Francesca Amarro is busy making cremas, cookies and serving customers at Antonia's Cafe. She is trying to avoid thinking about how much she misses her mom at Christmastime and wondering what's going on between Sammy and Ryan, a local policeman. Then Fran hears a teacher at Cape Bay High was murdered in the school parking lot! Fran had an unpleasant run in with the woman while trying to discuss the bake sale at the school play. Fran can't believe this woman was in charge of the play. Fran's own employees attend the school and they are not saddened by this woman's death. No one in town is. She was a newcomer and was not kind to anyone. Before Fran can think about investigating, or not, the police arrest a beloved teacher, Mrs. Crowsdale, whom everyone says is is too nice to murder anyone. Mike, however, says they have solid evidence that proves she did it and is glad he can close the case before Christmas. Sammy is devastated that her favorite teacher is surely being framed. Can't Fran just look into it, a little bit? Fran is reluctant to get involved but soon starts asking questions. Her suspicions lead her back to the school and an angsty teenage boy. Could he really have killed a teacher? What about one of the other teachers, like the former drama teacher, Gwen? When Mike learns of Fran's investigation he is LIVID! He's certain this is a closed case and doesn't need a civilian sticking her nose in, harassing an underage boy and ruining his life! Fran is heartbroken at the loss of the close friendship she once shared with Mike, but not even his lecture can stop her from trying to solve the mystery. Meanwhile, Sammy is beset with personal problems involving her non-relationship relationship with Ryan. Will this be a merry Christmas for everyone?
I liked this story a little less than the previous books. There's not much Christmas about the story and there's too much drama. Also, there is not enough Matt and Latte for me! I figured out who the murderer was and had a good idea why. It was fairly obvious.
Now Fran went a little crazy investigating, I feel like I can relate to her a little less. She makes some rash amd dumb decisions. Mike has every right, as a law officer, to lock Fran up for impeding his investigation and endangering a minor. It speaks to their friendship that he doesn't. She should have called Mike and told him to talk to Brett. Brett is a high school boy who acts like a punk and is written as kind of a stereotype but has a bit more depth than I thought he would have. I didn't particularly like him though. His mother is very high maintenance and over protective of her boy, but that's not a bad thing. I know both the Providence schools and Massachusetts north shore school districts and I found the teachers in the school highly implausible, especially Veronica. The two ladies from the school office are well known to Fran from her own school days. They are eager to gossip with her about the murder and I found that unprofessional of them. Ann Crowsdale seems lovely but she's hardly in the story so I can't say if she's innocent or not.
The recurring characters are hardly in the story. Sammy and Ryan are driving me crazy. Actually it's not them but everyone else's interest in them. If they want to go slow, that's fine. I'm waiting for Matt to propose to Fran though! They seem to be close to living together.
The narrator, Marguerite Gavin, does a fine job for the most part. At one point I thought Mike was speaking when it was another character and at another point she seemed to change her voice completely while speaking as Fran. A little more consistency in editing would be better but I like her voice and hearing her read the story. It sounds especially good with a bluetooth speaker while making Christmas cookies.