Miss Jenny Bamford committed suicide as well.
Reading the case file, James sees that Constable John Sawyer, a local lad, has acted with speed and clarity in investigating the case, interviewing witnesses and written up his notes with alacrity. But it bothered Inspector James Given that the whole case had been dispatched so readily and speedily.
Inspector Given is surprised to see Elizabeth Parry working at Grovestock House. She was a woman to whom he proposed marriage some time earlier. She had disappeared without a trace and he still is hurt by the whole situation. But she also knows more than she is telling.
The Inspector begins by re-interviewing the workers in and around the house. There seems to be something missing from some of the accounts, but Inspector Given can’t put his finger on it. Constable Sawyer is interviewing the people of the village and learns some interesting tidbits. There seems to be something about the Barleigh family that is not being told.
We learn about Inspector Given’s family and the apparent split. We learn about him changing his name.
The young man who was to be the best man at Tom’s pending wedding and was at the house when Isabelle, Tom and Jenny were killed comes under suspicion once more. It seems he was not totally honest with Inspector Given and he is in a lot of trouble, for more than just being evasive.
After reviewing the photographs that Constable Sawyer took of the murder scene, the Inspector learns that it was not Isabelle killing Tom and then herself. Someone had murdered all three victims.
This book is very well written and plotted. Inspector Given is a great character and I appreciated how well he got along with Constable Sawyer, who was just learning and honing his detective skills. This novel is pure police detection. Since they did not have all the forensic data that we have available today, the Inspector and the Constable solve this crime on their skills alone and the photos taken by an old Brownie camera. (I had one of those when I was much younger!) I am so taken with Mr. Garratt’s writing style and ideas that I can hardly wait until the next book is out.
I want to thank NetGalley and Holland House for forwarding to me a copy of this wonderful book to read and enjoy.
In late September 1938, Peter Bishop was hanged for his crimes with six people in attendance. One was Inspector James Given who arrested him for kicking a shopkeeper to death in the street. Given has been investigating the spate of beatings again Jewish people.
Superintendent Henry Dyer takes Inspector Given off the case and hands him a different sort of puzzle. Grovestock House is the home of a very influential and wealthy family named Barleigh. There has been a murder and two suicides. The police thought it solved until the press was quoted as saying the family got off too lightly because of their standing and wealth. So Dyer sends James out to take another look.
Apparently, Lady Isabelle Barleigh shot her disabled son Tom and then turned the gun on herself. Almost immediately, the son’s fiancée Miss Jenny Bamford committed suicide as well.
Reading the case file, James sees that Constable John Sawyer, a local lad, has acted with speed and clarity in investigating the case, interviewing witnesses and written up his notes with alacrity. But it bothered Inspector James Given that the whole case had been dispatched so readily and speedily.
Inspector Given is surprised to see Elizabeth Parry working at Grovestock House. She was a woman to whom he proposed marriage some time earlier. She had disappeared without a trace and he still is hurt by the whole situation. But she also knows more than she is telling.
The Inspector begins by re-interviewing the workers in and around the house. There seems to be something missing from some of the accounts, but Inspector Given can’t put his finger on it. Constable Sawyer is interviewing the people of the village and learns some interesting tidbits. There seems to be something about the Barleigh family that is not being told.
We learn about Inspector Given’s family and the apparent split. We learn about him changing his name.
The young man who was to be the best man at Tom’s pending wedding and was at the house when Isabelle, Tom and Jenny were killed comes under suspicion once more. It seems he was not totally honest with Inspector Given and he is in a lot of trouble, for more than just being evasive.
After reviewing the photographs that Constable Sawyer took of the murder scene, the Inspector learns that it was not Isabelle killing Tom and then herself. Someone had murdered all three victims.
This book is very well written and plotted. Inspector Given is a great character and I appreciated how well he got along with Constable Sawyer, who was just learning and honing his detective skills. This novel is pure police detection. Since they did not have all the forensic data that we have available today, the Inspector and the Constable solve this crime on their skills alone and the photos taken by an old Brownie camera. (I had one of those when I was much younger!) I am so taken with Mr. Garratt’s writing style and ideas that I can hardly wait until the next book is out.
I want to thank NetGalley and Holland House for forwarding to me a copy of this wonderful book to read and enjoy.
June 11, 2021
All is not what it at first seems.
When Inspector James Given is given an easy assignment in the wake of having to attend a hanging, the case he has to check seems cut and dried; an aristocratic mother has shot her disabled son, only to turn the gun on herself, followed by the son’s fiancee committing suicide. The local doctor confirms the causes of death but the young local policeman, Sawyer, who has done the first examination is not entirely convinced that the conclusions are correct. Naïve but enthusiastic and observant, he proves a valuable assistant when Given uncovers more inconsistencies.
