I first read this novel as a teenager, and my only recollection of it was that I enjoyed it a great deal. I’d only vaguely remembered some plot details—it’s set in an indeterminate medieval-ish time period somewhere in a forest featuring the titular fort-like structure, and it involves a conflict between men and dogs—but I was yearning to read it again. My second read reveals why some tales appeal to us more when we’re younger.
First, the positives. “The Haven” is a rollicking good adventure novel—a straightforward tale of war between men and anthropomorphic dogs (yes, all the animals in this novel—dogs, wolves, birds—can talk). Very subtle dashes of the Trojan War and “Planet of the Apes” season an otherwise standard story featuring light romance and heavily brutal battle scenes. With no abstract philosophical ideas or ponderous themes to consider, the characters are concerned only with survival, dominance, and power. Mourning the loss of fellow soldiers is about as profound as the emotion gets in this novel. Diamond’s tone is appropriately serious but not melodramatically so—he knows he’s telling a rather ordinary story (albeit with some extraordinary fantastical touches), and he chooses his words accordingly.
As for the drawbacks…well, there’s really very little beyond the surface of this tale. At a few points along the way, Diamond creates opportunities for himself to use one of his hero’s (Nigel) quest for the “New Lands” as a metaphor for the value of history; Nigel and his fellow explorers/soldiers discover ancient texts, and I was anticipating some thematic resonance between the past and the future, some “bigger meaning” for one of the major plot strands. But it turned out to be simply one more way for the humans to gain a tactical advantage in their war with the dogs—which, I suppose, could fall under the category of using-knowledge-from-the-past-to-make-the-future-better.
So, if it’s profound literature with complex themes that you seek, search elsewhere. If, on the other hand, you’re simply seeking a fun adventure—the literary equivalent of a popcorn movie—you’ll find it in the pages of “The Haven.”