I really wonder about all the reviewers throwing out all these 4 & 5 star ratings to everything they read.
Is this some kind of stupid participation award? Yay! You wrote words! First place blue ribbon for you!
The only problem is, if every book is the best thing you’ve ever read: A) you need to find a new rating method, because auto 5 star artificially makes awful books better than they are AND cheapens truly extraordinary work by rating them the same as everything else; B) you need to raise your standards; and C) you are letting your fellow readers down with inaccurate reviews AND not doing authors favors by NOT providing honest and fair reviews.
Being an author is terrifying. You put your heart and soul on the page, then submit yourself to judgement hoping that others like your work. The LAST thing you need is someone blowing smoke up your ass, telling you that your work is really good, when it is really not.
I can equate this to some contestants on shows like America’s Got Talent or So You Think You Can Dance, where the contestant is so abysmally awful, but thinks they’re the best because no one in their life ever bothered to tell them the truth. This benefits no one.
Yes, being an author is terrifying, but I would rather have an honest review telling me that I’m awful, than someone giving me 5 stars but being dishonest. Sure, that would sting, but I’ll get over it. It’s ok to not like something, and I’ll value your honesty more, and moreover, thank you for it.
Now, for this book. Ugh. Usually, I’m a sucker for rock star romance, but this one fell so far short.
First, the H, Harry Stiles, pardon, Harley Stile was cliche and one-dimensional, with quite a few requisite dirty phrases thrown in. Second, he was a really awful person, pursuing and sexually assaulting Kate, even though he knows she has a boyfriend.
Kate is also awful for allowing it. I want to know why the feelings of discontent about Ian didn’t surface until she encountered Harry, oops, Harley. (Ok, I’ll quit it now, I promise) And why is it always, ‘I’ve never felt like this before. I’m no virgin, but no one has ever made me feel like this!’ Again, if every author write this, then it’s nothing special.
Cliffy! Oh, how I hate cliffhangers.
Also, I think it’s really funny that the picture on the cover is of a man wearing boxing gloves and shorts.
I didn’t like this book at all.
There, I said it.