What do you think?
Rate this book
A Botanic Hill Detectives Mystery #1
Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets
World-famous Egyptologist Dr. Winston Thornsley died suddenly two months ago in disgrace. His widow, Ida Thornsley, remains convinced her husband was falsely accused of stealing an ancient burial urn he discovered in Egypt last summer, but local and federal law enforcement officers are stumped.
Mrs. Thornsley, desperate for answers, calls in her thirteen-year-old neighbors, the Botanic Hill Detectives—twins Lanny and Lexi Wyatt, Moki Kalani, and Rani Kumar. Their exciting mission? To find the urn and its real thief, bring the criminal to justice, and exonerate Dr. Thornsley so his spotless reputation can be restored.
A roomful of venomous snakes, the poisoned Egyptian pond, and Dragon Pit Man are just a few of the tests awaiting the four tech-savvy teenagers. As the detectives begin to unravel the sinister plot, the mystery takes a dangerous turn. Answers are at their fingertips—if they can only convince their parents to let them solve the case.
Mrs. Thornsley, desperate for answers, calls in her thirteen-year-old neighbors, the Botanic Hill Detectives—twins Lanny and Lexi Wyatt, Moki Kalani, and Rani Kumar. Their exciting mission? To find the urn and its real thief, bring the criminal to justice, and exonerate Dr. Thornsley so his spotless reputation can be restored.
A roomful of venomous snakes, the poisoned Egyptian pond, and Dragon Pit Man are just a few of the tests awaiting the four tech-savvy teenagers. As the detectives begin to unravel the sinister plot, the mystery takes a dangerous turn. Answers are at their fingertips—if they can only convince their parents to let them solve the case.
206 pages, Paperback
First published October 11, 2022
17 people are currently reading
192 people want to read
About the author
Sherrill Joseph
4 books98 followersSherrill Joseph, a retired teacher turned multiple award-winning author, created The Botanic Hill Detectives Mysteries series for children ages 9-14 so she could stay connected with kids, who rock.
Joseph presents responsible, role-model detective characters who provide readers with a fun mystery to solve and something to learn while showing that being respectful and helpful citizens can be cool!
She lives in San Diego, California, in a 1928 Spanish Mission Revival bungalow. Her historic neighborhood, Nancy Drew, and lexical-gustatory synesthesia inspire her writing. The author promises many more adventures with her detectives to come.
Joseph presents responsible, role-model detective characters who provide readers with a fun mystery to solve and something to learn while showing that being respectful and helpful citizens can be cool!
She lives in San Diego, California, in a 1928 Spanish Mission Revival bungalow. Her historic neighborhood, Nancy Drew, and lexical-gustatory synesthesia inspire her writing. The author promises many more adventures with her detectives to come.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 159 reviews
February 2, 2020
Blog | Twitter | Instagram | Amazon | B&N
Thank you NetGalley and Acorn Publishing for this ARC. All thoughts and opinions are mine.
As an adult, I've done my best to make up for those pre-teen years when other readers were gorging themselves on stories of Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys (or other like-minded mysteries that to this day I am not as well versed in as I wish I were). I've done a fairly good job with the Nancy Drew books, have greatly enjoyed them for the sake of nostalgia, and have even become a huge fan of the PC games based on the series. Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets brought back those same cozy and comfortable feels that I get whenever I pick up a Nancy Drew mystery.
Don't let the rating fool you, overall, I enjoyed the read. It's a cute mystery, with an adorable group of four young friends who go around solving cases on their parents' many travels and in their hometown. But the book was far too much like the Nancy Drew ones I've read, so much alike as a matter of fact that it was as if a template of it had been taken and the specifics altered to make it its own copy.
The story was fun to follow, but it was very simplistic. And the world around the characters is premised as a vibrant and lush setting but we barely get enough detail in it. Books for young readers can be as full and detailed as they are for adults—I think we're at a point in literature where this younger targeted audience is more than happy to become as engrossed in a heavier story as the more mature readers do.
All in all, for an easy and swift read, this is a good one to go with. Not a lot of time is spent dwelling on the culprit of the story and the mystery behind which he does what he does, but that's, again, very similar to past mysteries of of this book's ilk. Pick this one up and you will fly through it, and truly do get to meet an amusing and sweet bunch of kids who will take you on a merry little chase.
Thank you NetGalley and Acorn Publishing for this ARC. All thoughts and opinions are mine.
As an adult, I've done my best to make up for those pre-teen years when other readers were gorging themselves on stories of Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys (or other like-minded mysteries that to this day I am not as well versed in as I wish I were). I've done a fairly good job with the Nancy Drew books, have greatly enjoyed them for the sake of nostalgia, and have even become a huge fan of the PC games based on the series. Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets brought back those same cozy and comfortable feels that I get whenever I pick up a Nancy Drew mystery.
