I was a devoted reader of Sassy magazine and have followed Jane Pratt's career ever since, but for whatever reason I didn't hear about her website, xoJane, until it had already been around for a while. In fact, I discovered it just after Cat Marnell, its beauty editor, was let go for problems related to her unrepentant drug use. It was hard to catch up on exactly what had happened after the fact, so I was very curious to read the whole story as recounted by Cat herself in How to Murder Your Life.
But that didn't mean I expected to like it.
When they're actively using, addicts can be some of the most self-absorbed and irresponsible people around, and as such, writing about their addictions can be tricky. How do you describe your own terrible behavior without making the reader toss the book aside in annoyance? Plenty of addicts take the somber route in their memoirs, infusing every page with their regret and shame. Cat Marnell doesn't really do that. I mean, sure, by the time it's over she has plenty of regrets, but she also effectively captures the fact that, when you're just getting started, drug use can seem awesome: The moment when you first try a substance it seems you've been waiting for your whole life. The euphoria that makes you feel that you can do anything. The moments at parties and events when, inhibitions out the window, you can bond with other people and feel like you're really living an interesting life. Cat convincingly portrays all of this, in a conversational, exclamation point–laden style, sometimes addressing the reader directly ("I just love teen smokers, don't you?"). I can see how some readers might find this grating, but I generally found it quite charming, and most definitely entertaining.
Just as important, effectively portraying the highs of drug addiction makes it even more harrowing when the good times finally end and Cat's life becomes the sort of horror show you wouldn't wish on your worst enemy. While it's hard to say that I sympathized with her—it can be hard to sympathize with someone who makes so many stupid choices—I was definitely with her, let's put it that way. In fact, I had kind of an exasperating week at work, and yesterday, while sitting in a chair at my hair salon, my mind wandered to my various annoyances and problems—but I quickly realized I wasn't actually thinking of my own problems. I was thinking of Cat's. How often does that happen with any book?
Because Cat wrote for the internet and, before that, seemed to write mainly short beauty blurbs for Lucky magazine, I was expecting the sort of messy, casual, meandering, unstructured memoir we typically see from bloggers and other online types. I was shocked, but impressed, to find that this memoir didn't suffer from any of those usual flaws. Despite its exceedingly conversational tone, this book was quite focused. It proceeded through the years in an orderly fashion, with chapters in the book devoted to various chapters of Cat's life. This doesn't sound like such fantastic praise, but honestly, I was very impressed by how well done the book was. Given that Cat's life has been such a trainwreck, the fact that this book is not is quite an achievement.
Cat was not happy at xoJane. At one point, she complained that the site contained nothing but "internet garbage." While it's easy to say that Cat had made such a hash of her career by then that she should've been grateful for any opportunity to work as a writer/editor, that didn't change the fact that she was right: xoJane was internet garbage. Cat loved working in print magazines because of their creativity, flair, edgy glamour, and forward-thinking attempts to influence style and culture. She wasn't interested in the sort of dumbed-down clickbait you find so often on the web. These standards are entirely evident in How to Murder Your Life: Rather than going for quick, easy money, she slaved over the book for years while simultaneously getting out of the drug-induced hole she'd put herself in. At one point, concerned with how long the process was taking, Cat's publisher sent over a ghostwriter, but she sent him back and kept working. The result is a singular reading experience, better than it had any right to be, given the circumstances.
It's safe to say Cat Marnell has done many, many things she's not proud of, and at this point it's not at all clear whether she's ultimately going to be OK. But How to Murder Your Life shows that her considerable talents have so far survived her self-destructive tendencies, and I hope at least she can feel proud of that.
I won this book in a giveaway here on Goodreads. My thanks to the publisher.