In “Easy Innocence,” Libby Fischer Hellmann creates Georgia Davis, a former Chicago cop who was suspended from the force and who ends up working as a private investigator, while still hoping for reinstatement to her former job. It’s not entirely clear how long she has been on her own, but she’s having trouble making it and is happy to take a new case referred to her by a former mentor on the force (the stereotypical Sergeant O’Malley). The case, on its face, is helping a public defender (later replaced by a private defense lawyer) defend an autistic man who has been accused of a brutal murder. The victim is a beautiful high school junior at a trendy North End school. From the beginning, it seems like the mentally challenged man could not be guilty, and Georgia launches into the case to prove his innocence. The trail takes Georgia into a complex web of characters and events that also leads her into personal danger in which she gets shot at, her apartment gets burned down, and she spends a lot of time sleeping at a friend’s house. The plot moves along quickly, with many twists, and there is no shortage of action and motion throughout.
On the plus side, Ms. Hellmann’s prose is well-written and rich in detail. At times the level of detail is a little distracting and unnecessary, but the word picture drawn by the author is often engaging and beautiful. The main characters are also well-drawn and have rich back stories. We learn in small snippets Georgia’s history, her romance with a fellow cop that broke up a few years before, and we get to know her quirks and personality. She meets a recently divorced man who moves into her apartment building and there is a potential romance developing. We see what Georgia likes to cook and the clothes she likes to wear. We get insight into Georgia’s mind as the rest of the plot moves along. The peripheral characters are less deeply developed, but all are interesting and diverse enough to hold our interest.
The plot is interesting in both its broad strokes and also its small details. There is no real mystery about the secret lives of these high school girls, but how that interrelates to the other characters and eventually circles back to the murder of Sara is not obvious and is not fully revealed until late in the game. It’s a quick read and keeps the reader interested throughout. Georgia is a character that, by the end, you care about and you want to see how her PI practice pans out in the next book.
On the down side, there are far too many editing errors, which can be distracting. It’s a first book in the series, but the author should have gone back and cleaned up the technical issues before sending this out as a free sample in order to try to hook new readers. More significantly, the plot devices are a little too contrived, even for a light mystery. The appearance of Georgia’s former lover and the woman he left her for, are not really necessary to the story and distract more than add. The main coincidence that binds the whole plot together is so unbelievable (how could he not know?) that it impacts the reader’s ability to buy into the rest. An author in a mystery can get away with one or two instances where the protagonist stumbles upon some key bit of evidence, or makes a lucky guess, but when Georgia’s ability to solve the case is predicated upon a half-dozen such serendipitous events, along with her unexplainable ability to guess the key event without much context, it’s hard for the reader to remain fully engaged.
The action sequences are compelling, although here again there are some holes in the narrative, but in the end there is a satisfying finish and enough unresolved issues in Georgia’s life that there is plenty of fodder for future stories.