Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Despite growing pains in her 1846 Amish community in Indiana, Naomi Schrock has settled into a comfortable life in her parents' home with her adopted son, Davey. Surrounded by family and friends, she tries not to think about the fact that she's not at the top of any man's list of potential wives. Yet when Cap Stoltzfus moves into the area and befriends Davey, Naomi finds herself caught between the plans she has made for her future and the tantalizing thought that Cap might be part of a life she never dared to hope for.
When a couple shows up claiming to be Davey's true family, Naomi and Cap must unite to make the decision that will determine the boy's future as well as their own. How can she relinquish him to these unknown relatives? And can God somehow bring wholeness to her heart?

373 pages, Paperback

First published June 1, 2017

59 people are currently reading
604 people want to read

About the author

Jan Drexler

31 books343 followers
Jan Drexler brings a unique understanding of Amish traditions and beliefs to her writing. Her ancestors were among the first Amish, Mennonite, and Brethren immigrants to Pennsylvania in the 1700s, and their experiences are the inspiration for her stories. Jan lives in the Black Hills of South Dakota with her husband of thirty-eight years, where she enjoys hiking in the Hills and spending time with their expanding family.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
156 (59%)
4 stars
77 (29%)
3 stars
24 (9%)
2 stars
5 (1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews
Profile Image for Deanne Patterson.
2,423 reviews121 followers
June 26, 2017
It was fun catching up with characters from past books in the Journey to Pleasant Prairie series. Naomi's Hope is the third and final installment in this series.Things were not easy at times for the characters in this book but forgiveness is a key factor in what makes this book so good. The characters are flawed, just like we are and it makes the book so much more likable. My favorite character was Davey, the adopted son of Naomi. He had little boy spunk and a hard time of it at times but with the gentle help and wisdom of those around him he persevered.I look forward to seeing what this author has coming up next.
Pub Date 06 Jun 2017
Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
3,953 reviews1,764 followers
June 6, 2017
The third and final book in the Journey to Pleasant Prairie series and it's a bittersweet read because I'm not ready to let this Amish settlement go. No worries if you haven't read Hannah's Choice and Mattie's Pledge because Naomi's Hope makes a wunderbar gut standalone read. :-) But I also enjoyed catching up with some familiar faces -- sharing their joys and their sorrows in this final installment.

The mix of historical and Amish genres is a huge draw and Drexler does it so well. She brings the pioneering spirit to life through an array of appealing (and not so appealing!) characters. In fact there is one snide, conniving reprobate that put me in conniptions time and time again. Sometimes I had to stop reading because I couldn't see past the steam coming out of my ears. I fumed and railed and gnashed my teeth as I contemplated gruesome outcomes for this character! He's not one I will easily forget.

But I'll remember Naomi too -- though for very different reasons! She's a courageous young woman who takes in an orphaned boy and raises him as her own even though she's not married. Her family has endured a lot of hardships over the years and though she doesn't waver from the faith, her personal convictions are sorely tested and she's often at odds with God. "If she could, she'd tell God a thing or two about how he controlled his world." (p. 228) Loved her defiant questioning because it leads to some real soul searching and, ultimately, answers. But she struggles to get there and I could totally relate to that.

And then there's Cap -- a lonely stranger fighting his own battles. He's drawn to the Schrock family -- especially young Davey and his intriguing mamm. There's great dynamics between Cap and Naomi. A bit adversarial at times, often awkward but also incredibly sweet. Cap just really needs to work on his communication skills. But then Naomi is quick to take offense when it comes to criticism of her parenting. There's some lovely fireworks within the pages of this book which makes the romance all the more fun.

Add in a mischievous little boy with an adventurous spirit who stirs up trouble even when he's trying to be good and you get the kind of read it's easy to lose yourself in. A triumphant conclusion to an amazing series.

