I don't post reviews on here anymore (just Storygraph) once I learned that Amazon owns those words, but as usual I don't care if they own words of my rage so here you go:
This was actually one of the worst books I've ever bothered to read. And I only bothered to keep reading it because I wanted to lean into my rage that I suddenly needed an outlet for.
Why was this book pretentious as fuck? Let me count the ways.
- She barely mentions books published this century.
- The chapter on ebooks / screen-reading was ableist as fuck. And it didn't even TOUCH audiobooks. Weird considering I read this via audiobook.
-There were like two small nuggets of wisdom buried....
-...under hypocritical essays. One essay would say one thing and then she would completely backtrack it two essays later???
-Not one mention of romance, the BILLION DOLLAR INDUSTRY THAT KEEPS THE REST OF THE BOOK INDUSTRY AFLOAT. How can you write a whole book about a subject while not mentioning the literal backbone of it.
- In fact, there is little to no mention of ANY genre fiction book. Just nonfic or lit fic as your options. Even when she is saying things like 'feeling stagnant in your usual reading genre? Try something different! If you normally read philosophy, try a self help! If you are used to fiction, try something in business!' Like who the fuck reads just those genres. That is not branching out. A lost opportunity to say to try a SPACE ADVENTURE if you are tired of philosophy; you get the same thought provoking social issues turned inside out in a way that is unique and creative and stimulates the brain. But nope, nothing remotely close to that.
The tiny bits of the essays I enjoyed can be counted on one hand. And so I'll share those with you so you don't have to suffer through the rest of the crap.
#6 Underlining and Annotations: She mentions what her thought process is while reading. And even while we are having complex thoughts and emotions while reading, when we finish a book, for most people, you forget a lot. So why bother if you're just going to forget? Well, here she quotes Patrick Süskind's Three Stories and a Reflection. The essay (reflection) at the end of the collection is called Amnesia in Litteris "describes how, despite reading voraciously for more than three decades, he barely remembers details of any book [.......] he arrives at the conclusion that reading isn't about remembrance, but the change. In reading, it is not memory but change that is most important. We change as we read books. We just don't realize it. And this change may have an impact on the course of our lives."
I just realized what I liked about this wisdom isn't even the author's herself, but her quoting someone else.
#8 Choose Books not the Internet: She gets a little into some studies that have been done about focus and our attention span. The book she quotes is 15 years old, so that was a little disappointing as there have been a few more published since then. But the basic ideas still fit, it's just worse now. The essay ends with this from her, "Instead of forcing ourselves to read, we need to ask ourselves this: What's making it more difficult to read these days? There are always other fun activities competing for our time, but the internet is also a distraction. To draw closer to books, we have to distance ourselves from the internet. And according to Carr [author of the Shallows], to rewire our brains and improve our attention span, we should read. The more we read, the better we will be able to focus."
That's in folks. Now you don't have to read it. Stop into your local indie bookstore to chat with booksellers if you want to find your next book or need help on where to go next. Any bookseller worth their salt wouldn't dare hand you this book instead.