3.5 stars
Still a fun ride, but starting to feel familiar
As a longtime fan of the Wilde & Chase series (yep, I’ve read every book and loved it), diving into The Spear of Atlantis felt like catching up with old friends. Eddie’s still sarcastic and unkillable, Nina’s still brilliant and grounded, and the action? Still explosive and relentless, in true Andy McDermott fashion.
This time it’s all about Atlantis (again!) and a legendary spear tied to ancient secrets and world-ending stakes aka a very typical day for these two. The mythology was actually one of my favourite parts, with some fun twists on the usual Atlantis lore. And I’ll never complain about booby-trapped ruins and globe-trotting chaos it’s why I read these books.
That said, I did find myself wishing for something… different. Or deeper. The plot structure feels pretty by the numbers at this point, and while that can be comforting, it also made some of the twists feel a bit predictable. I was also hoping for more development in Eddie and Nina’s relationship it's been 14 books, and while their chemistry is still solid, their emotional arc feels like it’s stuck in place.
Still, if you’ve made it this far into the series, you know what you’re here for: fast-paced action, ancient mysteries, and a whole lot of snark. The Spear of Atlantis delivers that in full. Just don’t expect it to reinvent the formula.
Hoping Book 15 shakes things up a bit!