More detailed review to come!
Update 3/4/20:
Average rating: 3.72/5
Final rating: 3.5/5
I felt so all over the place with this collection, and I think ultimately my biggest takeaway is that this was sad to read. Not that it was badly written - it emphatically was not - but there is so much sadness here that it is ingrained in every single world, and I sometimes find that difficult to read. My mental health only allows for so much sadness before I'm desperate for any small amount of joy, and I think that's a huge part of why it took me an entire month to read 11 short stories. These are good, and I'll get into them each individually in a moment, but know that this isn't a happy collection in any way and I think you all should know that going in.
Ok. Let's talk about the stories themselves.
Sugar Babies - 4/5
God this was sad (be prepared to hear that more times). This is a story about motherhood and the past and digging up trauma, which are all ultimately the themes of this collection so this is a fitting introduction. It also has bitingly funny moments with Sierra, a girl already so sad at only 13-years-old. Beautifully written and so effective in describing a scene that sets a tone. I don't know how I would feel about this one if it hadn't been the introductory story of Sabrina & Corina, but I do think it perfectly set you up for the fiction you are going to read in the pages that follow.
Sabrina & Corina - 3.5/5
"Sabrina & Corina" is a meditation on femininity, on a family of women who only come together out of habit in times of tragedy. It's a reflection on how often violence is a visitor in their lives and how commonplace it's become in their rituals. It's a story of cousins, of parallel girlhoods that stray and become a part of the pattern. I feel like I'm describing a lot of what this covers rather than my personal feelings on the story, but that's mostly because I think every story has so much to say that I want to explain every part of it. I'm not parsing through simple stories, there is so much here to dig through that I could read it over and over again and get something different out of it every time. That being said, I think there was something missing here and it held me back from really getting into the story.
Sisters - 3.5/5
Another story of silence and violence. "Sisters" is about the commonplace aspects of violence that women endure and how no one will see that it's happening. Dory is our main character, and is potentially queer, seeing other women in a particular light that also allows her to recognize the horror that's happening all around them. I don't know that I fully understood the title "Sisters" but my guess is there is a double meaning there: a story about biological sisters and the story of a sisterhood formed through acts of violence and silence.
Remedies - 5/5
Easily my favorite of the collection. It's about things inherited (a theme of the collection) from mother to daughter, remedies to get rid of what makes you ill. It's also about broken family, about women doing more than they need to to make up for their perceived wrongs, and how women punish themselves for the acts of men. It's a truly brilliant story and I think it hits every single thematic note that Sabrina & Corina represents as a collection.
Julian Plaza - 3/5
This is a tragic story about a mother dying of cancer and her young daughters as they try to deal with their mother being sick. I didn't fully understand the plot of this story, it felt disjointed and unsure. I loved the descriptions and how disturbing it could sometimes be, but I think the the lack of cohesion in the plot really hurt my overall enjoyment of this one.
Galapago - 4/5
It's time for another round of GRIEF! AND! INHERITED! TRAUMA! This one hit hard. It's about a grandmother being forced into a nursing home after a misunderstanding caused a death. It's mournful but also sad even when it comes to the family members who are still living and the pain they can cause when they're trying to help.
Cheesman Park - 5/5
Another favorite, this is brilliant but just deeply sad. Mothers and daughters, wives and girlfriends, all bruised and grieving for different things. For feeling lost, for being left behind, for being the one to be hit, for the times they felt less lonely. It's a heartbreaking story of women and their tragedies. This story also had my favorite line in the collection:
"Time didn't feel as long or as wasteful in the company of another woman."
Tomi - 3.5/5
This added a lot to the collection because I think it brought something new that I was really needing. It was a break of sorts, a focus on slightly lighter things. It made me feel more prepared going into the remainder of the stories. I loved Tomi, the titular character, and his relationship to his aunt, the connection that they shared over stories real and fictional. However, this contained a lot of fatphobia and the use of the r slur and it was not the first time that either of those things had been present in the collection. Usually that would have meant a dnf for me (I generally avoid most books that contain casual slurs) but I do think it was attempting to be reflective of a certain community and a certain mindset. The fatphobia for the rest of the stories was definitely present though, and I would beware of that going in if that triggers you.
Any Farther West - 2/5
Frankly, I just didn't understand the purpose of this story. It's meandering, telling a story about a girl and her mother and yet another guy that should be treating women better. It began and it ended and I gained really nothing at all.
All Her Names - 3/5
This is another one where I wasn't fully sure what the point of the story was. I liked the idea of this woman making her mark by tagging trains, knowing her name would go all the places she never would, but there is an abortion storyline connected to the main character and her issues with her husband and I just didn't understand the resolution or even the purpose of that part of the story.
Ghost Sickness - 4.5/5
Beautifully told, and dreadfully sad (which should really be the tagline for ). It's a parallel story of a missing boyfriend, a rapidly approaching history final, and the undertones of death our lead girl isn't yet aware of. It's incredibly well done and a super strong conclusion to the collection.
Hopefully these mini reviews help to explain my all-over-the-place feelings on this collection. There were moments of truly inventive and brilliant writing, but it sometimes lost its way or fell flat in execution. I think there's a lot here to love, and I'm glad I chose this collection to start out my year of short stories, but I was really hoping for something slightly stronger than what I got.