The little girl with the pointy ears and curly hair was cute. Not sure what animal she was supposed to be. It was a waste to have the poster on the wall of a dinosaur eating a book, with the caption “Why are books delicious? Because they’re” and have the end disappear behind a student. I wanted to know the answer!
The page of Arthur at his desk was cute. He was writing down parts for the play, because Mr. Ratburn made him the director. There was the turkey and Gov. Bradford. There was a whole trash can full of wadded-up papers he had discarded. His ankles were crossed and his little shoes were so cute.
I didn’t understand the Nip N Tuck brand of milk. I also didn’t understand the problem, because every one of his friends requested a different part. He kept trying to get everyone to be the turkey, but he could have just assigned them to be the parts they wanted to be.
Kids would find it funny the mishaps they had on set. Francine was wearing movie-star glasses and ended up painting someone rather than the display. Buster messed up his lines and said we sailed to America on the cauliflower.
I didn’t understand the problems with their lines. I even read it twice and still couldn’t figure out what was wrong.
“When the Pilgrims and Indians decided to celebrate their friendship,” said Francine, “they began to hunt for a turkey.”
“We cooked beans and pumpkin pies,” whispered Sue Ellen.
“And the Pilgrim men went off to hunt for a turkey.”
“We made corn bread and picked cranberries,” said Muffy. “Oops! And the Indian braves went on their own turkey hunt.”
They can’t refer to the turkey during their rehearsal because Arthur hadn’t found anyone to play that part. He decided to rent a turkey but it wrecked the scene and everyone was mad and threatened to quit if he didn’t fill the part.
Buster was cute standing inside the model of the Mayflower. It was pretty obvious that Arthur would be the turkey, since no one else wanted to be. I felt so bad for him when he came walking out on stage and the audience laughed at him and he turned red. He stuttered on his lines, couldn’t think what the turkey was a symbol of. Until voices behind him said that it is a symbol of togetherness and Thanksgiving. His parent, sister and all of his friends were dressed as turkeys, except Francine who was dressed as a Pilgrim. He realized that his mom was right; the world is full of turkeys. He instructed them to say “Happy Thanksgiving” all together.
This was a pretty good story about Arthur. It wasn’t as long as I would have liked and I expected more from it. I wish there was more words to go with the illustrations, because a lot of it is up in the air. I didn’t know what the girl said “Oops” for when she was running her lines until I read my sister’s review that said she fell. We weren’t told she fell in writing, she was just on the ground in the picture so her saying oops didn’t correspond to her falling, which was a mistake. Also, I’ve noticed the author crams all of the writing together, like having the same character speak on the next line with no indication that it’s the same person speaking. It’s really confusing to keep up with who’s talking. There needed to be a way of separating the dialogue. When Arthur said let’s hear that last line, I thought he wanted everyone to repeat the turkey is a symbol of togetherness and Thanksgiving, but I flipped the page and learned they were saying Happy Thanksgiving, so that was unexpected.
Rather than having the lesson be that everyone is a turkey, which seems to be implying everyone’s silly or something, it should have been hit home that it’s about everyone supporting each other and helping each other out or something, and being thankful for family and friends. It definitely needed more and ended too soon. The play was so incomplete.