Each year my family reads all the Goodreads-award-nominated picture books. Everyone rates each book and adds a comment and it may (or may not) affect my overall rating. This is book #20 (and the last of 20!) of 2017.
Tara: (2 stars). It didn't rhyme and then did and then once in a while. It had cadence and then it didn't. I didn't like that.
Harry (13): (2.5 stars). I didn't really get it, but I liked the art.
Hank (11): (5 stars). Cool! Liked almost everything about it!
Lyra (10): (5 stars). Humans hated Franklin, until a sweet girl named Luna helped him make a library for all. Nice colors in the pictures. One of my favorites of the year.
Dave: (3.5 stars). Gorgeous watercolor illustrations (with gold leaf lettering on the cover) by Katie Harnett, extra large-sized, perfect for a fantasy about a dragon. Nobody understands Franklin; no one understands that he just likes to read! Until, that is, he meets Luna who helps him build a flying bookshop (cue to other books about bookshops from Campbell, who is a famous book you-tuber, too) to fly around on Franklin's back to show people. The art is 5 stars, the story is thin, though exuberant. That thing about the rhyming Tara mentions, above? Annoying; feels careless. As to the book-loving, well, it's more funny and flying and swirling about than book-loving, really, but it is pretty fun, and so beautiful.