What do you think?
Rate this book
Mages of the Wheel #3
Siren & Scion
She was beautiful the way the ocean was beautiful. In a new way every time one looked.
She is water, bright and alluring, fathomless and profound. He is a bridge between peoples, artist and criminal, vengeful and compassionate.
Amara Mutar has risen to the highest ranks of Tamar society by her wits and ambition. But it is not high enough to keep those she loves, and herself, safe from a past that will not release her.
Cassian Haydar has sunk as low as it is possible to sink, but he intends to take back what is his, and crush those who took everything that mattered from him—after he’s done stealing back all the other lives they’ve robbed.
In exchange for a betrothal that would secure Amara’s position and freedom, the Tamaran Sultana sends her on a dangerous hunt for lost mages of the Third House, in the last place any mage should be. Amara and Cassian, brought together deep inside the Republic, discover they have nothing, and everything, in common.
But their paths were never meant to converge, and there are horrors in the heart of a rising Empire that threaten both Amara’s plans and every mage in Tamar. Knowing the fate of the Circle rests in her hands, Amara must choose whether to serve her heart, or her people.
He was a shore upon which she crawled from the dark deep of her magic and fell against to breathe, and taste the air again.
She is water, bright and alluring, fathomless and profound. He is a bridge between peoples, artist and criminal, vengeful and compassionate.
Amara Mutar has risen to the highest ranks of Tamar society by her wits and ambition. But it is not high enough to keep those she loves, and herself, safe from a past that will not release her.
Cassian Haydar has sunk as low as it is possible to sink, but he intends to take back what is his, and crush those who took everything that mattered from him—after he’s done stealing back all the other lives they’ve robbed.
In exchange for a betrothal that would secure Amara’s position and freedom, the Tamaran Sultana sends her on a dangerous hunt for lost mages of the Third House, in the last place any mage should be. Amara and Cassian, brought together deep inside the Republic, discover they have nothing, and everything, in common.
But their paths were never meant to converge, and there are horrors in the heart of a rising Empire that threaten both Amara’s plans and every mage in Tamar. Knowing the fate of the Circle rests in her hands, Amara must choose whether to serve her heart, or her people.
He was a shore upon which she crawled from the dark deep of her magic and fell against to breathe, and taste the air again.
420 pages, Kindle Edition
First published May 28, 2020
557 people are currently reading
4396 people want to read
About the author
J.D. Evans
10 books1,103 followersJ. D. Evans writes fantasy and science fiction romance. After earning her degree in linguistics, J. D. served a decade as an army officer. She once spent her hours putting together briefings for helicopter pilots and generals. Now she writes stories, tends to two unreasonable tiny humans, knits, sews badly, gardens, and cultivates Pinterest Fails. After a stint in Beirut, J. D. fell in love with the Levant, which inspired the setting for her debut series, Mages of the Wheel.
Originally hailing from Montana, J. D. now resides in North Carolina with her husband, two attempts at mini-clones gone rogue, and too many stories in her head.
Originally hailing from Montana, J. D. now resides in North Carolina with her husband, two attempts at mini-clones gone rogue, and too many stories in her head.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 448 reviews
June 14, 2020
It’s 4am. I read most of this book in one sitting. I’m going to be an absolute zombie tomorrow but i don’t care, this was totally worth it. It’s my favorite book of the series so far. The ANGST. I loved the complexity of Cassian and Amara’s relationship. As always with this series, I fell head over hills in love with the male love interest. I’m so weak. Cassian was such a caring warm soul. I loved him. I liked that he had no material things to offer, oftentimes I think in fantasy we mostly read about powerful rich men and it was refreshing to see Amara falling for him, just for who he was as a person. The intimate scene was one of the best I have ever read, probably because the slow burn was impeccable too. Amara is extremely interesting and i cannot wait to see more of her in the following books. I highlighted so many quotes in this book, mostly things Amara said, probably my favorite was: “Too many think it is a compliment to elevate one at the expense of others. I find it repugnant. If you cannot compliment me for something that is mine, instead of taking away from other women, then do not bother at all”. Period!
Another thing I enjoyed tremendously was the world building in this book. I was fascinated with the new part of the world we got to visit and experience. Normally when it comes to fantasy romance, I’m mostly here for the relationship.. everything else is extra. I didn’t feel that way with this installment, I was truly immersed in the entire story. I thought the secondary characters were a great addition as well, particularly Djar. We need more f/m bffs!!
I cant begin to express how shocked i am that this author is not an international bestseller because this series deserves all the praise in the world. Her prose is beautiful. My favorite within the genre. Cannot wait to read what happens next! 🙉👀
Another thing I enjoyed tremendously was the world building in this book. I was fascinated with the new part of the world we got to visit and experience. Normally when it comes to fantasy romance, I’m mostly here for the relationship.. everything else is extra. I didn’t feel that way with this installment, I was truly immersed in the entire story. I thought the secondary characters were a great addition as well, particularly Djar. We need more f/m bffs!!
I cant begin to express how shocked i am that this author is not an international bestseller because this series deserves all the praise in the world. Her prose is beautiful. My favorite within the genre. Cannot wait to read what happens next! 🙉👀
October 25, 2022
This is definitely the weakest link in the series so far. It doesn’t have the political intrigue that R+R had going for it and the relationship doesn’t have the snap crackle pop that Storm + Shield had going for it (my hot take is that Bashir and Aysel have the best/most chemistry out of everyone so far, but I digress), so it’s lowkey falling short on a lot of fronts. I respect what Cassian and Amara have going on here and no one appreciates a soft caring king more than I do, but I found myself bored at times even though I can admit that their relationship was very romantic and sweet. There is a found family aspect in Siren + Siren that’s v cute.
We also get to see the Republic in this one which is just a not even thinly veiled analog for the Roman empire, and there’s also the introduction of the Suloi who have a little bit of magic and are like distant cousins to the Tamar mages and it’s like….ok. I want to be back in Narfour!
