What do you think?
Rate this book
Dr. Samantha Willerby Mystery #2
Lost In The Lake
She came at first for answers…now she’s back for you
Amateur viola player Rosie Chandler is the sole survivor of a crash which sends members of a string quartet plunging into a lake. Convinced the ‘accident’ was deliberate, but unable to recall what happened, she is determined to recover her lost memories and seeks out clinical psychologist, Dr Samantha Willerby.
But Rosie is hiding something…
Sam is immediately drawn to the tragic Rosie and as she helps her piece the fragments together, the police find disturbing new evidence which raises further questions. Why is Rosie so desperate to recover her worthless viola? And what happened to the violin lost in the crash, worth over £2m?
When Rosie insists they return to the lake to relive the fatal incident, the truth about Rosie finally creeps up on Sam – but by now, she’s seriously out of her depth…
The second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series, Lost in the Lake is a nail-biting, edge-of-your-seat Psychological Thriller that will leave you glancing over your shoulder.
Pre-Order on Amazon from 13 July 2017
Release date: 7 Sept 2017
Amateur viola player Rosie Chandler is the sole survivor of a crash which sends members of a string quartet plunging into a lake. Convinced the ‘accident’ was deliberate, but unable to recall what happened, she is determined to recover her lost memories and seeks out clinical psychologist, Dr Samantha Willerby.
But Rosie is hiding something…
Sam is immediately drawn to the tragic Rosie and as she helps her piece the fragments together, the police find disturbing new evidence which raises further questions. Why is Rosie so desperate to recover her worthless viola? And what happened to the violin lost in the crash, worth over £2m?
When Rosie insists they return to the lake to relive the fatal incident, the truth about Rosie finally creeps up on Sam – but by now, she’s seriously out of her depth…
The second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series, Lost in the Lake is a nail-biting, edge-of-your-seat Psychological Thriller that will leave you glancing over your shoulder.
Pre-Order on Amazon from 13 July 2017
Release date: 7 Sept 2017
385 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 1, 2017
312 people are currently reading
575 people want to read
About the author
A.J. Waines
11 books481 followersAJ Waines writes Psychological Thrillers with *over half-a-million* copies sold worldwide. She's a #1 International Bestselling Author: GIRL ON A TRAIN topped the full UK and Australian Kindle Charts in 2015 & 2016.
Follow on Facebook, Instagram or AJ's Blog
All her books can be read in any order:
The Evil Beneath, Girl on a Train, Dark Place to Hide, No Longer Safe, Inside the Whispers, Lost in the Lake, Don't you Dare, Perfect Bones, Enemy at the Window, Cut you Dead Find them all at: AJ Waines' Books
Formerly a Psychotherapist for fifteen years, she has worked with ex-offenders from high-security institutions, giving her a rare insight into abnormal psychology. She is fascinated by secrets and lies, crimes of passion, devious motives and anything hidden under floorboards.
*A Kindle (KDP) TOP 10 'MOST-READ AUTHOR' in UK (2016)*
AJ has book deals in UK, France, Germany, Norway, Hungary, Czech Republic and Canada (audiobooks). She lives in Hampshire, UK, with her husband.
Follow on Facebook, Instagram or AJ's Blog
All her books can be read in any order:
The Evil Beneath, Girl on a Train, Dark Place to Hide, No Longer Safe, Inside the Whispers, Lost in the Lake, Don't you Dare, Perfect Bones, Enemy at the Window, Cut you Dead Find them all at: AJ Waines' Books
Formerly a Psychotherapist for fifteen years, she has worked with ex-offenders from high-security institutions, giving her a rare insight into abnormal psychology. She is fascinated by secrets and lies, crimes of passion, devious motives and anything hidden under floorboards.
*A Kindle (KDP) TOP 10 'MOST-READ AUTHOR' in UK (2016)*
AJ has book deals in UK, France, Germany, Norway, Hungary, Czech Republic and Canada (audiobooks). She lives in Hampshire, UK, with her husband.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 78 reviews
March 10, 2021
5 stars again
Yet another fantastic book. Little bit different to the first book in the series, but still brilliant.
Having a Clinical physcologist investigating, is a neat twist. Don't think many writers could pull it off, but Ms Waines does with style.
There were so many clues, but how many are correct? I thought I had it all solved pretty early on, but boy was I wrong. About most of it anyway.
Got to wait a couple of days now for the third installment.
Yet another fantastic book. Little bit different to the first book in the series, but still brilliant.
Having a Clinical physcologist investigating, is a neat twist. Don't think many writers could pull it off, but Ms Waines does with style.
There were so many clues, but how many are correct? I thought I had it all solved pretty early on, but boy was I wrong. About most of it anyway.
Got to wait a couple of days now for the third installment.
October 29, 2021
This book is worth 5 star rating and more,fantastic series the second book it starts Rosie Chandler seeks help from Dr Sam Willerby,Rose survived a crash into a lake with her musicians friends shes the only one that made it out alive.she is trying to find what happened and Sam helps her to remember. Rose has a horrible past and relys on Sam to much....This is a mind blowing story,love to read about how the mind works.fantastic writing from this author looking forward to reading book three.The only slight criticism is the viola didnt think it needed to be part of the storyline.
October 28, 2018
After reading Inside The Whispers which is book one in the Dr. Samantha Willerby series I was really looking forward to reading more from this author. I wasn’t disappointed as I loved this story.
Rosie has a whole heaps of problems but when she’s the sole survivor in a crash she seeks out Dr. Samantha Willerbys help to recover her lost memories.
Like the previous book this is a really well told story. I was hooked from start to finish. The twits and turns kept on coming and I was gripped. Looking forward to reading more from this author.
Rosie has a whole heaps of problems but when she’s the sole survivor in a crash she seeks out Dr. Samantha Willerbys help to recover her lost memories.
Like the previous book this is a really well told story. I was hooked from start to finish. The twits and turns kept on coming and I was gripped. Looking forward to reading more from this author.
September 7, 2017
Lost In The Lake is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series. Even though I think it works fairly well as a stand alone, due to some references to events that happen in the first book, some readers may find it beneficial to read Inside The Whispers, the first book in the series prior to reading this one.
Rosie right from the start the reader knows that not all is right with her. She has had a lot go on in her life, mainly in her childhood and saw things no child should ever have to witness. It has obviously deeply affected Rosie, more than she probably realises. Her more recent accident has her feeling slightly helpless as she can’t remember stuff surrounding the event which is a position she doesn’t like being in.
Sam on the other hand, though wanting to help Rosie, knows that something isn’t quite right. She just can’t put her finger on it though. She knows Rosie is starting to get to dependent on her but Sam’s professional side is determined to see her sessions through with Rosie.
There are a couple of threads running through the story, mainly to do with Rosie but also with Sam trying to build bridges with her sister which are some what strained.
Lost In The Lake is an intriguing read that will hook you from the very start. The intrigue and tension builds up throughout the story so you are sent hurdling to a satisfying end. Really enjoying this series so far and very much look forward to the next book in the series.
My thanks to the author for an advanced readers copy of this book. All opinions are my own and not biased in anyway.
Rosie right from the start the reader knows that not all is right with her. She has had a lot go on in her life, mainly in her childhood and saw things no child should ever have to witness. It has obviously deeply affected Rosie, more than she probably realises. Her more recent accident has her feeling slightly helpless as she can’t remember stuff surrounding the event which is a position she doesn’t like being in.
Sam on the other hand, though wanting to help Rosie, knows that something isn’t quite right. She just can’t put her finger on it though. She knows Rosie is starting to get to dependent on her but Sam’s professional side is determined to see her sessions through with Rosie.
There are a couple of threads running through the story, mainly to do with Rosie but also with Sam trying to build bridges with her sister which are some what strained.
Lost In The Lake is an intriguing read that will hook you from the very start. The intrigue and tension builds up throughout the story so you are sent hurdling to a satisfying end. Really enjoying this series so far and very much look forward to the next book in the series.
My thanks to the author for an advanced readers copy of this book. All opinions are my own and not biased in anyway.
September 7, 2017
It wasn't until I finished the book that I realized that this was book two in a series. Yes, I have a short memory, but in this case did I not read up on the book before I started the book. The less I know about the book the better, and since I had forgotten what the book was about (lots of book in my head, hard to keep track on them all) did I start to read this book without having a clue about the story. And, I loved not knowing a thing about the story nor its characters. I was intrigued by the story, sure right from the start did I mistrust Rosie and I was worried about Sam who after an incident the year before with a patient was vulnerable. And, Rosie, her behavior through the book was very suspicious.
Lost In The Lake is a great book, I loved reading about Sam and her troubled relationship with her sisters and how Rosie started to insinuate herself into Sam's life. And, then we have the mystery with the accident when all people in the car drowned except Rosie, was it really an accident?