Don't let the rating fool you, overall, I enjoyed the read. It's a cute mystery, with an adorable group of four young friends who go around solving cases on their parents' many travels and in their hometown. But the book was far too much like the Nancy Drew ones I've read, so much alike as a matter of fact that it was as if a template of it had been taken and the specifics altered to make it its own copy.
The story was fun to follow, but it was very simplistic. And the world around the characters is premised as a vibrant and lush setting but we barely get enough detail in it. Books for young readers can be as full and detailed as they are for adults—I think we're at a point in literature where this younger targeted audience is more than happy to become as engrossed in a heavier story as the more mature readers do.
All in all, for an easy and swift read, this is a good one to go with. Not a lot of time is spent dwelling on the culprit of the story and the mystery behind which he does what he does, but that's, again, very similar to past mysteries of of this book's ilk. Pick this one up and you will fly through it, and truly do get to meet an amusing and sweet bunch of kids who will take you on a merry little chase.
February 5, 2020
A story where the kids get to be the investigators and have formed: The Botanic Hill Detective Agency. In this new series four best friends love solving mysteries together and learn a little about Egyptian history and reptiles.
Thoughts:
In the town of Las Palmitas are four friends who are well-known for solving mysteries. As the book opens we find Lanny, Lexi, Rani, and Moki at the home of Dr. Thornsley a famous Egyptologist who recently died. His widow, “Mrs. T.” as the kids affectionately call her, want the kids to investigate a missing urn. This isn’t just any urn – it was one found in Egypt containing a mummified Egyptian cobra. Over the last several months, Mrs. T tells the kids that odd things have been occurring – mysterious phone calls, a missing picture, and a break in. But what is most important to Mrs. T is to clear her husband’s good name. He was the last one to be seen with the ancient urn and there are many who believe he had something to do with its disappearance.
The four kids have a lot of fun working together and are a pretty cohesive group during their investigation. Lanny and Lexi are twins, with Lanny being the group leader and always knowing how to get down to business. Moki is from Hawaii and shares a lot of Hawaiian words with readers and Rani is from India and is a synesthete – someone who experiences a taste or smell when hearing a word or name.
Other fun facts kids will learn are:
- Hawaii has no snakes. (I had to look this one up to see how true it is)
- Van Gogh had synesthesia
- Egyptians had a cobra goddess named Wadjet
- Komodo dragons have venom sacs in their mouth
- At the end of the book is a Hawaiian dictionary with pronunciation guide and definitions of the
words used during the story.
Overall, the Nutmeg Street reminded me a little of Encyclopedia Brown in the way the kids went about solving the case, but in the Acknowledgement section the author mentions how she was inspired by Nancy Drew. Even though I enjoyed its enthusiasm and tone of the book, I did find the beginning a bit awkward in how the detective agency was introduced. The mystery starts with the kids already gathered at the house of Mrs. T and it makes you feel as if you are stepping into a story that has already started. But the four main characters have a lot going for them and I think young readers will really appreciate their energy and way they approach the mystery.
Rating: 3.5 stars
Thoughts:
In the town of Las Palmitas are four friends who are well-known for solving mysteries. As the book opens we find Lanny, Lexi, Rani, and Moki at the home of Dr. Thornsley a famous Egyptologist who recently died. His widow, “Mrs. T.” as the kids affectionately call her, want the kids to investigate a missing urn. This isn’t just any urn – it was one found in Egypt containing a mummified Egyptian cobra. Over the last several months, Mrs. T tells the kids that odd things have been occurring – mysterious phone calls, a missing picture, and a break in. But what is most important to Mrs. T is to clear her husband’s good name. He was the last one to be seen with the ancient urn and there are many who believe he had something to do with its disappearance.
The four kids have a lot of fun working together and are a pretty cohesive group during their investigation. Lanny and Lexi are twins, with Lanny being the group leader and always knowing how to get down to business. Moki is from Hawaii and shares a lot of Hawaiian words with readers and Rani is from India and is a synesthete – someone who experiences a taste or smell when hearing a word or name.
Other fun facts kids will learn are:
- Hawaii has no snakes. (I had to look this one up to see how true it is)
- Van Gogh had synesthesia
- Egyptians had a cobra goddess named Wadjet
- Komodo dragons have venom sacs in their mouth
- At the end of the book is a Hawaiian dictionary with pronunciation guide and definitions of the
words used during the story.
