The subtitle is a touch misleading as this is not really a book about playing golf, but a book about the sport in general, with the stories told by the people Plimpton meets as he plays in a few pro-am tournaments. It is timeless and doesn't really suffer from age, rather that there is quite a lot of filler.
The idea was that Plimpton would play in 3 PGA events after a warm-up invitational, to give a first-person account of a novice golfer playing in tournaments. His own experience actually took up quite a small proportion of the book, and clearly a round of golf (or 12) does not provide much material, hinted at when he writes of a previous round with a pro which yielded no copy whatsoever. There is a lot more about caddies, bar conversations and an odd creative writing exercise about a golfer stranded near a railroad crossing - I could have done without this fairly dull passage.
I did wonder at first whether his caddy was going to be the subject of cruel jokes, but this was generally a good-natured, humorous book rather than a caustic one, and it is Plimpton himself who is the butt of jokes. He is bad at golf, but only describes about 10 of his shots in detail and it is instead the minutiae of gift shop tat, translation misunderstandings in hotels and anecdotes pinched from his mobile library that provides the comic foil. It does give some insight into the sport and its characters, but the retelling of stories was disappointing as they tended to be rattled off one after another rather than woven into the narrative when appropriate.
Yet I did find myself smiling at a few of them. This was a readable book and despite some of the passages leaving me cold, it didn't feel as though it was far too long. Ultimately, it felt like Plimpton need not have bothered playing himself at all but instead hung around a few clubhouses to interview caddies and players. He is not a bad writer but nor was the book what I'd expected and there was limited value to the social history elements of a sixties book, and the compilation of golf anecdotes from others.