Now I'm quite eager to read the first book in the series and I'm looking forward to the next one after this one!
I want to thank the author for granting me a copy of this book for an honest review!
Lost In The Lake is a great book, I loved reading about Sam and her troubled relationship with her sisters and how Rosie started to insinuate herself into Sam's life. And, then we have the mystery with the accident when all people in the car drowned except Rosie, was it really an accident?
Now I'm quite eager to read the first book in the series and I'm looking forward to the next one after this one!
I want to thank the author for granting me a copy of this book for an honest review!
Read
October 10, 2018Lost in the Lake is a twisty tale of deception, jealousy, loneliness and the craving to belong: a tangled Murder Mystery on the surface and a sinister Psychological Thriller underneath.
For the ‘mystery’ part of Lost in the Lake I had to investigate what happens when a small clapped-out van hits deep water and how you escape when it’s sinking fast. My research brought up some surprises, I can tell you, and a word of warning – it’s not for the faint hearted!
Firstly, as soon as a vehicle hits the water and starts sinking, there’s no way you can get the doors open. This is because the pressure inside and outside is uneven until the interior has completely filled with water and the pressure has equalised. In other words, you have to wait until the car hits the bottom of the lake and is totally submerged before you can get a door open. If you try before then, you’re completely wasting valuable breath…
Once a vehicle has hit the water it usually takes between two and ten minutes for it to sink. This can happen faster, depending on the speed, angle of entry and the physical characteristics of the vehicle. So, if you can’t open the doors, what about the windows? Crucial to my story was whether the windows had winders or were electronic and I needed to know what effect the water would have on the electrics.
During my research, I came across a first-hand account of a driver who re-entered a submerged car through an open side window to retrieve his wallet. While he was inside trying to find it, the window automatically went up, the doors locked, the power shut off and he was trapped inside the car. Terrifying! The lesson being, that in most situations, the electrical system inside the car goes haywire after full submersion. That involves the central locking, windows and sun roof.
It’s worth remembering, though, that many cars have window winders in the back and central locking in the front. The vehicle in Lost in the Lake, however, is one of those small delivery vans with windows only at the front and glass panels in the back doors. In that case, if the windows lock, how on earth do you get out? My main character, Rosie, manages it somehow. She thinks she’s the only survivor…but is she?
Other amazing facts I learnt:
· You can’t break a window by kicking it even if you’re fighting for your life. You might kick so hard that the steel window frame bends out a fraction, but the glass won’t break.
· As a rule of thumb, when travelling near a large body of water, it’s advisable to crack open your window a fraction and, if the worst happens, open it fully as soon as you hit the water, before the electrics short out. This allows the water to come in and equalize the pressure faster, even if you can’t climb out that way. It will mean you can get the doors open quicker.
· Airbags need a collision force equal to running into a brick wall at 10 to 15 miles per hour to activate. Water cushions the blow in a crash into water, so airbags don’t deploy. I didn’t realise this!
I always find research for stories fascinating and an exciting outcome is that it invariably throws up new angles for the plot!
For the ‘mystery’ part of Lost in the Lake I had to investigate what happens when a small clapped-out van hits deep water and how you escape when it’s sinking fast. My research brought up some surprises, I can tell you, and a word of warning – it’s not for the faint hearted!
Firstly, as soon as a vehicle hits the water and starts sinking, there’s no way you can get the doors open. This is because the pressure inside and outside is uneven until the interior has completely filled with water and the pressure has equalised. In other words, you have to wait until the car hits the bottom of the lake and is totally submerged before you can get a door open. If you try before then, you’re completely wasting valuable breath…
Once a vehicle has hit the water it usually takes between two and ten minutes for it to sink. This can happen faster, depending on the speed, angle of entry and the physical characteristics of the vehicle. So, if you can’t open the doors, what about the windows? Crucial to my story was whether the windows had winders or were electronic and I needed to know what effect the water would have on the electrics.
During my research, I came across a first-hand account of a driver who re-entered a submerged car through an open side window to retrieve his wallet. While he was inside trying to find it, the window automatically went up, the doors locked, the power shut off and he was trapped inside the car. Terrifying! The lesson being, that in most situations, the electrical system inside the car goes haywire after full submersion. That involves the central locking, windows and sun roof.
It’s worth remembering, though, that many cars have window winders in the back and central locking in the front. The vehicle in Lost in the Lake, however, is one of those small delivery vans with windows only at the front and glass panels in the back doors. In that case, if the windows lock, how on earth do you get out? My main character, Rosie, manages it somehow. She thinks she’s the only survivor…but is she?
Other amazing facts I learnt:
· You can’t break a window by kicking it even if you’re fighting for your life. You might kick so hard that the steel window frame bends out a fraction, but the glass won’t break.
· As a rule of thumb, when travelling near a large body of water, it’s advisable to crack open your window a fraction and, if the worst happens, open it fully as soon as you hit the water, before the electrics short out. This allows the water to come in and equalize the pressure faster, even if you can’t climb out that way. It will mean you can get the doors open quicker.
· Airbags need a collision force equal to running into a brick wall at 10 to 15 miles per hour to activate. Water cushions the blow in a crash into water, so airbags don’t deploy. I didn’t realise this!
I always find research for stories fascinating and an exciting outcome is that it invariably throws up new angles for the plot!
September 12, 2017
Last year I was introduced to Dr Samantha Willerby in 'Inside the Whispers', a fabulous psychological thriller and the first in the series by A.J. Waines. I had really enjoyed that book and still remember much of its plot, so I was thrilled when the author offered me an ARC of the second one, Lost in the Lake. Needless to say, I immediately fell in love with the beautiful cover, and the blurb was just too intriguing not to accept. Now that I've finished it, all I can say is WOW!! What a chiller!! This is even better than the first one!
Trauma expert and clinical psychologist Dr Samantha Willerby (Sam) has a new patient. Rosie Chandler has nearly died in a recent horrific accident. Member of a string quartet, she was a passenger in the back of a van when it veered off the road and ended up in the bottom of a lake. She managed to resurface, but sadly, to date, the other three occupants, together with a priceless violin and Rosie's beloved viola are still missing.
But Rosie is not here to deal with any trauma... she's erm... okay... emotionally. She just wants Sam to help her remember what truly happened during the accident. She has gaps in her memory of that day she's desperate to fill in. She's sure that what had almost killed her was not an accident at all, but that someone intentionally made it happen. But who? And why?
Well Alison Waines has done it again. Though second in a series, 'Lost in the Lake' can be read as a standalone. It is a brilliant character-driven, suspenseful thriller with overwhelming obsession and malice at its centre. It's one of those books that once you read the first page, you just have to keep on reading. The more the story progresses, the more disturbing and claustrophobic it becomes. Sam is a professional woman that knows her boundaries well when dealing with patients, but against her better judgement, something in Rosie convinces her to relax a bit the strict rules she normally adheres to. Added to her recent trauma, it's evident that the woman has endured a horrible, tragic childhood. Sam wants to help her, but with every session Rosie becomes more needy, clingy and desperate to please, to be accepted and loved. She wants Sam to help her find out what happened in the lake, but there's definitely something odd about Rosie. Is she truly the innocent, unfortunate soul she gives the impression to be? What is her true intention? What had really happened in the lake? How come she seems to be the sole survivor? Was it pure luck? Or something else?
Rosie just blew my mind. She's one of the most intense characters I've come across in all the books I've read. Even though Sam is the main character in this book, it's as though she's overshadowed by Rosie's strong presence. The chapters from her pov are just creepy and made me feel uneasy. I didn't know whether to like her or not, whether to believe her or not, whether to feel sorry for her or not. At times I wanted to slap her and at others I wished I could cradle her and make all her pain go away. But you just have to keep one eye always open when Rosie is in the same room. I wasn't sure of her true motive. What was she after in reality? What I was certain of was that little by little, Sam was getting herself into a very dangerous situation. Will Sam come out of this in one piece? And Rosie? What about her? Will the mystery of the lake ever be solved? And what is Sam's other chronic problem, her schizophrenic sister, Miranda, up to behind her back? If this were a movie, I would have surely covered my eyes during that final heart-pounding part.
I really had a great time reading this fabulous chiller and now I can't wait for the next one in the series. I highly recommend it as I'm sure all readers will enjoy it as much as I did. With thanks to the author for an ARC of this book which I voluntarily accepted to read and review.
Trauma expert and clinical psychologist Dr Samantha Willerby (Sam) has a new patient. Rosie Chandler has nearly died in a recent horrific accident. Member of a string quartet, she was a passenger in the back of a van when it veered off the road and ended up in the bottom of a lake. She managed to resurface, but sadly, to date, the other three occupants, together with a priceless violin and Rosie's beloved viola are still missing.
