If you want to think highly of Dogfish Head and Sam Calagione please grab a copy of "Brewing Up a Business" and never ever ever get even close to this book. It's that bad. Yes.
For background - all the times throughout my homebrewing years to opening and growing my brewery I have been a fan of Sam and Dogfish Head. I had Dogfish Head hoodie, and I wore it to rags as I was determined that next one will be one with my brewery logo. I liked "Brewing Up a Business" a lot. It was authentic, passionate, insightful and fun read. It was motivating and inspiring. So I was hoping for next installment for a series - how small and budding brewpub grows into the internationally celebrated brand. Although, I got something very different.
First, it failed my "one hour test." If nothing interesting happens after one hour of reading it does not deserve any more of my time. Nothing happened in first few chapters. Given my particular relationship with Dogfish, I did make a rare exception and kept going, but it didn't get any better.
There was a nagging feeling that this full story is not genuine. After 20 years there is understanding that Sam's management style needs to change. But why? 20 years of running a successful business using "I'm majority stakeholder, and you do that I tell" and suddenly - "We need to change" with no hint of why. Dogfish is doing very well and keeps innovation, at the same time, best-selling beers have been around for the decade. Everyone is super happy and supportive and yadda-yadda, but we need to change. Why? If this is a real insight of the need for leadership style change why you still need signs in your car and tattoo to remind you of your decisions? For me, it's highly unlikely that Dogfish made such change without significant internal or external pressure. But actual "why" is carefully avoided. So we don't know.
Another problem for me is that it tells about intention, not about experience. Bookshelves are brim-full with well-intentioned and well-written books based on what someone thinks how one should run a company. Very few books are the reflection of real life experience. It would be a valuable book if, after few years, it would tell how Sam turned Dogfish around. Writing down your intentions and plans was probably very useful exercise for Sam, but it makes a lousy book. Reality has not yet given it's feedback to this lovely plan.
This book is full of marketing - how innovative we are, how creative is this beer, how we received this award, how our customers love us, etc. It forms constant background noise, and you feel like reading real estate ads for new homes.
No business or leadership ideas are being communicated. I was expecting some new and insightful ways how Dogfish Head is being managed. Preferably backed by real-life experience. What worked, what didn't work, why something worked and some other thing didn't. All you get in first half of the book is an intro to SWOT analysis.