What do you think?
Rate this book
The Troubadours Quartet #4
Song Hereafter: 1153: Hispania and the Isles of Albion
Thrilling conclusion to an award-winning series. Global Ebooks Award for Best Historical Fiction. FINALIST in The Wishing Shelf and the Chaucer Awards. The Historical Novel Society Editor's Choice.
Dragonetz and Estela: the troubadours. They thought they knew each other but they didn't even know themselves.
Dragonetz has failed Eleanor of Aquitaine once. Now that she plans to be Queen of England he could make amends. Although prepared to risk his own life on an impossible quest, a knight should protect his lady, or so say the troubadour songs.
His lady, however, plays to a different tune and she wants partnership, not protection. Estela and Dragonetz fight their enemies, both on the battlefield and in the courts of Christendom, from the sophistication of Zaragossa to the wilds of Wales. Can they win through to song hereafter, together? Or have they broken one rule too many?
Mystery, intrigue, romance and adventure fill the pages of this magnificent conclusion to an epic series sure to delight fans of Elizabeth Chadwick and Bernard Cornwell. Jean Gill captures the soul of the age and the characters who lived in it.
'Evocative and thoroughly riveting. A vividly-written, historical saga.' The Wishing Shelf
'Historical Fiction at its best.' Karen Charlton, the Detective Lavender Mysteries
jeangill.com
Dragonetz and Estela: the troubadours. They thought they knew each other but they didn't even know themselves.
Dragonetz has failed Eleanor of Aquitaine once. Now that she plans to be Queen of England he could make amends. Although prepared to risk his own life on an impossible quest, a knight should protect his lady, or so say the troubadour songs.
His lady, however, plays to a different tune and she wants partnership, not protection. Estela and Dragonetz fight their enemies, both on the battlefield and in the courts of Christendom, from the sophistication of Zaragossa to the wilds of Wales. Can they win through to song hereafter, together? Or have they broken one rule too many?
Mystery, intrigue, romance and adventure fill the pages of this magnificent conclusion to an epic series sure to delight fans of Elizabeth Chadwick and Bernard Cornwell. Jean Gill captures the soul of the age and the characters who lived in it.
'Evocative and thoroughly riveting. A vividly-written, historical saga.' The Wishing Shelf
'Historical Fiction at its best.' Karen Charlton, the Detective Lavender Mysteries
jeangill.com
330 pages, ebook
Published November 9, 2017
33 people are currently reading
590 people want to read
About the author
Jean Gill
45 books239 followersJean Gill is a Welsh writer and photographer living in the south of France with two scruffy dogs, a beehive named 'Endeavour', a Nikon D750 and a man. For many years, she taught English in Wales and was the first woman to be a secondary headteacher in Carmarthenshire. She is mother or stepmother to five children so life was hectic.
Publications are varied, including prize-winning poetry and novels, military history, translated books on dog training, and a cookery book on goat cheese. With Scottish parents, an English birthplace and French residence, she can usually support the winning team on most sporting occasions.
Sign up for Jean's newsletter at www.jeangill.com for updates and a free book. If you review one of Jean's books you can add a dog to Jean's Readers Dogs Hall of Fame on her website. Contact Jean at jean.gill@wanadoo.fr with comments or questions. She loves to hear from readers.
Publications are varied, including prize-winning poetry and novels, military history, translated books on dog training, and a cookery book on goat cheese. With Scottish parents, an English birthplace and French residence, she can usually support the winning team on most sporting occasions.
Sign up for Jean's newsletter at www.jeangill.com for updates and a free book. If you review one of Jean's books you can add a dog to Jean's Readers Dogs Hall of Fame on her website. Contact Jean at jean.gill@wanadoo.fr with comments or questions. She loves to hear from readers.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews
November 19, 2017
Beautifully written with well-developed characters Song Hereafter is the final instalment in The Troubadours Quartet and it's just riveting. Jean Gill gave us a story of political intrigue and thrilling adventure interwoven with love story. Gill truly brings to life the twelfth century Europe, rich, vivid descriptions, cultural accuracy, it all makes for a great read.
I loved Dragonetz and Estela. Complex and interesting characters, I soon grew really fond of them and wanted the best for them both. Estela especially captured my heart, it's so good to see such a well-written, engaging female protagonist.
Brava, Jean Gill, Song Hereafter is a fantastic book and I'm happy to recommend it to historical fiction fans.
I loved Dragonetz and Estela. Complex and interesting characters, I soon grew really fond of them and wanted the best for them both. Estela especially captured my heart, it's so good to see such a well-written, engaging female protagonist.
Brava, Jean Gill, Song Hereafter is a fantastic book and I'm happy to recommend it to historical fiction fans.
November 11, 2017
Song hereafter by jean gill.
They thought they knew each other but they didn’t even know themselves.
Dragonetz has failed Eleanor of Aquitaine once. Now she plans to be Queen of England he could make amends. Although prepared to risk his own life on an impossible quest, a knight should protect his lady, or so say the troubadour songs. His lady, however, plays to a different tune and she wants partnership, not protection.
Very good read. Not what I'm used to reading. I liked the story. 4*. Tbc on rb.
They thought they knew each other but they didn’t even know themselves.
Dragonetz has failed Eleanor of Aquitaine once. Now she plans to be Queen of England he could make amends. Although prepared to risk his own life on an impossible quest, a knight should protect his lady, or so say the troubadour songs. His lady, however, plays to a different tune and she wants partnership, not protection.
Very good read. Not what I'm used to reading. I liked the story. 4*. Tbc on rb.
April 16, 2021
I won this book in a goodreads drawing.
Back when I played Dungeons and Dragons, I always wondered about the bard and the people who played them. It just seemed weird to have these travelling musicians hang out with people killing dragons and rescuing princesses and the like. What were they FOR? What was their actual function?
This historical novel, part of a series, answers the question for me.
Back when I played Dungeons and Dragons, I always wondered about the bard and the people who played them. It just seemed weird to have these travelling musicians hang out with people killing dragons and rescuing princesses and the like. What were they FOR? What was their actual function?
This historical novel, part of a series, answers the question for me.
October 17, 2017
Jean Gill's Song Hereafter, the final book in the series about troubadours Dragonetz and Estela is a remarkable achievement. Every character, and that includes the horses, dogs and hawks, is bursting with vitality, and Gill's lush descriptions of Moorish palaces seduce you as they send you on journey full of treachery, adventure and romance.
At the heart of these books are the religious divisions that shaped that era, and so there are enemies aplenty, and real passions as each character crusades for their 'true' God and cause. I made the mistake of reading the first book and then the last in this series so I have some catching up to do! But I loved the characters and the settings - the chivalrous, courageous Dragonetz and the sweet-voiced Estela who is searching for a true place to belong. In this series, the places of twelfth century europe - the papermills of France, the wilds of Wales, the pilgrimage routes are all brought skilfully to life.
This is epic literary historical fiction at its best. Highly recommended.
At the heart of these books are the religious divisions that shaped that era, and so there are enemies aplenty, and real passions as each character crusades for their 'true' God and cause. I made the mistake of reading the first book and then the last in this series so I have some catching up to do! But I loved the characters and the settings - the chivalrous, courageous Dragonetz and the sweet-voiced Estela who is searching for a true place to belong. In this series, the places of twelfth century europe - the papermills of France, the wilds of Wales, the pilgrimage routes are all brought skilfully to life.