My thanks to the author and Revell Publishers for providing me with a copy of this book.
Profile Image for Lori.
1,892 reviews134 followers
June 9, 2017
I loved this book for many reasons. I liked how the author has made the characters doubt themselves in their Faith as we do sometimes today.
I loved the character Davey. I can relate to him in many ways because I am adopted too. I'm very thankful for the parents that raised me.
You can be a parent but it takes a special person to raise someone else's child. I call those ppl angels. God cannot be everywhere so He created earthly parents to help Him out.
Davey is a pretty cool dude in my opinion. A child after my own heart.
Naomi is pretty special too to raise Davey by herself. Oh, she has help but sometimes I wonder if she'll ever see what's right in front of her face?
I can relate to Naomi at times. Sometimes it's hard to see what blessings we have when we think we've taken a step forward, when actually we've taken two steps back!! I hate someone else telling me how to raise my own child when at times they think they have our best interests in their hearts. Most often I find this to be people without children.
It's how Naomi feels in the story.
Naomi is sensitive like me. Sometimes someone can tell me something and I'll take it the wrong way or get mad over something silly.
Jan writes with her heart on this conclusion of Hannah's Choice series. I loved all the books in the series!!
I first met Jan through Hannah's Choice and from then on it was love at first sight on this unusual Amish series.
I enjoyed this series so much that I'll reread it again!
Will Naomi find the many blessings that is right in front of her?
Cap is a fine man too!! Can't leave him out. It takes a lot of love and patience to connect with the right people. I find Cap special in a way because he doesn't deem himself above other people and never judges others who cross his path unlike Shem.
I didn't like Shem for various reasons but I guess you have to have all kinds of folks to make the world turn!!
Thank you for a wonderful story Jan!!!
Profile Image for Sarah.
958 reviews33 followers
June 16, 2017
I loved this book! For the final book in the series, I think Jan did a fantastic job with this amish book/ series. It can be read as a stand alone. I loved the elements of faith that were displayed, especially as Naomi struggled with Davey and wrestled with Cap through a very difficult season. My heart identified so much with Naomi, especially with surrendering. This book was fantastic! I got lost in this book and can see that the author put so much research behind it! I give this book a 5/5 stars. Thank you to the publisher for providing me a copy.
Profile Image for Carrie Schmidt.
Author 1 book516 followers
July 5, 2017
Naomi’s Hope spotlights the Amish migration west from Pennsylvania during the 1840s, and I love this rare opportunity to read an Amish historical novel. The field of Amish historicals is small but it’s one of my very faves because it gives such fascinating insight into how they settled in groups and interacted with other settlers – at a time when the manner of dress and speech of their non-Amish neighbors wasn’t as different from the Amish as it is today.

Both Cap and Naomi struggle with the age-old question of why a good God allows bad things to happen to people who love Him. I appreciated the way that Drexler honestly and grace-fully tackled this subject that will hit close to home for many readers. I think it’s especially important that both of these characters come from backgrounds of faith, surrounded by people who seem to have more peace with this issue – and with God – than they themselves do. Cap and Naomi’s authenticity – as well as God’s faithfulness – will encourage readers who are in the same boat.

Davey is adorable. Precocious. Tender-hearted. All boy. He desperately wants a father, and his relationship with Cap is sweet and full of adoration. Davey works his way into Cap’s heart the same way he will yours. Naomi’s interactions with Cap are wary at first but as their friendship develops we see more of her true personality. And Cap’s.

Bottom Line: An adventurous little boy. A grieving widower wrestling with his faith. A single mom struggling with trust. A nasty man with selfish motives. And a settlement of people who have left home and the comfort of the familiar to establish a new community with a whole different set of challenges. The honest questions, struggles, and emotions of life will resonate with a wide variety of readers, and the plot keeps you turning the pages to see how it all plays out.

(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)

see my original review at Reading Is My SuperPower
Profile Image for Maureen Timerman.
3,240 reviews491 followers
January 7, 2018
This is the third book in this series about the early beginning of an Amish settlement in 1840’s Indiana. We are reunited with dear friends and meet new ones, both friends and foe.
This is Naomi’s story, and in a way the whole settlement here, along with newcomers Cap and Shem, one loveable and the other, well, here is where forgiveness and living your faith comes in.
This is also a love story, between Cap and Naomi, and also between Naomi and Davey, the love of a mother. Can this group make a family and survive the hardships presented to them, and the evil that others want to throw at them.
Things we take for granted and was surprised that the Ordnung for this community was so strict that they could not use their horses for transportation on a Sunday.
Come back for another visit with this beloved community, and if this is your first time, you can read this alone, but you will quickly want to read the past two books. I hated to say goodbye, and wish there were more in this series.
I received this book through Revell Reads Blog Tour, and was not required to give a positive review.
Profile Image for Laura.
Author 39 books653 followers
August 18, 2017
NAOMI'S HOPE is third and final book in Ms. Drexler's Journey to Pleasant Prairie series. This historical Amish series does not stand alone and readers will want to read them in order, starting with Hannah's Choice and Mattie's Pledge. Naomi's Hope is a nice finale to the collection.

The story was slow paced, but as a reader I cared about Cap and admired how he had Davey's best interests in mind. Shem made for an ideal villain, one that the reader loves to hate. I was kind of glad the story ended the way it did and not how it could've ended.

There is some real life information included in the story, and I'd someday like to read Hans story. And hope that Crows Fly lives on.

Fans of Amish historical fiction will want to read NAOMI'S HOPE and the first two books in the series. Ms. Drexler is a wonderful historical writer and develops realistic characters that resonate with readers.

I received a copy of this book free. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Regina.
389 reviews1 follower
July 26, 2017
Naomi’s Hope by Jan Drexler is the third and final book of the Pleasant Valley Series. The book is set in the 1800’s. Jan did a splendid job of writing this book.

This is about Naomi Schrock and her little boy Davey. Along with Cap Stolztfus.

Naomi and Cap have different views of parenting. Despite their differences, love is stronger. A delightful book and series!

Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including Netgalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.
Profile Image for Kristina Anderson.
4,070 reviews82 followers
June 4, 2017
Naomi’s Hope by Jan Drexler is the third book in Journey to Pleasant Prairie series. It is April 1846 in LaGrange County, Indiana. Naomi Schrock is out looking for her adopted son, Davey and discovers him with their new neighbor, Cap Stoltzfus. Davey has taken an instant liking to Cap and wants to spend time with him. Cap moved to Indiana from Holmes County, Ohio to get away from the memories of his deceased wife and child. Cap is happy in the new community and enjoys spending time with young Davey, but then an old nemesis shows up. Shem Fischer, a bully from his childhood, moves to town. Shem came from Ontario, because he heard of the communities need for a minister. Cap distrusts Shem, but he keeps his own counsel. Shem soon starts showing his true colors when he spreads seeds of doubt and mistrust among the two different Amish districts of LaGrange County and the Clinton Township. Is there a chance of once again uniting these two factions? Naomi and Cap spend time with each other, and Naomi begins to hope of a future she never thought possible. But then Naomi’s world crumbles around her when relatives come to claim Davey. How will this impact Naomi and Cap’s relationship? Read Naomi’s Hope to find out how the Journey to Pleasant Prairie trilogy ends.

Naomi’s Hope contains good writing, but I found the pace of the novel to be slow. The story slowly unfolds, but then wraps up quickly at the end. After getting into Naomi’s Hope, I could anticipate how the story would unfold and end. It is a lovely story, though, and that I found pleasurable to read. While Naomi’s Hope is the third book in this series, it can be read alone. I appreciated the additional storyline of Naomi’s struggle with faith. A struggle many people are familiar with and understand. I give Naomi’s Hope 4 out of 5 stars. Some of the themes in the Naomi’s Hope are love, forgiveness, loss, greed, and faith. I thought the characters were realistic and relatable. I also liked the setting and time period. The author did a remarkable job at portraying that region of Ohio and time. Personally, I did feel that the story could have used a little fine tuning that would have made for a better novel. Naomi’s Hope is a novel worth reading, and I trust you will enjoy it as well.
2,044 reviews
July 3, 2017
Naomi’s Hope is the third in author Jan Drexler’s Journey To Pleasant Prairie series, and here we meet up with the migrating Amish families three years later. Naomi has been caring for Davey her adopted son since they had rescued him from the remains of his family home and parent’s deaths after the awful tornado on their travels. Davey is now a happy, hyper 8 year old boy that seems to always be getting into mischief but he is the center of Naomi’s world. Ever since taking him into her care, she has given up the hope of having a husband and any future children of her own. Then steps in Cap.

Cap is a wounded soul who has lost his wife and child and just wants to start fresh in his new home. Davey captures his heart from the first moment. He and Naomi start off as somewhat reluctant friends, but because of Davey they grow closer and Cap begins to have feelings that go deeper then friendship for Naomi. I really liked their relationship. He was a man who wanted to fix things; he wanted to be a father to Davey before he fell for Naomi. However both he and Naomi has some personal issues that they needed to work on and the author did a wonderful job showing how this needed to be done and the problems that could arise if these issues were not addressed.

This town has grown and we get to see previous characters and more of their growing stories. I liked seeing how this new town was settling in and how with standing together they had an easier go, but when a wolf in sheep’s clothing steps in to spread lies this town had to stand on what they knew as truth.

There are some deep spiritual truths the author delves into, and it is seamlessly woven into the characters’ lives, thoughts, and deeds. I liked seeing the fruition of the previous books journeys now in a settlement and the families growing and preparing for the future generations. I enjoyed reading this entire series about this group of Amish pioneers.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Revell Publishing. I was not required to post a positive review and the views and opinions expressed are my own.

https://pausefortales.blogspot.com/20...
Profile Image for Katrina Epperson.
615 reviews
June 25, 2017
This is the third book in the Journey to Pleasant Prairie series from the author. I was immediately swept back to 1846 in the fairly newly established Amish community in Indiana. This is the story of Naomi Schrock. Naomi is a sweet, young Amish woman who on her trip from Pennsylvania to Indiana encountered a young boy who had been orphaned by a violent storm. Naomi felt an immediately felt a connection to the little boy, Davey, and adopted him knowing that people would wonder about not only his parentage, but also her virtue. After their arrival to Indiana the family has settled into a routine, but there is an undercurrent of discord between their community about tradition and their faith.
Cap Stoltzfus has newly arrived to the community from Holmes County, Ohio. He has suffered a great loss and thinks starting over in a new place might let him put his past behind him. His property lies next to to Schrock farm and he meets Davey almost immediately. Davey brings his past memories to the surface and is immediately drawn to him.
As Cap is drawn into the Amish community he becomes quick friends to the Schrock family, but especially Naomi and Davey. Davey is a lively, young boy who is looking for a big adventure and doesn't always do what he is told which lands him in trouble from time to time. Naomi is attracted to Cap, but their different opinions on child rearing brings many questions about the possibility of a relationship with Cap. With the appearance of someone from Cap's past not only will he cause problems within the community, but also for Cap and Naomi's future.
This is a wonderful conclusion to this series. I loved this story. It has elements of forgiveness, crisis of faith, mystery and love. The plot is engaging and pulled me in quickly. The story quickly came to life for me through the characters and their journey. Even though this book is part of a series I believe this is a stand alone story. The author gives background details that makes it unnecessary to read the first two books, but I encourage you to read them to get the full impact of the story.
**I received this book from the publisher as part of their book bloggers program. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Marilyn.
1,272 reviews
June 6, 2017
Naomi's Hope was a phenomenal book to read. Jan Drexler held me spell bound with all my senses and emotions right there with well developed characters. It was nice to catch up with members of the new Amish community in Indiana that had settled there in what became known as Pleasant Prairie. Naomi Schrock is a loving and devoted mother to her adopted son, which readers read about in book two Mattie’s Pledge, in the Journey to Pleasant Prairie series. Cap Stoltzfus is a newcomer to settle in the community with little Davey being attracted to him. Cap had a way with Davey that touched Naomi’s heart as she felt like she would never marry with her being a single mother. Then Shem Fischer came from Ontario claiming he heard the district needed another minister. Cap and Shem knew each other in their childhood, thus Cap had some concerns about him being a minister. Who and what events will play out in the conclusion of Journey to Pleasant Prairie series? Will Davey remain with Naomi or will his relatives take him away from his beloved mother Naomi and special friend Cap?

