I stumbled across this series of books because the first one is called "Seven Spiders Spinning," and my son Harry loves books about spiders, so that was that. I was happy to see that it was part of a series because he loved it, and laughed basically all the way through.
Then when I was adding it to the list of books he's read I noticed that some of the reviewers here were, shall we say, less than enthusiastic about it. By that time we'd taken it back to the library and Harry had finished "Six Haunted Hairdos" and was giggling madly halfway through "Five Alien Elves," so I thought I'd pick it up and give it a read.
Loved it!
The story is original and engaging, the characters are funny and interesting, the language is excellent. Most of the criticisms I read either missed the mark or missed the point.
One person said the children's names seemed "dated" - so what? Comical and descriptive naming is common to lots of great writers - from Dickens to Dahl - and doesn't detract from the story at all. I also liked that the characters' names reflected a diverse society, as opposed to being all Dick & Jane.
Another said that the children's dialogue didn't seem realistic. True, it's no Junie B Jones, but I tend to see good grammar as a plus. Also, my son does talk like that, sometimes. Other times, he says, "Hulk! Smash!" I prefer the full, well-constructed sentences.
Finally, to those critics who think the humour in this series is aimed too old - more for the parents than the kids - while I love the humour as a middle-aged woman, my son loves it more as a six-year-old boy.
We are always on the lookout for age-appropriate, not-too-scary, not-too-mature (but also not boring) chapter books to keep him busy, and I am so glad we stumbled across Gregory Maguire. Will definitely recommend the series to other kids!