Really enjoyed this book! It is somewhat academic in tone, so not for everyone. But the narrative moves quickly and I learned so much.
I have been a DC-area resident on and off since 1984, when I moved there for college. I wish I could have read this book way back then, because it would have provided so much context for the politics that went on in the 80s and 90s. I remember hearing about The Plan, for example, for a white takeover of the city. Well, turns out there actually was a Plan! There had been various Plans for over a century. And while Marion Barry was becoming a cartoon version of a mayor by the time I got there, I now understand better why he inspired so much loyalty in the black community.
I'm a history geek and so I also was fascinated by the chapters regarding the earlier history of the city. I did not know that there was such a thriving free black community there even before the Civil War. The long history of the fight for Home Rule--struggling to get some kind of autonomy from under the thumb of a racist, reactionary Congress--puts so much of the present day into context, and reflects in many ways the story of our country.
When I arrived, crime rates were high and things were looking pretty shabby, but there was also a clear sense that DC was indeed Chocolate City. To me, coming from a southern city myself, it seemed much more normal back then. Since then, the downtown area has become safer, but also glitzy, overcrowded, and unaffordable. As a native of a city that has seen a similar transformation (Nashville) I can completely understand why many residents would feel that is has been a hostile takeover, and particularly in the case of DC, the racial element of the equation simply cannot be ignored. Black communities have simply been shoved aside, over and over again, in the name of redevelopment. This happens in many cities, but was especially pronounced in DC. I was stunned, for example, to learn that Southwest DC once looked pretty much like Capitol Hill. The whole quadrant was simply razed to the ground.
This book will make a lot more sense to anyone who has lived in DC and has a "mental map" of the landscape. If you don't already more or less know the layout of the city, it will be confusing. But for residents, ex-residents, and future residents with Google Maps on hand, it's a must-read.
Also, it's way, WAY past time DC became a state.