given that queens of geek and the brightsiders were five and four stars, respectively, and the former a favorite, i truly thought that if anyone could make me not hate a “serious topic fandom book,” it would jen wilde.
but.
nope nope nope.
content/trigger warnings; sexism, misogyny, anxiety, adhd, mentions of medication, mentions of past bullying, mentions of poverty, mentions of parental abandonment, coming out, cheating, queerphobic language, queerphobia, mentions of past homophobia, alcohol, underage drinking, predatory men, mentions of vomit, mentions of past racism,
rep; bex (mc) is gay with adhd and anxiety and questioning her gender*. shrupty (li) is gay and indian. parker (sc) is gay. alyssa (sc) is queer and black. will (sc) is gay.
*bex says “i’m still firmly in the questioning category when it comes to my gender identity” and then it’s never explored or even brought up again. so, it’s not an active part of the story, it’s just mentioned that her gender identity label is “questioning.”
i’m going to start with the two and a half positives i have.
one being the only two times the book made me laugh. when bex writes “i’m gay” on pancakes and gives them to parker in an attempt to come out to him, and he reads it and is like “i am gay! yay! gaycakes!” that was super adorable. and when shrupty’s dad comes downstairs when they’re gathering to film their teaser video and he’s all shy like “um...hello strangers in my basement” he kind of won me over with that one line.
two being the one excerpt that i liked enough to mark down. when bex tells shrupty about being poor and she’s like, “that’s okay, money isn’t important” and bex says, “see, you say that, but it is. money matters a lot, especially when you don’t have it. people love to talk about poverty like it’s romantic or grounding or character building. but it’s stressful. it’s traumatic. it’s, like, ninety percent of why i’m so anxious all the time.” and whew true!!!!!! people who say “money isn’t important/everything” are people who have it. money is everything to people who don’t have it. it could literally change their lives. the dismissive mindset that money isn’t important or helpful comes from privilege.
and the half being how unapologetically queer it is. i’m counting this as a half because it’s such a basic, given part of a jen wilde book at this point.
now, the main negative event.
this feels like it’s written by a bitter queer fan with a fantasy of hauling their teenage self into a writers room and taking over with their fanfiction writing experience and personal anger about their one specific favorite queer character/ship being screwed over, instead of being an actual well thought out commentary on queerbaiting, straightwashing, representation, etc. it takes a serious issue that very much matters to a lot of people and makes it shallow and cringeworthy by putting it through the eyes of a naive, teen fangirl.
it would’ve been better from the pov of an older, queer writer or showrunner (*cough* jane *cough*) fucking shit up and calling shit out from within her own writers room. teens can definitely have articulate, important discussions, but in my experience, books about important topics like queerbaiting and representation through the pov of a teenage fangirl makes the importance of the message a bit watered down and shallow. need i remind anyone of the hot fucking mess that is the book ship it by britta lundin? that shit made a mockery out of these topics, and this book doesn’t do it justice, either.
a very big part of why this take on this topic doesn’t work is because it’s so specific to these characters. this isn’t a book about queer people fighting against hollywood’s queerbaiting and straightwashing. this book is about one queer girl fighting to keep the queer character she wrote played by her girlfriend on her favorite show. her and her like three friends, who are queer actors on the show, team up to create social media buzz about the queerbaiting and straightwashing and expose the showrunner for being a one dimensional bad guy. when they get what they want (the showrunner fired, the queer character and ship back, the one decent female writer becoming showrunner, and bex being offered an actual job) the fight is over. they celebrate their win and bex says it’s her happy ending. the book ends.
there is literally zero mention of real life examples of bury your gays, straightwashing, queerbaiting, cast/writers mocking queer fans for thinking their characters could be queer, etc. there is no mention of how when a single instance of a campaign for queer rep is successful it doesn’t end there. there is not one single mention of these characters saying or thinking about how they’re going to keep doing this kind of advocacy for queer rep. there is no fucking acknowledgement anywhere of how just because they won this one single specific battle, that they got one single person fired and one single character and ship, doesn’t mean they changed anything on a greater scale, doesn’t mean the problem is gone, doesn’t mean the fight is over.
but what can you really expect from an author who makes their main queer character a clexa stan? the clexa fandom made all these campaigns about how queer rep is important and minorities aren’t disposable and to not bury your gays, but they only cared about lexa. they never mentioned any other queer characters or characters that represent any minorities. they never even mentioned the shitty treatment of minorities on their own fucking show, outside of lexa. their own fandom was racist towards the male lead and biphobic towards the female lead. a lesbian from another show was killed off around the same time and they didn’t rally over her. their “movement” died down when they didn’t get what they wanted. and this book ends with these characters “winning” by getting what they personally wanted and not even sparing a thought about how the fight doesn’t end, and didn’t even begin, with them and their character/ship.
now, these are some more negatives.
i can’t stand the main character. bex is so childish and naive that i can’t even root for her. everything she did and thought annoyed me. she had so many childish, naive expectations of people and situations and was so shocked and upset when faced with the reality. she 100% reads several years younger than she actually is, which is 18. she’s supposed to be this awkward, clumsy relatable fangirl geek, but she’s just so cringeworthy. and some of the “teen speak” feels like an adult plucked out how teens in fandoms talk online and figured that’s how they all talk in real life. an example of bex being super cringe is when shrupty perfectly destroys archer for being a gross douche who won’t take no for an answer, bex yells at him to get some ice for that burn as he’s walking away. like, please shut up.
fiction within fiction. one of the many things i hate. fandom books do not need excerpts from fanfiction, tv show scripts, and books. they really do not need several pages of the characters acting out scenes from the show as their characters, like the full audition scene the love interest had in this book. not necessary. 0/10 would not recommend.
i’m starting to get annoyed with people use the term queer, but then write things like “with every [queerphobic] word he says, i deflate a little more. it’s just another reminder that oh, right, i’m different” because the word queer historically is specifically about embracing and taking pride in that difference. not being desperate for non-queer approval to the point of assimilating to that culture and society and forgetting how we’re different in the first place. queer isn’t a cute polished little umbrella term we use because the mainstream approves of it. it’s raw and angry and political and radical and a defiant celebration of everything that is different about us, everything people reject about us. queer people don’t forget we’re different, we embrace it. that line just really rubbed me the wrong and reminds me of the people who think queer is simply another word for “lgbt.”
other dislikes
“antisocial” doesn’t mean what y’all think it means. bex projecting her own internalized hatred and shame of being poor onto literally everyone around her even after her cousin called her out for doing it to him. the cliche “character a tells character b something important but character b is asleep.” insta fucking love. “big dick energy.” the constant “we have the whole fandom behind us this isn’t over” mentality is ridiculous and naive, because you won’t get anywhere if the people who are actually in charge don’t give a fuck. the use of “mansplaining” in a situation where literally no mansplaining is happening. the relationship conflict is super ridiculous and could have been avoided with, you guessed it, communication!