What do you think?
Rate this book


243 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 4, 2017
Wild Wastes by Randi Darren is the first entry in the Wild Wastes series, and while it attempts to blend elements of LitRPG, harem, and adventure, it ultimately fails to deliver a coherent or satisfying story.
Pros: There’s a certain boldness in its world-building, but the execution is severely flawed.
Cons: Extremely problematic character dynamics, an incoherent plot, and excessive, gratuitous content.
Let’s break this down further:
Wild Wastes throws the reader into a post-apocalyptic fantasy world where human-like animals (referred to as "beastkin") and magic are the norm. Our protagonist, Vince, navigates through this world in a manner that feels erratic and poorly paced. The story never seems to settle into a cohesive rhythm. Plot points come and go without any sense of narrative structure, and there’s very little tension or challenge for the protagonist to overcome.
Vince gains power far too quickly, and rather than this being an interesting progression, it feels forced and artificial. In a genre where progression is key, Vince's development is so unbalanced that it drains the story of any real conflict. There’s no sense of stakes, and without them, the reader has no reason to care about the outcome.
Perhaps the most glaring issue in this novel is its treatment of characters, particularly women. Vince is surrounded by a harem of female characters, but none of them are developed beyond shallow archetypes that exist to serve his desires. The book objectifies women to an almost uncomfortable degree, reducing them to sexual objects without any meaningful personalities or autonomy.
Vince himself is difficult to empathize with, as he seems more interested in his harem than in anything else. He lacks depth, making it hard to relate to or even like him as a protagonist. He’s designed purely as a vehicle for the power fantasy, and that limits any potential growth or complexity.
The world of Wild Wastes has the potential to be interesting, with its blend of post-apocalyptic survival, beastkin, and magic. However, the worldbuilding feels haphazard and underdeveloped. There are many concepts introduced, but few are explored in depth. The setting could have been a great backdrop for complex political dynamics or survivalist challenges, but instead, it takes a backseat to the protagonist’s sexual escapades.
The writing style is simplistic, and while this might work in certain adventure stories, it doesn’t do the book any favors here. The dialogue is often stilted, and much of the prose lacks nuance. Randi Darren’s writing suffers from an excessive focus on titillation rather than plot or character development.
Additionally, the book is plagued by awkward tonal shifts. It tries to combine lighthearted moments with darker themes, but it often misses the mark, leaving the reader unsure of what kind of story they’re reading. Is it a serious fantasy adventure? A lighthearted harem comedy? The inconsistency detracts from the experience.
One of the most troubling aspects of this book is its handling of consent and power dynamics. The relationships between the protagonist and the women in his harem are uncomfortable, as the women often appear to have little agency or choice in their involvement with Vince. This is presented as acceptable, which raises significant ethical concerns.
Moreover, the focus on gratuitous sexual content over meaningful relationships or character development makes the book feel exploitative. Readers who are looking for a more balanced and respectful portrayal of romantic or sexual relationships will be sorely disappointed.
Wild Wastes is a novel that prioritizes sexual fantasies over storytelling, and it suffers because of it. While it introduces an interesting world, it fails to flesh out its potential, instead focusing on shallow power dynamics and problematic character relationships. The plot lacks structure, and the characters are one-dimensional at best.
For readers who are looking for a well-crafted LitRPG with meaningful progression and rich worldbuilding, Wild Wastes is not the right choice. It’s a disappointing and problematic entry in the genre, and I would recommend steering clear of this one unless you’re specifically looking for gratuitous harem content.