I had never considered myself a Swiftie, but after reading this book, I think I've realized that I am one!
I suppose I never took her songwriting so seriously before. I was always impressed with her ability to rhyme and the quality of language in her songs. For me, it was always annoying that she wrote only about boyfriends, at least that's what her most popular songs would indicate.
However, there are more serious issues she covers in those that aren't hit singles. 'The Best Day' on Fearless is about spending time with her mom; 'The Lucky One' on Red shows a different side of fame that Taylor doesn't typical address in interviews; 'Clean' on 1989 while on the surface talks about an unhealthy relationship, it could also apply to drug addiction (my personal interpretation). Of course the track 'Ronan' that is about a little boy dying of cancer from the point of view of his mom. I was really impressed with the songs she did for The Hunger Games soundtrack, especially Eyes Open.
It was interesting the one Rolling Stone article not included in the book was the one where she essentially pointed out it was Katy Perry who 'Bad Blood' was about. And I suppose there was the excuse of it's October publication date that Kim Kardashian's "breaking of the internet" by posting the recording between Taylor and Kanye in July didn't make it in the book. For a fan book, that would be an odd note to end on. But the book mentioned in several articles about their "feud" and the 'Famous' lyrics and her "outrage" at them. It'll be interesting to see if that's mentioned in the book that's published I guess in another book published 10 years from now celebrating her second decade in the industry.
The fan profiles included the book were a good touch because it showed how her music, shows, concerts, meet & greets, and philanthropy have made an impact on an impressionable young group of fans. It shows why Taylor Swift will go down in music history and is not just the current pop culture phenomenon.
The gathering of articles, album reviews, blog posts, fan-fiction, and fan art published in the book gave an impressive collection of Taylor and her career and shows why she'll be around for years to come. I'm glad that some of the articles selected showed legitimate criticisms about Taylor and the kind of music she writes and the purity element that seemed to show through her music. However, now that she's grown up, I feel her music has evolved to a point where that critique is no longer relevant.
If I'm remembering correctly, Taylor's dismissal of Nicki Minaj's comments about being left out of the VMA awards (it was one of those award shows) but not acknowledging race would be a potential factor was left out of the book, which I thought was an important criticism.
Regardless of her pettiness and self-involvement at times, she's a sweet person who has made amazing contributions to charity and goes out of her way to connect with her fans. She has such a strong rapport with them that she trusted select few with the secrets of her entire 1989 album and they kept the content of the album to themselves, that shows how strong the bond is!
I like how Taylor goes the extra length to make buying the physical album worth it, either with bonus tracks or little giveaways that go along with it. I've gotten the deluxe editions of 'Speak Now', 'Red', and '1989' at Target when they've come out because it's actually exciting to buy the new Taylor Swift album. I'm eager for whatever her 6th album contains (I guess it will be an entirely pop album again!) and despite the feuds, etc., lo and behold I am indeed a Swiftie.