But Rosie is not here to deal with any trauma... she's erm... okay... emotionally. She just wants Sam to help her remember what truly happened during the accident. She has gaps in her memory of that day she's desperate to fill in. She's sure that what had almost killed her was not an accident at all, but that someone intentionally made it happen. But who? And why?
Well Alison Waines has done it again. Though second in a series, 'Lost in the Lake' can be read as a standalone. It is a brilliant character-driven, suspenseful thriller with overwhelming obsession and malice at its centre. It's one of those books that once you read the first page, you just have to keep on reading. The more the story progresses, the more disturbing and claustrophobic it becomes. Sam is a professional woman that knows her boundaries well when dealing with patients, but against her better judgement, something in Rosie convinces her to relax a bit the strict rules she normally adheres to. Added to her recent trauma, it's evident that the woman has endured a horrible, tragic childhood. Sam wants to help her, but with every session Rosie becomes more needy, clingy and desperate to please, to be accepted and loved. She wants Sam to help her find out what happened in the lake, but there's definitely something odd about Rosie. Is she truly the innocent, unfortunate soul she gives the impression to be? What is her true intention? What had really happened in the lake? How come she seems to be the sole survivor? Was it pure luck? Or something else?
Rosie just blew my mind. She's one of the most intense characters I've come across in all the books I've read. Even though Sam is the main character in this book, it's as though she's overshadowed by Rosie's strong presence. The chapters from her pov are just creepy and made me feel uneasy. I didn't know whether to like her or not, whether to believe her or not, whether to feel sorry for her or not. At times I wanted to slap her and at others I wished I could cradle her and make all her pain go away. But you just have to keep one eye always open when Rosie is in the same room. I wasn't sure of her true motive. What was she after in reality? What I was certain of was that little by little, Sam was getting herself into a very dangerous situation. Will Sam come out of this in one piece? And Rosie? What about her? Will the mystery of the lake ever be solved? And what is Sam's other chronic problem, her schizophrenic sister, Miranda, up to behind her back? If this were a movie, I would have surely covered my eyes during that final heart-pounding part.
I really had a great time reading this fabulous chiller and now I can't wait for the next one in the series. I highly recommend it as I'm sure all readers will enjoy it as much as I did. With thanks to the author for an ARC of this book which I voluntarily accepted to read and review.
September 7, 2017
This is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series but I will start by saying that this book works well as a standalone. There are a few flashbacks to events that happened in the first book but there is never a feeling of missing out.
Samantha has a new client here in the shape of Rosie, who is the only survivor of an horrific car crash. The scenes where Rosie was trapped in a car sinking under the water of the lake were absolutely terrifying! For many people the fear of crashing into deep water is a nightmare scenario and here it’s brought realistically to life by an intense and disturbing account of how Rosie reacts to her near death experience. But when Rosie does start to open up to psychologist Sam, her story doesn’t quite add up. Her memory of the accident is very hazy and she seems obsessed with finding her viola. It also starts to become clear that she has a very disturbed past and Sam will need to be careful of she wants to help Rosie.
I always felt like Sam was a closed book here until she got really passionate about something and then everything came pouring out of her like hot lava flowing from a volcano! Her family life is complicated and she sometimes let’s her emotions get in the way of the path she knows she should take, but I still liked her! The aftermath of her previous case has obviously had more of an affect on the way she handles herself at work than she realises and I liked watching her handle her patients with a little more caution this time.
AJ Waines writes a fabulously twisted mystery here where I totally missed all the clues as to where it was heading, so caught up was I in the toxic relationship between client and therapist. I was gripped by their cat and mouse game with Rosie proving to be a stronger adversary than Sam had expected.
Overall I enjoyed this latest instalment in the series and look forward to meeting Sam again in book 3 which is out later in the year.
Samantha has a new client here in the shape of Rosie, who is the only survivor of an horrific car crash. The scenes where Rosie was trapped in a car sinking under the water of the lake were absolutely terrifying! For many people the fear of crashing into deep water is a nightmare scenario and here it’s brought realistically to life by an intense and disturbing account of how Rosie reacts to her near death experience. But when Rosie does start to open up to psychologist Sam, her story doesn’t quite add up. Her memory of the accident is very hazy and she seems obsessed with finding her viola. It also starts to become clear that she has a very disturbed past and Sam will need to be careful of she wants to help Rosie.
I always felt like Sam was a closed book here until she got really passionate about something and then everything came pouring out of her like hot lava flowing from a volcano! Her family life is complicated and she sometimes let’s her emotions get in the way of the path she knows she should take, but I still liked her! The aftermath of her previous case has obviously had more of an affect on the way she handles herself at work than she realises and I liked watching her handle her patients with a little more caution this time.
AJ Waines writes a fabulously twisted mystery here where I totally missed all the clues as to where it was heading, so caught up was I in the toxic relationship between client and therapist. I was gripped by their cat and mouse game with Rosie proving to be a stronger adversary than Sam had expected.
Overall I enjoyed this latest instalment in the series and look forward to meeting Sam again in book 3 which is out later in the year.
September 18, 2017
Having read and enjoyed the first book in this series I was looking forward to reading the second. Dr Samanatha Willerby is our leading lady and as much as I do like her as a character she also irritates me a little. Although that sounds like a negative I have found that with the storylines it actually works as a positive. Samantha can sometimes come across as a bit ‘wishy-washy’ but I think deep down it‘s just her trusting good nature. Maybe her naïvety at certain things worked in her favour as it didn’t put me off (if that makes sense). Rosie Chandler was the victim of an awful accident where she was the only survivor. When she has therapy with Sam the aim is to uncover missing pieces of that day.
Sam is drawn to Rosie and becomes more and more involved. Before Sam realizes it transpires that there is a lot more going on and she needs to uncover what or who is telling the truth. In addition to this storyline Samantha’s sister is featured after a fleeting introduction in book 1. I think AJ Waines has a real knack for characters and this is most definitely a major plus. The character Rosie was so intriguing and at times although you couldn’t help but feel sorry for her, at the same there is a horrible realization that she could be a little bit unhinged!
There is also a certain creepiness to this book because I think as a reader you question everything. Because the story is told from both Sam and Rosie’s POV, it’s easy to take favour with the character you are reading about. The story held my attention and I think this was most certainly a very enjoyable psychological thriller. Another cracking read by AJ Waines and I will certainly look out for the next book.
Sam is drawn to Rosie and becomes more and more involved. Before Sam realizes it transpires that there is a lot more going on and she needs to uncover what or who is telling the truth. In addition to this storyline Samantha’s sister is featured after a fleeting introduction in book 1. I think AJ Waines has a real knack for characters and this is most definitely a major plus. The character Rosie was so intriguing and at times although you couldn’t help but feel sorry for her, at the same there is a horrible realization that she could be a little bit unhinged!
There is also a certain creepiness to this book because I think as a reader you question everything. Because the story is told from both Sam and Rosie’s POV, it’s easy to take favour with the character you are reading about. The story held my attention and I think this was most certainly a very enjoyable psychological thriller. Another cracking read by AJ Waines and I will certainly look out for the next book.
October 27, 2018
This was a good read. I read it a few months ago. It took many sittings to finish the book. I loved Samantha, but I didn’t like the others.
The author did a very good job in keeping me confused with the versions of the truth. So I loved the plot. For me, it was a good read but not a very memorable one.
The author did a very good job in keeping me confused with the versions of the truth. So I loved the plot. For me, it was a good read but not a very memorable one.
October 17, 2018
This is book two in a series, and after reading book one I was looking forward to seeing how the character of clinical psychologist Dr. Samantha Willerby would develop. I was gripped right from the start and the tension builds up nicely throughout the book until it reaches fever pitch. I will definitely be reading the next book in the series.
September 7, 2017
I would like to thank AJ Waines for an ARC of this book which I chose to read and review, offering my unbiased opinion.
AJ Waines never fails to disappoint me with her psychological thrillers. Lost in the Lake ticked every box for me and I was thrilled once again to be caught off guard.
The story mainly takes place in London, although there are some references to the Lake District. Loneliness, loss, low self esteem, desperation, obsession, fear, guilt, anger, mistrust, crossed boundaries, distorted relationships and a search for the truth can all be found within the pages of this book.
The author had me from the prologue – reeled in instantly by the #killerhook, I knew I was in for a disturbing ride. The story is told from two people’s point of view: Sam Willerby (a Clinical Psychologist) and her patient Rosie. Each character is in first person POV and this was well written. It easily flowed and you knew exactly who’s point of view you were reading. As with all of this author’s previous books, I was kept guessing all the way throughout. I love AJ Waines’ writing style and the narrative is tight, enthralling and very believeable. Having a background in psychotherapy herself, it is clear the author knows exactly what elements would make a great thriller.