DESPERATELY want to know who the couples for the next 3 (5, if we’re including the side novels) books are
We also get to see the Republic in this one which is just a not even thinly veiled analog for the Roman empire, and there’s also the introduction of the Suloi who have a little bit of magic and are like distant cousins to the Tamar mages and it’s like….ok. I want to be back in Narfour!
DESPERATELY want to know who the couples for the next 3 (5, if we’re including the side novels) books are
March 24, 2025
This is a tough review for me, because I LOVED the two main characters in this book, but the story was a little slow for me.
The plot was riveting and, at times, SO heavy. The slavery, oppression and signs of abuse is so thematic in this, so it was a tougher read.
But, it made the pay off of the character arc’s and romance more worth it. Overall, I wish this book felt a bit more fast paced. I will give 4.25 stars to this book, for the beautiful love story, and the lovable characters, though.
The plot was riveting and, at times, SO heavy. The slavery, oppression and signs of abuse is so thematic in this, so it was a tougher read.
But, it made the pay off of the character arc’s and romance more worth it. Overall, I wish this book felt a bit more fast paced. I will give 4.25 stars to this book, for the beautiful love story, and the lovable characters, though.
June 7, 2021
I need book four. Now.
September 10, 2020
'To those who cannot see their own bright, glorious light, because the darkness is so deep. I see you.'
Mages of the Wheel is now officially among my all time favorite romantic fantasy series. Book 1, Reign & Ruin is among the best books ever written on my list. And this tale here is not far off behind it.
If I were to set it among other traditionally published romantic fantasy series out there, this beauty here will not only hold it's ground but do it in style! It is masterfully written.
Siren & Scion is a heartbreaking tale of courage, redemption, forgiveness and healing. And I absolutely loved it!
'Only those who hurt can so easily see the hurt in another. ... Is it not pain that gives compassion? Trauma that leaves wisdom where it treads?
Why is it so easy to forgive in others what we cannot forgive in ourselves?'
Amara Mutar has risen to the highest ranks of Tamar society by her wits and ambition. But it is not high enough to keep those she loves, and herself, safe from a past that will not release her.
In exchange for a betrothal that would secure Amara’s position and freedom, the Tamaran Sultana sends her on a dangerous hunt for lost mages of the Third House, in the last place any mage should be. The Republic. A place where Amara will have to face her greatest terror. One that may truly turn her into the monster she always feared she was.
'Strength is forged in pain. You were forged in pain, so that you could love. Be mercy peace of the Wheel. Be kindness in the dark of horror. Show them.'
If Amara will choose to be mercy where there is none, despite the horrors she faces... I'll leave that for you to find out. But be warned. Her journey is heartbreaking.
Knowing the fate of the Circle of Charah rests in her hands, Amara will have to choose whether to serve her heart, or her people. Not an easy thing to do when the heart feels so much!
'He was a shore upon which she crawled from the dark deep of her magic and fell against to breathe, and taste the air again.'
Cassian Haydar has sunk as low as it is possible to sink, but he intends to take back what is his, and crush those who took everything that mattered from him—after he’s done stealing back all the other lives they’ve robbed. He hadn't intended to steal Amara's heart too, somewhere along the way.
Amara and Cassian, brought together deep inside the Republic, discover they have nothing, and everything, in common. And their love story is heartbreaking!!
I swear the so called 'dumber than a dead camel' Cassian made me both want to hug him and smack him on the head at times. And yep. He's pretty swoon-worthy too. :D
Written in an old-style lyrical and flawless prose, The Mages of the Wheel series will appeal to all fans of romantic fantasy, but especially to those who love it mixed with a lot of court intrigue, rich wordbuilding and an intricate magic system.
Fascinating magic, wonderfully written fully fleshed characters, including supporting ones, a lot of fast paced action and a love to set your heart on fire! Siren & Scion has it all. Just as the previous two books in series.
Again, I'm gonna end this review with a heartfelt suggestion:
If you love romantic fantasy, YOU HAVE GOT TO GIVE THIS A TRY!
It is heartrendingly beautiful!!
Mages of the Wheel is now officially among my all time favorite romantic fantasy series. Book 1, Reign & Ruin is among the best books ever written on my list. And this tale here is not far off behind it.
If I were to set it among other traditionally published romantic fantasy series out there, this beauty here will not only hold it's ground but do it in style! It is masterfully written.
Siren & Scion is a heartbreaking tale of courage, redemption, forgiveness and healing. And I absolutely loved it!
'Only those who hurt can so easily see the hurt in another. ... Is it not pain that gives compassion? Trauma that leaves wisdom where it treads?
Why is it so easy to forgive in others what we cannot forgive in ourselves?'
Amara Mutar has risen to the highest ranks of Tamar society by her wits and ambition. But it is not high enough to keep those she loves, and herself, safe from a past that will not release her.
In exchange for a betrothal that would secure Amara’s position and freedom, the Tamaran Sultana sends her on a dangerous hunt for lost mages of the Third House, in the last place any mage should be. The Republic. A place where Amara will have to face her greatest terror. One that may truly turn her into the monster she always feared she was.
'Strength is forged in pain. You were forged in pain, so that you could love. Be mercy peace of the Wheel. Be kindness in the dark of horror. Show them.'
If Amara will choose to be mercy where there is none, despite the horrors she faces... I'll leave that for you to find out. But be warned. Her journey is heartbreaking.
Knowing the fate of the Circle of Charah rests in her hands, Amara will have to choose whether to serve her heart, or her people. Not an easy thing to do when the heart feels so much!
'He was a shore upon which she crawled from the dark deep of her magic and fell against to breathe, and taste the air again.'
Cassian Haydar has sunk as low as it is possible to sink, but he intends to take back what is his, and crush those who took everything that mattered from him—after he’s done stealing back all the other lives they’ve robbed. He hadn't intended to steal Amara's heart too, somewhere along the way.
