Twenty-nine year-old widow, Emily, is content to run the coffee and doughnut shop she co-owns with her father-in-law, Tom, the retired chief of police, and play with her cat, Deputy Donut. Emily enjoys getting to know the regulars, like the ladies of Knitpickers, a knitting group that meets every weekday morning. One regular, Georgia, even orders doughnuts to go to tide her over on the weekend. Now Georgia's friend Lois has moved back to town and joined the group. All should be well but when Georgia fails to appear for their regular meeting and doesn't call, Lois becomes worries. Later that day, the Knitpickers pick up Emily and hop in Lois's mini van to Georgia's house where Emily discovers Georgia lying on the floor of the kitchen pantry with a teen doll in a doughnut "dress" stuck in her mouth. When Emily removes the doll, Georgia doesn't respond. First responders declare Georgia dead and the neighbor across the street claims she was worried something had happened to Georgia. Then Emily's cat discovers a secret passageway between her walled garden and next door, which happens to be Lois's new house where Lois is lying in the mud in her garden, dazed and confused. Emily feels someone attacked Lois but Lois swears she fell on her own. Other little things don't add up and Lois eventually confesses she was attacked and is afraid if the police get involved it will put her and Emily in danger. Emily turns to her late husband's police partner, Alec, for help. Unfortunately, he suspects Lois's great-nephew is behind Georgia's murder and the attack on Lois. Lois swears Randy couldn't have done it but Alec isn't so sure. He isn't sold on Lois not being the killer either and when the chief brings in a state crime scene investigator, she suspects not only Randy and Lois but even Emily! It's up to Emily to put together the clues and save her new friend.
Well this was different! I expected a lot of world building and set up before the murder happened but this story gets off to a roaring start and is quick paced. I couldn't put it down! I liked the shop, it's very fancy for a doughnut shop. I wasn't sure if I would like all the law enforcement and first responder characters but it wasn't too much. If anything, it makes Emily less inclined to be stupid. There weren't enough characters in the story though so I figured out who the killer was pretty quickly, without even guessing at a motive, just by process of elimination. The story was well plotted and I wasn't 100% certain I was correct. The murderer was very clever and devious.
I like Emily well enough. She's a very caring person and has a good head on her shoulders. She worked as a 911 operator when her husband was killed in the line of duty. She was off that night and feels guilty, as if she could have saved Alec. Emily is still traumatized from Alec's death and nothing she's tried has helped her heal completely but life moves on and she just goes day by day. She SAYS she's not ready to date again and will never love again but I think she will. For all he's the co-owner of the shop, Tom doesn't appear much. He's the chief doughnut fryer and not the face of the business the way Emily is. He's also the retired chief of police though so I would expect him to want to be out there in the shop keeping an eye on things. Tom and Emily have a good rapport and work well together. Emily's cat, Deputy Donut, for whom the shop is named, is a great character. I'm not a cat person but I rather like this spoiled diva who knows how to get what she wants from TWO human "mothers"! She senses when something is wrong and leads Emily to act. When she likes someone, she's generous with her affection. When she doesn't, watch out because she becomes catzilla!
Georgia was a sweet little old lady who loved repairing dolls, knitting, crocheting and quilting. Her home was a doll hospital where she repaired and made cloth dolls. Five years ago her only son, her only child, Matthias, was murdered and his murder has been unsolved. Matthias was a well-liked grocer and no one can think of any reason for someone to want to murder him. How heartbreaking for Georgia's friends to watch Georgia lose her only child and then her own life. That's just awful! Her oldest friend Lois wants this murder solved. She is Emily's co-sleuth and pushes Emily into investigating. Lois seems like a nice old lady and a lot of fun. She was widowed 50 years ago at 22 (WWII?) after only one year of marriage and Georgia was like a sister to her and Matthias, a son. Her only family is a great-nephew, Randy and she loves him very much in spite of his shady past. I think Lois is sweet and I like her a lot but I think she's naive and too trusting. The other ladies in the knitting group don't appear again after discovering Georgia's body.