Character-wise, we meet Sam Willerby again (this is the second book of the series) and she is once again faced with a challenging case. She is an early riser, likes a TO DO list and…wait, I could be describing myself here! Maybe she is my doppleganger in the fictional world – just much smarter, and probably thinner….boo….Ok, seriously, I love her character! She frustrates the hell out of me as she can be just TOO nice at times and perhaps a little too trusting given her profession. But she wants to help people, so we can forgive her these traits – as she soon smartens up when she realises she may be being manipulated. Sam can be very self-critical and easily points out her own flaws, so there is no need for the reader to jump on board. She is relatable, and this is why I like her so much.
“Sometimes the truth doesn’t set you free”
Let’s talk about Rosie. There is no doubt she suffered a trauma which brings her to Sam in the first place – but this gal had problems before….oh yeah, probably an understatement. Rosie is narcissitic, needy, manipulative and damaged. At times I really liked her character, and at other times, I really despised her. I also felt sorry for her, until I realised I too was being drawn into her lies and delusions. What a fabulously written character.
We are introduced to Sam’s sister, Miranda in the first book Inside The Whispers so I was pleased to see her making an appearance again. Miranda has a child-like quality to her which frustrates Sam – and their relationship is not an easy one. I suspect, however, that a part of Sam wishes she could be as free-spirited as Miranda. But she sure does not make things easy on herself and I was a little pissed off to say the least – *no spoilers* though. But OMFG! Why Miranda….why!?
Needless to say, I could go on and include other characters who added to this story- but I have to leave some things for you to find out yourselves! I absolutely adore the psychological focus of this author’s books and turn each page in eager anticipation of the next WTAF moment I know I will be getting! After No Longer Safe AJ Waines has become a firm favourite author for me in terms of psych-thrillers that mess with my head. It doesn’t matter how much I think I know – she always knocks me for six!
The question is, do I recommend Lost In The Lake? Erm – that would be a most obvious Hell Yeah! If you are looking for an emotive, intense, catch-your-breath kind of read – look no further!
AJ Waines never fails to disappoint me with her psychological thrillers. Lost in the Lake ticked every box for me and I was thrilled once again to be caught off guard.
The story mainly takes place in London, although there are some references to the Lake District. Loneliness, loss, low self esteem, desperation, obsession, fear, guilt, anger, mistrust, crossed boundaries, distorted relationships and a search for the truth can all be found within the pages of this book.
The author had me from the prologue – reeled in instantly by the #killerhook, I knew I was in for a disturbing ride. The story is told from two people’s point of view: Sam Willerby (a Clinical Psychologist) and her patient Rosie. Each character is in first person POV and this was well written. It easily flowed and you knew exactly who’s point of view you were reading. As with all of this author’s previous books, I was kept guessing all the way throughout. I love AJ Waines’ writing style and the narrative is tight, enthralling and very believeable. Having a background in psychotherapy herself, it is clear the author knows exactly what elements would make a great thriller.
Character-wise, we meet Sam Willerby again (this is the second book of the series) and she is once again faced with a challenging case. She is an early riser, likes a TO DO list and…wait, I could be describing myself here! Maybe she is my doppleganger in the fictional world – just much smarter, and probably thinner….boo….Ok, seriously, I love her character! She frustrates the hell out of me as she can be just TOO nice at times and perhaps a little too trusting given her profession. But she wants to help people, so we can forgive her these traits – as she soon smartens up when she realises she may be being manipulated. Sam can be very self-critical and easily points out her own flaws, so there is no need for the reader to jump on board. She is relatable, and this is why I like her so much.
“Sometimes the truth doesn’t set you free”
Let’s talk about Rosie. There is no doubt she suffered a trauma which brings her to Sam in the first place – but this gal had problems before….oh yeah, probably an understatement. Rosie is narcissitic, needy, manipulative and damaged. At times I really liked her character, and at other times, I really despised her. I also felt sorry for her, until I realised I too was being drawn into her lies and delusions. What a fabulously written character.
We are introduced to Sam’s sister, Miranda in the first book Inside The Whispers so I was pleased to see her making an appearance again. Miranda has a child-like quality to her which frustrates Sam – and their relationship is not an easy one. I suspect, however, that a part of Sam wishes she could be as free-spirited as Miranda. But she sure does not make things easy on herself and I was a little pissed off to say the least – *no spoilers* though. But OMFG! Why Miranda….why!?
Needless to say, I could go on and include other characters who added to this story- but I have to leave some things for you to find out yourselves! I absolutely adore the psychological focus of this author’s books and turn each page in eager anticipation of the next WTAF moment I know I will be getting! After No Longer Safe AJ Waines has become a firm favourite author for me in terms of psych-thrillers that mess with my head. It doesn’t matter how much I think I know – she always knocks me for six!
The question is, do I recommend Lost In The Lake? Erm – that would be a most obvious Hell Yeah! If you are looking for an emotive, intense, catch-your-breath kind of read – look no further!
September 10, 2017
This psychological thriller is centred round one of my favourite premises, memory loss and psychotherapist, A.J. Waines, has enough knowledge about the subject to ensure that this tale rings true.
Rosie was in a terrible accident. So awful that she is the only survivor of the crash that saw the van she was travelling in plunge into a lake. Rosie was lucky, grabbing her viola she swam to shore but she needs to know what happened to the other members of the string quartet, and as of yet, no one can tell her. Rosie and the rest of the quartet had been offered pay over the odds to play at an anniversary party a decade after they’d first played for the couple, the difference is that then they were playing together regularly but these days they are all leading very different lives.
This is the first book I’ve read by this author, although this is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series, and it is the good doctor that Rosie turns to in a bid to recover the memories she knows are missing. It is clear that the author’s background has leant a real air of truth to the engagement between the good doctor and her patient. With Rosie convinced that if she can recover her memories all will be well, the doctor agrees to help her with the latest research methods which later include travelling to the scene of the crash.
From this synopsis it may appear that this is a straightforward piece of crime fiction albeit one with a clinical psychologist at the heart of the investigation rather than the story being told from the police’s viewpoint, but the dynamic between Rosie and Sam really adds a totally different dimension to the story.
With the chapters alternating between the two women with an overlap of part of their experiences I was both dumbstruck and totally involved in both women’s stories. Trying to sift through Rosie’s memories and her recall of the first party they played certainly gives the reader plenty to ponder over; exactly my kind of crime fiction.
I am pleased to confirm that I didn’t feel that my enjoyment was at all hampered by not reading the first book in the series as the author provided enough of the back story to fill in any gaps but cleverly despite hints, not enough to put me off going back to discover Inside the Whispers.
My favourite type of psychological thriller is those books that truly explore the crevices of the mind and it is brilliant that it isn’t only the patient in this book that gets that treatment; the doctor is unveiled not only as someone who cares greatly about her patients but one who doesn’t necessarily like them all, and in common with the vast majority of humanity, she can still be unnerved by unexpected behaviour. Isn't it wonderful when the characters are both intriguing and yet completely believable? All this resulted in a fascinating as well as thrilling read with enough twists and turns to keep this reader firmly on her toes.
Rosie was in a terrible accident. So awful that she is the only survivor of the crash that saw the van she was travelling in plunge into a lake. Rosie was lucky, grabbing her viola she swam to shore but she needs to know what happened to the other members of the string quartet, and as of yet, no one can tell her. Rosie and the rest of the quartet had been offered pay over the odds to play at an anniversary party a decade after they’d first played for the couple, the difference is that then they were playing together regularly but these days they are all leading very different lives.
This is the first book I’ve read by this author, although this is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series, and it is the good doctor that Rosie turns to in a bid to recover the memories she knows are missing. It is clear that the author’s background has leant a real air of truth to the engagement between the good doctor and her patient. With Rosie convinced that if she can recover her memories all will be well, the doctor agrees to help her with the latest research methods which later include travelling to the scene of the crash.
From this synopsis it may appear that this is a straightforward piece of crime fiction albeit one with a clinical psychologist at the heart of the investigation rather than the story being told from the police’s viewpoint, but the dynamic between Rosie and Sam really adds a totally different dimension to the story.
With the chapters alternating between the two women with an overlap of part of their experiences I was both dumbstruck and totally involved in both women’s stories. Trying to sift through Rosie’s memories and her recall of the first party they played certainly gives the reader plenty to ponder over; exactly my kind of crime fiction.
I am pleased to confirm that I didn’t feel that my enjoyment was at all hampered by not reading the first book in the series as the author provided enough of the back story to fill in any gaps but cleverly despite hints, not enough to put me off going back to discover Inside the Whispers.
My favourite type of psychological thriller is those books that truly explore the crevices of the mind and it is brilliant that it isn’t only the patient in this book that gets that treatment; the doctor is unveiled not only as someone who cares greatly about her patients but one who doesn’t necessarily like them all, and in common with the vast majority of humanity, she can still be unnerved by unexpected behaviour. Isn't it wonderful when the characters are both intriguing and yet completely believable? All this resulted in a fascinating as well as thrilling read with enough twists and turns to keep this reader firmly on her toes.
