Anna left home years ago after what she perceived as a horrible betrayal by her Aunt Rose. She returns home after another betrayal, to help Rose run the family restaurant while she figures out what she wants to do.
In my opinion, family isn't necessarily the people you are genetically related to. For lots of us, family is the group we create after learning to avoid some or all toxic birth-family situations. I was utterly absorbed in this book for the first 250 pages, thinking that I knew where Gaffney was headed with this--Anna needed to learn to forgive and Rose needed to learn that one's genetic family doesn't always deserve unquestioned loyalty and devotion (for one thing, she should have kicked Anna's ass way sooner).
But Gaffney's world is way less complex than that. If you're family, you're good. Staying in place is better than figuring out what is healthy and what you need, which might include leaving to find it. Loyalty is always right, even if you're being loyal to something that doesn't deserve it. Even though Carmen, Rose's cousin and the chef at the restaurant, was horrible, the reader was just somehow supposed to know she was worth keeping because she was FAMILY, the only good thing anyone, even Rose, can say about her.
But the ending was a disappointment. Rose turned out to be perfect, and pretty much right about everything, and Anna was just wrong, wrong, wrong. Perfect, warm, loving characters who have no serious flaws irritate me no end, and Rose is one of the worst of these I've read in awhile.
Unlike some other reviewers, my sympathies were with Anna. Yes, she held on to her anger years too long, but at least she was a believable, prickly, imperfect human being who learned some things that were worth learning. Rose was irritatingly perfect. Her only redeeming quality is that she did manage to resist being smug about always being right, which would have made this a one-star book for me.
I loved the setup of this book, and it's been awhile since I've been this absorbed in a story, so I'm still giving it three stars. Just wish it could have been a little more complex rather than going with the boring, cliche'd way Gaffney resolved the story. This was my first Gaffney, not sure yet whether I will read more. Based on the other reviews, it sounds like her other books are more this way rather than less. I guess I am a bit too curmudgeonly for this stuff.