Emily's two best friends since childhood, Samantha and Tina, are also in local public professions. Samantha is a fun-loving EMT who wants to date a nice man and Tina, an Amazon apparently due to Scandinavian heritage (totally unnecessary to describe her like that) is a tough cop when she's on duty but is a caring friend and can let loose when she's not working. She, too, wants a nice date.
Eligible bachelor #1 is Brent, Emily's late husband's partner on the force. Brent was with Alec when Alec was shot and survived. We don't get any intel on his thoughts, whether he feels survivor's guilt or how much he misses his best friend. He seems to care for Emily but she keeps him at arm's length. Brent is a good detective, he listens and has compassion for his suspects. He's kind and considerate towards everyone, for the most part. While the evidence is circumstantial, as the evidence builds, it does seem more and more like Randy is the culprit. Brent is cautious and doesn't build a case against Randy or arrest him for no good reason. He lets Emily in on secrets by speaking in monosyllables and letting her infer his meaning. I like Brent and I think he and Emily will get together but I have mixed feelings about that. I'm not sure they SHOULD.
Eligible Bachelor #2 is Oliver, the high school hottie every girl sighed over. His good looks make Emily blush and her friends are eager to go out with Oliver now he's divorced. I found his personality lacking. He seems like a mansplainer and isn't used to rejection. He just assumes all women want to go out with him and he only needs to pick one- Emily! She's too nice to let him down firmly but gently and he's too stupid to take the hints. I find him smarmy. Eligible bachelor #3 is Scott, a firefighter. He's young, good looking and good natured. Unlike with Oliver, Emily can tell HIM she's not interested in dating. Scott takes it well and he claims he's not interested either. Eligible bachelor #4 is Randy, Lois's great-nephew. He was a bad boy in high school who gave himself a tattoo and drove a beat up old car. All the girls thought he was cute but knew he was bad news. He left town 5 years ago after Georgia's son was murdered and now he's back. Lois is convinced her great-nephew has reformed and he's innocent. I'm not certain he is.
Emily starts looking into Matthias's death and discovers two people who had a motive to murder him. Honey, a bridezilla at the time, claimed Matthias sold her tainted meat that made her ill and caused her groom to ditch her. She, apparently, was the only one who didn't know about the tainted meat from the meat packer and the refund Matthias was offering. Honey is now overweight and alone. I didn't like how she's fat shamed by everyone or how she's portrayed as a whiny, sadsack loser. She's awful! I feel bad for her though because life has dealt her a rough hand. She's on the lookout for a new boy toy but unwilling to be friendly enough with anyone who can introduce her to one of the eligible bachelors in town. Did Honey kill Matthias? I think she just likes to whine and complain and try to get people to feel sorry for her. Frederick Aggelton bought Taste of Fallingbrook, a gourmet grocery, from Georgia after Matthias was killed. Frederick was after Matthias to sell him the shop for YEARS and finally wore down a grieving mother. THAT tells me what kind of man he is. Then there's Emily's description of the shop, no longer a gourmet grocery! No one shops there anymore and products are out of date and the place smells bad. Frederick is Emily's top suspect in Matthias's murder, especially when Brent reminds her Frederick had another motive. Frederick proclaims his innocence but I think he's over compensating and certainly has something to hide.
A prime suspect in Georgia's murder is Dr. Jierson, an expensive dentist who is on call 24/7 to make his patients feel good again. He had beef with Georgia before she was killed and reading between the lines, he's a controlling narcissist who doesn't treat his wife very well. Mrs. Jierson is young and doesn't seem to have her own identity. She acts nervous every time she speaks with Emily and may know more than she's willing to let on about the day Georgia died. Could they have conspired to kill Georgia or does Mrs. J know Dr. J is the murderer or suspect? That guy is a little creepy if you ask me. There's no reason to connect either Jierson with Matthias though so if they did kill Georgia, Matthias's killer is still out there somewhere.
I liked this story enough to want to keep going. I don't think the series will be a top favorite though. We shall see.