*** I received this book for free from Tasty Book Tours in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review, which was originally published on book blog Will Read for Feels.
When it comes to Georgian and Regency romance, nothing beats a ducal hottie in my book—it’s terrible, I know, but “duke” tends to grab my attention far earlier than “marquess” or “earl” or “viscount,” not to mention “baron.” Eek! I guess that makes me a historical romance snob! Nevertheless, when given the chance to check out Addie Jo Ryleigh’s The Duke’s Temptation, I immediately signed up for a review copy.
Although in my defense, this wasn’t just for the chance of ducal yumminess; I also liked that this book featured the whole big-brother’s-best-friend trope that’s a particular favorite of mine. And while this is my first Addie Jo Ryleigh book, it worked out okay for me, mostly thanks to the strengths of its characters—and its heroine, in particular.
But I’m getting ahead of myself. Let me introduce you to the characters: Gabe St. James is the sixth Duke of Wesbrook, and he isnt’ exactly a paragon of virtue and nobility when this book starts out. He’s something of an indolent womanizer, and he would rather leave the managing and oversight of his estate to his steward than see to matters himself. But he gets a rude awakening in the very first scene when he is confronted with the existence (and presence) of his illegitimate daughter, brought to his home after the death of her mother, the woman he had once thought to marry.
What follows is a struggle to prove himself better than his philandering father raised him to be, the same father who left several by blows himself and cared for none of them. Gabe, in his quest to care for his daughter, gains an unexpected ally in Lady Elizabeth Blakely, sister to his best friend, Marcus, Earl of Foxmoore. She’s also the one woman he desires above all but refuses to burden with the mess of his life and his emotional baggage.
Little does he know that Elizabeth has adored him since childhood and that he’s the reason why she’s turned down the offers of marriage she’s received thus far. Initially, she volunteers to act as the temporary companion and kinda-sorta-governess to his daughter while assisting him in finding a permanent solution in order to get closer to Gabe and show him she is no longer the child who trailed after him and her brother on their adventures. But she soon finds herself enchanted by Phoebe, Gabe’s daughter, and with her heart engaged on two fronts, she is all the more determined to make Gabe accept and return her love. Problem: it’s not quite as simple as batting her eyelashes and parading about in her night clothes.
As I’ve already mentioned, I quite enjoyed the characters in this novel. I particularly liked how Elizabeth took her destiny into her own hands, went after what she wanted, and, when it looked like Gabe didn’t return her affections, decided that she (and her love for him) was worth nothing less than love freely given and a full life partnership. She decided that she wouldn’t settle for what scraps of affection she could get from Gabe, no matter how deeply she cared about him.
I guess the reason why I couldn’t five-star this story was the way the mystery was handled. Early on in the story, Gabe received a note from a blackmailer threatening to reveal a painful secret from his past. Then, later, it appeared that someone was determined to harm Elizabeth, little Phoebe, or both the females who’d won Gabe’s heart.
While the idea of a blackmailer forcing the duke to confront his past was a good one, the excuse for it seemed weaker than it could be. Add to that the very anticlimactic resolutions to these two sources of conflict, where one villain turned out not to be a villain at all, but someone rather pathetic, and the true villain ended up being a character who seemed to come out of nowhere, well, it kind of made me wish the author had dispensed with the mystery altogether and focused instead on the layered interpersonal relationships between the characters.
Still, I’m curious to learn about the fate of some of the supporting characters we met in this series, so here’s to hoping I can get my hands on book 2.