Overall, the Nutmeg Street reminded me a little of Encyclopedia Brown in the way the kids went about solving the case, but in the Acknowledgement section the author mentions how she was inspired by Nancy Drew. Even though I enjoyed its enthusiasm and tone of the book, I did find the beginning a bit awkward in how the detective agency was introduced. The mystery starts with the kids already gathered at the house of Mrs. T and it makes you feel as if you are stepping into a story that has already started. But the four main characters have a lot going for them and I think young readers will really appreciate their energy and way they approach the mystery.
Rating: 3.5 stars
February 1, 2020
Four fun investigators were called to solve a dangerous case of theft.
Dr. Thornsley was falsely accused of theft of the ancient urn, and he died in disgrace. His wife wanted to prove his innocence so she hired her neighbors, the four investigators twins Lanny and Lexi, Moki and Rani. And yeh adventure began.
My first book by author Sherril Joseph, was a fun filled ride. Though meant for middle grade kids, I enjoyed the way they investigated. There was an innocent thrill along with nostalgia while reading the book.
Multicultural and informative, the Egyptian mythology and characterization caught my interest. It was quite informative too. The style of writing was easy to read, and the capers were fun filled and quite adventurous. The descriptions of the neighborhood of Botanic Garden made the visual imagery of the setting vivid.
The only niggle I could think of that sometimes I felt the characters were a little older thank their thirteen years. They sounded mature at times.
Overall, filled with twists and adventures, this book was easily read in less than two hours. A fun read
Dr. Thornsley was falsely accused of theft of the ancient urn, and he died in disgrace. His wife wanted to prove his innocence so she hired her neighbors, the four investigators twins Lanny and Lexi, Moki and Rani. And yeh adventure began.
My first book by author Sherril Joseph, was a fun filled ride. Though meant for middle grade kids, I enjoyed the way they investigated. There was an innocent thrill along with nostalgia while reading the book.
Multicultural and informative, the Egyptian mythology and characterization caught my interest. It was quite informative too. The style of writing was easy to read, and the capers were fun filled and quite adventurous. The descriptions of the neighborhood of Botanic Garden made the visual imagery of the setting vivid.
The only niggle I could think of that sometimes I felt the characters were a little older thank their thirteen years. They sounded mature at times.
Overall, filled with twists and adventures, this book was easily read in less than two hours. A fun read
October 30, 2020
Eucalyptus Street: Green Curse is a middle grade mystery novel by Sherrill Joseph.
This is a great story for young readers getting into mystrey novels because it has a lot of exciting elements, get doesn't become too complicated where they'd lose their interest. All the characters will be relatable to kids because even though they're detectives, at the end of the day they're still kids and their personalities resonate.
The writing could have been a little bit better, but it was in no way bad.
This reminds me of the detective novels I read during my childhood, but is more befitting and uplifted to fit the tastes of present day mystrey lovers (don't worry everyone can enjoy it but it has a more modern feel to it).
🦄🦄🦄
Rated 8.5/10
Melina L.
This is a great story for young readers getting into mystrey novels because it has a lot of exciting elements, get doesn't become too complicated where they'd lose their interest. All the characters will be relatable to kids because even though they're detectives, at the end of the day they're still kids and their personalities resonate.
The writing could have been a little bit better, but it was in no way bad.
This reminds me of the detective novels I read during my childhood, but is more befitting and uplifted to fit the tastes of present day mystrey lovers (don't worry everyone can enjoy it but it has a more modern feel to it).
🦄🦄🦄
Rated 8.5/10
Melina L.
August 30, 2022
In this latest Bonatic Hill Detectives mystery by author Sherrill Joseph, the crew is headed to Hawaii to search for a missing black pearl necklace. The necklace disappeared during its owner’s internment in a Japanese camp during World War II. Lanny, Lexi, Moki and Rani are eager to take on the case. Joseph peppers the book with tidbit of learning, from languages to cuisine, culture to the history of Japanese-Americans during WWII, but kids won’t feel like they’re at school. The investigation is action-packed, including a kidnapping, a theft, a silly string assault, and more. It’s Nancy Drew and The Hardy Boys rolled into one.
November 4, 2019
Perfect for upper elementary and middle school students! In the first book in the Botanic Hill Mystery series 4 teenagers work together to solve the mystery of a missing Egyptian urn. I enjoyed learning about the Egyptology that was woven throughout the story.
September 28, 2020
Sometimes I wish I had children, so I could share books like Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets by Sherrill Joseph with them. Good thing I have a god-daughter that I will pass this book onto when she gets to advanced elementary or middle school level in her reading!
Nutmeg Street really took me back to my childhood in regards to how much it reminded me of the various mystery series I read. But before I get to those ones, I want to mention the adult series Amelia Peabody by Elizbeth Peters. I feel like Ramses’, Amelia’s son, childhood would have been a lot like those of Lanny, Lexi, Moki, and Rani.
