In 'Cape Refuge', Thelma and Wayne Owens are saviours to released prisoners, thanks to their efforts in running Hanover House. Although the Owens are well-liked, not everyone is happy about having prisoners living amongst innocent people. Their son-in-law, Jonathan Cleary is adamant about getting his wife Morgan to move out. Shortly after he has an argument with them, they are found murdered hence making him the top suspect..
The first chapter was well-written and engaging. The heated discussions and arguments at the City Council Meeting highlighted the residents' understandable concerns about Hanover House. They simultaneously showed how Thelma and Wayne's daughters, Morgan and Blair were united in ensuring that no one shut down the home. The ending of that chapter instantly led to the shocking murders. Unfortunately, everything went downhill beginning from chapter two.
Despite the crime and mystery elements, this book was incredibly boring because the content was repetitive and uneventful. By the time I was close to the halfway point of the story, I could summarize the story as follows:
Thelma and Wayne were murdered. Everyone is in disbelief. Who could kill such sweet, kind people? They would help anyone. They were such angels. Why would anybody harm them? Did I mention they were kind? Yes, but let me mention it again (since that's what the author did).
Jonathan was immediately arrested because he owned the murder weapon. Never mind the fact that the stupid cop, Cade had little to no other supporting evidence.
Jonathan: I didn't do it, Cade! You have to believe me!
Cade: Sorry Jonathan but right now you look the most guilty.
Jonathan: But I'm not! You're my best friend, how could you do this to me?
Cade: I feel bad, okay. But it's my job to arrest you even though I don't want to.
Morgan: How could you arrest my husband, Cade? You know he's innocent!
Cade: Morgan, I wish I didn't have to but the weapon points to him.
Morgan: He didn't do it. He'd never do such a thing. You're wrong, Cade!
Cade: It's my job to arrest him, Morgan. Believe me, I don't want to.
The entire police procedural was not only inaccurate; it was also unrealistic and laughable. More importantly, Morgan was an idiot for not getting a lawyer to help free Jonathan. It could have been accomplished so easily since Cade was unable to place Jonathan at the crime scene and to prove without a doubt that he was the killer. Throughout the story, Cade pretty much did little to no investigating and instead tossed several people into jail without ever getting into trouble. Another thing that bothered me was how all the suspects (with criminal records) had no problems answering Cade's questions. Really? Not a single "I want my lawyer"?
Besides that, this sentence (among many) made it impossible not to roll my eyes: "With her library skills and command of the Internet, Blair was usually able to come up with information as fast as he (Cade) could". That sentence single-handedly dismissed police as utterly pointless because hey, all you need are "library skills" and internet access to solve crimes! To make things worse, there were numerous times where Blair relayed information (acquired through research via computer) to Cade. Who's the cop now??
The revelation of the identity of the murderer wasn't even satisfying enough to justify plodding through page after page of nonsense. The motive wasn't wholly convincing and the crime didn't quite fit the motive either. In addition, I was only curious to learn more about what had caused Blair's facial scars only to get a mediocre delivery that went like this: Cade found a newspaper article. Read it and told Blair to do the same and voila, the mystery behind her scars was solved! Talk about underwhelming..
Overall, 'Cape Refuge' should've been called 'Camp Disaster' considering the awful repetitive content, painfully flat characters and non-existent police procedural.