Posted on Les Romantiques - Le forum du site
Reviewed by Rinou
Review Copy from the Publisher
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Fourth volume in the Everton Domestic Society series but that can be read alone, A Lady’s Past features Diana, who’s running from the Napoleonic spy who killed her parents, and Jacques, a Frenchman who took refuge in England.
Jacques is a likeable hero, very understanding, and who admits really fast he has feelings for the heroine, even if he needs some times to understand which ones. I liked seeing his friendship with a hero from a precedent volume, but he doesn’t let people around him make him doubt the heroine’s innocence. Only black spot: the author mentions several times Jacques’ love past with a treason by the woman he loved then, but we don’t really know more. I suppose we learn about it more in one of the previous books but I don’t know which one.
Diana is a strong heroine who lived some very difficult things in the hands of the French people who kidnapped her parents and herself. She succeeded in running away to come back in England but she’s sure she’s being chased by at least one of these men. She spends her time turning down the hero, and every offer of friendship by other characters, because she feels she’s not worth it and she’s a danger for him and for them. And for a reason I didn’t understand she feels guilty for what happened to her parents.
Between them the attraction is fast but they both resist for a long time, her because of the danger hovering around her, and him because he wants to protect her. But it’s the heroine blowing hot and cold who ruins it all IMO, because once she finally believes in her feelings as in Jacques’, she repeats regularly that at the beginning he said he wasn’t thinking about marrying, even if he told her later he wanted to marry her. In short she annoyed me more often than anything, even if I was sorry for what happened to her.
Other drawback: I thought there was too much familiarity between them when they meet. Yes the events have them coming closer rapidly, but that left me with a strange sensation. Then there’s the fact everyone or so is very welcoming with Diana when nobody knows her, everyone likes her directly and offers a helping hand, except the hero’s best friend who’s wary but without insisting much. It’s only later, when her past comes back, that the new characters called to protect her are more suspicious of her, which seems more realistic than the Care Bears seen until then.
The plot with the spy is well found and quite interesting, and its resolution felt well done until a scene that I thought totally unrealistic: the prisoner succeeds in escaping during his transfer and in finding Diana’s room up the stairs in a castle, to try and choke her. IMO it was a useless event borderline ridiculous. In fact I thought it was the heroine having a nightmare and I was waiting for her to wake up.
So all in all it’s a historical romance that can be read easily but I missed it out, sorry.