As the survivor of an abusive stepdad of my own, this story resonates with me in a way few stories ever have. I originally picked it up used as a teenager, maybe in some vain hope that it would give me some pointers on how to deal with my own abusive stepfather, and it's even more chilling to re-read as an adult, knowing just how normal Simon's actions seemed to me as a child.
There are parts of the story that seem a bit far-fetched, yes, but more than anything else, this book reads like an abused child's revenge/survival fantasy. There is a part of me that wholly believes that Kathy Hepinstall either has experience with an abusive adult, or is very close to someone in a similar situation. She does an amazing job of showing Alice's steady loss of faith in her god and her mother, and her decline into helplessness and hopelessness. For someone who has experienced a violent, unpredictable stepdad and a passive mother, this was chillingly familiar.
The ending seems a bit rushed, with little more than a list of what happens over a period of time, but it's ultimately quite satisfying. The ending itself is what solidifies my belief in Kathy Hepinstall's experience with abuse; while the story is wonderfully detailed up until that point, painfully familiar to someone with my own background, the "happily ever after" sort of ending speaks far more of wish fulfillment than experience.
A good read for sure, though.