Naomi’s Hope is filled with beloved characters finding courage to face trials, faith, and total dependence upon God to see them through each crisis they faced along with forgiveness and love. Jan Drexler’s research of history with the struggles this young Amish community endures back in the 1840’s, action packed scenes with unexpected twists and turns kept me reading till the end. This book can be read as a standalone; however, I encourage readers to purchase the entire series to fall in love with the delightful characters and see their struggles that increase their faith and determination to make it in their new settlement they believed God had called them to.

I received a complimentary copy of Naomi’s Hope from the author and Revell publishing. An encouraging review was not required; however, all views expressed are this reader’s honest thoughts of this fantastic book. I look forward to reading more of Jan Drexler’s books when they are released.

Profile Image for Jo.
114 reviews1 follower
May 30, 2017
In 1846 Naomi Schrock is a good Amish woman who has adopted young Davey a few years ago, after her family came upon him after his family had been killed. She is a single woman who still lives at home with her family, but everyone agrees that Davey belongs to her.

Cap Stoltzfus moves into their area and begins building his home and farm, Davey ventures over and makes friends with Cap and naturally Naomi and Cap start a blossoming friendship as well. The path between the two farms becomes well worn as invitations come for dinners and picnics.

Naomi thinks no one will want to marry her because she adopted Davey as a single woman, but she will not give up her beloved Davey. But she is beginning to have stronger feelings for Cap.

Cap is having romantic feelings for Naomi, fatherly feelings for Davey-but he thinks that Naomi isn't parenting Davey properly and is outspoken about it. This leads to hurt feelings and harsh words between Cap and Naomi. Will they ever get past this?

Preacher Shem Fischer moves into the area, he has heard that the district needs more preachers in the area. He has come from Ontario. His wife is there with her parents, she was to sick to come. Shem will find a place for them and then she will follow after, when she feels better.

Cap went to school with Shem. He remembers the taunts and bullying from Shem and wonders if the Lord has worked a miracle with Shem or if Shem is still the same old Shem.

This is a great book, it gets you to thinking about many different things. The characters are highly developed. Many different characters, several different sidelines going off to make the book even more interesting.

I received a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Cheryl.
6,618 reviews237 followers
June 20, 2017
This book may be the third and final in this trilogy but it can be read as a stand alone novel. I liked Naomi and Davey. He was such a sweet and curious boy. The way that he attached himself instantly to Cap was charming. Davey needed a male figure in his life and he found a good one in Cap. Plus, Cap as able to heal as well.

While, I liked this book, I did struggle with the pacing of the story. It was slow. I like that the author set up the location and the people but after a while, it felt like there was more talking without much else happening. In fact, there was times where I must admit that I skipped ahead. Yet, I never really felt like I missed anything but doing this. In regards, to the religion aspect, I found this book to not be preachy. I have read a couple books now from this author and I am slowly finding my footing with the author and would read more.
Profile Image for Staci.
2,308 reviews673 followers
July 29, 2017
Naomi's Hope is the conclusion to the Journey to Pleasant Prairie Series. Naomi lacks self confidence and believes she will never marry. She puts her focus on her "adopted" son Davey.

My favorite parts about this novel were the imagery of stains on shirts as a way to describe sin and how it's taken away and the villain Shem. Shem's focus on destroying main male character Cap was extensive, yet believable.

The division between two Amish communities in Indiana was based upon fact. One community found the other to be too conservative and conversely the community deemed to be conservative found the other to be too progressive.

It was an enjoyable series and recommended for fans of Historical Amish novels.

