The body of a young man is found hanging from Winters Gibbet at dawn, the morning after the local country show. DCI Kate Daniels realises that she recognises him, she saw him only yesterday at the show, in the Cumberland wrestling. Kate is due to leave on a much needed, extended holiday with Jo Soulsby, after the demands of her last case, which led to danger in Spain. Determined to leave this case in a good position for handover, she is stopped in her tracks by the early arrival of her cover DCI James Atkins. He makes his presence felt with all the subtlety of a bull in a China shop and is deliberately provocative. Atkins and Daniels have history, there is much bad blood between them. The attempts of Bright to avoid their presence overlapping was scuppered by Atkins cancelling his rostered days off. Here is a man looking for trouble, will he find it?
The plot is quite straightforward, after determining that it wasn’t suicide there is a search for the killer. The complexity comes from the search amongst a close-knit community with a small number of likely suspects and most alibis interlinking. The real tension starts when Kate discovers that Atkin’s daughter Beth was a witness to a fight involving the victim the night before. The truth will only come out after a lot of questioning of troubled young adults, exposing their problems and fears. Surprises are revealed along the way and this aspect is covered with real sensitivity.
The heart of the novel is a series of clashes, some vociferous and abrasive, others more angst ridden with disappointment and resignation. This is a very emotive and emotional story. Quite simply it’s the past versus the present, the ability to put the events of the past behind you and move on, sometimes requiring some bridge building to do so. But this is career driven Kate, and she never has the time for things like this.
The main dispute, that between Kate and Atkins goes back to when Kate first started in the force, and so has festered for around twenty years. Bright has nurtured Kate’s career and protected her, but one day confrontation was going to come. When it comes it is explosive, angry and abusive leading to soul searching and reflection; will Kate have the heart to carry on?
The stand off relationship Kate has with her father comes to a head at just the wrong time, but when do they ever come at the right time. The trigger comes as a surprise, they are both stubborn but need to compromise if ever there is to be anything like a reconciliation.
Then there is the on-off relationship with Jo. A chance to get things back as they were, with affection rekindled by a holiday in Scotland. Understanding, support, affection, bickering, cold shoulders and cross words are all there, it must be so emotionally tiring being a lesbian.
All of this is skilfully pulled together in the sort of novel that becomes a turning point in a series. It fills in a big chunk of back story in a way that fits perfectly and makes complete sense. There is a fabulously delivered shock added to the story, that has the reader thinking what, wait a minute and a cliffhanger tagged on at the very end. Finish this and you will be desperate to crack on with Without a Trace.
Gallows Drop adds explanations and meaning to the back story of the DCI Kate Daniels series and sets her up with a series of big questions to answer in her immediate future.