Amara and Cassian, brought together deep inside the Republic, discover they have nothing, and everything, in common. And their love story is heartbreaking!!
I swear the so called 'dumber than a dead camel' Cassian made me both want to hug him and smack him on the head at times. And yep. He's pretty swoon-worthy too. :D
Written in an old-style lyrical and flawless prose, The Mages of the Wheel series will appeal to all fans of romantic fantasy, but especially to those who love it mixed with a lot of court intrigue, rich wordbuilding and an intricate magic system.
Fascinating magic, wonderfully written fully fleshed characters, including supporting ones, a lot of fast paced action and a love to set your heart on fire! Siren & Scion has it all. Just as the previous two books in series.
Again, I'm gonna end this review with a heartfelt suggestion:
If you love romantic fantasy, YOU HAVE GOT TO GIVE THIS A TRY!
It is heartrendingly beautiful!!
July 6, 2022
Fantasy Romance is my jam. And this series, feels like a hidden jar at the back of the pantry.
I would recommend to my Maas-fan friends that want to support binge-worthy indie author.
3.75/5 (Rounded Up because I’m feeling smitten over this series.)
I would recommend to my Maas-fan friends that want to support binge-worthy indie author.
3.75/5 (Rounded Up because I’m feeling smitten over this series.)
August 20, 2023
3.5/5 stars
Ironically, a flipped situation compared to the first two books; enjoyable on the epic story side, however not so much on the romance side.
Our female lead, Amara, is set the task of finding creation mages in the Republic by the Sultana, in return for a betrothal to her cousin, the prince, Ihsan. With the added stipulation that Amara, being a Charah herself, must join the circle to gain the position of power that she desires. Though, when she reaches the Republic city of Haenna and teams up with Cassian- a criminal who frees slaves- to find the mages, she didn't count on him stepping in to mess up her carefully laid plans.
My main hindrance to enjoying any sort of romance in this one was most definitely Amara. I tried my best to get on side with her, and reached a place where I could put up with her for the sake of the story, but on the whole, found her an unlikeable character. The manner in which she's introduced made me take an instant disliking towards her, purely for the fact that she was gunning to get her way with a character I already love and seemingly only to serve her own selfish interests. Along the way, we begin to understand and discover her reasoning; partly self-preservation and partly protective, due to her trauma and her past, but this would've been far more effective if presented the other way round by use of a prologue. Us the readers, would have gone into that meeting perhaps not liking Amara's intentions, but at least empathising with her and leaning far more in favour of her. Add to that, that Amara is presented as a woman that is proud, haughty and demanding, deepens the dislike, albeit all a mask for survival which is later revealed. I also feel here it would have been better to have her compensate by acting fiercer, guarded and untouchable, rather than prideful and high and mighty. It also would have been beneficial to see much more of her caring, compassionate side.
Cassian was an infinitely more likeable character, although not as strong a male lead as the previous two. A vastly different take on a romantic interest than his predecessors, being a rogue, a gambler, a criminal, and a smuggler, with a hobby as a talented artist. I loved those glimpses of his artwork and his artistry of his words, but what really sold him was his heart of gold; his unerring kindness and compassion. I feel we didn't really get enough of him though, of him in action and serving the story himself and of his vital back story and crucial work saving slaves, therefore the depth was missing. In the past two books the romantic interests have always added to the story with their own agendas, and here Cassian exists to serve Amara's.
Romance-wise, Cassian gave more of himself than Amara did and I felt that Amara was judgmental and pompous towards him for a lot of it (despite the physical attraction). The chemistry was present but contrary to Evans' other solid relationship building, they both did some stupid things or overstepped the mark in ways that went against their character and made you want to shake them both. However, the main flaw of the romance is that both Amara and Cassian were dealing with deep trauma; such complex and difficult topics need thorough detail and history for it to seem real and authentic in order for it to have any impact and be used as a device through which they bond with and heal one another. Due to not really feeling the romance, I wasn't really into the sex scenes either, though I did appreciate the marked difference of intercourse between a magic user and a person devoid of it, with the consequences that followed. It raised some interesting questions about magic control, love and passion between mages of differing abilities.
Epic fantasy-wise, the story really opened up, which is what I've been wanting all along. It was great to learn of other parts of the world, with Amara and her friends hailing from Menei (akin to Africa) and finally getting our first encounter with the enemy, the Corsan Republic (Roman-esque but technologically advanced). Although having gone from two tightly focused stories based in the same place to a radically different one, took a fair bit of adjustment and was a bit of a struggle at first, as mentioned before, I would've liked it if we'd had some more world-building prior to this.
We are also introduced to the Suloi, a tribal race living in the wilderness of the Republic, hunted and subjugated by them for the crime of possessing weak traces of magic. I particularly liked them, their demeanour and mannerisms, plus their appearance and spirituality put me in mind of Native Indians.
The real highlight and enjoyment of this book were the supporting characters, Amara's adopted family of other Meneians; Djar, Bek and Kiya, Cassian's best friend, Peio, and the Suloi that they sought out. All brilliant characters with their interactions and supporting scenes elevating the story. The part in the last chapter where all these new characters collide with old, along with their different customs was one of the most enjoyable of the story. I couldn't help imagining how awesome it would be if we had all of their back stories, viewpoints and romantic relationships (where applicable) interspersed with the characters we've already met from Tamar and the political situation there. (I still live in hope that a fantasy romance author will be brave enough to attempt this one day).
Evan's writing and storytelling is always solid and enjoyable. There are some truly beautiful descriptions of people and places, but I admit I found it a little difficult to envisage at times, so perhaps a less lyrical and simpler approach would aid in that. The magic manifestation was incredibly interesting and fascinating as usual, I particularly liked how Amara's house being water lent her towards melody and movement- she absolutely bossed the dance in the brothel (one of her scenes that I actually liked). Unfortunately, I felt rather robbed of action in this one, there were several instances where there should have been fighting which we should've experienced and the plot was also rather non-sensical in some parts.