This is epic literary historical fiction at its best. Highly recommended.
October 16, 2017
I’m a big fan of Jean Gill’s books and have been waiting for the final installment of the Troubadours Quartet with delicious anticipation. It exceeded all my expectations and I loved it!
Before the story starts the author shows us authentic maps of the area from the 12th century, gives us a short background into Wales of 1153, and introduces us to the historical characters who appear in her series, followed by her main fictional characters. Dragonetz and Estela already felt like old friends - along with Estela’s four-legged protector, the loveable dog Nici - but these introductions reminded me of their relationships with other characters and transported me to the 12th century.
Like the other books, this one is full of action, adventure and clever political intrigue, with a love story weaved throughout the series. Without giving away too many details, Dragonetz is sent on a mission to Wales (Gwalia) to obtain new allies for Alienor. The locals have their own problems, which the visitors are soon swept up in. There are some hair-raising scenes along the way where I was rooting for certain characters to endure and others to get their just desserts (no spoilers here).
The story answers the questions posed by the last book, and many others that I didn’t see coming. This ideal combination make it a thrilling page-turner and very hard to put down.
For me, this book has it all; love, adventure and politics in the twelfth century make for another stunning read from the uber talented Jean Gill.
I can see why the Troubadours Quartet has won many awards and highly recommend the whole series. You won’t be disappointed.
Before the story starts the author shows us authentic maps of the area from the 12th century, gives us a short background into Wales of 1153, and introduces us to the historical characters who appear in her series, followed by her main fictional characters. Dragonetz and Estela already felt like old friends - along with Estela’s four-legged protector, the loveable dog Nici - but these introductions reminded me of their relationships with other characters and transported me to the 12th century.
Like the other books, this one is full of action, adventure and clever political intrigue, with a love story weaved throughout the series. Without giving away too many details, Dragonetz is sent on a mission to Wales (Gwalia) to obtain new allies for Alienor. The locals have their own problems, which the visitors are soon swept up in. There are some hair-raising scenes along the way where I was rooting for certain characters to endure and others to get their just desserts (no spoilers here).
The story answers the questions posed by the last book, and many others that I didn’t see coming. This ideal combination make it a thrilling page-turner and very hard to put down.
For me, this book has it all; love, adventure and politics in the twelfth century make for another stunning read from the uber talented Jean Gill.
I can see why the Troubadours Quartet has won many awards and highly recommend the whole series. You won’t be disappointed.
February 18, 2018
Mythological fictions always give me an adrenaline rush. Traveling back to those ancient times, understanding the way of living, it just makes me awestruck, if only I could create a time machine and go back to those time period, but alas! So, in the meantime, I can come back to the book. This was my ever first Jean Gill book and to be honest, I enjoyed it quite a lot. The way the author has written down the characters making them come alive is absolutely stunning. With them, you will actually feel that the book is coming into life. Each moment is filled with details, beautifully described in a language filled with colour.
Although this is the third part of the series I found it very smooth, all I had to do was read out the first two book's description and I was good to go. Picking up where book three (Plaint for Provence) left off, we find Dragonetz at the court of El Rey Lobo alongside his Liege, Ramon Bereguer of Barcelone. There is a tension built up when you start reading the book and it is mainly between those three characters, and this chaos actually resulted in capturing my attention and keeping it intact throughout the journey. Soon we learn that Dragonetz feels guilty because he is keeping a secret from his lover, Estela. He chose to prevent her from being hurt by withholding the truth about the betrayal of Geoffroi de Rancor, a man she believed to be her friend. To do penance for what he views as a great wrong, he embarks on a pilgrimage.
The story has maintained its pace which usually becomes very difficult for most the authors and also there is a strong grip given to it. Once you start reading this book, it becomes next to impossible for you to leave it aside. Since I read a lot of mythological books (mainly Indian mythology), this side of the story was new for me and I really enjoyed it. The cover of the book actually attracts your attention all the more, it did to me.
For the full review, check my blog post:
https://bewitchinglyparanoid.wordpres...
Although this is the third part of the series I found it very smooth, all I had to do was read out the first two book's description and I was good to go. Picking up where book three (Plaint for Provence) left off, we find Dragonetz at the court of El Rey Lobo alongside his Liege, Ramon Bereguer of Barcelone. There is a tension built up when you start reading the book and it is mainly between those three characters, and this chaos actually resulted in capturing my attention and keeping it intact throughout the journey. Soon we learn that Dragonetz feels guilty because he is keeping a secret from his lover, Estela. He chose to prevent her from being hurt by withholding the truth about the betrayal of Geoffroi de Rancor, a man she believed to be her friend. To do penance for what he views as a great wrong, he embarks on a pilgrimage.
The story has maintained its pace which usually becomes very difficult for most the authors and also there is a strong grip given to it. Once you start reading this book, it becomes next to impossible for you to leave it aside. Since I read a lot of mythological books (mainly Indian mythology), this side of the story was new for me and I really enjoyed it. The cover of the book actually attracts your attention all the more, it did to me.
For the full review, check my blog post:
https://bewitchinglyparanoid.wordpres...
October 18, 2017
I’ve eagerly awaited the fourth book in the Troubadours series, and it was well worth waiting for. Song Hereafter by award winning author Jean Gill continues the story of Dragonetz los Pros and Estela de Matin. Capturing the flavor of the twelfth century, politically and culturally, Gill leads the reader along the path of history.
Gill’s ability to breathe life into her characters is stunning. They are not one-dimensional characters; every one experiences life fully. Each moment is filled with details, beautifully described in language rich with color.
Picking up where book three (Plaint for Provence) left off, we find Dragonetz at the court of El Rey Lobo alongside his Liege, Ramon Bereguer of Barcelone. The interactions between these three creates an immediate tension at the beginning of the book, capturing the reader’s attention and effectively holding it throughout. Soon we learn that Dragonetz feels guilty because he is keeping a secret from his lover, Estela. He chose to prevent her from being hurt by withholding the truth about the betrayal of Geoffroi de Rancor, a man she believed to be her friend. To do penance for what he views as a great wrong, he embarks on a pilgrimage. This is just the beginning of travels that take place in the book.
Called by Queen Alienor (Eleanor of Aquitaine) to her court, Dragonetz is offered the opportunity to clear his name by undertaking a task the Queen demands. Determined to sit as Queen of England alongside her spouse, Henri, Alienor has a plan and she needs Dragonetz to be successful. Despite her lover’s objections and the Queen’s reticence, Estela insists on joining him, leaving their son Musca in the care of trusted friends and servants. What ensues is a sometimes-perilous journey North to Gwalia (Wales) to assure the loyalty of the leader of these wild people to Henri, the King. Spying was a dangerous game, but Dragonetz was hungry to have his good name restored, so he agrees to take on the task. There are battles, intrigue, and an intense romance as the story progresses.
The language, names, and culture of Gwalia is added to this already culturally rich narrative. Gill’s skill at moving from culture to culture, savoring the distinctive colors of each, is breath taking. As I read, I was drawn along, experiencing each new character’s unique personality, relishing the flavor of their worlds. Through it all there is the music of the troubadours, Dragonetz and Estela. Their songs, which united them from the beginning, draws them always closer, sealing their bond of love and devotion. Even in the most harrowing moments of this story, there is no doubt of their commitment to one another, of a love that can withstand any trial.
