After a New Year's Eve party Fran discovers Sammy is being stalked and harassed by Cheryl, Ryan's evil ex. While Fran thinks Sammy should report the harassment, Sammy doesn't want to be "that girl." When Latte wants to go out early in the morning, Fran, barely awake and hung over, lets Latte wander through backyards until he sniffs out something unusual. The body of a woman is lying on the frozen ground face down. Fran believes the woman fell asleep outside after a wild night but when she gets closer, she discovers the woman is dead- probably murdered! Fran's scream wakes Ryan, whose yard the body is found in, and Sammy, who has spent the night. The body belongs to Cheryl and the police zero in on Sammy as the killer! Fran knows Sammy would never hurt a fly, literally, let alone kill someone but Mike is off the case for his failure to solve any of the previous murders (and also for being too close to Sammy) and obviously Ryan can't take this one either since he and Sammy seem to be an official couple. It's up to Fran to discover who killed Cheryl and save Sammy from jail. This may be Fran's toughest case yet!
This is the best mystery to date. It's impossible to solve. Of course it's a novel and there are only a limited number of characters and obviously Sammy didn't do it, so I suppose readers COULD figure it out, but putting myself in Fran's head and only allowing myself to think about what clues she uncovered or lack thereof, made this mystery impossible to figure out. I was beginning to think Matt's theory was correct! What I don't understand is why the detective was so awful in accusing Sammy without even considering other suspects. This is modern day America and while Cape Bay may not have the resources for forensics, surely the state police do. OK we know Cheryl was strangled to death by a pair of small, gloved hands. Small covers a lot of territory. Can't they measure the marks and determine the exact size? Where are the gloves? Wouldn't they have Cheryl's DNA on them? Is Ryan Sammy's only alibi? Why doesn't anyone consider these things? The state officer is about as incompetent as he believes Mike to be.
The cozy is kept fairly to a minimum. There are some interactions between Fran and Matt but not as many as usual. Sammy and Ryan are still secretive about their relationship and I feel that it's not anyone's business to put a label on it or speculate. There's not much Cape Bay in this novel as Cheryl was an outsider. Fran has to travel to Plymouth to investigate. It's a cozy mystery since Fran is an amateur and the mystery is pretty light. I was pleased Latte discovered the body but then Fran leaves him with Matt to go off and investigate. The cafe is closed a lot in this book and it's slow because of winter. Other that those things, I really enjoyed the mystery.
Fran behaves better here. She knows Sammy well and doesn't sit around to be asked to be a character witness at Sammy's trial. Fran could put herself and Sammy in jeopardy going off to Plymouth but she behaves responsibly when it comes time to catch a killer. She has Mike's grudging support on this one. She's rather naive though and thinks just because someone is nice they can't be a killer. She should know better by now! Sammy is a sweetheart who always thinks positively and could never kill any living creature. She'd be more likely to mourn Cheryl even though the woman was harassing Sammy all the time. I like how private Sammy and Ryan are in their relationship. In a small town of nosy people, they are right to have something for themselves. The sleepover could have been innocent, like it's past midnight and Ryan put his cop hat on and didn't want Sammy to go home alone, but they do seem to be a couple. It's been obvious for awhile and no one deserves a great guy like Ryan more than Sammy. Ryan is kind and gentle, just what Sammy needs after her loser ex and she is what he needs after the drama of Cheryl.
Something was not right in Cheryl's head. Her relationships with men were creepy and her relationships with their new girlfriends even creepier. I feel somewhat sorry for her after meeting her mother but a friend or two needed to sit her down and say that behavior is not cool. It sounds like she was either someone people loved or hated but not in-between. Who hated her enough to kill her? The list is, sadly, long and I don't understand why the police didn't ask the same questions.
The new detective from the state police is an arrogant jerk who looks down his nose at "soft" small town people. He likes his coffee black and insists on paying for it. Free coffee is a bribe he isn't going to take. Obviously he doesn't understand small town hospitality. Mike may be a bit gruff but he cares about Fran and wants to keep her safe. He's trying to look at the case objectively from a cop's standpoint but again, I wonder why he didn't ask the right questions. Was he afraid of being accused of bias or he didn't want to get in trouble because it wasn't his case? At least Ryan was unofficially helpful.
I am eager to see what happens next for Fran, Matt, Sammy and Ryan. My library does not yet have the newest mysteries. I had to get this one with my audible free trial.