So, overall, a bit of a mixed bag, however I'm looking forward to the epic story deepening in the books to come and to see how the mages will hone their powers.
Ironically, a flipped situation compared to the first two books; enjoyable on the epic story side, however not so much on the romance side.
Our female lead, Amara, is set the task of finding creation mages in the Republic by the Sultana, in return for a betrothal to her cousin, the prince, Ihsan. With the added stipulation that Amara, being a Charah herself, must join the circle to gain the position of power that she desires. Though, when she reaches the Republic city of Haenna and teams up with Cassian- a criminal who frees slaves- to find the mages, she didn't count on him stepping in to mess up her carefully laid plans.
My main hindrance to enjoying any sort of romance in this one was most definitely Amara. I tried my best to get on side with her, and reached a place where I could put up with her for the sake of the story, but on the whole, found her an unlikeable character. The manner in which she's introduced made me take an instant disliking towards her, purely for the fact that she was gunning to get her way with a character I already love and seemingly only to serve her own selfish interests. Along the way, we begin to understand and discover her reasoning; partly self-preservation and partly protective, due to her trauma and her past, but this would've been far more effective if presented the other way round by use of a prologue. Us the readers, would have gone into that meeting perhaps not liking Amara's intentions, but at least empathising with her and leaning far more in favour of her. Add to that, that Amara is presented as a woman that is proud, haughty and demanding, deepens the dislike, albeit all a mask for survival which is later revealed. I also feel here it would have been better to have her compensate by acting fiercer, guarded and untouchable, rather than prideful and high and mighty. It also would have been beneficial to see much more of her caring, compassionate side.
Cassian was an infinitely more likeable character, although not as strong a male lead as the previous two. A vastly different take on a romantic interest than his predecessors, being a rogue, a gambler, a criminal, and a smuggler, with a hobby as a talented artist. I loved those glimpses of his artwork and his artistry of his words, but what really sold him was his heart of gold; his unerring kindness and compassion. I feel we didn't really get enough of him though, of him in action and serving the story himself and of his vital back story and crucial work saving slaves, therefore the depth was missing. In the past two books the romantic interests have always added to the story with their own agendas, and here Cassian exists to serve Amara's.
Romance-wise, Cassian gave more of himself than Amara did and I felt that Amara was judgmental and pompous towards him for a lot of it (despite the physical attraction). The chemistry was present but contrary to Evans' other solid relationship building, they both did some stupid things or overstepped the mark in ways that went against their character and made you want to shake them both. However, the main flaw of the romance is that both Amara and Cassian were dealing with deep trauma; such complex and difficult topics need thorough detail and history for it to seem real and authentic in order for it to have any impact and be used as a device through which they bond with and heal one another. Due to not really feeling the romance, I wasn't really into the sex scenes either, though I did appreciate the marked difference of intercourse between a magic user and a person devoid of it, with the consequences that followed. It raised some interesting questions about magic control, love and passion between mages of differing abilities.
Epic fantasy-wise, the story really opened up, which is what I've been wanting all along. It was great to learn of other parts of the world, with Amara and her friends hailing from Menei (akin to Africa) and finally getting our first encounter with the enemy, the Corsan Republic (Roman-esque but technologically advanced). Although having gone from two tightly focused stories based in the same place to a radically different one, took a fair bit of adjustment and was a bit of a struggle at first, as mentioned before, I would've liked it if we'd had some more world-building prior to this.
We are also introduced to the Suloi, a tribal race living in the wilderness of the Republic, hunted and subjugated by them for the crime of possessing weak traces of magic. I particularly liked them, their demeanour and mannerisms, plus their appearance and spirituality put me in mind of Native Indians.
The real highlight and enjoyment of this book were the supporting characters, Amara's adopted family of other Meneians; Djar, Bek and Kiya, Cassian's best friend, Peio, and the Suloi that they sought out. All brilliant characters with their interactions and supporting scenes elevating the story. The part in the last chapter where all these new characters collide with old, along with their different customs was one of the most enjoyable of the story. I couldn't help imagining how awesome it would be if we had all of their back stories, viewpoints and romantic relationships (where applicable) interspersed with the characters we've already met from Tamar and the political situation there. (I still live in hope that a fantasy romance author will be brave enough to attempt this one day).
Evan's writing and storytelling is always solid and enjoyable. There are some truly beautiful descriptions of people and places, but I admit I found it a little difficult to envisage at times, so perhaps a less lyrical and simpler approach would aid in that. The magic manifestation was incredibly interesting and fascinating as usual, I particularly liked how Amara's house being water lent her towards melody and movement- she absolutely bossed the dance in the brothel (one of her scenes that I actually liked). Unfortunately, I felt rather robbed of action in this one, there were several instances where there should have been fighting which we should've experienced and the plot was also rather non-sensical in some parts.
So, overall, a bit of a mixed bag, however I'm looking forward to the epic story deepening in the books to come and to see how the mages will hone their powers.
October 1, 2024
3.5 stars
I’m binge-reading an incomplete series. I don’t know why I do this to myself. I know I’ll suffer heartbreak and large doses of impatience after I gobble these 5 books up, but these books are so good and engaging and fun that I had to force myself to stop reading multiple times just so it wouldn't end so quickly😭😭
while I enjoyed this book, I’m only giving it 3.5 because I felt the romance wasn't as strong as the other books— the main characters were very well-written and likable, but for some reason, I just didn’t get as attached, didn’t feel the same longing and attraction between the couple as I did the others in previous books. steamy scenes were a 10/10 though and the world-building was extremely well done as always. I liked how we got more information about the Republic and its cultures. very curious how the plot will develop over the next books.
immediately jumping onto the next one!
