Water from Heaven

by Robert S. Kandel

From where―and what―does water come? How did it become the key to life in the universe? Water from Heaven presents a state-of-the-art portrait of the science of water, recounting how the oxygen needed to form H2O originated in the nuclear reactions in the interiors of stars, asking whether microcomets may be replenishing our world's oceans, and explaining how the Moon and planets set ice-age rhythms by way of slight variations in Earth's orbit and rotation. The book then takes the measure of water today in all its states, solid and gaseous as well as liquid.

How do the famous El Niño and La Niña events in the Pacific affect our weather? What clues can water provide scientists in search of evidence of climate changes of the past, and how does it complicate their predictions of future global warming? Finally, Water from Heaven deals with the role of water in the rise and fall of civilizations. As nations grapple over watershed rights and pollution controls, water is poised to supplant oil as the most contested natural resource of the new century. The vast majority of water "used" today is devoted to large-scale agriculture and though water is a renewable resource, it is not an infinite one. Already many parts of the world are running up against the limits of what is readily available.

Water from Heaven is, in short, the full story of water and all its remarkable properties. It spans from water's beginnings during the formation of stars, all the way through the origin of the solar system, the evolution of life on Earth, the rise of civilization, and what will happen in the future. Dealing with the physical, chemical, biological, and political importance of water, this book transforms our understanding of our most precious, and abused, resource. Robert Kandel shows that water presents us with a series of crucial questions and pivotal choices that will change the way you look at your next glass of water.

Genres: Science, History, Nonfiction

272 pages, Hardcover

First published January 15, 2003

Reviews

[Jonas]

Okay so this was one of the earliest books on my TBR-shelf here on Goodreads. The book got recommended to us during a hydrology lecture by a Professor about 3 or 4 years ago. Somehow I had a working internet connection (not to be taken for granted inside the ETH Hauptgebäude!) and put it on my TBR list where it accumulated dust until recently. That is, until I started downloading the epub-files of these early TBR-books that were still of interest to me. Long story short: This is how I came to read this rather niche book. Though in its scope it isn't niche at all. Kandel draws (or tries to) an extensive picture; starting from the beginning of the universe up until the 2000s (with the odd venture of traveling a billion years or so in the future). Through it all he follows the path of water - or that's what I imagine he set out to do. Often he isn't all that successful following that thread, with some sub-chapters literally having nothing to do with water at all. This made the book feel really unfocused and not all that well thought out. I mean of course (aquatic) life should be part of a book about the history of water on our planet, but is it really necessary to delve into the various theories about how life originated on this planet in a book about the history of water? The same question may be asked for about every second footnote - almost every time a (more or less) famous name crops up, Kandel has something to say about the person despite no connection whatsoever to the wider context. They, whilst interesting at times, felt more like the author showing of how smart he is and how much he knows than adding anything to the book. Another irritating thing that crops up, albeit sparingly, is his obvious problem with "environmentalists". He seems to be really angry with them for reasons that elude me - he does see the danger of climate change and even mentions its negative effects on the biosphere but somehow can't grasp that some people may be concerned about all the non-human life on this planet. These weird outbursts of his are made even weirder by the fact that, throughout the book, he tries to come across as an impartial scientists. This touches on another point; the unceasing mention of different units and the numbers associated with them (most of the time unimaginably huge). Whilst interesting, the book would have been better if he presented them more sparingly - this isn't a research paper after all. Still, I did learn quite a lot of new things but am glad it is over now.

[Dr. Carl Ludwig Dorsch · Rating 2 out of 5]

Kandel, with a background in astrophysics (astronomy at Harvard, astrophysics at the Paris-Meudon Observatory, presently emeritus senior scientist at the Ecole Polytechnique’s Laboratory of Dynamic Meteorology) and experience working with satellite monitoring of earth systems (radiation budgets, atmospheric interactions), tends towards a wide and fairly abstracted view.