I highly recommend reading this series in order. By doing so the reader will appreciate the relationship between Dragonetz and Estela, and can fully enjoy the development of their relationship. Characters may come and go, but Dragonetz and his lady love are a constant. Even when they are apart, they are in one another’s thoughts, united by their love and their music.
Readers of historical fiction will appreciate Gill’s attention to detail, romance readers will be captivated by the relationship between the lovers, adventurers will appreciate the thrills of battles, and all readers can celebrate a tale well told.
Gill’s ability to breathe life into her characters is stunning. They are not one-dimensional characters; every one experiences life fully. Each moment is filled with details, beautifully described in language rich with color.
Picking up where book three (Plaint for Provence) left off, we find Dragonetz at the court of El Rey Lobo alongside his Liege, Ramon Bereguer of Barcelone. The interactions between these three creates an immediate tension at the beginning of the book, capturing the reader’s attention and effectively holding it throughout. Soon we learn that Dragonetz feels guilty because he is keeping a secret from his lover, Estela. He chose to prevent her from being hurt by withholding the truth about the betrayal of Geoffroi de Rancor, a man she believed to be her friend. To do penance for what he views as a great wrong, he embarks on a pilgrimage. This is just the beginning of travels that take place in the book.
Called by Queen Alienor (Eleanor of Aquitaine) to her court, Dragonetz is offered the opportunity to clear his name by undertaking a task the Queen demands. Determined to sit as Queen of England alongside her spouse, Henri, Alienor has a plan and she needs Dragonetz to be successful. Despite her lover’s objections and the Queen’s reticence, Estela insists on joining him, leaving their son Musca in the care of trusted friends and servants. What ensues is a sometimes-perilous journey North to Gwalia (Wales) to assure the loyalty of the leader of these wild people to Henri, the King. Spying was a dangerous game, but Dragonetz was hungry to have his good name restored, so he agrees to take on the task. There are battles, intrigue, and an intense romance as the story progresses.
The language, names, and culture of Gwalia is added to this already culturally rich narrative. Gill’s skill at moving from culture to culture, savoring the distinctive colors of each, is breath taking. As I read, I was drawn along, experiencing each new character’s unique personality, relishing the flavor of their worlds. Through it all there is the music of the troubadours, Dragonetz and Estela. Their songs, which united them from the beginning, draws them always closer, sealing their bond of love and devotion. Even in the most harrowing moments of this story, there is no doubt of their commitment to one another, of a love that can withstand any trial.
I highly recommend reading this series in order. By doing so the reader will appreciate the relationship between Dragonetz and Estela, and can fully enjoy the development of their relationship. Characters may come and go, but Dragonetz and his lady love are a constant. Even when they are apart, they are in one another’s thoughts, united by their love and their music.
Readers of historical fiction will appreciate Gill’s attention to detail, romance readers will be captivated by the relationship between the lovers, adventurers will appreciate the thrills of battles, and all readers can celebrate a tale well told.
November 22, 2017
what can I say I was hooked from the beginning of the book I couldn't put it down loved the story, had me joining in there journey of love and betrayal even though I haven't read books1-3 I caught up with what was happening in the book but I will be buying books 1 -3
I really did enjoy reading this one I was hooked from start to finish had me wondering whats going to happen next, I recommend this book to anyone who like reading historical fiction I gave this book a 4 star
I really did enjoy reading this one I was hooked from start to finish had me wondering whats going to happen next, I recommend this book to anyone who like reading historical fiction I gave this book a 4 star
January 6, 2018
Perfection
I looked forward to this publication knowing it was the last book in a wonderful series and then put off actually reading it. I so loved the characters that I couldn't bear for it to end. And then I realized that enough time had passed and I could start over with the first book to live it all again. I've never been so pleased with the final chapter in any series as this. The story is so engaging, one almost doesn’t realize the lessons in history, poetry, music and medicine are being taught. The realationships between characters are enchanting, intriguing, and sometimes frightening. And the dog! You will recognize your own special dog in this hero, no matter the size or breed. Bravo!
I looked forward to this publication knowing it was the last book in a wonderful series and then put off actually reading it. I so loved the characters that I couldn't bear for it to end. And then I realized that enough time had passed and I could start over with the first book to live it all again. I've never been so pleased with the final chapter in any series as this. The story is so engaging, one almost doesn’t realize the lessons in history, poetry, music and medicine are being taught. The realationships between characters are enchanting, intriguing, and sometimes frightening. And the dog! You will recognize your own special dog in this hero, no matter the size or breed. Bravo!
November 19, 2017
A wonderful book - brava! Jean Gill's stories are so tightly woven into the tapestry of medieval France and England and the politics thereof that I simply marvel as I read them. Her complex plot lines and immersion in the atmosphere of the regions and the time are wonderful, and her use of Occitan lyrics throughout in her troubadors’ songs enhances the authentic flavor. As her characters travel farther afield, she draws the differences in the cultures of the time period so clearly that the people and their world view come alive. Although it was sad to say good-bye, this was a fitting end to the saga of Dragonetz and Estela. If you like history, if you like romance, if you like France, you have a treat awaiting you in this masterfully conceived and written quartet.
I received an electronic Advanced Reader Copy of this book prior to publication, in exchange for an honest review.
I received an electronic Advanced Reader Copy of this book prior to publication, in exchange for an honest review.
November 10, 2017
A blast of medieval air and irresistible storytelling you can’t put down. The fourth and final book in the Troubadours Series which continues with Dragonetz los Pros and Estela de Matin, two characters I have been rooting for since the very beginning. Without giving a précis of the book, I would rather give interested readers a ‘feel’ for what they are about to read.
Song Hereafter is brought to life in ways that only Jean Gill fans will appreciate. It’s easy to see why this author has won so many awards, readers and fans across the globe. She gets her historical facts right when it really matters because her research and her dedication to the finer details of the period is impeccable. With courtly intrigue and power struggles, you can’t help but feel the beauty and live the fear.
Swept along by the unique flavor and mood of the story, I particular enjoyed the accounts of medicine and healing, wills and hunting deer, architecture, singing and the wise traveler. Fascinating aspects of the time and had me pinned to my reader.
I’m very sad, however, to see the last of these captivating and enchanting historical novels. Although the books could be standalones, I recommend reading all four from the beginning to gain a thorough insight of the period and a deeper sense of these well-rounded and richly developed characters.
Song Hereafter is brought to life in ways that only Jean Gill fans will appreciate. It’s easy to see why this author has won so many awards, readers and fans across the globe. She gets her historical facts right when it really matters because her research and her dedication to the finer details of the period is impeccable. With courtly intrigue and power struggles, you can’t help but feel the beauty and live the fear.
Swept along by the unique flavor and mood of the story, I particular enjoyed the accounts of medicine and healing, wills and hunting deer, architecture, singing and the wise traveler. Fascinating aspects of the time and had me pinned to my reader.
I’m very sad, however, to see the last of these captivating and enchanting historical novels. Although the books could be standalones, I recommend reading all four from the beginning to gain a thorough insight of the period and a deeper sense of these well-rounded and richly developed characters.