I’m binge-reading an incomplete series. I don’t know why I do this to myself. I know I’ll suffer heartbreak and large doses of impatience after I gobble these 5 books up, but these books are so good and engaging and fun that I had to force myself to stop reading multiple times just so it wouldn't end so quickly😭😭
while I enjoyed this book, I’m only giving it 3.5 because I felt the romance wasn't as strong as the other books— the main characters were very well-written and likable, but for some reason, I just didn’t get as attached, didn’t feel the same longing and attraction between the couple as I did the others in previous books. steamy scenes were a 10/10 though and the world-building was extremely well done as always. I liked how we got more information about the Republic and its cultures. very curious how the plot will develop over the next books.
immediately jumping onto the next one!
January 14, 2025
Amara is a self-made merchant, reluctant to use her magic as it feels uncontrollable. She is sent on a mission to the Republic to find the Suloi and bring willing Third House mages with her in exchange for a betrothal to the Sehzade.
Cassian is spurned in the republic, fallen from grace. He steals Suloi slaves and helps them escape from smuggling rings.
In this instalment, we get a more expansive view of the world. We see how Tamar is dependent on magic which makes them technologically slacking: we see the repercussions of the Sundering and the persecution of mages.
Amara comes from a broken past of indenture, brothels, and violence. Cassian has faced betrayal, shame, and guilt. They can both see each other reflected back at themselves but both are scared to trust someone else.
It was a crime that she was beautiful, a ploy by the gods to fool people into trusting her. Or perhaps it was warning, like the bright colors of a venomous serpent. But gods… if he could paint her. Or there was that piece of mahogany that had been taunting him for years, refusing to tell him what it wished to be…
The emphasis was on finding and creating and protecting your own family.
The ending felt more fast-paced, jam-packed and rushed than the other instalments and that made me feel slightly unsatisfied.
Bookstagram
Cassian is spurned in the republic, fallen from grace. He steals Suloi slaves and helps them escape from smuggling rings.
In this instalment, we get a more expansive view of the world. We see how Tamar is dependent on magic which makes them technologically slacking: we see the repercussions of the Sundering and the persecution of mages.
Amara comes from a broken past of indenture, brothels, and violence. Cassian has faced betrayal, shame, and guilt. They can both see each other reflected back at themselves but both are scared to trust someone else.
It was a crime that she was beautiful, a ploy by the gods to fool people into trusting her. Or perhaps it was warning, like the bright colors of a venomous serpent. But gods… if he could paint her. Or there was that piece of mahogany that had been taunting him for years, refusing to tell him what it wished to be…
The emphasis was on finding and creating and protecting your own family.
The ending felt more fast-paced, jam-packed and rushed than the other instalments and that made me feel slightly unsatisfied.
Bookstagram
Read
May 28, 2020Siren & Scion is book three in the Mages of the Wheel series. It's available now!
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0888388LN
She will stop at nothing to rise from her past. He wants revenge on those who stole everything from him.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0888388LN
She will stop at nothing to rise from her past. He wants revenge on those who stole everything from him.
December 16, 2022
Wasn't a big fan of the romance in this one but i love the worldbuilding, plot and characters so much. I can't wait for the next books in this series (I want Cemil to get a book soooooo bad, the redemption arc would be absolutely delicious)
June 8, 2025
4.5 stars. This is such a great series. I really loved the characters in this book and the introduction to water magic too. I thought this book was a little lighter on the angst and political shenanigans, which are two things I adore about this series. I didn't feel torn apart. However, I loved Amara and Cassian and the found family.
The audiobook was fantastic.
The audiobook was fantastic.
January 7, 2024
5⭐️ Absolutely stunning. This series keeps cementing itself as an all time favourite. Will return to write a fuller review—but in case I forget, do yourself a favour and read this entire series via audiobook. It’s so immersive and I just want to talk about it all day long.
September 24, 2024
"She was beautiful the way the ocean was beautiful. In a new way every time one looked"
A beautiful continuation of the brilliant story set up in Reign & Ruin. If I had to pick though, this one might be the weakest of the 3 so far. That being said, compared to most other romantasies - it's still a solid read.
It follows Amara sent off to the Republic to recruit/find a mage of the house thought extinct. She sails off with her accomplices and along the way encounters a duo that agrees to help them. As they all start to work together, circumstances and emotions alike become messy and entangled.
Both the plot and the romance in this one felt muuuch slower than the first 2. It kinda feels like a side quest, and the first half in particular is kinda meandering. The second half is strong though, and the plot and romance do indeed pick up.
Found family is a major part of this book and I think that was done beautifully!! My biggest gripe with this book, unfortunately, was the FMC Amara. She starts out seemingly great, but in the middle she does become a bit insufferable and hypocritical - I had so much secondhand embarassment for her lol. She does have an epiphany towards the end and pulls it together, but it's a bit of a rough ride. Cassian, the MMC however, is an absolutely adorable, awkward ray of sunshine. I didn't find the romance quite as compelling as in the first two books. There aren't a ton of meaningful interaction between the MCs at first, but eventually it does become clear why the two respect and admire the other so much.
On to the next! Still enamoured with this world.
"Our paths are the trails our feet tread while we are looking at the road we want to take."
A beautiful continuation of the brilliant story set up in Reign & Ruin. If I had to pick though, this one might be the weakest of the 3 so far. That being said, compared to most other romantasies - it's still a solid read.
It follows Amara sent off to the Republic to recruit/find a mage of the house thought extinct. She sails off with her accomplices and along the way encounters a duo that agrees to help them. As they all start to work together, circumstances and emotions alike become messy and entangled.
Both the plot and the romance in this one felt muuuch slower than the first 2. It kinda feels like a side quest, and the first half in particular is kinda meandering. The second half is strong though, and the plot and romance do indeed pick up.
Found family is a major part of this book and I think that was done beautifully!! My biggest gripe with this book, unfortunately, was the FMC Amara. She starts out seemingly great, but in the middle she does become a bit insufferable and hypocritical - I had so much secondhand embarassment for her lol. She does have an epiphany towards the end and pulls it together, but it's a bit of a rough ride. Cassian, the MMC however, is an absolutely adorable, awkward ray of sunshine. I didn't find the romance quite as compelling as in the first two books. There aren't a ton of meaningful interaction between the MCs at first, but eventually it does become clear why the two respect and admire the other so much.