Sure there’s Egypt playing such a large role in both series, but more so how intelligent, inquisitive, and polite the kids are.
Also in the Amelia Peabody series, the family had servants and tutors, and Lanny and Lexi have a live-in cook and a 25 year old tutor who also acts as their chauffeur with his Mustang that the kids feel give them a cool factor.
As for the children’s series it reminded me of, I would have to say Nancy Drew and Scooby Doo. I didn’t read the Boxcar Children or the Bobbsey Twins, but I feel like there could be nods to these series too in the Botanical Hills series, and one obvious one is the twins in this series and in the Bobbsey Twins.
As for reminding me of Nancy Drew, the biggest thing is the group of friends aspect. And I smiled when the criminal was revealed, because although they didn’t say it exactly, there was a Scooby Doo expression along the lines of, “And I would have gotten away with it too, if it wasn’t for you meddling kids!”
At times the Botanical Hills series has a bit of an old-timey feel, but I think parents will really appreciate that if reading this with their children. And even though Lanny and Lexi still have a landline at their house, today’s technology is used in the story.
Another great thing about this book that I think parents will enjoy is the way it doesn't shy away from big words and how well Joseph incorporates defining them into the story. There are also a couple pages in the back of the book with Hawaiian words and pronunciations, since Moki is originally from there. Plus you have all the interesting history about Egypt seamlessly woven into the book. And one last fun thing is Rani and the author both have a form of synesthesia, where they can taste words.
I am really looking forward to Eucalyptus Street: Green Curse out October 20, 2020. What mystery lover doesn’t enjoy reading about a mysterious old mansion, a seventy-year old puzzle poem, dusty secret passages, a hidden gemstone, and a flickering light in a nearby cemetery. And book three appears to be called, Walnut Street: Phantom Rider which may have a cowboy theme. I really think it’s cool how the series seems to showcase different subjects in each book, kind of like the Magic Tree House series.
Nutmeg Street really took me back to my childhood in regards to how much it reminded me of the various mystery series I read. But before I get to those ones, I want to mention the adult series Amelia Peabody by Elizbeth Peters. I feel like Ramses’, Amelia’s son, childhood would have been a lot like those of Lanny, Lexi, Moki, and Rani.
Sure there’s Egypt playing such a large role in both series, but more so how intelligent, inquisitive, and polite the kids are.
Also in the Amelia Peabody series, the family had servants and tutors, and Lanny and Lexi have a live-in cook and a 25 year old tutor who also acts as their chauffeur with his Mustang that the kids feel give them a cool factor.
As for the children’s series it reminded me of, I would have to say Nancy Drew and Scooby Doo. I didn’t read the Boxcar Children or the Bobbsey Twins, but I feel like there could be nods to these series too in the Botanical Hills series, and one obvious one is the twins in this series and in the Bobbsey Twins.
As for reminding me of Nancy Drew, the biggest thing is the group of friends aspect. And I smiled when the criminal was revealed, because although they didn’t say it exactly, there was a Scooby Doo expression along the lines of, “And I would have gotten away with it too, if it wasn’t for you meddling kids!”
At times the Botanical Hills series has a bit of an old-timey feel, but I think parents will really appreciate that if reading this with their children. And even though Lanny and Lexi still have a landline at their house, today’s technology is used in the story.
Another great thing about this book that I think parents will enjoy is the way it doesn't shy away from big words and how well Joseph incorporates defining them into the story. There are also a couple pages in the back of the book with Hawaiian words and pronunciations, since Moki is originally from there. Plus you have all the interesting history about Egypt seamlessly woven into the book. And one last fun thing is Rani and the author both have a form of synesthesia, where they can taste words.
I am really looking forward to Eucalyptus Street: Green Curse out October 20, 2020. What mystery lover doesn’t enjoy reading about a mysterious old mansion, a seventy-year old puzzle poem, dusty secret passages, a hidden gemstone, and a flickering light in a nearby cemetery. And book three appears to be called, Walnut Street: Phantom Rider which may have a cowboy theme. I really think it’s cool how the series seems to showcase different subjects in each book, kind of like the Magic Tree House series.
January 2, 2020
When I was a child some of my favorite books were "Alfred Hitchcock and the three investigators" so when I learnt of "Nutmeg Street: Egyptian secrets" I knew this was right up my alley. In this first book in the Botanic Hill Mystery series, four teenage detectives have to uncover a thief and blackmailer while restoring one of their neighbors reputation.
Not only was this entertaining but also a tool for kids to learn about Ancient Egypt (one of my favorite themes), herpetology or Hawaiian language.
I think it was nice that the four main characters were from different cultures, making it appealing to a wider range of readers.
Although the plot was a bit predictable, you have to keep in mind that this is aimed to middle grade kids, not adults who have been reading mysteries for years (and that's directed to my almost 40 year old self).