November 13, 2017
I don’t read a lot of historical fiction, but I love when a book such as this is packed with historical details that make the story that much richer. Whether it’s a description of a scenic landscape or an article of clothing, these tidbits put you in the time and place of a story. I found myself alternating between reading this book and Googling about this time period because I wanted to know more. This isn’t, for me at least, a setting I’ve seen much in books.
On top of all that, I loved the cast of characters. Their reactions are believable even if I can’t imagine what I would do in their place. The lengthy journey this book takes you on allows you to learn right along with the characters, and all the different directions the plot takes you are interesting and keep you reading. Overall, I enjoyed this book very much. The story was fascinating, riveting, suspenseful, and heartwarming all at once.
On top of all that, I loved the cast of characters. Their reactions are believable even if I can’t imagine what I would do in their place. The lengthy journey this book takes you on allows you to learn right along with the characters, and all the different directions the plot takes you are interesting and keep you reading. Overall, I enjoyed this book very much. The story was fascinating, riveting, suspenseful, and heartwarming all at once.
November 13, 2017
This is a moving and riveting conclusion to what has become one of my favorite historical series. Dragonetz and Estela have to face some of their greatest challenges, both personally and professionally. Estela's family rears its ugly head again and she is forced to confront what family means and accept the choices she has made while Dragonetz struggles with honor and loyalty in a way that he can't imagine that spins both Estela and Dragonetz in the middle of intrigue and danger. Throughout it all the music and their love provide the strong thread that helps them that helps make this novel so engaging. I am so sad that this is the last one. I hated to see it finish.
November 11, 2017
I cannot begin to express how highly I rate the whole Troubadours series and as much as I was looking forward to this final instalment, I was also sad to think that this was the end of my journey with Estela and Dragonetz. I do love historical fiction but before starting this series, I hadn't read anything set in the 12th Century and whilst it has been a fascinating history lesson it has also been an emotional and exciting journey.
Eleanor of Aquitaine, who we first met in Song at Dawn, offers Dragonetz a way to get back into her favour: he must travel to the isles of Albion to pave the way for her new husband, Henri of Anjou, to take the crown of England and become Henry II. Estela is determined to make the journey with him, and Dragonetz knows he can't argue with her when she has got something into her head. So Estela and Dragonetz head to Wales where Dragonetz must make allies of the Welsh lords of Deheubarth: brothers Maredudd and Rhys ap Gruffyd. The brothers are naturally suspicious of the foreign visitors but after passing their tests, Estela and Dragonetz soon become a welcome addition to the welsh court...or do they? Sometimes appearances can be deceptive and Estela and Dragonetz are in more danger than they realise.
At the conclusion of this series, I think I finally understood why I love Jean Gill's writing so much: she has taken real historical characters and events but added strong fictional characters who I came to know and love. I could read a book about Elizabeth I, but because she was a real person I don't have any intense feelings about her. With Dragonetz and Estela, I've watched them grow and evolve from their first meeting when Estela was no more than a girl to the intense feelings of love and respect they have for each other as husband and wife. When their lives were in danger, both at home and abroad, I felt real fear for them and utter devastation that they were in this situation; I couldn't, and wouldn't, believe that their luck could have run out. With such vibrant and strong characters, this is historical fiction with heart.
I loved the Welsh setting of Song Hereafter as I do have Welsh ancestors. Having dabbled in genealogy, I found that I have more Welsh blood than I first thought and can trace my ancestors to both North Wales on my Grandad's side and to South Wales on my Nanna's side. Jean Gill has reawakened my desire to travel to the land of my ancestors, and follow in the footsteps of Estela and Dragonetz.
I heartily recommend that you add the whole series to your reading list. The magnificent Troubadours Quartet is an epic journey through the 12th Century and a series that I will return to again and again.
I chose to read an ARC and this is my honest and unbiased opinion.
Eleanor of Aquitaine, who we first met in Song at Dawn, offers Dragonetz a way to get back into her favour: he must travel to the isles of Albion to pave the way for her new husband, Henri of Anjou, to take the crown of England and become Henry II. Estela is determined to make the journey with him, and Dragonetz knows he can't argue with her when she has got something into her head. So Estela and Dragonetz head to Wales where Dragonetz must make allies of the Welsh lords of Deheubarth: brothers Maredudd and Rhys ap Gruffyd. The brothers are naturally suspicious of the foreign visitors but after passing their tests, Estela and Dragonetz soon become a welcome addition to the welsh court...or do they? Sometimes appearances can be deceptive and Estela and Dragonetz are in more danger than they realise.
At the conclusion of this series, I think I finally understood why I love Jean Gill's writing so much: she has taken real historical characters and events but added strong fictional characters who I came to know and love. I could read a book about Elizabeth I, but because she was a real person I don't have any intense feelings about her. With Dragonetz and Estela, I've watched them grow and evolve from their first meeting when Estela was no more than a girl to the intense feelings of love and respect they have for each other as husband and wife. When their lives were in danger, both at home and abroad, I felt real fear for them and utter devastation that they were in this situation; I couldn't, and wouldn't, believe that their luck could have run out. With such vibrant and strong characters, this is historical fiction with heart.
I loved the Welsh setting of Song Hereafter as I do have Welsh ancestors. Having dabbled in genealogy, I found that I have more Welsh blood than I first thought and can trace my ancestors to both North Wales on my Grandad's side and to South Wales on my Nanna's side. Jean Gill has reawakened my desire to travel to the land of my ancestors, and follow in the footsteps of Estela and Dragonetz.
I heartily recommend that you add the whole series to your reading list. The magnificent Troubadours Quartet is an epic journey through the 12th Century and a series that I will return to again and again.
I chose to read an ARC and this is my honest and unbiased opinion.
November 10, 2017
A WISHING SHELF BOOK REVIEW
17th August, 2017
TITLE: Song Hereafter
AUTHOR: Jean Gill
Star Rating: *****
‘Evocative and thoroughly riveting. A vividly-written, historical saga.’ The Wishing Shelf
REVIEW
For the last week or so, I have been thoroughly immersed in Song Hereafter by Jean Gill. It is the last book in The Troubadours Quartet, an historical novel full of intrigue, mystery, romance and adventure. Let me begin by saying how gripping this story is. Not only is the plot packed full of twists and turns, but the setting – and the characters – are lovingly described. There is, I think, nothing better than an historical novel written by an author who knows how to balance setting, speech and plot.
It is set in the 12th Century, a time in history a little lost to me. To most I think. It is simply too long ago. The 17th Century, yes, but the 12th! And, for me, that is why I enjoyed it so much. You see, Jean Gill is as much a researcher as an author. Yes, her writing skills are stellar, but it’s her knowledge of the time that brings this story alive. Also, she understands how important it is not to just simply describe the ‘historical’ setting but, rather, have the characters interact with it in a natural and unobtrusive way. Many authors, who set a book in a different century, seem determined to describe every silver spoon and every woolen tunic. Thankfully, this author has not fallen into that trap.
It is a longish novel but that’s okay. The twisting plot and ‘jump of the page’ characters, particularly Dragonetz and Estela, will soon draw you in. You will soon be immersed in a feudal world of political intrigue, bloody conflicts and even a scattering of romance.
