1 out of 5 stars
What an utter and complete waste of paper — the fact that this book has at least 62 different editions is a testament to the fact that publishing has always released absolute garbage and will continue to.
I’ve read some absolute drivel in my time as a student of language and an enjoyer of literature, but I have never been more relieved to be able to close the back cover of a book in my life.
Zinsser’s ‘On Writing Well’ is a book about how to write well, if you couldn’t tell from the title. Beyond the pretentiousness and egocentrism of this very quest, Zinsser thinks himself more of a professional writer than he is in actuality. Quite frankly, if you’re going to write a book on how to write well maybe follow the advice you preach within those pages.
Initially, when I began to comb through the first chapter of the book I was unsure if the humourless and arrogant persona was a purposeful attempt at teaching the readership about tone and narration. Unfortunately, he’s apparently just like that on a regular Tuesday.
This book may have a few valuable suggestions littered (however infrequently) throughout, but it is immensely difficult to reap any substance in Zinsser’s ‘lessons’ through the foggy sea of his sexism, cis-normativity, and eurocentrism.
My absolute favourite part of the book is in a section (truthfully, I can’t remember which chapter precisely) in which Zinsser touches on the use of pronouns and gender inclusivity and outright insists against using they/them pronouns. While I understand this book was initially published in 1976, gender non-conforming people aren’t a newly discovered species and have been around for a lot longer than that. Similarly, subsequent editions of the book weren’t published in 1976 — some have been published as recently as 2020 and 2021 and could have been amended.
Funnily enough, Zinsser does acknowledge that he had a lack of inclusivity in previous works of his; which is to say he acknowledged that he forgot women exist while he was working on other writings. However, he then proceeds to spend what I generously estimate as 85 per cent of the book using examples exclusively about men. Similarly, the writer — us, the reader — is always, ALWAYS, referred to as he. Never once does Zinsser add she or, God forbid, they. Call it misogyny, call it male superiority, call it a borderline obsession with Woody Allen (Zinsser mentions him every other chapter), call it ego — whatever shoe fits.
While I cannot speak to the racism in this book on a personal level; I can attest that it is there. When describing a piece he wrote on a desert tribe, he exoticizes, others and dehumanises them with phrases pulled straight out of Joseph Conrad’s ‘Heart of Darkness’. Zinsser’s disdain for the “other” is evident in every chapter; from his ignorance of and refusal to use inclusive language, to ignoring the mere existence of women, to using dehumanising and exoticizing other cultures.
Another reviewer on Goodreads reviewed this book by saying “I wanted to stab the author in the ankles” and frankly that is a sentiment I can get behind.
Zinsser writes, very ironically that: “Clutter is the disease of American writing. We are a society strangling in unnecessary words, circular constructions, pompous frills, and meaningless jargon.” This essentially sets the tone for the entirety of Zinsser’s book — he demands the reader do one thing, such as don’t clutter your writing or be economic with your writing and then waffles on over 300 pages about the same thing. For instance, this book features two chapters — one titled Simplicity and the other titled Clutter — on the exact same topic; be economical when writing. How is two chapters about the same topic economical, dear Zinsser? How?!
Ultimately, if your desire is to write commercially and publish the lowest brow of content that appeals to the dullest, braindead, and intellectually lacking denominator of audiences then congratulations; this book is for you. Ironically, my workplace made me read this book as part of a professional development session to be a better content writer. Go figure.
If you’d like to read some actually good books on how to write well, try ‘Bird By Bird’ by Anne Lamott. ‘Story Genius’ by Lisa Cron, ‘Craft in the Real World’ by Matthew Salesses, or even ‘On Writing’ by Stephen King. Don’t read this. The best part about reading this book was getting to boot my copy down the stairs when I was done.