September 7, 2017
This is the second outing for Dr. Samantha Willerby and it just confirmed in my mind that someone who wants to be a clinical psychologist is just pure crazy. Yes ok they help people to deal with every day struggles, which is brilliant but then ……….. well read for yourself as to see what I mean.
A quartet are on their way to perform at a 25th wedding anniversary but Rosie, who is bouncing around in the back of the van and not wearing a seat belt feels that there is something very wrong. Before she really has time to think the van has plunged in the water and she is fighting to save her life, then nothing as she blanks out.
Rosie is the only survivor of this horrendous crash and has no really memory of events surrounding it so she is referred to Samantha Willerby, a clinical psychologist who becomes fascinated with the case. The story is then told through alternating chapters between these two main characters and how they see the relationship between them develop besides finding out about the crash.
This is a tense and edgy story from the start but oh my take one unstable young lady and a psychologist that has issues herself from the previous case and you have a belter. It was intriguing to be in the mind of both of these women both seeing the relationship very differently. There is far more to Rosie than the crash as Sam delves back further into her childhood years. Rules are broken and confidences shattered.
There is a gradual build as the story of both women unfolds and at times it feels like you are walking on egg shells where the slightest crack will have devastating results and oops there it goes!
I wish to thank the author for an ARC of this book which I have reviewed honestly
A quartet are on their way to perform at a 25th wedding anniversary but Rosie, who is bouncing around in the back of the van and not wearing a seat belt feels that there is something very wrong. Before she really has time to think the van has plunged in the water and she is fighting to save her life, then nothing as she blanks out.
Rosie is the only survivor of this horrendous crash and has no really memory of events surrounding it so she is referred to Samantha Willerby, a clinical psychologist who becomes fascinated with the case. The story is then told through alternating chapters between these two main characters and how they see the relationship between them develop besides finding out about the crash.
This is a tense and edgy story from the start but oh my take one unstable young lady and a psychologist that has issues herself from the previous case and you have a belter. It was intriguing to be in the mind of both of these women both seeing the relationship very differently. There is far more to Rosie than the crash as Sam delves back further into her childhood years. Rules are broken and confidences shattered.
There is a gradual build as the story of both women unfolds and at times it feels like you are walking on egg shells where the slightest crack will have devastating results and oops there it goes!
I wish to thank the author for an ARC of this book which I have reviewed honestly
October 29, 2018
https://donnasbookblog.wordpress.com/...
I loved the plot for this book and I thought that the lead character was great, I have really enjoyed getting to know more about her character, background, and way of thinking.
This is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series and I am thoroughly enjoying the series – I am already looking forward to reading the third book!
I do love a good psychological thriller and this was definitely one that had me guessing and intrigued from the outset – and I have to say that the cover is fabulous and really suits the book too!
This books is fine to read as a stand alone but it does mention at times the storyline from the first book, so if you are planning on reading the full series, I’d recommend that you start with Inside The Whispers (which I also enjoyed).
Four stars from me for this one – a thoroughly enjoyable read!
I loved the plot for this book and I thought that the lead character was great, I have really enjoyed getting to know more about her character, background, and way of thinking.
This is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series and I am thoroughly enjoying the series – I am already looking forward to reading the third book!
I do love a good psychological thriller and this was definitely one that had me guessing and intrigued from the outset – and I have to say that the cover is fabulous and really suits the book too!
This books is fine to read as a stand alone but it does mention at times the storyline from the first book, so if you are planning on reading the full series, I’d recommend that you start with Inside The Whispers (which I also enjoyed).
Four stars from me for this one – a thoroughly enjoyable read!
September 27, 2017
I'm a huge fan of author A.J. Waines so I was absolutely thrilled when she asked me to take read an ARC of her latest book Lost in the Lake.
This is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series but don't worry if you haven't read Inside The Whispers (Book One in the series) as the author has neatly given past events references so it can easily be read as a standalone, but it's always a good excuse to buy another book though right?
Rosie Chandler was involved in an accident and as far as she knows, she is the sole survivor. She can remember some of the events leading up to the accident, but she is desperate to fill in the gaps as she's starting to suspect that the crash she was involved in wasn't an accident at all. With her fellow passengers missing, presumed dead, she turns to clinical psychologist Sam Willerby to help her find the answers.
Sam is still reeling from her last case where she strongly believes she let her patient down so when she meets Rosie she's determined not to let her down. After a few sessions with Rosie, however, Sam starts to have suspicions about Rosie's story but her mind keeps going back to her previous patient and she soon finds herself overcompensating and allows Rosie to edge closer and closer to the patient/doctor boundary.
It's clear that Rosie has had a troubled life and it's not just the accident that is affecting her, she is definitely a girl with issues and the more Sam meets with her, the more uncomfortable she feels but she wants to do her job and help Rosie regain her memory of the accident, end their sessions and recommend someone else who can help Rosie with her other problems. What she doesn't know is that Rosie has other idea's and she has no intention of letting Sam pass her onto yet another shrink!
Told in alternating chapters from both Sam and Rosie's point of view you can see exactly which direction each character wants to take but the two women have different end goals and it makes for compelling reading. Rosie is obviously lying about things but how is Sam going to find out the truth?
Reading Lost in the Lake is like riding a roller coaster in the dark, you know that there are going to be highs and lows, but you never know when to expect them, how high or low they're going to be or how they're going to make you feel. One thing that is for sure though, is that it will leave you shaken. AJ Waines has a background in psychotherapy and I think it gives her the edge in getting inside her characters heads and making them believable to the reader without ever seeming far-fetched. This is a book that had my heart racing at times and I can't wait to read the next installment. If you don't have any books by AJ Waines on your bookshelf and you love psychological thrillers, then this is the author you need to check out, she's one of the best in the genre!
This is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby series but don't worry if you haven't read Inside The Whispers (Book One in the series) as the author has neatly given past events references so it can easily be read as a standalone, but it's always a good excuse to buy another book though right?
Rosie Chandler was involved in an accident and as far as she knows, she is the sole survivor. She can remember some of the events leading up to the accident, but she is desperate to fill in the gaps as she's starting to suspect that the crash she was involved in wasn't an accident at all. With her fellow passengers missing, presumed dead, she turns to clinical psychologist Sam Willerby to help her find the answers.
Sam is still reeling from her last case where she strongly believes she let her patient down so when she meets Rosie she's determined not to let her down. After a few sessions with Rosie, however, Sam starts to have suspicions about Rosie's story but her mind keeps going back to her previous patient and she soon finds herself overcompensating and allows Rosie to edge closer and closer to the patient/doctor boundary.
It's clear that Rosie has had a troubled life and it's not just the accident that is affecting her, she is definitely a girl with issues and the more Sam meets with her, the more uncomfortable she feels but she wants to do her job and help Rosie regain her memory of the accident, end their sessions and recommend someone else who can help Rosie with her other problems. What she doesn't know is that Rosie has other idea's and she has no intention of letting Sam pass her onto yet another shrink!
Told in alternating chapters from both Sam and Rosie's point of view you can see exactly which direction each character wants to take but the two women have different end goals and it makes for compelling reading. Rosie is obviously lying about things but how is Sam going to find out the truth?
Reading Lost in the Lake is like riding a roller coaster in the dark, you know that there are going to be highs and lows, but you never know when to expect them, how high or low they're going to be or how they're going to make you feel. One thing that is for sure though, is that it will leave you shaken. AJ Waines has a background in psychotherapy and I think it gives her the edge in getting inside her characters heads and making them believable to the reader without ever seeming far-fetched. This is a book that had my heart racing at times and I can't wait to read the next installment. If you don't have any books by AJ Waines on your bookshelf and you love psychological thrillers, then this is the author you need to check out, she's one of the best in the genre!
September 13, 2017
I hadn’t yet read anything by A J Waines but had seen many favourable and positive reviews of previous books and when I was invited to take part in the blog tour for Lost in the Lake, I didn’t hesitate.
Lost in the Lake is book #2 in the Sam Willerby series but can easily be read as a standalone.
When Rosie Chandler, the survivor of a car crash goes to see clinical psychologist, Dr Samantha Willerby it is on the premise that she wants to regain her lost memories of the accident. Rosie was a passenger in the car which went off the road and into a lake. Her fellow passengers have yet to be found and Rosie is convinced that the crash was not an accident but is unable to remember anything.
Memory recall is an area that Sam Willerby specialises in and during their therapy sessions she gradually takes Rosie through each stage of her journey however it seems that Rosie has secrets she doesn’t want to reveal, even to Sam.