On to the next! Still enamoured with this world.
"Our paths are the trails our feet tread while we are looking at the road we want to take."
January 21, 2025
~ 3.5 stars ~
Wow, this series is one of kind! This was a huge improvement for me over Storm & Shield. While I still think Reign & Ruin is the best of the series so far, Siren & Scion was a return to form, with greater focus on plot and world building that I felt fell by the wayside in Book 2. I loved the expansion of the world and the accompanying expansion of the political machinations.
Amara and cassian were individually interesting and i enjoyed their playful dynamic, though i did find the shift from more disdain to romance a bit abrupt for my tastes. I really like the side characters, they add in more depth to the story.
This book moved the overall series plotline forward significantly, which I appreciated, and seeing another part of the world made the book and the series as a whole feel more fleshed-out.
Wow, this series is one of kind! This was a huge improvement for me over Storm & Shield. While I still think Reign & Ruin is the best of the series so far, Siren & Scion was a return to form, with greater focus on plot and world building that I felt fell by the wayside in Book 2. I loved the expansion of the world and the accompanying expansion of the political machinations.
Amara and cassian were individually interesting and i enjoyed their playful dynamic, though i did find the shift from more disdain to romance a bit abrupt for my tastes. I really like the side characters, they add in more depth to the story.
This book moved the overall series plotline forward significantly, which I appreciated, and seeing another part of the world made the book and the series as a whole feel more fleshed-out.
September 3, 2024
Another great installment in a wonderful series that manages to strike just the right balance between fantasy & romance. After a more light-hearted & playful love story in book 2, the main characters in Siren & Scion experienced a very tender romance that kept growing throughout the story.
I liked how the world was expanded upon and a new region finally explored. Also, the side characters and found family vibes added so much to the story, I enjoyed that aspect a lot. We still don't know enough about the big overarching plot, though, so I hope we will get more insight in the next one.
I liked how the world was expanded upon and a new region finally explored. Also, the side characters and found family vibes added so much to the story, I enjoyed that aspect a lot. We still don't know enough about the big overarching plot, though, so I hope we will get more insight in the next one.
November 28, 2022
i don’t know what happened to this book, it was slow, boring, and i couldn’t feel the chemistry between the love interests at all. if you compare them to makram and naime or aysel and bashir they’d look as bland as flour. the romance has been so swoony in the last two books, this one was just…there.
i’ve been loving this series so much, the worldbuilding is amazing and the characters are beautiful, but this one?? kinda fell off.
i was excited for siren & scion. after all, it talks about being hidden in an enemy kingdom to rescue prisoners and freeing slaves. it had the found family and a cute smuggler with a heart of gold, all the things that were supposed to make this a GREAT book. i thought it was gonna have me at the edge of my seat the whole time, but it didn’t. it took me SO LONG to read this, i could not just get into it?? it wasn’t TERRIBLE, but it’s definitely not my favorite of the series.
i had to claw my way to the end cause i want to read the following books and i knew i had to read this one to read the rest. it’s the only reason why i kept going, or i would’ve dropped it long ago. i think i’m so harsh to it cause i loved the other books SO MUCH and i had such high expectations for this.
don’t get me wrong, amara and cassian have really sweet and beautiful moments together, after all, it’s still the same amazing author that wrote those scenes and there’s nothing i adore more than the worshipper male characters she writes about. cassian’s words were beautiful and thoughtful, he was just such a romantic character, you could tell he was an artist. i liked how amara was so confident in her own body even when she was afraid of herself. how she achieved every goal she set, saw what she wanted and took it.
either way, i never felt the connection between cassian and amara. you could tell that they were going to be lovers, of course, but i never felt the tension and yearning i felt with the other books. it bothered me how LONG it took amara to get ahold of herself and her magic. more than the 70% of the book went through and she was still fighting it and letting everything go to absolute hell when she could’ve helped. everything was dragged too long but her joining the circle was so rushed? it didn’t sit right with me. i do want to see more about djar though, i loved his character so much.
to be honest, i wanted to give it 2 stars instead of 3 but i love the author’s writing too much, and after all, it was a pretty good book. maybe i just wasn’t in the right time to read it. who knows. what i do know is that i can’t wait for the next one.
i’ve been loving this series so much, the worldbuilding is amazing and the characters are beautiful, but this one?? kinda fell off.
i was excited for siren & scion. after all, it talks about being hidden in an enemy kingdom to rescue prisoners and freeing slaves. it had the found family and a cute smuggler with a heart of gold, all the things that were supposed to make this a GREAT book. i thought it was gonna have me at the edge of my seat the whole time, but it didn’t. it took me SO LONG to read this, i could not just get into it?? it wasn’t TERRIBLE, but it’s definitely not my favorite of the series.
i had to claw my way to the end cause i want to read the following books and i knew i had to read this one to read the rest. it’s the only reason why i kept going, or i would’ve dropped it long ago. i think i’m so harsh to it cause i loved the other books SO MUCH and i had such high expectations for this.
don’t get me wrong, amara and cassian have really sweet and beautiful moments together, after all, it’s still the same amazing author that wrote those scenes and there’s nothing i adore more than the worshipper male characters she writes about. cassian’s words were beautiful and thoughtful, he was just such a romantic character, you could tell he was an artist. i liked how amara was so confident in her own body even when she was afraid of herself. how she achieved every goal she set, saw what she wanted and took it.
either way, i never felt the connection between cassian and amara. you could tell that they were going to be lovers, of course, but i never felt the tension and yearning i felt with the other books. it bothered me how LONG it took amara to get ahold of herself and her magic. more than the 70% of the book went through and she was still fighting it and letting everything go to absolute hell when she could’ve helped. everything was dragged too long but her joining the circle was so rushed? it didn’t sit right with me. i do want to see more about djar though, i loved his character so much.
to be honest, i wanted to give it 2 stars instead of 3 but i love the author’s writing too much, and after all, it was a pretty good book. maybe i just wasn’t in the right time to read it. who knows. what i do know is that i can’t wait for the next one.
