The poem is great. However, Mary Elizabeth Frye is likely not the author of "Do Not Stand at My Grave and Weep." Look at the Wikipedia entry. It is highly probable that Kansas native Clare Harner (1909–1977) wrote the poem after the sudden death of her brother, Olin Wade Harner, who died at age 31 on 11/11/1932. She published "Immortality" in the December 1934 issue of The Gypsy, a poetry magazine, with a reprint in the February 1935 issue. Harner's poem began to be read at funerals in Kansas and Missouri. It was soon reprinted in the Kansas City Times and The Kansas City Bar Bulletin. Wikipedia also says that Harner (who earned a degree in industrial journalism and clothing design at Kansas State University) published several other poems. She later married and moved to San Francisco, where she worked as a journalist.
The case for Mary Elizabeth Frye's authorship seems much weaker. Frye, living halfway across the country in Baltimore, would apparently hand out copies of the poem with her name attached, but it appears she wasn't "incorrectly cited" as the author of the poem in 1983--49 years after its publication and six years after Harner's death, so Harner wasn't around to correct he record. Yes, Frye insisted that her authorship was "undisputed" and had been confirmed by Dear Abby, but what I see in Wikipedia and elsewhere is that Pauline and Jeanne Phillips (the "Abigail van Buren" of Dear Abby) are on the record that they could not confirm who wrote the poem.
Before embracing Frye's unlikely tale of jotting the poem down on a paper bag and the circumstances which inspired it, look at the timeline as well:
1. Harner's brother died at the end of 1932.
2. Harner published the poem in Kansas in 1934, and it was republished multiple times in the next year. In the next few years it was used at memorial services in Kansas and Missouri.
3. In 1934 Frye lived in Baltimore, halfway across the country from where the poem had been published and was being used at funerals. This was a time before photocopiers and easy dissemination of writing that wasn't published.
4. Frye's origin story includes a claim that she hosted a German Jewish immigrant girl. In 1933 there was definitely a marked uptick in Jewish emigration from Germany, given Hitler's rise to power, but the destination was often to Palestine or other European countries, not so much to the U.S. It was quite difficult to get U.S. visas. This was at the time of the Great Depression. According to the Holocaust Memorial Museum, "The 1924 US quota law set a limit of 25,957 immigration visas for people born in Germany. In 1933, the State Department issued visas to only 1,241 Germans, Although 82,787 people were on the German waiting list for a U.S. visa, most did not have enough money to qualify for immigration." It appears the number wasn't much greater in 1934, and not all German immigrants were Jewish. .
5. Harner died in 1977. By that time the poem was widely known. For example, John Wayne read it at the 1977 service for director Howard Hawks.
6. Per Wikipedia, Mary Elizabeth Frye handed out xeroxed copies of the poem with her name attached. Photocopiers were not widely used until the mid-1960s.
7. Wikipedia also says that Frye was first wrongly cited as the author of the poem in 1983.
To accept Frye as the poet you must believe that an unpublished poem written by a housewife/part-time florist during the Great Depression in Baltimore made its way in pre-photocopy days to Harner in Topeka in 1934, and that Harner, grieving her brother's death, was willing to tarnish her reputation and her brother’s memory by engaging in blatant plagiarism and falsely publishing someone else's work under her own name. And she would have been taught journalism ethics at K-State too. The whole scenario is troubling..
If you don't want to attribute the poem to Harner, you should at least hesitate before gullibly giving unquestioned credit to Frye. I sure hope I am not falsely maligning her, but it's possible she started lying, had to stiick with the lie, was able to spin a good (and improbable) story, and basked in the unearned attention she got. .