I would happily recommend this book to any reader of historical novels, particularly if ‘medieval’ is your thing. Should you read the other books in the set first? Probably. It works as a stand-alone novel but, if you really want to delve into this fascinating world the author has created, I’d start at Song at Dawn. Why rush it when it’s such a wonderful journey?
A ‘Wishing Shelf’ Book Review
www.thewsa.co.uk
17th August, 2017
TITLE: Song Hereafter
AUTHOR: Jean Gill
Star Rating: *****
‘Evocative and thoroughly riveting. A vividly-written, historical saga.’ The Wishing Shelf
REVIEW
For the last week or so, I have been thoroughly immersed in Song Hereafter by Jean Gill. It is the last book in The Troubadours Quartet, an historical novel full of intrigue, mystery, romance and adventure. Let me begin by saying how gripping this story is. Not only is the plot packed full of twists and turns, but the setting – and the characters – are lovingly described. There is, I think, nothing better than an historical novel written by an author who knows how to balance setting, speech and plot.
It is set in the 12th Century, a time in history a little lost to me. To most I think. It is simply too long ago. The 17th Century, yes, but the 12th! And, for me, that is why I enjoyed it so much. You see, Jean Gill is as much a researcher as an author. Yes, her writing skills are stellar, but it’s her knowledge of the time that brings this story alive. Also, she understands how important it is not to just simply describe the ‘historical’ setting but, rather, have the characters interact with it in a natural and unobtrusive way. Many authors, who set a book in a different century, seem determined to describe every silver spoon and every woolen tunic. Thankfully, this author has not fallen into that trap.
It is a longish novel but that’s okay. The twisting plot and ‘jump of the page’ characters, particularly Dragonetz and Estela, will soon draw you in. You will soon be immersed in a feudal world of political intrigue, bloody conflicts and even a scattering of romance.
I would happily recommend this book to any reader of historical novels, particularly if ‘medieval’ is your thing. Should you read the other books in the set first? Probably. It works as a stand-alone novel but, if you really want to delve into this fascinating world the author has created, I’d start at Song at Dawn. Why rush it when it’s such a wonderful journey?
A ‘Wishing Shelf’ Book Review
www.thewsa.co.uk
December 31, 2017
Song Hereafter (Troubadours 4) by Jean Gill
A good historical novel gives you the opportunity to explore a distant and all but unknown world, not as a tourist, not as a scholar, but as a native – seeing and understanding and living in that world.
That’s what you get from Jean Gill’s ‘Troubadours’ series. With her characters Estela and Dragonetz we explore a tumultuous world of colour and danger, cruelty and beauty. A world where superstition and bigotry rub shoulders with brilliance and nobility. It all comes alive in Gill’s writing and when you put the book down you are amazed at how people lived in those times.
Of course, this is not just down to historical accuracy, or even to vivid descriptions. What really draws you into these books are the characters. Both the major and the minor players are well developed and believable, but in Dragonetz and Estela we meet people who are complex, passionate and engaging. They are people we come to care about. After following the course of their lives and their love through all four books and across half the world of their time, we want to see them settled and at peace: they’ve certainly earned it!
But it’s not guaranteed. There are too many enemies, too many uncertainties. ‘Song Hereafter’ takes them to the wild and barbarous lands of Gwalia – Wales. Far from home and caught up in a war that is not their own, they nevertheless discover amazing beauty: and other things less welcome.
I don’t wish to include any spoilers here, but for those who have read the previous ‘Troubadours’ novels, ‘Song Hereafter’ is a fitting and satisfying conclusion. For those who have not – you should! You will not find any better historical fiction, nor a more powerful evocation of a vivid past than in Gill’s brilliantly written series.
The Provence of Estela and Dragonetz is long gone, though it has left its mark in the world. Their native Occitan is still spoken in some parts, but the famous troubadours no longer delight the courts of the great with their powerful voices and clever lyrics. Gill’s novels bring them back and give us a sense of what it was like to live and fight and love in those distant times.
A good historical novel gives you the opportunity to explore a distant and all but unknown world, not as a tourist, not as a scholar, but as a native – seeing and understanding and living in that world.
That’s what you get from Jean Gill’s ‘Troubadours’ series. With her characters Estela and Dragonetz we explore a tumultuous world of colour and danger, cruelty and beauty. A world where superstition and bigotry rub shoulders with brilliance and nobility. It all comes alive in Gill’s writing and when you put the book down you are amazed at how people lived in those times.
Of course, this is not just down to historical accuracy, or even to vivid descriptions. What really draws you into these books are the characters. Both the major and the minor players are well developed and believable, but in Dragonetz and Estela we meet people who are complex, passionate and engaging. They are people we come to care about. After following the course of their lives and their love through all four books and across half the world of their time, we want to see them settled and at peace: they’ve certainly earned it!
But it’s not guaranteed. There are too many enemies, too many uncertainties. ‘Song Hereafter’ takes them to the wild and barbarous lands of Gwalia – Wales. Far from home and caught up in a war that is not their own, they nevertheless discover amazing beauty: and other things less welcome.
I don’t wish to include any spoilers here, but for those who have read the previous ‘Troubadours’ novels, ‘Song Hereafter’ is a fitting and satisfying conclusion. For those who have not – you should! You will not find any better historical fiction, nor a more powerful evocation of a vivid past than in Gill’s brilliantly written series.
The Provence of Estela and Dragonetz is long gone, though it has left its mark in the world. Their native Occitan is still spoken in some parts, but the famous troubadours no longer delight the courts of the great with their powerful voices and clever lyrics. Gill’s novels bring them back and give us a sense of what it was like to live and fight and love in those distant times.
June 12, 2018
All is well.
If I were able to write a brief book review, the line above would probably be the shortest ever but would cover everything.
After reading four books in this series, what I can definitely say, as a fan of this type of historical fiction and Jean Gill’s dedicated writing style, is that this is the perfect ending to a phenomenal series. And yes – all is well. The writing is excellent, the characters are strong, developed fully and with all facets and dimensions, the plot is strong and unfaltering, the details of historical research, descriptions and relationships, both private and political, are astoundingly vivid and intriguing. Now, you may read this book without having read the previous three, but why deny yourself the absolute literary and emotional journey of reading the entire series?
I remember thinking how exciting history can be while I was reading the first book. By the time I got to the fourth book, I was no longer thinking that, because Estela and Dragonetz, along with an entire myriad of splendid heroes and villains, were no history for me. They were real, they were vivid and alive, and closing the book after that last page felt like saying goodbye to friends. Yes, that’s the kind of book it is – you don’t read it, you live it.
I can honestly thank the author for alowing me to travel to all those distant places (old Wales is absolutely striking in this book), experience extraordinary customs and witness amazing events, but most of all – meet the admirable, passionate, courageous people (oops, characters) I will always miss. The great thing about books though is that you can always revisit them.
If I were able to write a brief book review, the line above would probably be the shortest ever but would cover everything.
After reading four books in this series, what I can definitely say, as a fan of this type of historical fiction and Jean Gill’s dedicated writing style, is that this is the perfect ending to a phenomenal series. And yes – all is well. The writing is excellent, the characters are strong, developed fully and with all facets and dimensions, the plot is strong and unfaltering, the details of historical research, descriptions and relationships, both private and political, are astoundingly vivid and intriguing. Now, you may read this book without having read the previous three, but why deny yourself the absolute literary and emotional journey of reading the entire series?