December 1, 2023
Characters were likable but for me it was still hard to relate to them. They didn't feel interesting enough.
I still adore the world and setting, it felt again adventurous. I would have loved to know more about the big story that connects all the books in the series.
This felt a bit too long, and for me it dragged.
I still adore the world and setting, it felt again adventurous. I would have loved to know more about the big story that connects all the books in the series.
This felt a bit too long, and for me it dragged.
September 5, 2020
Heartbreaking, empowering, and exquisitely beautiful. I continue to be entranced by everything Evans writes. I loved Amara’s magic and her relationships with her created family.
January 10, 2026
The next one in the series moves away from the location of the previous books, into The Republic, which is kind of a steampunk ancient Rome? I kind of missed the desert vibes that I'd liked in the first books, and also the other characters were barely present since they were across the ocean. Which is less of a big deal since each book focuses mainly on another couple, but because of both the location and character change it felt a little more disconnected from the previous ones.
The thing that brought this book down for me was her constant belief that her powerful magic made her evil, and she always refused to use it and thought it made her a terrible person. You have badass magic, just don't abuse it and you'll be fine! The constant self hatred she had for herself because of it, and her refusal to embrace her power got pretty old.
I was also not sure that I bought the relationship between them on an emotional level, it seemed to be based more on physical attraction and just a general feeling of being drawn together without as much explanation about what they specifically liked about each other. I thought her character did have a lot of promise though, I'd liked that she was this kind of self made business woman who was pretty confident (except when it came to her magic). But overall there was something with this one that didn't click for me.
The thing that brought this book down for me was her constant belief that her powerful magic made her evil, and she always refused to use it and thought it made her a terrible person. You have badass magic, just don't abuse it and you'll be fine! The constant self hatred she had for herself because of it, and her refusal to embrace her power got pretty old.
I was also not sure that I bought the relationship between them on an emotional level, it seemed to be based more on physical attraction and just a general feeling of being drawn together without as much explanation about what they specifically liked about each other. I thought her character did have a lot of promise though, I'd liked that she was this kind of self made business woman who was pretty confident (except when it came to her magic). But overall there was something with this one that didn't click for me.
September 22, 2025
The first 25% of the book weren't really my cup of tea. It was very political and filled with heavier emotional content. Yeah, I know, all the other books in this series are centered around those topics, but this one was just a bit too much at the start. It wasn't helping that I found Amara as an unlikeable FMC. Now after I finished the story I don't think she's unlikeable anymore, but I find it really hard to connect with her. Nevertheless, the rest of the story compensated really well for the rocky begging. I think this might be my leaf favourite book in this series so far, but I'm excited for the next one.
Also, 🗣️ PEOPLE NEED CEMIL'S STORY! (I'm people 🤭)
Also, 🗣️ PEOPLE NEED CEMIL'S STORY! (I'm people 🤭)
December 22, 2020
With this being the third book in the series, I figured I had a good idea of what to excpect. There would be a man and a woman, and they'd fall for each other, suffer complications, and sort things out. There would be a bit of action, a bit of sex, some magic shenanigans, and the overarching plot of the series would move forward a little bit.
It's what I got from the previous books, and it worked really well with them, so I was hoping for more of the same.
I'm happy to say I was not disappointed.
The book is more of the same, but it's not just more of the same. What I realised while reading is that each book so far has been different in the way it approaches its characters and its reader.
The first book is set against a backdrop of political intrigue, and centred around high-stakes power plays. Tense, and serious.
The second book is more light hearted, and I laughed out loud several times. There's a focus on trust and duty, and while it's often funny, there are a lot of very serious undertones in it.
The third book now, is different again. It's about broken people struggling against themselves and their pasts. It's about knowing yourself, and how what we want isn't necessarily what we need.
I'm looking forward to seeing where the fourth book takes us.
What I'll whine about.
The overarching plot of the series is really interesting, and I'd like to see a bit more of it. That said, that's a complaint that arose after I finished the book, and not something I paid attention to while actually reading.
I'll never be as awesome a lover as Cassian. I'll just stay single.
What I'll gush about.
The writing. It's smooth, clear, and flows like running water. There's no need to stop and reread anything, and there's no confusion about who's talking. There are no stumbling stones between me and the story, and I love that.
The magic. It manages to be both spectacular and subtle at the same time. It's held back and kept in the background for a lot of the story, but when it's finally released, it knocks the world over.
Final words
This series is turning out to be my big positive reading surprise for the year. I really didn't expect to enjoy this as much as I did.
It's what I got from the previous books, and it worked really well with them, so I was hoping for more of the same.
I'm happy to say I was not disappointed.
The book is more of the same, but it's not just more of the same. What I realised while reading is that each book so far has been different in the way it approaches its characters and its reader.
The first book is set against a backdrop of political intrigue, and centred around high-stakes power plays. Tense, and serious.
The second book is more light hearted, and I laughed out loud several times. There's a focus on trust and duty, and while it's often funny, there are a lot of very serious undertones in it.
The third book now, is different again. It's about broken people struggling against themselves and their pasts. It's about knowing yourself, and how what we want isn't necessarily what we need.
I'm looking forward to seeing where the fourth book takes us.
What I'll whine about.
The overarching plot of the series is really interesting, and I'd like to see a bit more of it. That said, that's a complaint that arose after I finished the book, and not something I paid attention to while actually reading.
I'll never be as awesome a lover as Cassian. I'll just stay single.
What I'll gush about.
The writing. It's smooth, clear, and flows like running water. There's no need to stop and reread anything, and there's no confusion about who's talking. There are no stumbling stones between me and the story, and I love that.
The magic. It manages to be both spectacular and subtle at the same time. It's held back and kept in the background for a lot of the story, but when it's finally released, it knocks the world over.
