John Hodgman, he of the Daily Show and the Mac/PC ads, is a funny guy to be sure. His essay on his home state of Massachusetts in "State by State" is clever and well-written, and when I saw him interviewed by Tom Perrotta at the Boston Book Festival, Hodgman was hilarious, quick-witted and off the cuff. His first book, "The Areas of My Expertise", reflects that sense of humor, although not as well as in person.
"Expertise" is itself an odd compendium; it is, as Hodgman puts it, "a collection of fake trivia". Basically it's a compilation of lists, charts, and short articles of data that Hodgman has made up. As you might expect from the author, the humor is dry and often absurdist, which is typically in my wheelhouse.
Unfortunately, it's pretty hit-or-miss. He does well when twisting an old theme; a hotel tipping chart starts off with advice on concierge and bellboy gratuities, and then goes onto magicians, lullabyists, and the differences between regular and 'feral' turn-down service (the latter involves leaves and twigs in place of bedding). He also explains to the reader how to win a fight (including, among other tactics, attack ads in which you accuse your opponent of masturbating out of windows). But for every winning entry, there seems to be a gag that goes on way too long; Hodgman draws out recurrent tangents on werewolves, prophets, and squirrels past their breaking points. And he is positively obsessed with hobos; hobo names like "Illinois Obama" and "Yum Yum Sinclair Snowball Eater" are funny, but do we need 700 of them?
This is certainly more of a bathroom reader than a piece to be read straight-through, and I did laugh out loud a few times, but ultimately even a book to be paged through randomly should have a higher ratio of funny bits, especially if it's already on the slender side. Perhaps Hodgman works best in small doses, and perhaps his follow-up book "More Information Than You Require" is stronger. But after seeing the man in person and reading some of his other writing, I was expecting more from this collection.