I remember thinking how exciting history can be while I was reading the first book. By the time I got to the fourth book, I was no longer thinking that, because Estela and Dragonetz, along with an entire myriad of splendid heroes and villains, were no history for me. They were real, they were vivid and alive, and closing the book after that last page felt like saying goodbye to friends. Yes, that’s the kind of book it is – you don’t read it, you live it.
I can honestly thank the author for alowing me to travel to all those distant places (old Wales is absolutely striking in this book), experience extraordinary customs and witness amazing events, but most of all – meet the admirable, passionate, courageous people (oops, characters) I will always miss. The great thing about books though is that you can always revisit them.
November 11, 2017
Song Hereafter was the first book I've read by Jean Gill, I was assured it could be read as a standalone so despite never reading books out of order, I dove in. I really struggled in the first few chapters as to where I was and what was going on, I felt this was perhaps due to not knowing the characters but I soon got into the story.
I'm a huge fan of history books but I don't think I've ever read after from this time period, I loved it. It was a little confusing about the places but there are maps in the book to refer to.
The characters were well-developed and they seemed real to me, my favourite character was Estela. She was so strong and she wanted to fight on the journeys to create a better life for her family. The journeys they embarked upon were brilliant, beautifully written and I could really imagine what the characters went through to reach their destination.
I would have given it 5 stars if I'd read the series and so I would have known more about the characters. I will definitely go and read from book 1 now! This is a beautifully written book about a fabulous time period, Jean Gill's writing style sucks you right in to the book and it really feels you are there with Estela and Dragonetz.
I'm a huge fan of history books but I don't think I've ever read after from this time period, I loved it. It was a little confusing about the places but there are maps in the book to refer to.
The characters were well-developed and they seemed real to me, my favourite character was Estela. She was so strong and she wanted to fight on the journeys to create a better life for her family. The journeys they embarked upon were brilliant, beautifully written and I could really imagine what the characters went through to reach their destination.
I would have given it 5 stars if I'd read the series and so I would have known more about the characters. I will definitely go and read from book 1 now! This is a beautifully written book about a fabulous time period, Jean Gill's writing style sucks you right in to the book and it really feels you are there with Estela and Dragonetz.
November 19, 2017
Wow, this book grabs you from the beginning. Dragonetz and Estela are on a mission by the queen Eleanor, and are on their way to Wales where they gave to prove to the people that Eleanor’s husband is a worthy ally and he can become Henry II. . First they must prove themselves in a series of tests.
Even though it’s the last book (4) in the series and I hadn’t read 1-3 I didn’t feel left behind. There were times when I scratched my head when reading but there is such a wealth of information that you soon catch up. I now need to get 1-3 and read a song hereafter again.
Would definitely recommend.
Even though it’s the last book (4) in the series and I hadn’t read 1-3 I didn’t feel left behind. There were times when I scratched my head when reading but there is such a wealth of information that you soon catch up. I now need to get 1-3 and read a song hereafter again.
Would definitely recommend.
January 4, 2018
Great read
Finally read all four books. My thanks to the author. Really enjoyed each and every one. Would recommend for those wishing light but great reading to delve into these books!
Finally read all four books. My thanks to the author. Really enjoyed each and every one. Would recommend for those wishing light but great reading to delve into these books!
April 4, 2018
Jean Gill asked me to read her novel, "Song Hereafter". It is the fourth book in her "The Troubadours" series and the fourth book of hers that I have reviewed. I wished I had a Hall of Fame on my blog because this is also the fourth book of hers that I find excellent. I will examine Plot, Character, and Polish, and then assign a grade.
PLOT
The overarching plot here is that of Dragonetz and Estela's relationship trouble; not with each other but with their situation. They are effectively a married couple (common-law marriage?) but for previous-book reasons, they can't be officially married. This causes certain problems in 12st century European society. These problems take the form of several, smaller, more concrete arcs. The biggest of which, and what is the meat of this book, is a stealth-diplomatic mission to Gwalia (i.e. Whales).
Upon initially reading the book, it can come off as disjointed because certain plot points are set up and then resolved shortly after (with exception, of course, to the main plot in Gwalia) without any obvious connection. However, one soon sees how they are all connected to the larger plot and build off on each other. It can sometimes be surprising just how well they connect. It is a tapestry of life, sort of thing.
I like what Jean Gill does with scenery and other landscape details. It is a great balance of what is beautiful and what is necessary. When the leading couple approach the Palace of Joy in Zaragoza, there is this depiction of its splendor. The natural landscapes in Gwalia are similarly attentive but not every location is described. That would be exhausting. Reaching this balance is something I try to do in my own writing, but I am not as consistently skilled in this area as Miss Gill.
Question: "What's in the bag?" Answer: "A badger." WHACK. Simultaneously, this scene is funny, serious, and an establishing character moment for two critical characters and their society.
Over the course of this book, Estella writes a travel guide she calls "The Wise Traveler". Not only does it show another development of Estella's creative nature but it also serves as a handy and non-intrusive way to provide exposition. It is actually a meta device because the information provided about the places Estella visits also informs the person reading Miss. Gill's book about Estella's point of view and audience.
There is a satisfying conclusion, both to this book and to this series. The Romance Genre aspect of the series is fulfilled in full and many plot threads are tied. It is a good place to stop in the lives of Estela and Dragonetz, though there is definitely more to them.
CHARACTERS
Estela's character continues to develop as her character arc takes a new turn. This book places a special emphasis on the roles of wife and mother, which unfolds in how Estela is vs how the society at the time and place expects both to act. There is patience and understanding but also stubborn support (whether he likes it or not). There is also a heightened contrast with Alienor that was previously absent.
Contrasting this is her coming into her own as a healer by saving her own medical mentor from a disease that is really tough to cure. It turns out that her first task with a patient is convincing the family that A.) it is not yet time for Last Rites and B.) she, personally, can heal them. Then there is writing "The Wise Traveler", which shows another facet of her artistic side, apart from writing and singing.
It is interesting to note that despite getting beaten over the head with social norms like wives being absolutely obedient to their husbands, Estela is not portrayed as a feminist. Sure, she doesn't want to "count to four" whenever her husbands commands it of her, and would really appreciate it if people didn't assume that her man was responsible for her lyrics, and bristles when a court lord forbids her from singing because of her gender, but she is also totally on board with supporting her husband's goals even if she doesn't agree with them, making sure her children are taken care off even if it precludes other opportunities, and generally putting family first.
As for Dragonetz, the self-flagellating continues. He is a complex chivalric character. It's like he is a Knight in Sour Armor that aspires to be a Knight in Shining Armor but has too many human frailties and too much disillusionment to do so.
Despite all the good he does, he never feels like it's enough. There's this scene where he goes to a notary to legally designate the son he sired with Estela as his heir and make sure they're both provided for in the event of his untimely death (which, considering his line of work, is a very likely thing) but leaves it feeling like he's betrayed her since she's legally his mistress instead of his wife (incidentally, this is also his fault due to a previous attempt at helping her).