This was a fun read perfect for young readers whom are discovering the pleasure of reading.
Thanks to Netgalley and Acorn Publishing LLC for providing an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Not only was this entertaining but also a tool for kids to learn about Ancient Egypt (one of my favorite themes), herpetology or Hawaiian language.
I think it was nice that the four main characters were from different cultures, making it appealing to a wider range of readers.
Although the plot was a bit predictable, you have to keep in mind that this is aimed to middle grade kids, not adults who have been reading mysteries for years (and that's directed to my almost 40 year old self).
This was a fun read perfect for young readers whom are discovering the pleasure of reading.
Thanks to Netgalley and Acorn Publishing LLC for providing an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
February 12, 2020
This is the first of a series with an already established group of friends who solve mysteries. They are official, with a name and credentials and past cases that we are only given glimpses of. The past will probably be referenced in future books in more detail to provide a better picture.
The pair of twins have parents who travel the world for their work and are well versed in most things Egyptian. The case that has been handed to them has to do with a missing urn, the disappearance of which was blamed on a friend of theirs. His widow now wants closure, and they aim to help. There are earthquakes, chase scenes and a thorough examination of all connected topics, especially snakes and the ending makes sense while being unexpected. Although I am not the target audience of this book, I still felt like there was a lot more telling than showing. The nuances of the scenes were told to us instead of being implicit. The children did seem a little on the nose, with the Hawaiian being the biggest and hungriest, the Indian in a Sari (and with previous direct experience with snakes). I agree with another reviewer here that very few thirteen-year-olds would wear a full saree (although my 5-year-old niece does have a custom fun-sized one, usually it is limited to adult women). There are these half saree versions if you are from the south which would have been more comfortable given the spread of the bottom part, or the 'skirt'. The author has actually responded to state that this is taken from an actual person of her acquaintance so that reaction is a moot one.
Overall, it is a promising start, but the narrative style was not exactly my thing. I did like the premise and the potential within it, and I think people younger might like it to broaden their horizons, but slightly older ones might not require the amount of detail in the telling.
I received an ARC thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, but the review is entirely based on my own reading experience.
The pair of twins have parents who travel the world for their work and are well versed in most things Egyptian. The case that has been handed to them has to do with a missing urn, the disappearance of which was blamed on a friend of theirs. His widow now wants closure, and they aim to help. There are earthquakes, chase scenes and a thorough examination of all connected topics, especially snakes and the ending makes sense while being unexpected. Although I am not the target audience of this book, I still felt like there was a lot more telling than showing. The nuances of the scenes were told to us instead of being implicit. The children did seem a little on the nose, with the Hawaiian being the biggest and hungriest, the Indian in a Sari (and with previous direct experience with snakes). I agree with another reviewer here that very few thirteen-year-olds would wear a full saree (although my 5-year-old niece does have a custom fun-sized one, usually it is limited to adult women). There are these half saree versions if you are from the south which would have been more comfortable given the spread of the bottom part, or the 'skirt'. The author has actually responded to state that this is taken from an actual person of her acquaintance so that reaction is a moot one.
Overall, it is a promising start, but the narrative style was not exactly my thing. I did like the premise and the potential within it, and I think people younger might like it to broaden their horizons, but slightly older ones might not require the amount of detail in the telling.
I received an ARC thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, but the review is entirely based on my own reading experience.
July 16, 2020
Twins Lanny and Lexi along with their friends Moki and Rani are detectives solving mysteries in their Botanic Hill neighborhood of Southern California. In this story they are working on the mystery of the death of their friend and neighbor Dr. Thornsley. They also want to clear his name as he is being blamed for stealing from the Antiquities Research Collective where he worked with Lanny and Lexi's parents. By staying with Mrs. Thornsley, after her backyard pond was found with broken pieces the kids find clues that break the case wide open. Knowledge of Egypt and of those who work and live in their neighborhood help them along the path of discovery. There are many twists and turns in this mystery it will keep all readers interested from beginning to end.
I liked all the characters and look forward to reading about more mysteries solved by the friends.
I liked all the characters and look forward to reading about more mysteries solved by the friends.
May 4, 2020
Was looking for a book to read while staying at home during the Covid 19 pandemic when I came across Sherrill Joseph's debut novel Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets, which I was given an ARC (Advanced Reader Copy to read and post an honest review online).
The main characters Lexi, Lanny, Moki and Rani will definitely keep the attention of young readers. These four amateur sleuths demonstrate traits found in real teenagers making them relatable in every sense of the word. Like the reader, the foursome not only expresses all the same emotions but also speaks the younger reader's language.
I believe young readers (ages 9-12) would enjoy Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets (Botanic Hill Detectives Book 1) and highly recommend it.