Final words
This series is turning out to be my big positive reading surprise for the year. I really didn't expect to enjoy this as much as I did.
October 28, 2024
3.5 stars
To go from 5 stars to 3.5 seems so dramatic, but the FMC was a water sign and she was just SO emotional, at times it was hard to read lol.
The world building continued as we finally got to see the Republic. This book had high stakes, but it seemed like they got out of it easily. I wasn’t a fan of Amara. Not once did she realize that she is judging Ihsan so harshly, I felt like she never gave him compassion for why his magic is now ice. Or the fact that she was using him, comparing him to Cassian wasn’t fair. She was using Ihsan for her own gain, don’t put him down just because… also, I never understood why Amara was so hesitant to use her magic. There were so many times I just wanted to say “girl if you don’t use this mf magic” Anyway, the MC weren’t my favorite but their romance was very sweet. Evans KNOWs how to write romance that is just soooo romantic.
Anyway… let’s get to Ihsan’s book :D
To go from 5 stars to 3.5 seems so dramatic, but the FMC was a water sign and she was just SO emotional, at times it was hard to read lol.
The world building continued as we finally got to see the Republic. This book had high stakes, but it seemed like they got out of it easily. I wasn’t a fan of Amara. Not once did she realize that she is judging Ihsan so harshly, I felt like she never gave him compassion for why his magic is now ice. Or the fact that she was using him, comparing him to Cassian wasn’t fair. She was using Ihsan for her own gain, don’t put him down just because… also, I never understood why Amara was so hesitant to use her magic. There were so many times I just wanted to say “girl if you don’t use this mf magic” Anyway, the MC weren’t my favorite but their romance was very sweet. Evans KNOWs how to write romance that is just soooo romantic.
Anyway… let’s get to Ihsan’s book :D
June 6, 2020
I had my doubts at the start of this book but I ended up liking it as much as the first book in the series. I really like the author's writing style and the lyricism of her word choice. She got me to root for two characters who I was less than enamored with at first glance at the start of the book and their unfolding relationship. The magic system while confusing at points is really fascinating.
June 9, 2025
The complexity of the world-building in these books is stunning. Evans builds out diverse groups of people with their own ways of speaking and viewing the world, and the detail is immaculate.
As with the other books, we have unique characters with rich complexities - and, in keeping with the first book, we have an MMC who is happy to be "less than" the FMC. Evans ignores the alpha male tropes in favor of writing strong men who do the right thing and are happy to let their women be the stronger ones. Indeed, Amara even speaks multiple times to the fact that women are the strength in every culture, in every nation.
While it was interesting to have a change of setting here, I think removing the action from Tamar for almost all of the book somewhat lessened the heft of the overarching plot. Were I in a less critical mood, this would be a five-star book.
As with the other books, we have unique characters with rich complexities - and, in keeping with the first book, we have an MMC who is happy to be "less than" the FMC. Evans ignores the alpha male tropes in favor of writing strong men who do the right thing and are happy to let their women be the stronger ones. Indeed, Amara even speaks multiple times to the fact that women are the strength in every culture, in every nation.
While it was interesting to have a change of setting here, I think removing the action from Tamar for almost all of the book somewhat lessened the heft of the overarching plot. Were I in a less critical mood, this would be a five-star book.
April 16, 2025
3.5 stars
I continue to like the world and characters, and really enjoyed learning about another culture in this world..but again this one feels more normal to the genre vs books 1 and prequel feeling more stand out
We get a little more schemey back which I appreciate, but this one could’ve been shorter.
I’m also starting to get confused on how the changing perspectives from book to book will allow us to actually wrap things up - both the throughline plot and especially in this one loose threads from the individual books.
Guess just keep trusting the process as I am having fun, and higher hopes for much more scheming in the next book based on who the POV will be
I continue to like the world and characters, and really enjoyed learning about another culture in this world..but again this one feels more normal to the genre vs books 1 and prequel feeling more stand out
We get a little more schemey back which I appreciate, but this one could’ve been shorter.
I’m also starting to get confused on how the changing perspectives from book to book will allow us to actually wrap things up - both the throughline plot and especially in this one loose threads from the individual books.
Guess just keep trusting the process as I am having fun, and higher hopes for much more scheming in the next book based on who the POV will be
November 11, 2024
3,75 stars
I didn't like this book as much as the first two, but it was still really good. It took me a while to get into, and there were parts I wasn't really invested in.
I liked Cassian and Amara, especially how pathetic Cassian was for her, but they didn't stick out to me. I'm so excited to continue and read Ilshan's book (I just know it's going to be my favourite).
I didn't like this book as much as the first two, but it was still really good. It took me a while to get into, and there were parts I wasn't really invested in.
I liked Cassian and Amara, especially how pathetic Cassian was for her, but they didn't stick out to me. I'm so excited to continue and read Ilshan's book (I just know it's going to be my favourite).
August 28, 2024
Amara and Cassian’s book was great - just to get into the rest of the continent and meet new countries and races and magic systems.
This series is so good simply because the magic system is balanced and smart, the characters feel true to themselves and the plot is actually moving somewhere larger than just this book
All in all - highly recommend for high fantasy lovers
This series is so good simply because the magic system is balanced and smart, the characters feel true to themselves and the plot is actually moving somewhere larger than just this book
All in all - highly recommend for high fantasy lovers
October 26, 2024
This is the third book in the Mages of the Wheel series and probably my least favorite so far. It wasn’t bad, it just wasn’t great. The story between Amara and Cassian just didn’t grab me the same way the couples in the first two books did. I am also noticing a pattern with the plots, and I think that distracted me from really enjoying the story and deterring me from wanting to read book 4.
Anyway, I’ll be taking a break before I continue on with the series.
Anyway, I’ll be taking a break before I continue on with the series.
August 24, 2025
3.75
This series continues to scratch the romantasy itch
This series continues to scratch the romantasy itch
Displaying 1 - 30 of 448 reviews