Also, there's this running gag where he jokes about using his sword on any warrior or bard that Estela shows too much admiration for; Estela hopes he's joking. It turns out to be another human frailty that he feels a need to metaphorically whip himself for.
The third character that I want to focus on is John Halfpenny, a master minter. He's mostly here for comedy, whether it is rants about how he hates working with gold, clowning around as the Lord of Misrule, or standing perfectly still while Estela practices knife-throwing on him. Yet he, too, is a complex character, with his backstory regarding The Anarchy in England at the time, and the role he plays in the stealth-diplomacy mission.
There isn't really a villain here. It's more like a series of grey-scale antagonists. Here are people who could be allies or enemies. It is part of a general greyness that is upheld well through all of Miss. Gill's series. Lords Rhys and Marredud are like neutrals who could go either way depending on the actions of their guests/captives, Patronella doesn't do much more than sniff disdainfully at how the lead couple is living in sin, and Miquel, despite being a stellar example of Faux Evilly Affable, thinks he's doing the right thing.
POLISH
I didn't see any typos or grammar errors. That's a difficult thing to do with a novel.
I also like the glossaries and maps that are included at the start of the novel.
Trickster Eric Novels gives "Song Hereafter" an A+
PLOT
The overarching plot here is that of Dragonetz and Estela's relationship trouble; not with each other but with their situation. They are effectively a married couple (common-law marriage?) but for previous-book reasons, they can't be officially married. This causes certain problems in 12st century European society. These problems take the form of several, smaller, more concrete arcs. The biggest of which, and what is the meat of this book, is a stealth-diplomatic mission to Gwalia (i.e. Whales).
Upon initially reading the book, it can come off as disjointed because certain plot points are set up and then resolved shortly after (with exception, of course, to the main plot in Gwalia) without any obvious connection. However, one soon sees how they are all connected to the larger plot and build off on each other. It can sometimes be surprising just how well they connect. It is a tapestry of life, sort of thing.
I like what Jean Gill does with scenery and other landscape details. It is a great balance of what is beautiful and what is necessary. When the leading couple approach the Palace of Joy in Zaragoza, there is this depiction of its splendor. The natural landscapes in Gwalia are similarly attentive but not every location is described. That would be exhausting. Reaching this balance is something I try to do in my own writing, but I am not as consistently skilled in this area as Miss Gill.
Question: "What's in the bag?" Answer: "A badger." WHACK. Simultaneously, this scene is funny, serious, and an establishing character moment for two critical characters and their society.
Over the course of this book, Estella writes a travel guide she calls "The Wise Traveler". Not only does it show another development of Estella's creative nature but it also serves as a handy and non-intrusive way to provide exposition. It is actually a meta device because the information provided about the places Estella visits also informs the person reading Miss. Gill's book about Estella's point of view and audience.
There is a satisfying conclusion, both to this book and to this series. The Romance Genre aspect of the series is fulfilled in full and many plot threads are tied. It is a good place to stop in the lives of Estela and Dragonetz, though there is definitely more to them.
CHARACTERS
Estela's character continues to develop as her character arc takes a new turn. This book places a special emphasis on the roles of wife and mother, which unfolds in how Estela is vs how the society at the time and place expects both to act. There is patience and understanding but also stubborn support (whether he likes it or not). There is also a heightened contrast with Alienor that was previously absent.
Contrasting this is her coming into her own as a healer by saving her own medical mentor from a disease that is really tough to cure. It turns out that her first task with a patient is convincing the family that A.) it is not yet time for Last Rites and B.) she, personally, can heal them. Then there is writing "The Wise Traveler", which shows another facet of her artistic side, apart from writing and singing.
It is interesting to note that despite getting beaten over the head with social norms like wives being absolutely obedient to their husbands, Estela is not portrayed as a feminist. Sure, she doesn't want to "count to four" whenever her husbands commands it of her, and would really appreciate it if people didn't assume that her man was responsible for her lyrics, and bristles when a court lord forbids her from singing because of her gender, but she is also totally on board with supporting her husband's goals even if she doesn't agree with them, making sure her children are taken care off even if it precludes other opportunities, and generally putting family first.
As for Dragonetz, the self-flagellating continues. He is a complex chivalric character. It's like he is a Knight in Sour Armor that aspires to be a Knight in Shining Armor but has too many human frailties and too much disillusionment to do so.
Despite all the good he does, he never feels like it's enough. There's this scene where he goes to a notary to legally designate the son he sired with Estela as his heir and make sure they're both provided for in the event of his untimely death (which, considering his line of work, is a very likely thing) but leaves it feeling like he's betrayed her since she's legally his mistress instead of his wife (incidentally, this is also his fault due to a previous attempt at helping her).
Also, there's this running gag where he jokes about using his sword on any warrior or bard that Estela shows too much admiration for; Estela hopes he's joking. It turns out to be another human frailty that he feels a need to metaphorically whip himself for.
The third character that I want to focus on is John Halfpenny, a master minter. He's mostly here for comedy, whether it is rants about how he hates working with gold, clowning around as the Lord of Misrule, or standing perfectly still while Estela practices knife-throwing on him. Yet he, too, is a complex character, with his backstory regarding The Anarchy in England at the time, and the role he plays in the stealth-diplomacy mission.
There isn't really a villain here. It's more like a series of grey-scale antagonists. Here are people who could be allies or enemies. It is part of a general greyness that is upheld well through all of Miss. Gill's series. Lords Rhys and Marredud are like neutrals who could go either way depending on the actions of their guests/captives, Patronella doesn't do much more than sniff disdainfully at how the lead couple is living in sin, and Miquel, despite being a stellar example of Faux Evilly Affable, thinks he's doing the right thing.
POLISH
I didn't see any typos or grammar errors. That's a difficult thing to do with a novel.
I also like the glossaries and maps that are included at the start of the novel.
Trickster Eric Novels gives "Song Hereafter" an A+
December 16, 2018
Song Hereafter by Jean Gill: a Review
Song Hereafter is the fourth in the author’s Troubadour Quartet, and whilst there is certainly room and reason for further novels, it does form a suitable finale to a series which has been full of character growth, rich detail and very well-thought-out plotting!
The pace is just right: there is a definite Beginning, wherein the broad plots are laid out, and developments from the previous novels continued; a Middle, full of movement, action and discovery both of people and places, and an End, in which issues are resolved and the main characters placed in a position where they could - if the author wished - live out the rest of their lives in as much relative peace and quiet as 12th Century France is likely to allow a famed knight and his sort-of wife - and the demand for their joint services as renowned musicians!
I have enjoyed these books; this last one I found to be just as fast-paced and detail-rich as the first, with a fine appreciation of the much higher stakes now being played for all around them as Dragonetz and Estrella find themselves on a mission to - of all places - Wales! Her sense of loss and longing for what she considers basic comforts in this new and wilder land are very well described; there is little place for her in the native culture, and that feeling is also very well brought out. Conversely, Dragonetz adapts readily, though again the less advanced state of military technology and thinking in the West is perfectly presented. But by the end, Home cannot come soon enough for either of them, though in true Gill style, their troubles are far from over even then.
This is, therefore, a fine and fitting end to an enthralling series, and comes highly recommended.
Song Hereafter is the fourth in the author’s Troubadour Quartet, and whilst there is certainly room and reason for further novels, it does form a suitable finale to a series which has been full of character growth, rich detail and very well-thought-out plotting!