My gratitude to publisher Revell for a Net Galley copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
Profile Image for victoria.
347 reviews2 followers
June 4, 2017
This book was a wonderful writing and compelling to read with the good of romantic full line of the beautify line of story telling in a good of historical was in the mid - 1800s, Drexler's historical fiction, that base on love, family, grief, forgiveness, restoration and has intriguing plots of sweet roman that will give you all the story from the begging to the end of the books. I highly recommend to everyone must to read this book. " I received this book free from Revellreads for this review
Profile Image for Cherese Akhavein.
423 reviews
August 25, 2017
Book 3 in the Journey to Pleasant Prairie Series by Jan Drexler " Noami's Hope"
First let me say what a wonderful way to wrap up a series!!! Jan Drexler has done a super job with this collection and you really don't want to miss it! I'm going to keep my review short a I don't want to spoil to much. Let me just say if your looking for history, adventure, faith, love, heartbreak, compassion, understanding, peace, you will find it all so much more in this series! Jan Drexler brings you right into the heart of Amish life in the 1800 and you will learn how early life for them really was.
Noami's life and hope was one of simple understanding, love, and to care for her adopted little boy Davey who her family found while traveling to their new home in Pleasant Prairie. Davey's entire family was killed during a storm/tornado and Noami's family friend Jacob found Davey hiding in the only remaining structure left on the cabin the fireplace. Noami and Davey quickly became insuperable and for all accounts Naomi became Daveys adopted mommi.
Cap Stolzfuz moved to pleasant Prairie to start a new life after his wife and son died in childbirth,
Davey quickly becomes friends with Cap after all who would not get along with the spirited Davey,
Now Cap realizes he is starting to have feeling for Naomi's how will she feel about that? Come find out
The rest of Naomi's story you won't be sorry, it's a fantastic book and series.
341 reviews2 followers
June 1, 2017
Naomi’s Hope by Jan Drexler is an Amish historical romance novel, focusing on the kindhearted Naomi Schrock. Naomi has an adopted son, Davey, but she also longs for marriage. The characters were likeable, and I enjoyed seeing Naomi make choices in life and in love. Davey was a nice addition to the cast of characters; many Amish romance novels center upon a single, childless woman looking for love, so it was nice to see Naomi as a mother who wanted the best for herself and her son. I liked the setting of northern Indiana, because Amish fiction novels are often set in Pennsylvania. Drexler uses vivid description in her writing, and the book has a charming, cozy feeling to it. Naomi’s Hope is a heartwarming story.

*I received this book for review*
Profile Image for Mardell.
405 reviews1 follower
June 18, 2017
Naomi's Hope is book three in Jan Drexler's Journey to Pleasant Prairie series. I have enjoyed this series from the start of the journey along the Conestoga Creek through to arriving after many trials to their land in La Grange County, Indiana in 1843. Three years have passed and the community that started as a dream is now settling into permanent homes. Families are thriving, crops are plentiful and there is peace among their new church district and it continues to grow.

Naomi Schrock has raised her adopted seven-year old Davey for three years. They found him, the lone survivor of a Tornado hiding inside a large fireplace. The storm killed his parents and baby sister and raised the house and farm to rubble. Single and likely to remain so, Naomi loves and dotes on Davey.

Cap Stoltzfus moved to the area for a fresh start. He lost both his wife and son in childbirth seven years ago and is determined to break free of his grief. By chance, Christian Yoder drops by the clearing where Cap is building his home alone. It doesn't take long for Christian to size things up and organize a house raising. The work of many hands quickly builds the sides and roof of his home. Overwhelmed by the generosity of his new neighbors Cap quickly becomes one of their own.

Davey found Cap first, quite by accident simply by being a curious boy of seven. Their farms are adjacent and it's not long before Davey wore a path is to Cap's. Both are taken with each other and develop a special bond. Naomi and Cap, through Davey, spend time together, developing feelings for one another. Could they possibly become a family?

Naomi's Hope (Journey to Pleasant Prairie Book #3) by [Drexler, Jan]This is a story of strength, courage and forgiveness. When community warmly welcomed Cap, they also welcomed Shem Fischer, a minister from Canada to the area. Shem is agreeable, seemingly devout and insinuates himself comfortably among the people. Cap is wary, having known Shem under different circumstances growing up. Before long, there is rising mistrust that threatens to splinter the community. It takes courage and strength to rise above strife.

Davey is central to the story, tying so many facets together. Young and innocent, his strongest desire is to have a family. His story will win your heart as he weaves into and out of mishaps. My heart was warmed by this special young man and the love he truly brings to his family. I heartily recommend this book. I have grown fond of the characters in this series. I admire the strength and courage they had to move from their homes and travel to a new land only to start over.

