“Their time apart had truly separated them. Now they seemed to be little more than strangers fumbling into an acquaintanceship. They traversed separate paths, the distance between them ever widening. It saddened her to consider they might never truly converge.” Sebastian had been living on nothing but the need for retribution ever since his birthright was stolen from him years ago. Now a hardened and scarred man, he finally came back for what is rightfully his. Lady Mary Wynne-Jones was shocked to discover that her childhood best friend was alive. There had been many rumors surrounding the lost Lords of Pembrook, speculations whether they were alive or not. Lady Mary had suffered greatly when she helped the said the Lords escape. Now that Sebastian is back, he was nothing like the boy she loved dearly as a friend in her younger years. Many things have changed. He is a scarred man and she is betrothed to another man but she can't help the need to help her old friend. But this need to help might just lead to many problems...one that could be solved by marriage to each other!
She Tempts the Duke is the first book from Lorraine Heath's historical romance series, The Lost Lords of Pembrook. Well, Who am I if not reading a series out of order? I've already read Rafe's story, the third and last book from this series which I've enjoyed better than this one. I had a hard time thinking of a synopsis because there was so much going on in the book yet it felt dry. I do not know if I am getting harder to please or if this book was just not satisfying at all.
Meet Lady Mary Wynne-Jones. She is the daughter of an earl. She was sent to a convent by her father when she helped Sebastian and his two younger brothers escape the tower which they were locked in by his uncle. She had her first season in London at age four and twenty, way past the marrying age (by society's standards back then). She was quickly betrothed to a viscount, heir to a marquessate. Her betrothed loved her dowry more than her. She fancied the said viscount. She was like a door mat at first, allowing her father and betrothed to tell her how to act. But she eventually grew a backbone and was back to being the girl who was courageous enough to help the young Lords escape their uncle's scheming.
Meet Sebastian Easton, Duke of Keswick. At age 14, he and his brothers escaped from their mad uncle who planned to kill them off in order to gain the title. He had no choice but to go separate ways with his brothers, ensuring that at least one of them survives to reclaim what is rightfully theirs. He spent years serving in the military. He is now a scarred man, literally. But he finally came back to reclaim his title as the rightful Duke and his beloved lands, most especially Pembrook.
Lady Mary and Sebastian were childhood bestfriends. They were very close. But of course, with the circumstances, Sebastian had to escape. They met again at a ball hosted by his uncle. He made a very grand entrance with his brothers. Mary was shocked but very happy to know that Sebastian and his brothers were still alive. Years being away from London and its glittering world, The Duke has a hard time adjusting. Mary sees that she's fit to help Sebastian. Many years had passed since the night she last saw him but her care for him is just the same. This need to help Sebastian eventually led to many scandals, ruining Mary's reputation and causing her betrothed to call off the engagement. Sebastian then offered marriage which she accepted. But Sebastian has many things he needs to over come, the marriage is not smooth-sailing. Things happen and he realizes that Mary is much more important than any of his lands and title. The end.
Oh wow this book was disappointing. I love Lorraine Heath's writing— especially the way she writes angsty books, she nails it most of the time. But she failed this time. Sadly, I felt nothing. The chemistry was not there. It felt so dry. I liked them enough to keep reading. It flowed well and I finished this book in one sitting but there was something lacking. I just did not believe in their love. The ending felt so rushed. There were so many things happening at once but at the same time it felt like there was nothing happening?
I loved the trope served here, could've been better if executed well. I am a sucker for Childhood BFFS to strangers to lovers. It sure is a recipe for an angsty read but this one just did not hit the right spot. I am not even sure I loved either of the heroine or hero. I did not dislike them, but I did not love them. They were just okay. The uncle was stupid and the reasons for his actions were cringy. Did he die in the end? I could not tell. The climax was so dramatic, I can't. Also, I am not the biggest fan of the sudden realization of undying love. I could be if it was done right but sadly, it did not work in this book. It felt very contrived. Anyway, I loved Lord Tristan and of course, Rafe. Their back story saddened me. But the romantic aspect of the book felt lacking.
Sebastian was an okay hero. I felt quite sad for him regarding his relationship with his brothers. I totally understand his motivations but well...“I could not take you with me. Not twelve years ago. I can take you with me now.” “It’s too late.” this made me sad. He was trying to be a good brother but at his young age, he could not be. Ahh! I loved whenever Lord Tristan and Lord Rafe appeared in this book. There were redeeming parts. It was not all that bad. It could have been better maybe if there was more chemistry? Then maybe I would've felt the angst.
Mary was an okay-ish heroine. Her time in the convent felt so random and was not discussed properly. It felt like the author just threw it there for the sake of it. She was so annoying at first, trying to please her fiancé who was obnoxious and later on married her cousin, Alicia. I liked her aunt, Lady Ivers and how she was the number one Sebastian and Mary shipper. I liked Mary enough to keep the story going but she isn't going on my list of favorite book heroines.
Over all, I am rating this book a 3 because it's not so bad that it should be given a two. However, it is not the most satisfying. Pretty forgettable and did not stand out. I wanted to love this so bad but I just didn't and it's sad. I hope my next Lorraine Heath read is more satisfying!
Some quotes:
"It was a public acknowledgment that regardless of how tattered her reputation, he would stand proudly beside her."
“How in God’s name do you think I would suffer if you were my wife?” “I bring with me scandal.” “You are no more notorious than I.” She bit her lip, gave a curt laugh. “I suppose our notoriety is tied together, isn’t it?” “Very much so.”
“For a moment it was almost as though they were there, as though the pain and separation of the intervening years had never happened.”
She clutched his arms. “Don’t leave me, Sebastian. Take me with you.” “I’m Keswick now. And I can’t take you with me, but I promise you that I shall return. Ten years, on this night, at the abbey ruins.” Bending down he gave her a kiss, brushing his lips so quickly and lightly over hers that it resembled little more than touching a butterfly’s wings as it took flight. “Thank you, Mary. I’ll never forget what you did for my brothers and me.”