The volume is full of large-scale quantifications: “the world’s streams and rivers contain only 2,000 cubic kilometers of freshwater (each cubic kilometer being a billion cubic meters or metric tons)”; the annual European freshwater runoff per capita is 4,600 cubic kilometers per year compared with 6,400 for Asia; “over the whole year, average solar radiant energy flux reaching the top of the atmosphere ranges from 140 W/m2 [watts per square meter] at the North Pole (150 at the South Pole) to more than 400 W/m2 at the equator”, etc.

At times these may seem illuminating, as for instance that “on average, the atmosphere contains the equivalent of a layer of 26 mm (a little over an inch) of water…”, or that the moisture of the entire biosphere has a similar equivalent depth of only 2 mm*, or even the unexplained assertion that water entering the North American Great Lakes can spend as much as 300 years before finding its way out the St. Lawrence (400 years for Lake Baikal before exiting through the Angara), but often, particularly in relation to current and near-term human water needs, the perspective seems only to reflect the cold distance of satellite observation and quantitative aggregation. Dr. Kandel’s French and Parisian digressions aside (this volume was originally published as Les Eaux du Ciel and translated into English by the author), his take can rather unrelentingly seem that of a remote and curious analyst, not an earth inhabitant – of any species.

Our experience and expertise are varied – and Dr. Kandel’s are evidently both extraordinary – and whether the approach here is simply governed by these or by a higher intent, I do not presume to argue with it, but as a water creature myself I found it routinely disorienting; only after completing the book did I realize that at least one of the multiple readings of its title had flown completely over my head.

Nonetheless Water from Heaven is a remarkable tour, from Big Bang to our star’s presumed eventual turn as a “red giant,” addressing along the way elemental and planetary formation; tectonic and tidal effects; the origins (and decimations) of biology; glacial pulses and Milankovitch cycles; atmospheric, oceanic and freshwater systems and their relations to soil and vegetative regimes; the rise of human civilization; water resource issues; water borne and sustained disease; the vagaries of anthropomorphic climate change, and a good deal more.

The volume frequently repeats facts or observations, sometimes usefully so, but often in a way suggesting it might have been composed in bursts, as perhaps to be expected from a busy working scientist. It is also illustrated with some two score uncredited diagrams, which though more or less intelligible, are not up to university press standards, although perhaps these are only weak substitutes for those of the original edition.

In the end I take Water from Heaven as a useful overview, but not a moving one. While the organization of elemental being – the stuff of stars, planets, moons, the churnings of the earth and its atmospheres – is a fundamentally worthy subject, from my current perspective water is primarily not a cosmic factor, but a biological one. I would welcome, even in passing, the overcoming of that distinction – the integration of the celestial and bodily, the upper and lower waters – as a highly valuable and presumably clarifying experience, but that did not much occur in my reading of Water from Heaven. The sea did not flow through my veins (even if a bit of the H2O in the interstellar medium did), I did not know my thought and speech as cloud and rain. I did however witness the record of the quantitative priesthood’s struggle, on a planetary scale no less, with their methods and understandings, and for that I am grateful.


*Both these depths presumably float on an idealized planetary sphere.

[Dan · Rating 3 out of 5]

I read this book over a long period of time. It covered a very broad scope of the role of water on our planet. I really appreciated the international tone of the text. It was originally written in French. As I result it seemed to bring to light examples from Europe most frequently. This was nice because most of my reading on water has been centered on North America. The book read a bit like a physical geography book at time, which was fine, you just really have to want to read it.
I'm glad I read it.

[Carlos · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book just blew me away. Having picked it up from a discount pile I expected nothing else than a more thorough look at the water cycle, instead, Kandel gives the reader the best explanation I’ve ever read of the formation, effect, use and future of the water in our planet. Drawing from fields as diverse as astrophysics and politics, he takes the reader through the profound effect that water has had on our planet, species and political history. By dwelling in seemingly unrelated aspects of our planet, such as plate tectonics and mass extinctions, Kandel gives the reader a wonderful context in which to understand the role of water. I have learned more from this one book that from all the geography and natural science classes I ever took. I cannot recommend this book highly enough. It will massively change how you view this rocky spaceship we call home.

[Janet]

Reviewed in the Telegraph on the 25 July 2009 (good)