"Jan Drexler brings a unique understanding of Amish traditions and beliefs to her writing. Her ancestors were among the first Amish, Mennonite, and Brethren immigrants to Pennsylvania in the 1700s, and their experiences are the basis for her stories. Jan lives in South Dakota with her husband, their four adult children, two active dogs, and a cat. She is the author of The Prodigal Son Returns, A Mother for His Children (winner of the 2013 TARA award), and A Home for His Family (finalist for the 2016 Inspirational Reader's Choice Award), as well as Hannah's Choice and Mattie's Pledge."- Amazon
1,294 reviews
June 15, 2017
Naomi's Hope, written by Jan Drexler, is book 3 in the Journey to Pleasant Prairies series. The year is 1846 and Naomi Schrock and her family have settled in an Amish community in Indiana. A few years earlier, Naomi and her family stopped at a home that had been damaged by a storm. Inside they found a little boy, Davey, who had hidden in the fireplace. He is the only one who survived. Naomi adopted Davey and is raising him with the help of her family. Every year they celebrate his birthday by allowing him to look through a box they took from the house. Inside the box are items that belonged to Davey's family, including the title to their property.
Davey is an energetic little boy and spends time walking to their new neighbor's place. Their new neighbor, Cap, is a single man who lost his wife and child years earlier. Davey and Cap develop a relationship and Davey wants to pretend Cap is his father. With Davey visiting Cap frequently, Naomi also spends time with Cap. Naomi doesn't feel any one would want her and Cap is still mourning his family. They develop a friendship but Naomi does not approve of Cap's suggestions and opinions of how she raises Davey.
A new preacher moves to the area. Shep and Cap knew each other when they were younger and Cap is not fond of Shep. Shep has left his wife with her family, saying her health was not good. She shows up at his door one day when a young girl is visiting him. When Shep does not get chosen to be a preacher for the area, he convinces the other Amish community to separate. Shep also breaks into the Schrock home, taking papers from Davey's box. On one of his travels and he meets a family that looks like Davey. He talks them into going back with him and pretending to be Davey's family. They will take Davey away and also get the papers for his family's property.
I really enjoyed this story. It is a nice blend of historical fiction and Amish fiction. While this book could be a stand alone story, reading the books in order will help the reader know other characters and events. While things happen that test the people's strength, the message of faith and hope are very evident in this story. The story gives us some incite into the Amish life and life in general at the time. While this is an Amish romance story, it is also a story of family and community coming together and helping each other out. I believe anyone who enjoys reading Amish stories will love this series.
I received a copy of this book from Revell Publishing and I have chosen to write this honest review.
341 reviews
July 3, 2017
Naomi Schrock and her family decided to move west to Pleasant Plain. It is the 1840’s so wagons are the mode of transportation; difficult and with danger always lurking around the bend. On their journey they came across a horrendous scene. A family’s home had been utterly destroyed and the only survivor was a small boy, Davey. The family took him in and their daughter Naomi adopted him as her own. In this book they have arrived at their destination and have been there 3 years. At seven years of age Davey is a lively, high spirited boy that gives Naomi a run for her money!
The new Amish settlement is prospering and many other families are coming to make it their home also. One of those people was a widower Cap Stolzfus. Still grieving over the loss of his wife and baby he is resolved to make a fresh start. His farm is beside Naomi’s parents. Davey meets Cap in one of times of exploration and they become fast friends. The young boy longing for a Dad and family decides to make believe Cap his father. As little ones will, he brings Naomi, her family, and Cap together as they become dear friends. Romance begins to blossom but both have doubts and concerns, not to mention their disagreement in how Davey should be raised.
An old acquaintance of Cap’s arrives at the settlement wanting to become a second minister. He presents himself as a man of the cloth, but is a sheep in wolves clothing. Cap knows Shem Fischer will be trouble and that is exactly what he brings to the peaceful community, especially Naomi.
The book is very exciting and fast paced. Not your usual Amish novel with mild conflicts and struggles. I liked that it shows a different side of the Amish life especially during that era. Davey’s antics and escapades were spot for a rambunctious boy that age. My heart went out to Naomi for trying to deal with his nonstop mischief. I liked it that the author fleshed out many characters with their own outlooks and experiences, but it was not hard to keep them straight. It added to the realism and entertainment of the story. I appreciated the fact that the characters lived out their faith and biblical principles no matter what hardships or problems they faced. A read alone book from the 1st two in the trilogy, but you definitely want to read the others!
I received this book from Revell Publications in exchange for an honest review. The opinions I stated are my own.
.


Profile Image for Jessica Baker (A Baker's Perspective).
1,436 reviews89 followers
July 5, 2017
This book combines two things I enjoy - Amish fiction with Historical fiction. It was so neat to see an Amish community start to grow and settle in the 1800's. And Ms. Drexler seemed to have the facts - right down to having land papers showing your ownership for property. I appreciated her including things like that, as it makes the story more realistic.

Two characters stood out in this book to me. First, little Davey. He certainly had a lot of energy, but he brought a light hearted mood to the book that I enjoyed. His relationship with Naomi was endearing, although I had mixed feelings about him wanting to find his "real family". I think selfishly I just wanted him to be content with Naomi, she was taking care of him and basically became his mother after all. Couldn't that be good enough? But let's face it, in real life people have real emotions and I imagine all of us would feel that way. Great job to the author for portraying realistic emotions, and not just the ones that we went to see!

The other character that stood out was Shem. Shem was the obvious villain, but I have to be honest. I never would have imagined a villain like him! He made me angry in most every scene he was in, and I just couldn't stop thinking about him. Typically bad guys do not get me worked up, I just roll with the punches knowing that it is just a book. So not the case here! The more I read about Shem, the more I had to keep reading to see what happened to him in the end. I needed to be sure justice would be served so to speak. I won't give that part away, but I will tell you that I was gnawing on my fingers waiting for some big scene where the community would learn the truth about Shem. One of the funniest scenes in this book was where Shem got an unexpected visitor at an inopportune time. I had a huge smile on my face and did literally laugh out loud! 