This was an intriguing and suspenseful read told from both the perspectives of Sam and Rosie. There was one particular event – quite insignificant if you weren’t paying attention but which I just KNEW would would have repercussions and I was waiting for the penny to drop. Rosie seemed to be the most unstable of characters whose personality changed depending on who she was with. She veered from being clingy and vulnerable to manipulative and at times, downright devious. She was certainly a troubled soul for reasons which later become clear. Although I could feel some sympathy for her, I didn’t trust her at all and all through the book I was trying to work out which part of her story was the truth or a lie.
Despite being a medical professional, Sam turns detective in her quest to help Rosie and becomes as keen as Rosie to know what really happened. Against this backdrop, Sam is also having issues with her own sister Miranda. They have never been particularly close but Miranda has become secretive and Sam, being the older sister is worried. Their relationship would presumably have been more fully explained in book #1 however there was enough history given here to give the reader an idea of the complex relationship between the two sisters.
As the story unfolds the tension increases and the various strands come together and lead to a chilling finale. I have mixed feelings about Sam. I thought she was perhaps a little too gullible at times for someone experienced in her profession and I admit that there were times when I became frustrated with her however I was interested enough to know more about her and will be catching up with the first book.
Lost in the Lake is book #2 in the Sam Willerby series but can easily be read as a standalone.
When Rosie Chandler, the survivor of a car crash goes to see clinical psychologist, Dr Samantha Willerby it is on the premise that she wants to regain her lost memories of the accident. Rosie was a passenger in the car which went off the road and into a lake. Her fellow passengers have yet to be found and Rosie is convinced that the crash was not an accident but is unable to remember anything.
Memory recall is an area that Sam Willerby specialises in and during their therapy sessions she gradually takes Rosie through each stage of her journey however it seems that Rosie has secrets she doesn’t want to reveal, even to Sam.
This was an intriguing and suspenseful read told from both the perspectives of Sam and Rosie. There was one particular event – quite insignificant if you weren’t paying attention but which I just KNEW would would have repercussions and I was waiting for the penny to drop. Rosie seemed to be the most unstable of characters whose personality changed depending on who she was with. She veered from being clingy and vulnerable to manipulative and at times, downright devious. She was certainly a troubled soul for reasons which later become clear. Although I could feel some sympathy for her, I didn’t trust her at all and all through the book I was trying to work out which part of her story was the truth or a lie.
Despite being a medical professional, Sam turns detective in her quest to help Rosie and becomes as keen as Rosie to know what really happened. Against this backdrop, Sam is also having issues with her own sister Miranda. They have never been particularly close but Miranda has become secretive and Sam, being the older sister is worried. Their relationship would presumably have been more fully explained in book #1 however there was enough history given here to give the reader an idea of the complex relationship between the two sisters.
As the story unfolds the tension increases and the various strands come together and lead to a chilling finale. I have mixed feelings about Sam. I thought she was perhaps a little too gullible at times for someone experienced in her profession and I admit that there were times when I became frustrated with her however I was interested enough to know more about her and will be catching up with the first book.
September 13, 2017
I read and fell in love with the first book in the series, Inside the Whispers last year so this sequel was eagerly anticipated at damppebbles HQ.
And I LOVED it. In fact, I would go as far as saying I probably preferred this second book to the first. As a Clinical Psychologist, Samatha Willerby begins a series of consultations with a new patient, Rosie Chandler. Rosie suffered great trauma after the van she was travelling in, along twisty Penrith roads in the Lake District, careered off course and into a lake. Rosie was able to swim through the broken back window and survive the terrifying ordeal. The other three occupants were not so lucky and are still missing, along with a priceless violin. Rosie’s viola was also lost in the accident; worth nothing in a monetary sense but worth everything to Rosie. With the help of Sam, Rosie plans to work on her missing memories and try to piece together exactly what happened on that devastating evening.
I am very fond of Samantha Willerby. When Rosie waltz’s into Sam’s office she initially throws the confident and able psychologist Her behaviour is…odd. Her tone is unexpected. Sam struggles to see the normal signs of trauma typically present in other patients. The reader begins to realise this latest case isn’t going to be as straight forward as Samantha first expected. My feelings towards Rosie changed throughout the book. At times I pitied her, at other times I found her possessive and very creepy. I never found myself liking her.
I really felt for Samatha who was battling her own demons following a teen suicide she was blamed for the previous year. She is determined to make sure the same thing doesn’t happen again but refuses to cross any lines that may be construed as inappropriate between a psychologist and a patient. But in Rosie’s case, she will push that line to the absolute limit, just to be sure the same heartbreaking situation doesn’t happen again. Rosie appears to be quite fragile and Samantha is nervous of ignoring the signs and failing to listen to a patient in need for a second time. But has she gone too far?
Sam’s relationship with Miranda, her sister remains hard going and despite Sam’s desire to be closer, Miranda seems set on keeping multiple heart-breaking secrets from her sibling. Adding additional stress to our usually calm and competent female protagonist.
A very readable novel about an incredibly likeable character who I will keep coming back to time and time again. I loved the way the story was set out, with Rosie recovering memories at different points throughout and adding to what the reader already knew. Gradually building the story to a somewhat blistering conclusion, wow!
Would I recommend this book? Most definitely. It can be read as a stand alone but why bother when you get pick up a copy of Inside the Whispers for a mere £1.99 on amazon.co.uk. This is an outstanding series; both books have been a joy to read and I heartily recommend them to all psychological thriller fans, particularly those (like me!) who have an interest in psychology. I cannot wait for the next instalment.
Five out of five stars.
I chose to read and review an eARC of Lost in the Lake. The above review is my own, unbiased opinion.
And I LOVED it. In fact, I would go as far as saying I probably preferred this second book to the first. As a Clinical Psychologist, Samatha Willerby begins a series of consultations with a new patient, Rosie Chandler. Rosie suffered great trauma after the van she was travelling in, along twisty Penrith roads in the Lake District, careered off course and into a lake. Rosie was able to swim through the broken back window and survive the terrifying ordeal. The other three occupants were not so lucky and are still missing, along with a priceless violin. Rosie’s viola was also lost in the accident; worth nothing in a monetary sense but worth everything to Rosie. With the help of Sam, Rosie plans to work on her missing memories and try to piece together exactly what happened on that devastating evening.
I am very fond of Samantha Willerby. When Rosie waltz’s into Sam’s office she initially throws the confident and able psychologist Her behaviour is…odd. Her tone is unexpected. Sam struggles to see the normal signs of trauma typically present in other patients. The reader begins to realise this latest case isn’t going to be as straight forward as Samantha first expected. My feelings towards Rosie changed throughout the book. At times I pitied her, at other times I found her possessive and very creepy. I never found myself liking her.
I really felt for Samatha who was battling her own demons following a teen suicide she was blamed for the previous year. She is determined to make sure the same thing doesn’t happen again but refuses to cross any lines that may be construed as inappropriate between a psychologist and a patient. But in Rosie’s case, she will push that line to the absolute limit, just to be sure the same heartbreaking situation doesn’t happen again. Rosie appears to be quite fragile and Samantha is nervous of ignoring the signs and failing to listen to a patient in need for a second time. But has she gone too far?
Sam’s relationship with Miranda, her sister remains hard going and despite Sam’s desire to be closer, Miranda seems set on keeping multiple heart-breaking secrets from her sibling. Adding additional stress to our usually calm and competent female protagonist.
A very readable novel about an incredibly likeable character who I will keep coming back to time and time again. I loved the way the story was set out, with Rosie recovering memories at different points throughout and adding to what the reader already knew. Gradually building the story to a somewhat blistering conclusion, wow!
Would I recommend this book? Most definitely. It can be read as a stand alone but why bother when you get pick up a copy of Inside the Whispers for a mere £1.99 on amazon.co.uk. This is an outstanding series; both books have been a joy to read and I heartily recommend them to all psychological thriller fans, particularly those (like me!) who have an interest in psychology. I cannot wait for the next instalment.
Five out of five stars.
I chose to read and review an eARC of Lost in the Lake. The above review is my own, unbiased opinion.
October 7, 2018
Rosie has been in an accident where the three others in the vehicle are all now missing presumed drowned. She goes to see Dr Samantha Willerby who is a clinical psychologist specialising in Post Traumatic Stress disorder. This is the second in the series and happily stands alone- but would be better understood in some ways if the first has also been read. Sam has her own issues as her sister is schizophrenic and although currently doing well she feels responsible for her. Rosie thinks that there is more to the crash than it being an accident and gets rather fixated on Sam who she wants as a friend as well as her psychologist. Rosie is especially keen to get back her viola. It was nothing special so why is she so attached to it? Sam has her demons to face as one of her last patients committed suicide and she feels responsible. Again AJ has the knack of being able to draw you in early on which then for me meant the pages turned easily. I wanted to know the whys and wherefores. Psychology having always been one of those interesting subjects. I liked Sam and found Rosie rather disturbing- perhaps a dark side that we hadn’t seen yet- I won’t give anything away other than to say what a wonderful. clever, well researched read. Can’t wait for the next one
For more reviews please see my blog http://nickibookblog.blogspot.co.uk/
or follow me on Twitter @nickijmurphy1
For more reviews please see my blog http://nickibookblog.blogspot.co.uk/
or follow me on Twitter @nickijmurphy1
September 7, 2017
Rosie Chandler is desperate to uncover her locked memories from the night of a terrible tragedy and she turns to psychologist, Sam Willerby for help, but does Rosie want more than Sam is prepared to give her and just how much can Sam trust in what Rosie is telling her. I read this one with the creepy horror film soundtrack playing in my head!