The main characters Lexi, Lanny, Moki and Rani will definitely keep the attention of young readers. These four amateur sleuths demonstrate traits found in real teenagers making them relatable in every sense of the word. Like the reader, the foursome not only expresses all the same emotions but also speaks the younger reader's language.
I believe young readers (ages 9-12) would enjoy Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets (Botanic Hill Detectives Book 1) and highly recommend it.
March 20, 2020
-I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author via Voracious Readers-
I really liked the story! Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets is full of adventure, fun, and friendship in the mystery. The author did a great job in explaining words or ideas to the audience in a way that was easy to understand and flowed well in the narrative. The only thing I would change was the references to previously solved cases when this is the first book in the series. I highly recommend this book! I am excited to read more adventures with Lanny, Lexi, Moki, and Rani!
I really liked the story! Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets is full of adventure, fun, and friendship in the mystery. The author did a great job in explaining words or ideas to the audience in a way that was easy to understand and flowed well in the narrative. The only thing I would change was the references to previously solved cases when this is the first book in the series. I highly recommend this book! I am excited to read more adventures with Lanny, Lexi, Moki, and Rani!
May 28, 2020
I received this book in exchange for an honest review, which has not altered my opinion of this book.
I love mysteries and I love ancient history and so together it’s logical that they would be a lot of fun together. This story really did bring both aspects together, however the writing left something to be desired for me. I will say that there were plenty of fun facts and tidbits of information that I really appreciated, this was awesome and I learned quite a bit from the story. There’s also a solid mystery that I had nearly figured out by the end of the book. I liked the characters as well, they were interesting and unique and really smart, but didn’t always act like the kids they were.
The story took a bit of getting into and the characters were difficult for me to keep straight at several different points. That being said, they were smart and talked like dictionaries and almanacs which was helpful as far as learning but not quite as good for the plot. I understand the desire to keep facts true and not to overimgine anything but this story got a bit tiresome at points and I found myself getting stilled by the choppy writing.
All that being said, this was a solidly good mystery with a lot of interesting and fun information. I’m curious if there will be more books in the series, I would probably give it a shot so that I can see the change in characters, but we will see if that happens. Overall, 3.5 out of 5 from me.
I love mysteries and I love ancient history and so together it’s logical that they would be a lot of fun together. This story really did bring both aspects together, however the writing left something to be desired for me. I will say that there were plenty of fun facts and tidbits of information that I really appreciated, this was awesome and I learned quite a bit from the story. There’s also a solid mystery that I had nearly figured out by the end of the book. I liked the characters as well, they were interesting and unique and really smart, but didn’t always act like the kids they were.
The story took a bit of getting into and the characters were difficult for me to keep straight at several different points. That being said, they were smart and talked like dictionaries and almanacs which was helpful as far as learning but not quite as good for the plot. I understand the desire to keep facts true and not to overimgine anything but this story got a bit tiresome at points and I found myself getting stilled by the choppy writing.
All that being said, this was a solidly good mystery with a lot of interesting and fun information. I’m curious if there will be more books in the series, I would probably give it a shot so that I can see the change in characters, but we will see if that happens. Overall, 3.5 out of 5 from me.
June 25, 2021
This first book in the Botanic Hill Detectives mystery series is full of fun facts about Egyptian culture and snakes, but what I enjoy most is the interplay among the characters. The four young detectives come from three different homes (two are twins) and cultures, but they complement each other as they investigate a mysterious theft. I enjoy their interactions with adults, as well. It's been a while since I was a young adult, but the scenes ring true, and as I read, I find myself wanting to jump into the story and help solve the crime. It's easy to see why the book has won a Mom's Choice award. I recommend it to any youngster who wants to enrich his summer vacation with a captivating story.
December 24, 2020
This was such an adorable book to read. Sherrill kept the story rolling with no slow parts at all. As an adult I felt like it could be a bit predictable, but looking at this book through a child's eyes, this is a fun and educational mystery that keeps you guessing till the very end! Thank you Sherrill for a delightful reading experience!
October 5, 2020
Wonderful book for tweens with action, adventure and a mystery to solve! I will definitely be reading this to my kids and recommending it to friends. Looking forward to solving more mysteries with this squad!
I received a copy of this book through Voracious Readers Only.
I received a copy of this book through Voracious Readers Only.
March 7, 2021
This was an entertaining and fun book. While I would normally read more complex adult novels, this was a trip down memory lane as I remembered what I used to read as a child. Definitely recommend, especially to younger readers.
February 7, 2020
Egyptologist Dr. Thornsley discovers an ancient burial urn while on a dig in Egypt but is accused of stealing it. He has recently died a couple months prior as a disgrace. His wife Ida insists that he was innocents even if the authorities don’t really care. To clear her husband’s name, Ida hires four local kids to look into this matter.
