I’m a big Jill Mansell fan. She’s one of my favorite comfort, read under the covers authors. But I have a hard time recommending this one, a book from 1993 re-released in Digital in 2019.
Like most Mansell books, it’s chock full of quirky characters and interlacing story lines. Almost every character has a journey to go on and many become better persons and perhaps fall in love as the story goes along. Others learn to assert their independence. The central character is Izzy, an irrepressible single mom who’s been waiting her whole life for her big break. Shortly after the book begins, she’s hit by a car driven by Gina, whose husband just left her for his girlfriend whose pregnant. The cliched way for Gina’s story to play out would be for her to get back together with her husband. That doesn’t happen, but it opens the way for a story line that ruins the book for me.
The following comments are kinda-spoilerish, but the events happen toward the beginning and may bother other readers as much as they bothered me. Gina’s husband Andrew is a schlep. His character is thinly drawn and he has no redeeming qualities. It’s never clear why he drifted away from Gina to Marcy, who is another one dimensional character. What makes him worse, and the story worse, is that he sets his sights on Izzy’s 17 year old daughter Katerina and embarks on an affair with her. Yep, a 17 year old. Not sure what that amounts to in the United Kingdom, but in many states that would be illegal. This is such a turn off for me that I can’t rate this book more highly. Maybe in the intervening years since this was written we as a society have become more aware of the problematic nature (and potentially illegal nature) of such a romance. And right now, as I write this, the world is beginning to learn more about the real life sex-trafficking of underage women by Jeffrey Epstein, heightening sensitivity to this issue. But ugh, this was so unnecessary. There’s a slight acknowledgement of the problem here, but it’s more focused on the fact that Katerina’s living with Gina when this happens. Ugh, ugh, ugh. If the betrayal story line was necessary, she could have been of legal age. Yuck, yuck, yuck.
Sorry Jill, I love your books, but I can’t on this one. 2/5