The pace is just right: there is a definite Beginning, wherein the broad plots are laid out, and developments from the previous novels continued; a Middle, full of movement, action and discovery both of people and places, and an End, in which issues are resolved and the main characters placed in a position where they could - if the author wished - live out the rest of their lives in as much relative peace and quiet as 12th Century France is likely to allow a famed knight and his sort-of wife - and the demand for their joint services as renowned musicians!
I have enjoyed these books; this last one I found to be just as fast-paced and detail-rich as the first, with a fine appreciation of the much higher stakes now being played for all around them as Dragonetz and Estrella find themselves on a mission to - of all places - Wales! Her sense of loss and longing for what she considers basic comforts in this new and wilder land are very well described; there is little place for her in the native culture, and that feeling is also very well brought out. Conversely, Dragonetz adapts readily, though again the less advanced state of military technology and thinking in the West is perfectly presented. But by the end, Home cannot come soon enough for either of them, though in true Gill style, their troubles are far from over even then.
This is, therefore, a fine and fitting end to an enthralling series, and comes highly recommended.
December 2, 2018
A Most Worthy Finale
I hope you read the first three books, since this one is a supremely satisfying finish to enjoy. It's a Welsh feast to be sure.
When it comes to knives and accuracy Estela is without peer (except perhaps for Vertat, the goshawk whose weapon is talons, and whose accuracy Ms. Gill displays with breathtaking speed, force and supremely controlled power - much like Estela's when throwing that knife!).
The author who created them both is no slouch herself in those departments.
From the first sentence to the last, the story speeds true to its conclusion. Forces which the characters can (and cannot) control harass them constantly, and left ME as dizzy as them with equal measures of relief and foreboding.
Power in battle, and politics. Power in knowledge and superstition.
Power in arts and languages.
Powerful love. Powerful hatred.
I hated to see it end, and was never so relieved in my reading life as I was when it did.
That's never happened to me before. I've read literary masterpieces from Abraham to Zora. I live to read. I have done so for all my 60+ years and I can say of Jean Gill as I say of her Estela
"She is without peer. "
I hope you read the first three books, since this one is a supremely satisfying finish to enjoy. It's a Welsh feast to be sure.
When it comes to knives and accuracy Estela is without peer (except perhaps for Vertat, the goshawk whose weapon is talons, and whose accuracy Ms. Gill displays with breathtaking speed, force and supremely controlled power - much like Estela's when throwing that knife!).
The author who created them both is no slouch herself in those departments.
From the first sentence to the last, the story speeds true to its conclusion. Forces which the characters can (and cannot) control harass them constantly, and left ME as dizzy as them with equal measures of relief and foreboding.
Power in battle, and politics. Power in knowledge and superstition.
Power in arts and languages.
Powerful love. Powerful hatred.
I hated to see it end, and was never so relieved in my reading life as I was when it did.
That's never happened to me before. I've read literary masterpieces from Abraham to Zora. I live to read. I have done so for all my 60+ years and I can say of Jean Gill as I say of her Estela
"She is without peer. "
March 22, 2018
I received Song Hereafer 1153 as part of a Goodreads giveaway.
Troubadours and lovers Dragonetz and Estela set out to assist Alienor (Eleanor), previous Queen of France and would-be Queen of England. Together, their party travels to the wilds of Wales to secure the cooperation of the Welsh for Henry, Eleanor's husband, encountering danger and adventure alike.
For me, not having read the previous novels, it took a while to get into the book and to figure out the various relationships and personalities at play in this, the final chapter. I'd definitely recommend reading the other volumes, as it's not always evident what's going on if you haven't. That said, the prose is lush and vivid, the characters are compelling, and the point of view is different from that of much of traditional medieval European fiction/romance.
Troubadours and lovers Dragonetz and Estela set out to assist Alienor (Eleanor), previous Queen of France and would-be Queen of England. Together, their party travels to the wilds of Wales to secure the cooperation of the Welsh for Henry, Eleanor's husband, encountering danger and adventure alike.
For me, not having read the previous novels, it took a while to get into the book and to figure out the various relationships and personalities at play in this, the final chapter. I'd definitely recommend reading the other volumes, as it's not always evident what's going on if you haven't. That said, the prose is lush and vivid, the characters are compelling, and the point of view is different from that of much of traditional medieval European fiction/romance.
August 30, 2020
I won this a long time ago in a Goodreads giveaway. This is the first thing i've read by the author.
This is a solid 4.5 star book. At first I was wishing I had read the first 3 in the series before starting this one but as I read through it was easy to catch up on things I'd missed by not reading the other books. The characters are well thought out and interesting. The story has a great flow and pacing. I will eventually go back and read the other 3 books.
This is a solid 4.5 star book. At first I was wishing I had read the first 3 in the series before starting this one but as I read through it was easy to catch up on things I'd missed by not reading the other books. The characters are well thought out and interesting. The story has a great flow and pacing. I will eventually go back and read the other 3 books.
January 19, 2023
epic tale told so well
Every one of the books on this series is just incredibly written. The author is a master storyteller that does a great justice to both hero and heroine of this epic tale of adventure and romance. I am so sad that my time with Dragonetz and Estela is over but I could hardly put these books down and devoured them much too quickly! I will read anything this author writes, the words are genius on the page!
Every one of the books on this series is just incredibly written. The author is a master storyteller that does a great justice to both hero and heroine of this epic tale of adventure and romance. I am so sad that my time with Dragonetz and Estela is over but I could hardly put these books down and devoured them much too quickly! I will read anything this author writes, the words are genius on the page!
October 26, 2018
Troubadour Quartet Series
For readers who enjoy historical fiction, this series checks all the boxes. It's a story of great love, great battles, and great treachery. Ms. Gill's writing brings the reader into the time of the story with great detail and beautiful prose. I would highly recommend these 4 books to any reader of this genre.
For readers who enjoy historical fiction, this series checks all the boxes. It's a story of great love, great battles, and great treachery. Ms. Gill's writing brings the reader into the time of the story with great detail and beautiful prose. I would highly recommend these 4 books to any reader of this genre.
October 21, 2022
Hated to finish this book because it is the last in the series. One of point of interest to me was that Dragonetz finally found a live version of the music he had dreamed about. Clergy in various churches had told him it was impossible or heretical but while in Gwalia (Wales) he heard people singing in that style - harmony instead of unison.
June 12, 2018
Wonderful story!
I'm a fan! Loved this story from the first pages. Epic in four books, it provided me with many hours of enjoyable reading. The travels and trials of this couple was interesting. The time and setting were well researched and informative. Loved and recommended!
I'm a fan! Loved this story from the first pages. Epic in four books, it provided me with many hours of enjoyable reading. The travels and trials of this couple was interesting. The time and setting were well researched and informative. Loved and recommended!
March 3, 2023
Captivating Historical Fiction
I loved the richness of this medieval world, and the intertwining of historic and fictional characters. Jean Gill held me in her spell, as I read breathlessly to find out what happened to these amazing romantic troubadours.
I loved the richness of this medieval world, and the intertwining of historic and fictional characters. Jean Gill held me in her spell, as I read breathlessly to find out what happened to these amazing romantic troubadours.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews