I genuinely have never wanted a book to end so much. Do you know how many times I scoffed or rolled my eyes?? I have so much to rant/criticize, so buckle up. There are spoilers so read at your own risk.
The beginning was beautiful!! I had so much hope going into it. It was gorgeous, sad, and the details were just on point. Perfect. I was so ready for a five-star read, because it definitely started that way. Then, everything went downhill.
First and foremost, the characters are awful. Absolutely unbearably annoying to read about. Let's start off with Miss. Serena, our resident hunky-fae magnet and the ultimate Mary Sue character. I hated her. There was not a single redeeming quality. She started off docile and shy, but at one point in the book, she turned into a completely different character. She's vulgar, lustful, and a 'badass'. There's NOTHING wrong with those traits. However, her character isn't set up to be that way initially. I'd buy into it if there was development that showed her changing, but there was none! Zero, zip, nada!! And of course, she's soo special and a princess and just very powerful as well and the antagonist is after her because she's so special, blah blah blah. NEXT.
Now, we have hunky Hunter. Ohhh, he's soooo mean and neeeever is nice to humans, EXCEPT FOR SERENA! He kidnaps her and then has sooo much interested vested in her. He wants the best for her. Why?? Where in the hell did this interest come from! I don't understand!! Then, he asks Serena to OPEN UP about her LIFE two seconds after the kidnapping? And you know what, Serena does it! She starts to fall in lust with him. What in the Stockholm Syndrome is this! I'm so done.
Then, our next hot fae is Wilder. Yes. The instructor. There is zero build-up to Serena and Wilder's relationship. One second he's her instructor and the literal next second, they're lusting after each other like two horny high schoolers. He does a lot of... uh... growling, biting, and "carnal" sounds (not my words). He starts to call Serena, "darling" and "my love" randomly. And then she says, "I love you" to him. Where the fuck did this come from! Weren't y'all supposed to be keeping "attraction" to each other low-key? Again, I'm so done.
Ohh, then NEXT, we have our THIRD! Yes, you heard me right: THIRD love interest, Frazer. He's quiet, dark, and brooding and is celibate. Yes, the author included this. He never, EVER talks to anyone, except our Miss. Serena of course. I mean, she's sooo attractive and all the fae males fall at her feet. Also, yes, males. Cause fae males aren't men and the author has made that very clear. Frazer goes from ignoring Serena one second to literally swapping BLOOD with her to create a KIN BOND and they start calling each other BROTHER AND SISTER. WHAT THE FUCK!! Didn't you hate her two pages ago?? WherE IS THE DEVELOPMENT? NOT ONLY DOES THIS HAPPEN, Serena goes and says that she LOVES HIM. What the actual fuckity fuck.
Alright, now, the supporting characters. Let me tell you-- just as bland and stupid as the main four in the love quadrangle. The twins Cai and Li literally fall at Serena's feet to help her. They share a very important secret with her TWO SECONDS after meeting her. What compels people in this realm to spill their secrets that could have them killed to Serena? I wanna know.
Then, we have the dialogue between these characters which is all so unnatural. It's as if the author was planning her book and used the "who, what, where, why, when" questions and answered them, but didn't rewrite her answers and just threw them in the book. Does that make sense?? There are so many moments when someone is explaining something and another character replies with, "Why's that?" Then they answer, and the other character will reply with another "wh" question. It's so boring to read! I want to see, not be told everything. The entire plot is carried by talk and almost no action.
Also, 90% of the book is composed of the stupid trials these characters go through to join the army?? There are literally six trials and YOU HAVE TO READ THROUGH EVERY SINGLE ONE. IT'S PAINFUL, because it's so boring!! I don't care about Serena running laps and swimming with Adrianna for five pages! That's not that relevant!
Then, we have the world-building which felt so off. In the beginning, it's clear we're in a small village in a high-fantasy set world. However, as we move into the fae realm and the characters start training, the language, food, slang gets so modern. Even the setting is so modern and feels more dystopian than high-fantasy.
The plot is also so so predictable. I saw many reviews saying it was a lot like SJM's series and I'd have to agree. Going in, I knew this, but I didn't care. People are allowed to have similar ideas. But, this plot... The antagonist in this book is named Morgan. We have a character in SJM's book called Morrigan. It's just very uncanny.
I'm so frustrated. I can't believe I sat through 585 pages of pure blagh. However, I like to end my reviews with the fact that we all have different tastes. What I like, you may not and what I dislike, you may like. And as always, it's hard work writing a book, so the author's work should not be discredited.