Right from the outset you just know that Rosie Chandler is bad news but there is also something ever so endearingly vulnerable about her that draws people in like moths to a flame. Her horrific childhood would reduce even the hardest professional to tears and it is clear that she is suffering greatly from the traumas she has experienced. She was a bit of an enigma and it was difficult to know when she was lying or telling the truth but it was clear that she was in need of some form of help that’s for sure!
As I hadn’t read the previous book in the series I had no preconceptions of what to expect from Sam. I’m now interested to go back and read the first one to find out just a little more about her and what makes her tick. If I’m totally honest at times she really irritated me and I found her inability to say no to Rosie infuriating at times, although, I could understand why she was reluctant to let her go. I didn’t dislike Sam’s character, I just wanted to understand her a little better. Sam’s sister, Miranda and their relationship is also intriguing and I engaged well with Miranda as a character and could understand her frustrations at Sam constantly checking up on her but also got the sense that Miranda, at a subconscious level appreciated and indeed welcomed this.
The plot is certainly twisted and chilling and as a reader, I was constantly re-evaluating what was truth and what was lies; just what memories did Rosie have and what exactly was it she was hiding from Sam? The whole topic of memory loss and retrieval, especially in the area of trauma, is a fascinating subject in itself and this engrossed me throughout. I wanted to go and find out more about the subject and treatment!
I could imagine Lost in the Lake transferred onto the big screen, it would work perfectly as a psychological thriller. A dark and twisted journey into memories and the mind that will have you checking the doors behind you and looking under your bed before you go to sleep!
Right from the outset you just know that Rosie Chandler is bad news but there is also something ever so endearingly vulnerable about her that draws people in like moths to a flame. Her horrific childhood would reduce even the hardest professional to tears and it is clear that she is suffering greatly from the traumas she has experienced. She was a bit of an enigma and it was difficult to know when she was lying or telling the truth but it was clear that she was in need of some form of help that’s for sure!
As I hadn’t read the previous book in the series I had no preconceptions of what to expect from Sam. I’m now interested to go back and read the first one to find out just a little more about her and what makes her tick. If I’m totally honest at times she really irritated me and I found her inability to say no to Rosie infuriating at times, although, I could understand why she was reluctant to let her go. I didn’t dislike Sam’s character, I just wanted to understand her a little better. Sam’s sister, Miranda and their relationship is also intriguing and I engaged well with Miranda as a character and could understand her frustrations at Sam constantly checking up on her but also got the sense that Miranda, at a subconscious level appreciated and indeed welcomed this.
The plot is certainly twisted and chilling and as a reader, I was constantly re-evaluating what was truth and what was lies; just what memories did Rosie have and what exactly was it she was hiding from Sam? The whole topic of memory loss and retrieval, especially in the area of trauma, is a fascinating subject in itself and this engrossed me throughout. I wanted to go and find out more about the subject and treatment!
I could imagine Lost in the Lake transferred onto the big screen, it would work perfectly as a psychological thriller. A dark and twisted journey into memories and the mind that will have you checking the doors behind you and looking under your bed before you go to sleep!
September 7, 2017
I am always wary about reading a book when it is number 2 or 3 etc. in a series, as I wonder if I would miss something going on in the background. Well I didn't have to worry about this book as it works great as a standalone novel.
I initially found the story a bit slow, but I could tell it was going to pick up as it was starting to hold my interest. I found the character of Sam, the Psychologist, as a very strong and caring person. She seemed very enthusiastic about helping Rosie.
Rosie was a very interesting character. She came across as vulnerable, but to me she also seemed quite unstable. For some reason as I was reading the book, there was just something about her that I didn't trust, and this was with me throughout the book. She had been in a serious road traffic accident, where the van had gone into the lake, and her "friends" were missing. However she seemed more interested in getting her lost viola back than to finding her friends, and her focus was more on the viola. She was hoping that Sam could tell her how or why the accident had happened as she couldn't remember. I still didn't trust her though and was very keen to see what it was about her that made me mistrust her so much.
The author managed to hold my interest throughout, despite the slow start. I kept coming up in my head with my own theories about why Rosie was like she was, only for the Author to take me in another direction and make me change my mind. It was the gaps in her memory that were making me think, could she really remember or was she lying. It really kept me guessing.
I didn't see the ending coming which is just what you would expect from a well written book. Yet another great read from AJ Waines.
I initially found the story a bit slow, but I could tell it was going to pick up as it was starting to hold my interest. I found the character of Sam, the Psychologist, as a very strong and caring person. She seemed very enthusiastic about helping Rosie.
Rosie was a very interesting character. She came across as vulnerable, but to me she also seemed quite unstable. For some reason as I was reading the book, there was just something about her that I didn't trust, and this was with me throughout the book. She had been in a serious road traffic accident, where the van had gone into the lake, and her "friends" were missing. However she seemed more interested in getting her lost viola back than to finding her friends, and her focus was more on the viola. She was hoping that Sam could tell her how or why the accident had happened as she couldn't remember. I still didn't trust her though and was very keen to see what it was about her that made me mistrust her so much.
The author managed to hold my interest throughout, despite the slow start. I kept coming up in my head with my own theories about why Rosie was like she was, only for the Author to take me in another direction and make me change my mind. It was the gaps in her memory that were making me think, could she really remember or was she lying. It really kept me guessing.
I didn't see the ending coming which is just what you would expect from a well written book. Yet another great read from AJ Waines.
October 27, 2018
Rosie Chandler is the only survivor of the crash where the vehicle they were in plunged into a lake. She has lost her memory of the event and has lost her Viola and is desperate to get both back so she goes to Dr. Samantha Willerby. But Sam quickly sees that Rosie is hiding something and has become possessive of Sam. When Sam agrees to take Rosie back to where the crash happened he truth comes out and Sam realizes she is in more trouble than she thought.
Sam is a therapist for traumatic accident survivors so it is natural that she would be asked to help Rosie. Rosie has some serious issues from a young age. When she comes to Sam you can just tell that something is up but not what. She starts to see Rosie relying on her more and more but wants to help her find her lost memories.
This is a great thriller that kept me on the edge of my seat. You can’t help but feel sorry for everything Rosie has gone through but at the same time you know something if off and don’t trust her. Although Sam has a set of rules she follows to stay safe from potential troubled patients she disregards them to help Rosie, big mistake. But Sam also has to worry about her sister and what she is up to. I think this is why she dropped her guard so much for Rosie.
I loved Inside the Whispers and was excited to Read Lost in the Lake. This is a great series that will draw you in, leave you guessing, and thrilled at the unexpected ending. Lost in the Lake could easily be read as a standalone novel but I think reading them in order adds to the story. I recommend checking this book out.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I voluntarily chose to read and post an honest review.
Sam is a therapist for traumatic accident survivors so it is natural that she would be asked to help Rosie. Rosie has some serious issues from a young age. When she comes to Sam you can just tell that something is up but not what. She starts to see Rosie relying on her more and more but wants to help her find her lost memories.
This is a great thriller that kept me on the edge of my seat. You can’t help but feel sorry for everything Rosie has gone through but at the same time you know something if off and don’t trust her. Although Sam has a set of rules she follows to stay safe from potential troubled patients she disregards them to help Rosie, big mistake. But Sam also has to worry about her sister and what she is up to. I think this is why she dropped her guard so much for Rosie.
I loved Inside the Whispers and was excited to Read Lost in the Lake. This is a great series that will draw you in, leave you guessing, and thrilled at the unexpected ending. Lost in the Lake could easily be read as a standalone novel but I think reading them in order adds to the story. I recommend checking this book out.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. I voluntarily chose to read and post an honest review.
September 6, 2017
This is the second outing for A.J. Waines’s clinical psychologist, Dr Samantha Willerby. A great first start to a series can often disappoint with the follow-up, but this most certainly does not.
Sam has a new patient, Rosie Chandler, a musician who is the only survivor of a horrendous car accident. In the accident, Rosie’s fellow members of a string quartet drowned. Trouble is, Rosie can’t remember the deeply traumatic event and so she needs Sam’s professional expertise to recover her memory and ultimately a cherished viola that she has lost.