Lanny, Lexi, Moki, and Rani are the Botanic Hill Detectives and are ready to solve this case. What follows is an amazing adventure for kids both locally and internationally as they survive traps and chase down clues to what really happened.
This is a wonderful mid grade cozy mystery that has a lot of information about Egypt and plenty of action to keep reader involved in the story. I will admit that at time the story was a touch quick and simple where there could have been more detail to wrap up the reader in the story.
Overall I really enjoyed this story. It brought me back to my childhood reading Nancy Drew stories. I think any kid that enjoys mysteries and Egypt will enjoy this book. It would be a great addition to their shelves.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I voluntarily chose to read and post an honest review.
Lanny, Lexi, Moki, and Rani are the Botanic Hill Detectives and are ready to solve this case. What follows is an amazing adventure for kids both locally and internationally as they survive traps and chase down clues to what really happened.
This is a wonderful mid grade cozy mystery that has a lot of information about Egypt and plenty of action to keep reader involved in the story. I will admit that at time the story was a touch quick and simple where there could have been more detail to wrap up the reader in the story.
Overall I really enjoyed this story. It brought me back to my childhood reading Nancy Drew stories. I think any kid that enjoys mysteries and Egypt will enjoy this book. It would be a great addition to their shelves.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I voluntarily chose to read and post an honest review.
March 20, 2020
I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author via Voracious Readers Only. This is a cute, fun mystery book for kids.
September 9, 2020
This was a fun read and I think I would have loved this series as a kid!
February 21, 2020
Aloha,
Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets is A Botanical Hill Detectives Mystery Book 1. A caper for Nancy Drew or Hardy Boys fans. The story takes you up and down over and under searching for clues that these four detective friends have a knack for. Some detective head, some Egyptology knowledge, some cookie craving and some tactical strategies- perfect recipe for solving this case. Kudos Sherrill Joseph. This one is a winner!
Nutmeg Street: Egyptian Secrets is A Botanical Hill Detectives Mystery Book 1. A caper for Nancy Drew or Hardy Boys fans. The story takes you up and down over and under searching for clues that these four detective friends have a knack for. Some detective head, some Egyptology knowledge, some cookie craving and some tactical strategies- perfect recipe for solving this case. Kudos Sherrill Joseph. This one is a winner!
August 1, 2022
This is not the worst book but it is oddly heavy handed with the “goodness” of the kids. They could be shown to be trust worthy with out making comments about how they have to convince their parents to let them spend the night at the neighbor lady’s house. I would actually argue that this makes them seem less trust worthy. I never had to convince my parents I wasn’t going to do wrong. Overall, it is reminiscent of the Egyptian game and mixed up files to me. They don’t seem to be modern kids. Some of the language is old fashion and they also just seem older than 13. Moki was the most child like with his love of sweets. Also ,
Lexi’s quirk of hurting people is odd, if they are so mature and wonderful children, you would think that her quirk wouldn’t be something that is literally hurting others.
Lexi’s quirk of hurting people is odd, if they are so mature and wonderful children, you would think that her quirk wouldn’t be something that is literally hurting others.
February 1, 2020
This was a fun caper that reminded me of Scooby Doo. The kids were smart and savvy, and the villains practically said "If it weren't for you meddling kids!" The Egyptian history was well interwoven and interesting too. And I learned a lot about the Hawaiian language, which I wasn't expecting but was very cool too. If you're looking for a good old fashioned mystery caper, check out the Botanic Hill detectives!
October 8, 2021
An attractive group of friends, an intriguing neighborhood, and a well-balanced mixture of mystery, danger and fun make this a very enjoyable read. It reminds me in some ways of the Ava and Carol series, especially with the strong historical background. I do love the self-consciously responsible attitude of the detectives and the respect they receive from the adults.
January 31, 2020
I received this book from Netgalley in an exchange of an honest review.
I really loved most aspects of this book, the plot, characters, the setting. The characters are funny and very likeable. The only aspect that I had a very small problem with was that it seemed like a sequel. Nevertheless, I loved the book and hope that we get to read about more of the Botanic Hill Detectives mysteries again.
I really loved most aspects of this book, the plot, characters, the setting. The characters are funny and very likeable. The only aspect that I had a very small problem with was that it seemed like a sequel. Nevertheless, I loved the book and hope that we get to read about more of the Botanic Hill Detectives mysteries again.