This book is set in 1938 and beneath the twists and turns of the crime investigation, which is nothing like as pat as at first suggested, runs pre-war unease and a growing anti-Semitism which impinge on Given himself. This adds depth to the character interactions and the underlying social commentary in Garratt’s books. This one is neatly and provocatively plotted and although the characters may occasionally be from stock they are still well fleshed out, warts and all. Given’s emotions are part of his investigative armoury, which ensures that he is easy for readers to relate to and results in a satisfying and layered story. The first of a series, it is an inviting introduction to an appealing and promising lead character.
When Inspector James Given is given an easy assignment in the wake of having to attend a hanging, the case he has to check seems cut and dried; an aristocratic mother has shot her disabled son, only to turn the gun on herself, followed by the son’s fiancee committing suicide. The local doctor confirms the causes of death but the young local policeman, Sawyer, who has done the first examination is not entirely convinced that the conclusions are correct. Naïve but enthusiastic and observant, he proves a valuable assistant when Given uncovers more inconsistencies.
This book is set in 1938 and beneath the twists and turns of the crime investigation, which is nothing like as pat as at first suggested, runs pre-war unease and a growing anti-Semitism which impinge on Given himself. This adds depth to the character interactions and the underlying social commentary in Garratt’s books. This one is neatly and provocatively plotted and although the characters may occasionally be from stock they are still well fleshed out, warts and all. Given’s emotions are part of his investigative armoury, which ensures that he is easy for readers to relate to and results in a satisfying and layered story. The first of a series, it is an inviting introduction to an appealing and promising lead character.
November 10, 2020
What is a shadowed livery? Is livery not a special uniform worn by servants of nobility?
Anyway, there is a lot going on in this story. We have Inspector James Givens who starts the book by witnessing a hanging of someone who assaulted and killed a Jew. So a bit grim.
It is 1938, Chamberlain has his talks with Hitler. In some parts of London Jews and their businesses have been attacked. However, a series of deaths have taken place at a country estate, Grovestock House, and everything has been wrapped up a shade too quickly. Givens is charged with checking that it really was at it seemed, three deaths (two suicides and a murder).
Givens meets an old flame who unaccountably disappeared from his life, now working at Grovestock House as the housekeeper.
Two members of staff have vanished.
On another front Givens uncle and aunt are stuck in Hitler’s Germany can he do anything for them.
MI5 are snooping around his case.
Some shady Italians, from an incident in his past, are looking for him and not to say hello and ask how he’s been doing either.
Then another body is found.
Ably assisted by local bobby PC Sawyer he uncovers long held secrets and sorts out some of the mess.
Inspector Givens narrates the story so everything is seen through his eyes making for a more ‘closed in’ story.
Not a bad read even with the feeling of ‘whatever next’ for the poor man.
Anyway, there is a lot going on in this story. We have Inspector James Givens who starts the book by witnessing a hanging of someone who assaulted and killed a Jew. So a bit grim.
It is 1938, Chamberlain has his talks with Hitler. In some parts of London Jews and their businesses have been attacked. However, a series of deaths have taken place at a country estate, Grovestock House, and everything has been wrapped up a shade too quickly. Givens is charged with checking that it really was at it seemed, three deaths (two suicides and a murder).
Givens meets an old flame who unaccountably disappeared from his life, now working at Grovestock House as the housekeeper.
Two members of staff have vanished.
On another front Givens uncle and aunt are stuck in Hitler’s Germany can he do anything for them.
MI5 are snooping around his case.
Some shady Italians, from an incident in his past, are looking for him and not to say hello and ask how he’s been doing either.
Then another body is found.
Ably assisted by local bobby PC Sawyer he uncovers long held secrets and sorts out some of the mess.
Inspector Givens narrates the story so everything is seen through his eyes making for a more ‘closed in’ story.
Not a bad read even with the feeling of ‘whatever next’ for the poor man.
August 15, 2017
This book has everything I love about golden age mysteries, country house setting, cast of varied characters all hiding something, murder and deceit, crime and a satisfying payoff. There are several interwoven subplots and the characters (and their imperfections and foibles) are three dimensional and believable in the context of the book.
I like that the author didn't shy away from the antisemitism of England in 1938. The history and background were well researched and I didn't find any egregious mistakes.
I enjoyed this book very much and I sincerely hope the author continues this series. I look forward to finding out what the wartime years hold for inspector Givens and his sidekick Sawyer.
It's a bit cliché to describe it as 'writerly' but this really is a well written book, nothing clunky or awkward here.
Five stars
Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher.
I like that the author didn't shy away from the antisemitism of England in 1938. The history and background were well researched and I didn't find any egregious mistakes.
I enjoyed this book very much and I sincerely hope the author continues this series. I look forward to finding out what the wartime years hold for inspector Givens and his sidekick Sawyer.