I don't think it matters if you are an amish fiction reader, or a historical fiction reader. Both will enjoy this book. I received a complimentary copy of this book. I was not required to write a favorable review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Tamara Tilley.
Author 10 books23 followers
June 24, 2017
NAOMI’S HOPE by Jan Drexler was an enjoyable read. The pacing is slow, but the story is charming.

Naomi Schrock has come to terms with her future. Knowing she isn’t overly attractive, and that she’s a single mother to Davey, an orphaned boy, Naomi figures her chances at love and marriage are not to be. Even when Cap Stoltzfus shows up and befriends Davey, Naomi figures his interest is solely in Davey. Though they strike up a friendship, Naomi assumes that is the extent of Cap’s feelings for her.

Cap Stoltzfus is still mourning the death of his wife and child. Settling on property next to the Schrock family, Cap feels an instant attachment to Davey. The young boy is curious, bright, and makes Cap feel alive again. Cap also develops a friendship with Naomi, but they have different opinions when it comes to God and raising Davey, so Cap isn’t sure their relationship will grow deeper than friendship.

As Naomi and Cap navigate their feelings for each other, a stranger shows up in town, causing trouble for Cap and Naomi, and division in the community. Cap knows this man from his past, and expects he’s up to no good. But, never in his wildest dreams would he have guessed the lengths this man would go to, to seek his revenge.

NAOMI’S HOPE is much like other Amish-themed books. There is a situation that challenges the characters commitment to the church and the rules of Ordnung. At times, the story slowed, having more talking than action, and the day’s events became repetitive. I understand the Amish culture is simple, but portraying that simplicity slowed the story down. I did like the characters Ms. Drexler penned. Cap is charming, Naomi is feisty despite her Amish upbringing, and Davey is adorable. The secondary characters rounded out the story well. But, I must say, the actions of Shem Fischer seemed a bit extreme. Overall, NAOMI’S HOPE was still an entertaining story.

I received this book through Revell Reads Blog Tour, and was not required to give a positive review. The review given is my honest opinion of the book.
Profile Image for Veronica.
1,059 reviews8 followers
July 4, 2017
I really enjoyed this well-written story! I liked Naomi and felt for her lack of self-confidence due to a physical issue. It was nice to see a character who wasn't portrayed as perfect. I also felt that she was very relatable in that she had a hard time forgiving. I think that's a hard issue for a lot of people to overcome. Cap was such a great guy. He really looked at Naomi's heart and took Davey under his wing and yet he wasn't afraid to say the hard things to Naomi when she needed to hear some truth or to be strict with Davey. It was wonderful to see both Cap and Naomi's transformations from someone who doesn't think God cares to someone who knows He does, from thinking He wants rule followers to knowing He wants your heart. I especially liked the part where Cap compared Naomi being a mother to God being a father and that He cares about what we're doing, if we're safe or happy, even what we had for breakfast! I liked that the gospel was spelled out simply and clearly. There were some good discussions about suffering and God's goodness. I was a little surprised that Cap first was going to obey God in something, then changed his mind. I was very frustrated with a character who showed up to cause some issues in the community and especially for Cap. It's hard to fathom someone who's deliberately evil like that, especially when he's supposed to be a man of God. He's also part of the reason it was hard to stop reading, though, because I wanted to find out what he would do next. I'm always amazed when I read Amish books to see their commitment to non-resistance. It really takes a lot of determination and trust in God to not fight back and I admire that, even if I don't always agree. There was a bit of romance. This worked well as a stand-alone, though it's book three, and it was nice to see characters from the first two books. I'd definitely recommend this book if you like Amish stories as it's one of the better ones I've read.

I received this book from Revell free to review.
Profile Image for Patty.
151 reviews
August 24, 2017

When I started reading Naomi's Hope I didn't know it was part of a trilogy, let alone the final book of it. I feel it could be a stand alone novel. It is the first time I have read any book by Jan Drexler. Her writing is good to me - really good. I started reading and couldn't stop! There Is no fluff or filler in this story. It is Historical Fiction, taking place in 1846. There are interesting details and descriptions about the characters and their way of life.

I would say the main character is Naomi Schrock but there is so much more than just her story. Naomi's Hope is about her whole community and the new life they are building. I enjoyed the liveliness of seven year old Davey, his age was depicted well.

I saw a few great themes throughout the book. Coming home is definitely one of them. Another theme is trust and who holds ours. It also pointed out how easy it is the be a believer in God but not really have a relationship with Him. Naomi's Hope is about finding out who one truly is to themselves, others, and God. It is a sweet romance that deals with joy, heartbreak, happiness, loss, envy, being unforgiving, forgiveness, trust, and hope. I am so glad to have been introduced to Jan Drexler and her writing through this novel. l was provided a complimentary review copy of this book. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
Profile Image for Brandi (Rambles of a SAHM).
817 reviews33 followers
July 13, 2017
I have been eagerly waiting for Naomi's story since the beginning of this series. Naomi is such a gentle and giving person and to see her be passed by time after time was heartbreaking. But of course we know that everything comes in God's timing.

