I was sent a copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. This is an honest review.
First things first, I’m currently unwillingly incubating a viral infection and my brain isn’t firing on all cylinders, but I’m going to try my best.
Secondly, I love My Life As A Background Slytherin. It’s the only Harry Potter-related thing, official or otherwise, that I engage with anymore. I was super stoked to find out not only that Emily had written a graphic novel but that it was available on NetGalley.
I really, really enjoyed this. It was exactly the kind of madcap paranormal regency adventure I expected, complete with mystery, quests, subterfuge and ill-advised flirting, as well as references to other well-beloved fantasy and regency tales and a sneaky cameo by a certain bibbling old wizard, and, of course, Lord Byron being a right old dickhead.
(As one expects of Lord Byron.)
Near the end I did feel like it got a little meandering and I kept thinking “oh this is near the end” and I’d check the page number to find that I was only in the middle. But that is probably more to do with my being sick and generally exhausted and possibly not following on as well as I usually could, than any shortcomings in the narrative. Something I did specifically take note of was the character development, which a book like this easily could have left off, but this one did it and I was pretty proud of everyone for coming to terms with their feelings.
(Except Byron, who did not because he is the Worst.)
My one dissatisfaction with this graphic novel is that the nonbinary character Sham was never given space on-page to express her pronouns. The characters use “she” for her which appears to be fine, but it would have been nice if Sham could give this information personally. She is asked at one point (rather rudely) if she’s a boy or girl, to which she replies “yes,” so it would have been fairly simple for the interrogating character to then ask about pronouns—but this may have been a publishing decision and not necessarily an authorial one.
Sham is later asked (by someone else) if the correct term of address is “Mr Sham or Ms Sham” and the reply given was “no.” Sham is also variously referred to as “old chap” or “fellow,” and a few times Sham, Lucy and Virginia are collectively called “girls,” and Sham didn’t seem to feel strongly either way about any of those terms.
Sham was shown at one point shaving her face while her shirt hung open to display binding bandages, but this was halfway into the book and we had already seen both conversation examples mentioned above, so it wasn’t the classic and gross “trans reveal via nudity” that we all hate. In one scene where the other characters are notably naked, Sham remains fully clothed. So all in all, I thought it was pretty respectful and well done, the seemingly assumptive nature of her pronouns notwithstanding.
The humour and wild adventurous style was reminiscent of Nimona, which I also love, and I enjoyed this immensely and took many screenshots of my favourite bits. I would recommend it to anyone who likes Nimona or Background Slytherin, or who just wants to dunk on Lord Byron. It’s no more than he deserves, after all.