It's a bit cliché to describe it as 'writerly' but this really is a well written book, nothing clunky or awkward here.
Five stars
Disclosure: I received an ARC at no cost from the author/publisher.
August 25, 2017
Antisemitism in the 1930's was not confined to Germany. England had its share of fascists (Oswald Mosley and his British Union of Fascists) and other far right prejudices. The increasing number of refugees from Germany only exacerbated the feelings of resentment from certain elements of the population.
The book begins with Inspector James Givens witnessing the execution of a man who murdered a Jewish shopkeeper.
Although Givens had been investigating the increasing number of attacks on Jews, his superior pulls him off that investigation when a murder and two suicides involving a wealthy and influential family takes precedence. The notoriety of the case has the police scrambling, especially as the initial investigation was a bit precipitous.
Inspired by an actual case, A Shadowed Livery by Charlie Garratt appears to be a possible new series featuring Inspector Givens.
NetGalley/Holland House
Historical Mystery. 2015. Print length: 262 pages.
The book begins with Inspector James Givens witnessing the execution of a man who murdered a Jewish shopkeeper.
Although Givens had been investigating the increasing number of attacks on Jews, his superior pulls him off that investigation when a murder and two suicides involving a wealthy and influential family takes precedence. The notoriety of the case has the police scrambling, especially as the initial investigation was a bit precipitous.
Inspired by an actual case, A Shadowed Livery by Charlie Garratt appears to be a possible new series featuring Inspector Givens.
NetGalley/Holland House
Historical Mystery. 2015. Print length: 262 pages.
August 6, 2019
Very enjoyable, first time I have read a Charlie Garret novel. Key characters of James Given and John Sawyer lead us through a seemingly obvious suicide/mercy killing combination set just before the onset of WWII which as DI Given sees fairly early on is not as “obvious” as it seems to appear. As I am from Coventry the book it set around the county I love, Warwickshire, with both Leamington and Kenilworth playing a lead role. The area and countryside descriptions in the book are perfect. With Given’s Jewish heritage other previous episodes in his life and also the threat from Hitler to Jews in Germany, where Given has relatives, all fold well into the mix. Plenty of other characters, Superintendent Dyer and Elizabeth Parry allow for further development of both the characters and the story. Well written, enjoyable read, easy to read novel
August 20, 2019
First book in the series of Inspector Given and I really enjoyed this murder/mystery set between the two Great Wars, when Britain was just recovering from one but looking at the likelihood of another. Set in a country mansion. Given is sent to re-evaluate the conclusion of what appears to be a double murder and a suicide, only to find that all is not as it appears. We are told some personal details about Given who family are Jewish refugees from Russia, although he himself is in denial to some extent and the book sensitively covers that area about the racism and brutality towards the Jewish communities throughout Europe at this time.
I did guess the 'who' quite early on but not the 'why' and would recommend this book to read.
Thanks to Sapere Books for a copy to review.
I did guess the 'who' quite early on but not the 'why' and would recommend this book to read.
Thanks to Sapere Books for a copy to review.
April 22, 2022
The mystery at the heart of the book is pretty good. However, the "solving" dragged as Given repeatedly rehashed who were suspects and who were not. That would not have ruined. What detracted were the digressions completely unrelated to the plot. There was one with Sicilian bad guys and another with Jewish persecution in Germany. Both were hurriedly fleshed out to some extent near the end when a reader would be expecting the mystery to be the focus. One cannot tell if the author was trying to make depth rather than a straight Agatha Christie mystery or if he were setting up for sequels. Nothing in the book endeared me to Givens and nothing made me curious about the digressions. I doubt I will move on to #2
May 1, 2020
When a supposed murder and double suicide take place in a quaint country house, James Given is sent to investigate when the media outcry becomes too much.
Pulled into the world of upstairs-downstairs with an old flame, the ghost of WW1 and the looming shadow of WWII, Given is to question the identity of everyone, their motive and their lies to work out whether this was a triple murder or just a terrible accident.
For once, I did guess the murderer but I didn't work out the why (although hindsight is 20-20).
Next please!
Pulled into the world of upstairs-downstairs with an old flame, the ghost of WW1 and the looming shadow of WWII, Given is to question the identity of everyone, their motive and their lies to work out whether this was a triple murder or just a terrible accident.
For once, I did guess the murderer but I didn't work out the why (although hindsight is 20-20).
Next please!
April 6, 2020
This was an excellent mystery. I really enjoyed it and I enjoyed the character of the detective. It is based on a true story which makes it all the more incredible. Set in 1938 England where they are still suffering from the Great Depression and the memories of the Great War still abound.
This is NOT a 'cozy' this is for true mystery aficionados. I am just starting the second book of the series and it seems to be just as good.
This is NOT a 'cozy' this is for true mystery aficionados. I am just starting the second book of the series and it seems to be just as good.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 60 reviews