It's looking like Naomi is going to have to be content to just be a momma to her adopted son Davey. A husband doesn't seem to be in her future. But just as she's determined to set that dream aside her family gets a new neighbor in the form of Cap Stoltzfus. He's kind and handsome to boot so of course Naomi is sure he would have no interest in her. Naomi is selling Cap short. He sees beyond her physical imperfections and into her heart.

Naomi's Hope was a wonderful conclusion to the Journey to Pleasant Prairie series. Lots of intriguing situations that remind us that the Amish communities face many of the same issues as the rest of the world. Some people are deceitful and can't be trusted. While others can be truthful and very trustworthy. Discerning the difference between the two is a blessing the Holy Spirit brings.

This series left me wanting to know what happens next in the lives of these interesting people. I hope that Jan sneaks some of them in the next series she writes!

I received a copy of this book to facilitate my review.
1,575 reviews30 followers
October 27, 2017
My Thoughts on this book
Naomi Shrock is content with living with her family and her son Davey. That is until Cap Stoltzfus moves into the area and starts giving Naomi a little attention. The beginning of this story starts out slow, and difficult to keep your attention. But wanting to know the end results for Davey and Naomi, I kept reading and it gets much better. Naomi’s character got on my nerves some because she has so self confidence, but this was a good thing because it kept me reading to see if that would change. Even when Cap shows interest. I like Cap. He was very good with Davey, and Davey needed the man in his life.

And then he couple shows up claiming to be family of Davey’s and wanting to claim the land belonging to Davey. To me this entire scene was off or something. It was too fast happening and almost no details. It just didn’t seem to fit, but maybe that’s the way things happened back in the 1840’s. Overall this is a very nice read. And a nice ending to this series. I encouraged you to grab a copy for yourself. You will enjoy the few hours of entertainment!

I received this book from Revell to read and review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 55.
Profile Image for Angela (Kentuckybooklover) Brocato-Skaggs.
1,978 reviews37 followers
July 6, 2017
I would have given 3.5 stars if the option was available. The reason for 3/3.5 stars is the book started out very slowly for me. The blurb made the book sound so good I kept at it but it did not pick up for me until a little over a quarter of the way through it. The last forty percent of the book was very good.

A few years before the book starts Naomi adopted a young boy, Davey, her and her family found hiding in his family's chimney after a tornado destroyed the property and killed his family. They have since moved to LaGrange, Indiana with other Amish families to start a new settlement. Davey befriends the new neighbor, Cap, and has his heart set on making him his new friend and dad. As Davey works on his plan, a few scrapes and almost near tragedies almost derail the plan. Will Naomi and Cap fall in love to create the family Davey so desperately desires?

As I mentioned before the book had its slow spots but it is a book I would recommend to others. The history woven into the story is very interesting. I also found it interesting as I have visited the modern day LaGrange, Indiana to see the Amish and I found it fascinating to learn about how it started.

This is the third book in a series. I have not read the first two but have put them on my list of books to read.
Profile Image for Linda.
457 reviews24 followers
June 13, 2017
The Journey to Pleasant Prairie series ends with Naomi’s Hope, a wonderful story set in an 1846 Amish community in Indiana. Although there are various trials and tribulations, I found the common thread woven throughout the story is hope. The characters are so authentic; however, you will find there are a couple of exceptions! Although words like selfless and brave describe Naomi Schrock, she struggles with her faith. As a single woman, she adopts a recently orphaned young boy named Davey. Rambunctious Davey befriends newly arrived and widowed neighbor, Cap Stoltzfus. Davey confides in Cap how desperately he wants a family, the kind with a ma and pa. Will Cap help Naomi discover the faith she needs, or will her heart be broken? Can Davey find the family he yearns for so badly? Naomi’s Hope is a captivating story filled with inspiration, trust, and seeking to make the right choices. I look forward to reading the first two in the series and felt this book was completely stand-alone. You’ll want to add this series to your must-read stash!
I was given a complimentary copy by the author/publisher.
Profile Image for Kathleen Friesen.
Author 7 books40 followers
June 25, 2017
When I requested Naomi’s Hope, I didn’t realize it was the final installment of a trilogy, Journey to Pleasant Prairie. If I had, I would have read the other two first, as there were times it seemed I’d missed some important information. Not so much that it bothered me, mind you. This story is well told, with a large cast of characters, each important in their own way.
This story focusses on Naomi, Cap, and Davey, but Naomi’s family have struggles that impact her journey—especially her sisters. Other members of the community, such as Christian and Annalise, faced severe trials with amazing faith. Their part in the story truly moved me.
Then there’s Shem, and old nemesis of Cap’s who wanders into the new Amish settlement with manipulations and plans to further his wicked plans. His machinations raised my blood pressure—an effective villain.
Naomi and Cap endure a difficult path back to faith, and thanks to the author’s skillful writing, I traveled it with them. Naomi’s Hope earns four stars and is recommended.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher; all opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.