January 17, 2020
As a child psychologist, I found this book a WONDERFUL and healthy departure from some other children's literature for three reasons: 1. These children are good role models while also being realistic and relatable. I'm excited to have my daughter read a book with polite, responsible children who do chores and homework. Yay! A good reinforcement of what I'm teaching at home. 2. I really like the Botanic Hill neighborhood. I find it to be a welcome wholesome place for kids to rest their imagination in an often too chaotic and dystopian world. And, 3. I love how this models competency for kids and demonstrates that kids and adults can interact in a respectful, cooperative way.
Although I find this to be a psychologically healthy book for kids to read, I also found the mystery to be fun, and captivating. I think it will be a wonderful springboard for kids' imaginations. This is well written and very well thought out. It reminds me of a newer version of the Johnny Quest cartoons and Harriet the Spy. Well done by Sherrill Joseph. I hope we see more of the Botanic Hill Detectives very soon!
Although I find this to be a psychologically healthy book for kids to read, I also found the mystery to be fun, and captivating. I think it will be a wonderful springboard for kids' imaginations. This is well written and very well thought out. It reminds me of a newer version of the Johnny Quest cartoons and Harriet the Spy. Well done by Sherrill Joseph. I hope we see more of the Botanic Hill Detectives very soon!
January 23, 2020
Took me back to my childhood days of reading the Famous Five by Enid Blyton and this author and series should wow preteens and early teens for as many years. I was given a free copy of this book by the author and through Voracious Readers to read and review and I'm so glad I did. I will definitely be investing in this author and this series for my nephews in preparation for when they are old enough to enjoy these children and their adventures.
January 25, 2020
I found this book on the website VoraciousReadersonly.com. I found this book to be of great entertainment and would recommend for anyone to read. The story was full of excitement, could hardly put it down and also has some good information so that we learn a bit about ancient Egypt civilizations.
January 12, 2020
This book has a great premise. I mean, who wouldn't want to read a book about a group of friends solving mysteries, especially when it involves ancient Egypt? However... even though this is the first book in the series it feels more like a sequel. The 4 main characters already have a reputation in town regarding their detective skills. So when you start reading the story you feel like you've missed out on something.
But the major disappointment for me was the fact that all four main characters are 13 years old and yet they talk as if they were 33 sometimes.
Example A:
Just before interviewing a suspect, one of the boys says: "We'll have to do so carefully so as not to inadvertently transmit our intentions."
That's NOT how 13 year olds talk.
Another thing that brought the rating of this book down is the fact that the main characters, who are meant to be 13, don't act like real 13 year olds.
Example B:
After offering to help with dinner and laundry (which no 13 year old would do... let's be honest) one of the girls says: "BFF, have you ever noticed that it's more fun to do chores when it's your idea, not someone else's?"
That's just too unrealistic. If a group of teenagers were solving a big mystery they'd be on their phones looking for clues, or talking to one another to solve the mystery, NOT offering to do extra chores!
As a teacher who reads a significant amount of middle-grade books and who's in contact with children on a regular basis, I don't think children will relate to (or sometimes even understand) this book. The characters are not relatable enough to real 13 year olds. The dialogues seem robotic and too grown-up for a middle-grade book. Just adding a "bro" or "dude" here and there does not make the dialogues any better.
In my opinion, this book should have been re-edited. It's just not ready yet.
But the major disappointment for me was the fact that all four main characters are 13 years old and yet they talk as if they were 33 sometimes.
Example A:
Just before interviewing a suspect, one of the boys says: "We'll have to do so carefully so as not to inadvertently transmit our intentions."
That's NOT how 13 year olds talk.
Another thing that brought the rating of this book down is the fact that the main characters, who are meant to be 13, don't act like real 13 year olds.
Example B:
After offering to help with dinner and laundry (which no 13 year old would do... let's be honest) one of the girls says: "BFF, have you ever noticed that it's more fun to do chores when it's your idea, not someone else's?"
That's just too unrealistic. If a group of teenagers were solving a big mystery they'd be on their phones looking for clues, or talking to one another to solve the mystery, NOT offering to do extra chores!
As a teacher who reads a significant amount of middle-grade books and who's in contact with children on a regular basis, I don't think children will relate to (or sometimes even understand) this book. The characters are not relatable enough to real 13 year olds. The dialogues seem robotic and too grown-up for a middle-grade book. Just adding a "bro" or "dude" here and there does not make the dialogues any better.
In my opinion, this book should have been re-edited. It's just not ready yet.
January 17, 2020
I received a free copy of this book from the author via vorocious readers in return for an honest review. I found the book well written Ina similar style to the Nancy Drew mysteries although in this book there are a group of four friends solving the mystery. I personally would recommend the book for older children rather than young adults. One thing I did lie was the way in where chnthe author introduced some interesting vocabulary which may well be new to the younger reader by using the personality trait of one of the main characters. A great way to extend the vocabulary of readers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 159 reviews