This might be one of the hardest reviews to write. On the first hand, James Rollins is in my top three authors, all tied for first place. When I buy his books, I countdown to the release date and then I devour them instantly. His style of writing is superb. His ability to link real world elements with fiction and fantasy is phenomenal. His character development is amazing. On the second hand, I had a really really hard time with this third installment of fantasy. I found big portions of it to be beyond boring, as in, I started skimming to get through what felt like redundant descriptive and repetitive descriptive sections. I felt like character development was much less creative or pronounced, and the storyline, in general, felt very slow. There were small sections peppered throughout that would grab me, hold me, and allow me to feel the “normal” James Rollins writing style and capture my full attention and intrigue, but then would without fail drop off again. While I love world building and the creation of something new, I had a hard time remembering the distinct different creations, places and peoples without constantly referencing back to the maps and pictures and even previous books. In all, there is really only a few characters I actually connected to or loved, and many of them just felt more distant, less defined, less developed. So while I feel more invested in the overall storyline (mostly because of how much I liked the first two books), this third one in some ways fell flat for me. Some elements of the storyline felt repetitive- here they go, to the other side of the world like they did in the last book, where they will encounter some major setback like they did in the last book, and face a new sect of enemy or people like they did in the last book, where they still won’t get to the ultimate goal of stopping moon fall, like the last book, and then they will learn of the next thing to do and head back home or to the next mission, like the last book. Of course none of the big enemies meet a fateful end, and it feels both redundant, aggravating and slow, with glimpses of excitement and tiny touches of development for only a few select characters. I wanted to love it as I love all of Rollins’ other things, but I just didn’t. I am kind of worried for the remainder of the series, and for what the next book holds (or doesn’t).