Sound quite straightforward? Not at all! For this is an A.J. Waines novel and after the first couple of chapters, I was in my usual ‘What the heck is going on?’ mode. The story is told from Sam’s and Rosie’s point of view, which works so well in ratcheting up the tension and keeping those pages turning.
Successful psychological thrillers rely on a skilful slow burn, which Waines delivers so well. Throw in a nail-biting climax and you have a real treat. Gripping reading.
Note: I received an ARC of this book. This is my independent opinion.
Sam has a new patient, Rosie Chandler, a musician who is the only survivor of a horrendous car accident. In the accident, Rosie’s fellow members of a string quartet drowned. Trouble is, Rosie can’t remember the deeply traumatic event and so she needs Sam’s professional expertise to recover her memory and ultimately a cherished viola that she has lost.
Sound quite straightforward? Not at all! For this is an A.J. Waines novel and after the first couple of chapters, I was in my usual ‘What the heck is going on?’ mode. The story is told from Sam’s and Rosie’s point of view, which works so well in ratcheting up the tension and keeping those pages turning.
Successful psychological thrillers rely on a skilful slow burn, which Waines delivers so well. Throw in a nail-biting climax and you have a real treat. Gripping reading.
Note: I received an ARC of this book. This is my independent opinion.
December 7, 2024
The weak link in this book is named Rosie.
I hate Rosie. That is all you need to know about why I didn't like this book more than I did.
The author handles Rosie as an obsessive character very well, but our dear Dr. Willerby is sadly so frustratingly naive towards this disturbed individual, I'm tempted to call her incompetent.
And no, I don't really care that it has to be done for the plot to end up where the author wants it to. I still thought it was pretty bad. (And stupid.)
I still somehow like Sam though. Her sister was better in this book, but I'm still on the fence about Miranda.
I hate Rosie. That is all you need to know about why I didn't like this book more than I did.
The author handles Rosie as an obsessive character very well, but our dear Dr. Willerby is sadly so frustratingly naive towards this disturbed individual, I'm tempted to call her incompetent.
And no, I don't really care that it has to be done for the plot to end up where the author wants it to. I still thought it was pretty bad. (And stupid.)
I still somehow like Sam though. Her sister was better in this book, but I'm still on the fence about Miranda.
September 7, 2017
Even though this is the second book in the Dr Samantha Willerby Series it easily passes as a standalone story. I haven't read book one but there are parts that explain some of the events of the first book and this just helps to add to Samantha's character. I felt like Samantha's character was pretty well developed making it just that bit easier to be pulled into her story. Once I picked up this book I found that an hour had passed and I hadn't even realised. It's a story that will have you wondering what will happen next and because of this I found I didn't want to put the book down.
Rosie is an intriguing character and I loved Sam and Rosie's first meeting it was almost like a cat and mouse game as they each tried to figure the other out. I found Rosie's character very intriguing there is something almost innocent about her and the way she talks so matter of fact. However there is also something else there especially as it is clear she is hiding something but what is it? The story is character driven and they are two fantastic characters in their very own different ways but it certainly makes for a compelling read. The psychology side really interested me and it was written in a way that made me take in all the information and enjoy the subject. Memory loss is such an intriguing subject and it was woven into the story brilliantly.
There is an underlying tension throughout and it really managed to grab hold of me. I thought the dual perspective really added to this with a twisty and almost chilling atmosphere of not really knowing which way the plot would go next.
There are shocks and tension throughout!
With thanks to A.J. Waines for my copy. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
Rosie is an intriguing character and I loved Sam and Rosie's first meeting it was almost like a cat and mouse game as they each tried to figure the other out. I found Rosie's character very intriguing there is something almost innocent about her and the way she talks so matter of fact. However there is also something else there especially as it is clear she is hiding something but what is it? The story is character driven and they are two fantastic characters in their very own different ways but it certainly makes for a compelling read. The psychology side really interested me and it was written in a way that made me take in all the information and enjoy the subject. Memory loss is such an intriguing subject and it was woven into the story brilliantly.
There is an underlying tension throughout and it really managed to grab hold of me. I thought the dual perspective really added to this with a twisty and almost chilling atmosphere of not really knowing which way the plot would go next.
There are shocks and tension throughout!
With thanks to A.J. Waines for my copy. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
December 20, 2017
After reading the first in the series I was straight on to the next and I must admit I enjoyed the first book, but loved this.
I found it darker, twister and didn’t guess the plot as much.
I enjoyed getting to know Sam’s character in ore depth and her tenuous relationship with her sister.
The setting of the Lake District was descriptive and gave a real sense of place.
Looking forward to more in this series and hope I don’t have to wait too long.
I found it darker, twister and didn’t guess the plot as much.
I enjoyed getting to know Sam’s character in ore depth and her tenuous relationship with her sister.
The setting of the Lake District was descriptive and gave a real sense of place.
Looking forward to more in this series and hope I don’t have to wait too long.
September 12, 2017
I won a copy of this book from Librarything in exchange for my honest review. This is the first book that I have read in this series and I can definitely say that it can be read as a stand alone without worry. I really enjoyed this story, Dr. Sam Willerby is a Psychologist and has begun seeing her patient Rosie through "extended visits" in her home and she is rightfully feeling as if maybe this was a bad idea. Rosie is the soul survivor from a car crash and has been tryjng to get her memories of that crash back. She is also trying to deal with her feelings of abandonment when as a child she witnessed the murder-suicide of her parents, these events have left Rosie psychologically damaged and Dr. Willerby has become Rosie's latest target. I loved the gradual build up of suspense and intensity, a good read!
September 28, 2017
So, I must admit this book didn't grab me from the beginning. In fact, I didn't start to become invested until around 50% which is hard for me to admit because I have loved all of this author's books. It lacked intrigue and suspense, it appeared to just be Rosie, who we know is a bit off, talking about all of the musical instruments that were lost when she went into the lake. It finally picked up though mid way through and finished strong. Once it started going, I was quickly turning the pages. 3.5 stars rounded to 4. I do believe that it may just be me as others seem to love it. I will continue to read more from this author including the next one in this series.
January 28, 2019
Really good read will definitely be reading the 3rd in the series. It's nice to see how the characters evolve. Really hope there will be more in the series
September 3, 2017
Having read other books by AJ Waines, I was expecting another cleverly-plotted psychological thriller and this one didn’t disappoint! I am pleased to be the first to review this...
At the beginning of the story, Rosie seems to be the only survivor of a crash, when a van goes out of control on a lakeside road and sinks into the water. Three other musicians who were travelling with her appear to be missing, presumed dead. Rosie can only remember patches of what happened, but she’s certain the crash wasn’t an accident and is given sessions with Dr Samantha Willerby, a hospital psychologist, to deal with the trauma and help recover her memories.
Before long we find out that Sam is diligent and always goes the extra mile, but she made a bad mistake a few months ago when she didn’t trust her own judgement and a patient died. She’s haunted by the memory and is determined never to let anyone down again. As a result, she overcompensates with Rosie and soon finds herself wanting to back-track.
The story has alternate chapters told through the eyes of Sam and Rosie, but it’s clear straight away that both viewpoints are entirely at odds with each other. Sam thinks Rosie wants her memories back, but Rosie has a different agenda altogether and it’s this misdirection and deception that forms the heart of the story - I never quite knew where it was heading.
What I liked most about this book is that it wasn’t just a page turner. The author seemed to get right inside the heads of the characters and I felt genuinely emotionally involved. There’s a big shock towards the end that certainly pulled the rug from under me! I’d certainly recommend it.
At the beginning of the story, Rosie seems to be the only survivor of a crash, when a van goes out of control on a lakeside road and sinks into the water. Three other musicians who were travelling with her appear to be missing, presumed dead. Rosie can only remember patches of what happened, but she’s certain the crash wasn’t an accident and is given sessions with Dr Samantha Willerby, a hospital psychologist, to deal with the trauma and help recover her memories.
Before long we find out that Sam is diligent and always goes the extra mile, but she made a bad mistake a few months ago when she didn’t trust her own judgement and a patient died. She’s haunted by the memory and is determined never to let anyone down again. As a result, she overcompensates with Rosie and soon finds herself wanting to back-track.
The story has alternate chapters told through the eyes of Sam and Rosie, but it’s clear straight away that both viewpoints are entirely at odds with each other. Sam thinks Rosie wants her memories back, but Rosie has a different agenda altogether and it’s this misdirection and deception that forms the heart of the story - I never quite knew where it was heading.
What I liked most about this book is that it wasn’t just a page turner. The author seemed to get right inside the heads of the characters and I felt genuinely emotionally involved. There’s a big shock towards the end that certainly pulled the rug from under me! I’d certainly recommend it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 78 reviews