Another one....
I really was expecting this to be at least a fun read, I saw all the hype this was getting not so much in book communities just generally - like theres some big names attached to the movie and book 2 is out so I was hopeful bc I wanted to start a new fun sci fi series.
Clearly this wasnt the case for me! The writing was fine but with this kind of concept I was hoping to get into more existential questions of what it means to have your value be rooted in dying for others, being a tool for the good of the whole. How would that chnage a person, but here we mostly see him snark at people that 'being an Expendable is hard actually'. Would love it if there was a little more dread since they can essentially wake him up with changes to his recorded personality or produce a new mickey after days of a previous mickeys death, to know you have given people such absolute power and they think you're an abomination??? Isnt that terrifying? I think it goes some of the way with exploring this concept with the ship of theseus argument but the focus is very clearly elsewhere and I dokt think this novel had the right tone (was more lighthearted? Not sure how to explain)
I honestly dont know how I got the impression that this was a book centred around themes but I kept expecting thIs book to do more than it was. Leaving my expectations to the side I will say I very much enjoyed the little worldbuilding flashbacks exploring the history of space colonies, by far the best part of the book.
The way information was fed to us that changes our view of characters was so weird, I dont mind being given information in retrospect but what's the point when it doesnt really clarify anything? With nasha we get fed some information in mickeys inner dialogue that was actually pretty interesting and brought to the forefront some conflicts unique to the world (although it essentially recreates modern day xenophobia and racism but we move!) Howverr this reveal doesnt mean anything, it doesnt really give you this moment of realisation as to why she behaves as she does. It doesnt impact her choices later in the book either really so what was the point?
Every character is there to fulfil some purpose, and fair that's the case it most books but you need to make them interesting characters as well. The religion introduced exists to create conflict for Mickey and the concept of being an expendable, truly what else do we know about Natalists? It's just another aspect of the story that's created to serve the plot. Why is it that over halfway through we get information about why multiples are so reviled? It just feels silly, things will happen and then a flashback appears to explain to is how we should feel or alternatively explain why the characters are feeling a certain way, makes the story feel very patchwork with bits being jumbled up and out of order.
Finally my biggest gripe with this book, the mickeys are DUMB, they are so so unbelievably stupid. We are told over and over the dangers of people finding out they are multiples, but neither of them put nearly enough effort in to their disguise, they'll both be in different spots of the ship AT THE SAME TIME, no attempts at communication or keeping their stories straight. One of them will mess up their cover and just say 'oh sozzz Haha' ??? Make a fucking effort, it's a miracle they were able to keep things under wraps for so long. Now this could have been a reflection on how dying so many times can make someone reckless with their survival, or desensitized to idea of their own death, but that wasn't a purposeful choice here, the author wanted to give us stakes but they fall flat because of how the characters behaved.
The characterisation issues continue with Nasha who existed to be the perfect partner with very little else defining her as a character and the only other female character is implied to also have feelings for Mickey of course, who wouldn't...
The final straw for me was no matter how stupid mickey is he is the only one who can figure things out, everything works out and theres no real consequences at all. Its not satisfying as a story and following him became very old very quick.
Overall this book is really held back in its tone, when reading sci fi that's so futuristic I'm expecting that society feels markedly different but excepting for the technology it honestly could have been set in the modern day, with modern day conflicts and a patriarchy that continues to be expressed in a very similar if not the same way it does now.
I do think I'll watch the movie because it's possible this will work better as a film and will benefit from charismatic actors. Gonna leave you with my most loathed quote from the book:
"What Eight is doing,” Nasha says, her voice a low, feline rumble, “is stealing away your woman. What’re you gonna do about it?"
Really hope the screenplay leaves out parts like this.